You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Ukraine Situation - Should We Be Worried?
November 21 2026 9.57pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Ukraine Situation - Should We Be Worried?


Page 268 of 280 < 264 265 266 267 268 269 270 271 272 >
Stirlingsays Flag 26 Dec 23 8.25pm

This is a maths professor that I've followed for many years because....well he's very good at what he teaches.

He's on the left but not the 'establishment' left and has been very critical of this war and how it came about since it started.

People on our side only get fed the establishment line, which....like our poster's response, is designed to argue for how we got here as the best outcome.

If you believe that I just don't know what to say to you.

Anyway, here is the professor's video in response to his opinion on this war.

[Link]

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 26 Dec 23 10.14pm

Originally posted by Helmet46

Thats the only thing you’ve ever written that I agree with.


Edited by Helmet46 (26 Dec 2023 8.24pm)

Thanks for that but surely there might have been the odd comment before?

In Palace Talk perhaps on how we played?

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 26 Dec 23 10.30pm

Did the cold war ever go away? If I were to be facetious I guess Afghanistan and Syria were much of the answer. Ukraine is an obvious yet avoidable part of that. Yet, there is in my belief an undesired Russian overreach here. Do something without the actual military prowess and this happens.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Helmet46 Flag Croydon 26 Dec 23 10.30pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

Thanks for that but surely there might have been the odd comment before?

In Palace Talk perhaps on how we played?

lol - yeah fair point. I meant on the news chat!

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 26 Dec 23 10.34pm

The views expressed in the “professor’s”:video are very familiar and duplicate what has repeatedly been posted here. As it’s the same line it doesn’t require detailed refutation.

He approaches the issue from a completely different perspective than those actually taking the decisions and seems to me to be a committed pacifist and appeaser.

I am sure he is sincere but I can also see why he has been removed from mainstream social media platforms. He claims not to be an apologist for Putin but his words tell another story.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Stirlingsays Flag 26 Dec 23 11.10pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

Did the cold war ever go away? If I were to be facetious I guess Afghanistan and Syria were much of the answer. Ukraine is an obvious yet avoidable part of that. Yet, there is in my belief an undesired Russian overreach here. Do something without the actual military prowess and this happens.

I think the Russians have a right to protect the ethnic Russians in East and South Ukraine from what was happening to them. Also the removal of the elected government in 2014 and US involvement in that was obviously very counter to their interests.

However, did that extend to going to war? No, not in my view. I believe that Russia have a lot of valid points when it comes to US state policy however it's also a matter of the pot calling the kettle black.

That said, we see the same behaviour here as we saw with covid. Huge pressure from establishment to censor on any alternative opinions on its policy. Even though those opinions were very common before the war. We have had many lies pumped out like 'Russia's running out of ammo', 'Russia's economy is destroyed', 'Putin's dying' and so on. I react against my side lying because I hold to a different standard where I object to lies for political purposes. No difference at all between them and Russia, yet they claim to be different.

Those shills support a simplistic goodies v baddies narrative because Putin = bad.....when the reality is that this is very much a 'baddies v baddies' reality that we shouldn't be tainted with. Same as with the Israeli/Hamas ethnic cleansing event.

I look at what the benefits v negatives are and the risk/gain out of this war. In that sense we have the lions led by donkeys with hyenas cheering for the donkeys.

It's always the European man in the street who will have to pay for these decisions.....there won't be any accountability because hyenas own the megaphone.

And most people will support every policy that harms us because the paid media present it within a moral frame and then complain about their standard of living without even connecting the dots.

Orban is the only elected head of state in Europe who actually cares about his country as a cohesive state that's resembles its history and has the same view the future of the Europeans is only good if they do the same. He had the right take on this war from the beginning and its outcomes are proving that obvious prediction correct.

They are trying to undermine and destroy him the same as they do to any figure who opposes them....same as what their ideological colleagues are trying to do with Trump and Musk.


Edited by Stirlingsays (26 Dec 2023 11.29pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 27 Dec 23 9.39am

I think every country has a duty to protect all its citizens, whatever their ethnicity, and that no other country should directly interfere in that in any way. Should abuses occur then international condemnation and sanctions are the way to rectify them. If you live in a country your loyalty should be to that country. We expect that here, so the same applies elsewhere. No compromises. If you cannot accept that then you must leave.

The reason the government fell in 2014 was that the then President refused to sign an order overwhelmingly passed by the parliament which was seeking stronger ties with the EU. He did so in response to pressure from Russia with whom he was closely associated and to where he fled when things kicked off. Russia then occupied Crimea and encouraged the ethnic Russians in the east.

It was the precursor to today and all part of the same basic issue of Putin’s Russia not accepting the collapse of the USSR. That the USA and the EU offered verbal support and encouragement to the Ukrainian people in their desire for self determination is clearly true but they weren’t the cause. That lies in Moscow.

I don’t detect any pressure by government to censor any alternative views. Search and you can find them being freely expressed at the time, just as they can be with Covid. What’s actually true is that those arguments lost to better arguments, and not that the arguments were silenced. The “paid” media!!! Who pays the media? Murdoch and Harmsworth?

To then champion Orban as a hero when his government above all others in the EU does actually suppress opposition comment and has reduced public broadcasting to a government propaganda machine, ought to be a joke, but sadly isn’t.

Trump is a danger to democracy. Musk seems intent on destroying his own business.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

snytaxx Flag London 27 Dec 23 6.17pm

Originally posted by Badger11

Poking the bear.

Firstly, hope you had a very enjoyable Christmas

Secondly, I think I pointed this out earlier on this thread but cant remember if a got a reply (i might have just missed it if I did so apologies in advance). However, this 'poking the bear' narrative is unfortunately complete nonsense when applied to the reality of international relations.

The Russian narrative in order to cover for what is an appalling act of colonial aggression is to play the victim card, 'I was provoked', 'I had not choice' etc however the arguement doesnt really stack for two reasons.

Firstly, if it was any other country that was being provoked, espiecally a Western country, we would argue that country at least tries to conduct themselves in a way which follows international law and convention, key example would likely be Iraq which I think we can all agree is probably the most overt example of western 'agression' and intervention we have witnessed in modern times. Even at it's most questionable, history shows that the coalition at least tried to go down a diplomatic route first.

[Link]

Did Russia try and do this? Indeed they actually spent 4 months gas lighting the 'hysterical' West they would never invade, only to invade. Yet we seem to just let Russia off as 'the bear was poked'. Guess thats fine then!

Secondly, what was it that 'poked the bear'? Ah yes the infamous Nato claim (refering to the previous post you were responding to). Odd that Ukraine actually asked to join Nato in 2008 and Russia didn't feel any need to invade Ukraine then. I guess it took a long time for the bear to feel poked!

[Link]

Even stranger that the bear would feel poked given the bear itself actually asked to join NATO, but didn't want to 'wait in line' with the plebs.

[Link]


 

Stirlingsays Flag 28 Dec 23 4.11am

There's just a refusal to accept reality.

Once reality finally comes to you just don't blame me. I was pointing out these realities at the near start and arguing for better outcomes than what Ukraine will get and the prior March 21 documentation that Russia had agreed to will prove it.

There are an awful lot of people dead now who would still be living.

Edited by Stirlingsays (28 Dec 2023 4.13am)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stirlingsays Flag 28 Dec 23 5.01am

The final US aid package allotment has been agreed to Ukraine,

Any future aid has to receive congressional approval, which is not as forthright as in the past.

250 million dollars are part of the package and includes

additional ammunition for NASAMS;
Stinger missiles;
components of the air defence system;
additional ammunition for HIMARS;
155 and 105 mm calibre artillery shells;
TOW missiles;
Javelin and AT-4 systems;
more than 15 million cartridges for small arms;
explosive ammunition for clearing obstacles;
spare parts, medical and other equipment.

Right now Ukraine is on a war economy and needs 37 billion just to pay its public sector let alone spend on military.

The unreality and all or nothing policy is the exact opposite of common sense as the Republicans are intrinsically more isolationist and less neo con so once the Ukrainian counter offensive failed in its objectives (which was always likely) the same level of support was always going to be hard.

The Ukrainians....might...might get enough to just cover expenses this year....I'd put it at fifty fifty depending on how far Biden caves on border policy and how much the Republicans believe him..... but I don't see the level of support they would need to ever gain back lost regions. They can talk about mobilising half a million but who is paying those wages and equipping those conscripts? These are gamblers and chancers.

The problem with leaders who go all in and don't play the percentages is that failure is far more of a disaster than would have been the case.

Edited by Stirlingsays (28 Dec 2023 5.20am)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stirlingsays Flag 29 Dec 23 6.02pm

I wonder if this means the Biden administration has decided not to cave to the GOP on border policy and hence Ukraine aren't going to get their sixty billion.

If Ukraine don't get at least around 40 billion this year they will collapse. This was the burden taken on.

We know that the Americans have been looking for negotiations with Russia and are frustrated with Zelensky and I'm hearing that backing is being transferred to options more likely to negotiate.

Edited by Stirlingsays (29 Dec 2023 6.04pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stirlingsays Flag 06 Jan 24 5.02pm

Regardless of whether Ukraine get more aid or not this is going to be a difficult year for them due to production levels between Russia and even the west.

shells.JPG Attachment: shells.JPG (52.52Kb)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stirlingsays Flag 12 Jan 24 7.44pm

I'm hearing that, as I had feared on these very pages, that Gonzalo Lira has been confirmed dead in Ukraine according to his father.

Looks like I was right to raise those concerns and now he's dead.

If this is true this needs answers. This case was specifically raised with the Biden administration who fobbed off concerns.

lira55.JPG Attachment: lira55.JPG (49.78Kb)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

eaglesdare Flag 13 Jan 24 1.18am

The crook has just fleeced the UK of 2.5 billion quid. Everyone's taxes going into his back pocket.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 13 Jan 24 4.46am

Originally posted by eaglesdare

The crook has just fleeced the UK of 2.5 billion quid. Everyone's taxes going into his back pocket.

I know, it's beyond a joke. Highly taxed, borrowing high, huge debts and you can't drive down the road for potholes in this country or get a GP appointment but we have billions to throw away for Ukraine for a war they can't win.

This country just loves to spend money....low quality elites.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

snytaxx Flag London 14 Jan 24 9.19pm

Originally posted by eaglesdare

The crook has just fleeced the UK of 2.5 billion quid. Everyone's taxes going into his back pocket.

Apart from he didn't...

1. £2.5 billion is the amount projected for the next financial year, its not a lump sum. I doubt most of it is even allocated as of yet.

2. If you think we are packing up money and putting in a van then there is little helping you. Most of this money actually stays in the UK where it helps creates jobs. For example £200 million on drone manufacturing.

[Link]

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 17 Jan 24 9.11am

I suspect the result of the Iowa caucus has just sealed the fate of Ukraine.

Trump has talked about a meeting with Putin early into his tenure.

There, no doubt, he will extract an undertaking that Russia can take Ukraine and retain effective control of Belarus through vassal status but will proceed no further.

Trump will then return to the US where he will triumphantly hold up a piece of paper and declare peace in our time.

Putin will wait till Trump's (no doubt) turbulent tenure is finally over, consolidate his power over those 4 years, and then advance into the Balkans, Moldova etc.

But of utmost importance, there will be considerable fiscal savings, fuel supply will resume, world inflation will drop, house prices will rise and Israel will continue to be generously funded.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 17 Jan 24 9.44am

Originally posted by silvertop

I suspect the result of the Iowa caucus has just sealed the fate of Ukraine.

Trump has talked about a meeting with Putin early into his tenure.

There, no doubt, he will extract an undertaking that Russia can take Ukraine and retain effective control of Belarus through vassal status but will proceed no further.

Trump will then return to the US where he will triumphantly hold up a piece of paper and declare peace in our time.

Putin will wait till Trump's (no doubt) turbulent tenure is finally over, consolidate his power over those 4 years, and then advance into the Balkans, Moldova etc.

But of utmost importance, there will be considerable fiscal savings, fuel supply will resume, world inflation will drop, house prices will rise and Israel will continue to be generously funded.

I'm pretty sure that won't happen.....and the main reason for that is Poland, which just wouldn't accept Russia on its border and the security agreements Ukraine has with us and soon France and others.

While Trump will draw back from Nato he won't abandon it for several reasons.

Here is what I think happens.....the eventual agreement (whether Trump wins or not) sees Russia take its four regions and maybe Odessa.

Enabling this in Ukraine will probably be done via the election of a candidate who promises peace with Russia. I very much suspect that this is what happens....there might even be a level of internal conflict in Ukraine similar to how the Irish had their own internal war before settling with the British in 1917.

If Russia has other territory, other than the areas it identified it'll negotiate it away for a neutral Ukraine that isn't allowed to join Nato and hence not to be militarised against it. How much of that they get remains to be seen.

As for the further expansion by Russia into eastern European states that have sided against it. This isn't knowable and no doubt Europe can flood these countries with weapons like they did Ukraine. Personally I don't see Russia staying within regions that don't have Russian friendly populations already there.

The idea that Putin will be Stalin and take back the old empire goes directly against what he has said since the nineties. He has criticised the Soviet empire many times. However, states that are willing to be 'Ukraines' aren't being particularly sensible.

I said at the start that this course of action was insane and I have no pleasure in these outcomes. Hundreds of thousands dead in the most avoidable war I've ever seen.

The decisions to essentially jump to neo con policy in the US state department has been a terrible decision by Europe. I predict my opinion will slowly become recognised across Europe.....mainly because defence budgets will rise and welfare will have to be cut for that to happen.

The policy of not supporting the confrontational agenda of the US is prominent in several rising parties in Europe. Farage supported it and so do the Afd in Germany, who are leading the polls.

The policy put Russia into China's arms, led to a global split in the world with a new cold war with now several flash points for WW3.


Edited by Stirlingsays (17 Jan 2024 10.43am)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stirlingsays Flag 17 Jan 24 10.38am

Mike Benz (who it shouldn't be forgotten was in the state department) on US and EU policy and attitudes towards Ukraine in this west v east policy.

Edited by Stirlingsays (17 Jan 2024 10.38am)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

silvertop Flag Portishead 17 Jan 24 11.25am

What is and has been anathema to Russia throughout its history is an opposing force on its border. It has endured a long, bitter history to forge this position. The post WWII Eastern Bloc states surrounding the Soviet Union and providing a buffer zone against further invasion (whether perceived or real), is just the latest iteration of how Russia and USSR have sought to achieve that.

The hybrid you envisage may be accepted by Putin as a stage 1, but he will not rest until Mother Russia is secure with vassal states or open seas on every border.

What Poland accepts or does not accept is neither here not there. Russia will not be interested in its view. Trump will pretend to listen but ultimately sell them down the river in favour of diverting resources to US domestic policy, especially homeland security at the Rio Grande. US allies in Europe will be placated so long as they agree to pay their way in NATO. Since they won't, they will ultimately be left to wring their hands in impotence.

You may be correct in terms of Russia's further ambitions. And that Putin is not Stalin. Uncle Joe had reached the Elbe and apparently addressed his generals. We have 400 divisions in the field (c4million men at arms) why should we not continue to the Azores? The Bomb apparently persuaded him not to or at least to put that ambition on ice.

Putin harks back not to that world domination by the proletariat, but to Tsarist Russia and the need to protect the Motherland through border expansion. Finland may be considered a safe border but there have been centuries of conflict. However, the Baltic states continue to have a lot of Russian speakers and have morphed into and out of Russian control over history. They are under genuine threat.

But they are also NATO members with US airbases. For this reason, I think this risk is hyperbole used by the West to drum up support for supporting Ukraine. Putin has seen how effective his army is against his undernourished neighbour with relatively limited Western support. He will know it will end very badly if he attacks a NATO member and sees the dogs of war fully unleashed... I suspect he will settle for a pet Ukraine and some medium term stability will be restored.

 

Page 268 of 280 < 264 265 266 267 268 269 270 271 272 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Ukraine Situation - Should We Be Worried?