This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by silvertop
What is and has been anathema to Russia throughout its history is an opposing force on its border. It has endured a long, bitter history to forge this position. The post WWII Eastern Bloc states surrounding the Soviet Union and providing a buffer zone against further invasion (whether perceived or real), is just the latest iteration of how Russia and USSR have sought to achieve that. The hybrid you envisage may be accepted by Putin as a stage 1, but he will not rest until Mother Russia is secure with vassal states or open seas on every border. What Poland accepts or does not accept is neither here not there. Russia will not be interested in its view. Trump will pretend to listen but ultimately sell them down the river in favour of diverting resources to US domestic policy, especially homeland security at the Rio Grande. US allies in Europe will be placated so long as they agree to pay their way in NATO. Since they won't, they will ultimately be left to wring their hands in impotence. You may be correct in terms of Russia's further ambitions. And that Putin is not Stalin. Uncle Joe had reached the Elbe and apparently addressed his generals. We have 400 divisions in the field (c4million men at arms) why should we not continue to the Azores? The Bomb apparently persuaded him not to or at least to put that ambition on ice. Putin harks back not to that world domination by the proletariat, but to Tsarist Russia and the need to protect the Motherland through border expansion. Finland may be considered a safe border but there have been centuries of conflict. However, the Baltic states continue to have a lot of Russian speakers and have morphed into and out of Russian control over history. They are under genuine threat. But they are also NATO members with US airbases. For this reason, I think this risk is hyperbole used by the West to drum up support for supporting Ukraine. Putin has seen how effective his army is against his undernourished neighbour with relatively limited Western support. He will know it will end very badly if he attacks a NATO member and sees the dogs of war fully unleashed... I suspect he will settle for a pet Ukraine and some medium term stability will be restored. Interesting and intelligent analysis. How much comes to past I suppose we all will get to see. I find it all quite depressing and saddening. I think Russia's and Europe's attitude towards each other is quite similar. I have more sympathy for the fear of eastern block countries if I'm honest rather than us due to the soviet history....However, these aren't socially liberal countries either and these countries...much as Ukraine was, become internally discordant over their futures. Personally I hope for a meeting of the practical and pragmatic over what currently holds court.....otherwise it's all going to get rather more expensive.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
The post script I omitted is that we may be seen to be right to support Ukraine, even though the outcome seems likely to end with what Putin wants. Simply put, while Putin shares Stalin's disregard for the lives of his own troops, he has seen that it is politically and financially too costly to prosecute an offensive campaign on his western borders. Edited by silvertop (17 Jan 2024 1.01pm) Policy that led up to 2014 is why we are in this situation in the first place. In terms of supporting Ukraine, we would probably disagree on the nature of that support as being good for either Ukraine or our future. I'm far more in agreement with Orban's analysis on that point and I'm also of the mind that this viewpoint will ultimately prevail due to necessity if nothing else. The stomach for the high spending necessary to maintain a military confrontation stance with Russia will end with the weakening of social liberalism in Europe due to economic decline.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
The post script I omitted is that we may be seen to be right to support Ukraine, even though the outcome seems likely to end with what Putin wants. Simply put, while Putin shares Stalin's disregard for the lives of his own troops, he has seen that it is politically and financially too costly to prosecute an offensive campaign on his western borders. Edited by silvertop (17 Jan 2024 1.01pm) Surely that was the point of NATO providing the support it has, and applying the sanctions? If he had been able to walk all over Ukraine with little resistance and his army largely intact who knows where the line would then be drawn or what the future would hold. Especially with the threat of a second Trump presidency lurking in people’s minds?
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
I see our know-it-all expert on everything is pontificating again on Putin’s motivations and ambitions along with throwing in the usual condemnation of our responses to it. I prefer to trust genuine experts who have real knowledge gathered from years of study and experience. This analysis published shortly after the invasion began fits this category and provides a useful insight, especially given what we know has actually happened since:- This is also an interesting analysis of Putin’s rise to power, success in restoring confidence and ambitions:- Then there is this from Putin himself, which shows just how deeply his attitude is dependent on history:- There is a joke in Russia that goes something like this. The future is certain. Only the past is unpredictable. Putin is doing what Russian leaders and great thinkers have done for donkeys' years. Use a largely mythologized view of Russian history to shape their future. He's nothing new. As to how that translates into current policy, what he says to justify his actions and inspire his people does not necessarily translate into what he actually intends to do. He may consider the fall of the Soviet Union to be a catastrophe, but he has shown no desire to rebuild it. He is no true Red. Had they won the revolution, he would be a White. His restoration of the Orthodox church and constant referencing of Tsarist history is proof of that. Also, any thoughts of rebuilding the Russian empire c1917 is something he may imply in morale raising speeches, but he is not an idiot. He knows he cannot regain Finland or part of Poland or central Asia. Poland would be particularly problematic after NATO blows his country to bits. There will be no Russian tanks grinding down the Royal Route in Warsaw or the Baltic states. Poland and Lithuania may want us to say there is such a risk in order to encourage funding for Ukraine, but that has more to do with then wanting a friendly neighbour than any genuine risk to their sovereignty. And that, as I said above, is what I think are the twin aims of Putin. Restore the Motherland of ancient Rus in which he believes Belarus and Ukraine are integral parts (perhaps the way we see Wales etc.). And ensure that its borders are occupied by friends loyal to Russia and not the West. This would include Georgia to the south and the central Asian republics. He would rather that was achieved through influential control and non military means (Belarus by example) but will resort to violence if all other avenues are exhausted, as with Georgia and now Ukraine. However, Russian aggression has almost always been what they see to be a defensive strategy as opposed to, say, imperial expansion. I don't see this as any different and, for once, Putin can lean on accurate Russian history to provide a basis for that battle plan.
|
|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
There is a joke in Russia that goes something like this. The future is certain. Only the past is unpredictable. Putin is doing what Russian leaders and great thinkers have done for donkeys' years. Use a largely mythologized view of Russian history to shape their future. He's nothing new. As to how that translates into current policy, what he says to justify his actions and inspire his people does not necessarily translate into what he actually intends to do. He may consider the fall of the Soviet Union to be a catastrophe, but he has shown no desire to rebuild it. He is no true Red. Had they won the revolution, he would be a White. His restoration of the Orthodox church and constant referencing of Tsarist history is proof of that. Also, any thoughts of rebuilding the Russian empire c1917 is something he may imply in morale raising speeches, but he is not an idiot. He knows he cannot regain Finland or part of Poland or central Asia. Poland would be particularly problematic after NATO blows his country to bits. There will be no Russian tanks grinding down the Royal Route in Warsaw or the Baltic states. Poland and Lithuania may want us to say there is such a risk in order to encourage funding for Ukraine, but that has more to do with then wanting a friendly neighbour than any genuine risk to their sovereignty. And that, as I said above, is what I think are the twin aims of Putin. Restore the Motherland of ancient Rus in which he believes Belarus and Ukraine are integral parts (perhaps the way we see Wales etc.). And ensure that its borders are occupied by friends loyal to Russia and not the West. This would include Georgia to the south and the central Asian republics. He would rather that was achieved through influential control and non military means (Belarus by example) but will resort to violence if all other avenues are exhausted, as with Georgia and now Ukraine. However, Russian aggression has almost always been what they see to be a defensive strategy as opposed to, say, imperial expansion. I don't see this as any different and, for once, Putin can lean on accurate Russian history to provide a basis for that battle plan. I think there is a lot of accuracy in your analysis. To be objective in relation to Putin, his regime had no military ambitions in Ukraine for twenty years post Berlin wall precisely because they perceived no Nato threat from it. How we got from the Berlin war to now could be the subject of much gnashing of teeth but elites failing at their jobs and swanning off in glory is a feature both in the west and Russia itself and corrupt states worldwide. I don't think Putin wanted to be engaged in taking over all of Ukraine due to the military and financial requirements of where Russia were pre 2021. Even now I don't think Russia running Ukraine is realistic due to the Poland problem. Both sides want to avoid that. What Russia wants is a buffer zone between it and Nato's missile capability. Ukraine is five miles drive to Moscow....it was always an incredibly stupid policy to try to pull Ukraine away from Russia especially when it had a large ethnic population on its border willing to fight. So I think Ukraine ends up being that buffer zone with negotiation with the west on no Nato membership....How the rest of the agreement goes I don't know but I find it unrealistic that Putin would agree to an anti Russian government chomping on the bit to take back the east and south....he'd just keep fighting. I think some agreement will be found especially if Trump wins and even within Europe if he doesn't, especially if the current German government falls....which is likely come their next election even though that isn't until October 25. I don't think Eastern European states who are being aggressively anti Russian now are being particularly bright but there you go. Some of them have made a rod for their own backs. Personally I think the US state department has left Europe in a mess. Edited by Stirlingsays (18 Jan 2024 1.07pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I think there is a lot of accuracy in your analysis. To be objective in relation to Putin, his regime had no military ambitions in Ukraine for twenty years post Berlin wall precisely because they perceived no Nato threat from it. How we got from the Berlin war to now could be the subject of much gnashing of teeth but elites failing at their jobs and swanning off in glory is a feature both in the west and Russia itself and corrupt states worldwide. I don't think Putin wanted to be engaged in taking over all of Ukraine due to the military and financial requirements of where Russia were pre 2021. Even now I don't think Russia running Ukraine is realistic due to the Poland problem. Both sides want to avoid that. What Russia wants is a buffer zone between it and Nato's missile capability. Ukraine is five miles drive to Moscow....it was always an incredibly stupid policy to try to pull Ukraine away from Russia especially when it had a large ethnic population on its border willing to fight. So I think Ukraine ends up being that buffer zone with negotiation with the west on no Nato membership....How the rest of the agreement goes I don't know but I find it unrealistic that Putin would agree to an anti Russian government chomping on the bit to take back the east and south....he'd just keep fighting. I think some agreement will be found especially if Trump wins and even within Europe if he doesn't, especially if the current German government falls....which is likely come their next election even though that isn't until October 25. I don't think Eastern European states who are being aggressively anti Russian now are being particularly bright but there you go. Some of them have made a rod for their own backs. Personally I think the US state department has left Europe in a mess. Edited by Stirlingsays (18 Jan 2024 1.07pm) Which is a huge disappointment given their superb track record in international affairs!
|
|
|
At least the US has not bombed us or the EU, whether by accident or intent. We are last on the list.
|
|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
Which is a huge disappointment given their superb track record in international affairs! Indeed, a country run by interests not entirely aligned with their own.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
At least the US has not bombed us or the EU, whether by accident or intent. We are last on the list.
Unless you have a pipeline that interferes with buying their energy.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I'm hearing that Russians are now fighting inside the city of Avdiivka on two sides. Unless the Ukrainians can force them out before they reinforce that city is on a timer. Your only about 3 months two late on this one. This city has been on the frontline since 2014 and under renewed Russian offensive since October of last year. Luckily its part of that defensive DMZ you said would hold the Russians back.
|
|
|
Originally posted by snytaxx
Your only about 3 months two late on this one. This city has been on the frontline since 2014 and under renewed Russian offensive since October of last year. Luckily its part of that defensive DMZ you said would hold the Russians back. I don't think I've said that Russia were fighting inside Avdiivka before. Sure, Ukraine took back territory in the north, they have been approaching it for some time but obviously trench warfare, fighting in woods and fields are different from the actual urban warfare required to take a city. As for a DMZ, well one is very likely, in my view, once this war is negotiated. We will see. Edited by Stirlingsays (20 Jan 2024 4.51pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I don't think I've said that Russia were fighting inside Avdiivka before. Sure, Ukraine took back territory in the north, they have been approaching it for some time but obviously trench warfare, fighting in woods and fields are different from the actual urban warfare required to take a city. As for a DMZ, well one is very likely, in my view, once this war is negotiated. We will see. Edited by Stirlingsays (20 Jan 2024 4.51pm) I can pull up some Rybar maps from October 2023 where the Russians had claimed a 'serious breakthrough' with the town 'all but taken'. Given the town has been surrounded on three sides since 2014. Russian telegram and news agencies have been going full Bakhmut on this since then running 'any minute now' headlines and updates. I suspect given the frequency of videos the past three months of Russian tanks getting their turrets yeeted several dozen metres into the air Russia is pushing very hard to take the town. Its all really fog of war at this stage.
|
|
|
Originally posted by snytaxx
I can pull up some Rybar maps from October 2023 where the Russians had claimed a 'serious breakthrough' with the town 'all but taken'. Given the town has been surrounded on three sides since 2014. Russian telegram and news agencies have been going full Bakhmut on this since then running 'any minute now' headlines and updates. I suspect given the frequency of videos the past three months of Russian tanks getting their turrets yeeted several dozen metres into the air Russia is pushing very hard to take the town. Its all really fog of war at this stage. I think that's fair enough. It seems to be very fortified and difficult to take. Even more so than Bakhmut, which itself took....I think an estimated twenty thousand Russian lives to take, mostly Wagner. I think the sources I'm using try to be accurate, and you can find those on both sides....just as you can find those who want to craft the battlefield in a more positive light for their side. I'm hearing that Russia are inside the city, the latest being that Ukraine might have forced them out of western part but Russia having gain via the residential sectors of the south. The coke plant in the north seems to be steady at the moment for Ukraine while Russia push at supply roads. How long Ukraine will fight in Avdiivka is difficult to say. Maybe they can exhaust the Russian advance there. Only the next few weeks will say. Personally I think they will fall back if the coke plant falls or gets cut off.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
I am watching the BBC series of documentaries on Putin and his relationship with the west on the iPlayer. Very illuminating it is too. Most of the major players speak openly about their dealings with him and how he is a total and constant liar who cannot be trusted. It is very clear that he has never regarded Ukraine as a separate country but as a part of a greater Russia. It’s an excellent watch for those who seek unvarnished information. It's on my list to watch for sure, but I did see the part at the security council which just surreal. Sadly I can't see it changing many minds on here given it's produced by the BBC and not a reputable news source like RT or Grayzone.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.