Quote Stirlingsays at 22 Jul 2014 1.10pm
Quote Cucking Funt at 22 Jul 2014 12.55pm
I merely asked the question. I've said before, it comes down to whether one believes if Israel has a right to exist or not. History has shown that, whenever they drop their guard, someone, somewhere, has a pop at them. I'm pretty certain Israel would welcome an undertaking that none of their neighbours will try to obliterate them.
Did Israel have a right to exist back in 47.....Debatable. It was a massive call as the Jews had mainly chosen Europe for more than a thousand years.......Though to be fair the Romans had kicked and burned them out.
The terms they were offered in 47 were very preferential for a population who were mainly new to the area from Europe and had flooded the area in just a few decades.
All the lefties who complain about the unfairness are probably also fans of unfetted immigration today....The parallels are almost amusing.
Anyway 55 percent of the land was offered to a Jewish population of 30 percent..The Arabs refused...The UN made it happen and when they and the British left multiple Arab armies invaded and all got their behinds kicked....(The Jewish were considerably outnumbered but were fighting for their lives and had better US arms)..The Arabs proceeded to lose several wars and the territory that went with them....Like the Golan heights.
Still......Your question is about now not then.
Yes, Israel has a right to exist........The alternative now would be genocidal war as they aren't moving. They are a wealthy and healthy democracy in the middle east and as such a rarity in the region.
The answer is a fair two state solution....There is no other acceptable game in town.
But none of the current players in power or their backers are willing to accept it.
We have lots more bloodshed to go yet.
Edited by Stirlingsays (22 Jul 2014 1.14pm)
Which is why we need boycotts and embargoes.