This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Stirlingsays at 15 May 2014 2.08pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 15 May 2014 1.57pm
But that has never been the case, all societies are divided by their sub-cultures. If you look back through history, you'll see societys exist as cultural discourses in conflict, not alignment and cohesion. Probably the only times when society cultural divisions are put aside is during times of war or great tragedy. To imagine a past England where everyone belonged to the same culture, spoke the same language, had a sense of cohesion and belonging is a myth. The nature of those subcultures might have been different, but they existed in conflict, not harmony or even alignment.
Just because there are sub-divisions within all cultures that doesn't mean that they don't all agree that they exist within the same framework and share the same alligence. It just isn't accurate to suggest that these things aren't worthy of definable protection due to an argument based upon perceptions. We can use the argument of perception about anything and everything. Culture exists because people believe it does....The fact that people can point to sub-divisions doesn't mean that the difference in shared cultures between me and my mate in the pub isn't different to the Polish bloke I work with. Usually sub-cultural movements have a number of share themes, what they tend to differ on is how those shared ideas are expressed and valued. Typically thats where conflict occurs, and change in society occurs as those discourses are resolved, and then the next generation of discourses evolve. Its almost human nature for culture to change over time, as people interact and engage in social behaviour and self expression. The British culture of my youth is a far cry from that of my 40s - and thats inevitable, the nature of all things is change. The problem is we tend to nostaligise a past that never really existed. When I say conflict I don't mean war and violence, but of clashing ideologies, views and social movements. The recent past was one of conflict, the very nature of Industrial society was one of social divsions acting in direct opposition. The 60s to late 80s were a period of great upheaval, and social and cultural change in the face of resistance to those changes. Trying to 'control' cultural change is like trying to order back the sea. Culture doesn't exist because people believe in it, so much as culture and people are utterly inseperable concepts. Successive migrations into the UK created new and different patterns and cultural influences as well as options, that over time have merged into, and some times supplanted, existing cultures.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Stirlingsays at 15 May 2014 2.11pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 15 May 2014 1.51pm
Massive fuss about nothing. The UK ecconomically cannot afford to do away with low wage migrant workers from the EU. The consequent impact of losing those workers would be a need to migrate people from elsewhere in the UK to fill employment gaps, and thats not something any government is finance. Its important to remember than in large parts the influx of migrant workers has been to fill lower wage manual and semi-skilled work in high employment areas. Whilst some unemployed exist in those regions, they aren't in sufficent numbers to fill those gaps. As for culture, culture is dynamic and changes on a continual basis. British Culture changes every generation. Those who hark back to some imagined gold age of Britishness or British culture have fallen into the trap of nostalgia and selective memory. Migration changes cultures, it doesn't render them obsolete. Culture is a discourse, not an intrinsic thing.
Apparently people just don't understand and their feelings on belonging and cultural/national attachment are invalid. I wouldn't go so far as to say they're invalid, they're invalid to some, questioned by others. I think its always more interesting and important as to why people think or feel something, than just accepting that they are validated just because they experience them. I have cultural attachments, feelings of belonging, and a national identity (admittedly one probably based on the rejection of the idea of nation identity). We all do, its impossible not to, we are all produced within the discourses of our social environments and experiences.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Stirlingsays at 15 May 2014 3.40pm
Quote Proper_Gander at 15 May 2014 3.33pm
Quote Stirlingsays at 15 May 2014 2.11pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 15 May 2014 1.51pm
Massive fuss about nothing. The UK ecconomically cannot afford to do away with low wage migrant workers from the EU. The consequent impact of losing those workers would be a need to migrate people from elsewhere in the UK to fill employment gaps, and thats not something any government is finance. Its important to remember than in large parts the influx of migrant workers has been to fill lower wage manual and semi-skilled work in high employment areas. Whilst some unemployed exist in those regions, they aren't in sufficent numbers to fill those gaps. As for culture, culture is dynamic and changes on a continual basis. British Culture changes every generation. Those who hark back to some imagined gold age of Britishness or British culture have fallen into the trap of nostalgia and selective memory. Migration changes cultures, it doesn't render them obsolete. Culture is a discourse, not an intrinsic thing.
Apparently people just don't understand and their feelings on belonging and cultural/national attachment are invalid. Oh yes, filling jobs which are paid too badly for the local populace to pick up, with foreign peasants, to enrich business owners, is a real left wing ideology.
You're right about certain elements of big business libertarianism but those are different arguments and beliefs even if they end up with the same result. Its more based on Social Constructionist theory and phenomonological research of culture. Traditionally the leftists have always been more influenced by modernism and empiricisim. I've been a long critic of the effect that ecconomic migration has had on producing an artifically low working wage - and how that has perpetuated the problem of an underclass and 'benefits' classes.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.