You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Sorloth thread
November 16 2026 6.50am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Sorloth thread


Page 27 of 54 < 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 >
redpalace91 Flag Bromley 09 Jan 19 9.10am

Another one of those transfers where you are left wondering whether the Palace scouting team have any clue at all.

 

Frickin Saweet Flag South Cronx 09 Jan 19 9.28am

what an absolute waste of money on our part. It's not his fault - no young European striker one would turn down a move to the Premier League. I hope he can get himself back on track and find his level. I lost 5 Euros against Grimsby as i bet my uncle he would score. Damn all those Guinness making me an optimist.

 

palace99 Flag New Mills 09 Jan 19 9.36am

Originally posted by kevlee

Whoever was responsible for his signing and basically pissing £9m up the wall should be given a written final warning!

It was a lot more than £9m.

In addition to the up front payment I think we paid an extra £3m if we stayed up that season (we did) and the same this season. There were also goal and appearance add ons to take it to c£16.5m maximum.

It's likely he'll cost c£15m in total not to mention agent and signing on fees etc.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 09 Jan 19 10.16am

Even this loaning him out is wrong.

He needs experience in this country so a loan to anyone below Prem is what should of been the case not sending him abroad which just shows he is not in Palaces plans for future.

Complete waste

We have so many problems poor scouts and no good coaching staff to make players better.

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

palace777 Flag belfast 09 Jan 19 11.32am

Love the interview with him
"I'm big,fast and strong"
Well 1 out of 3 ain't bad!

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 09 Jan 19 11.51am

Originally posted by palace777

Love the interview with him
"I'm big,fast and strong"
Well 1 out of 3 ain't bad!

Maybe the FA need to investigate him for any Nazi superior race beliefs with claims like that. Or maybe just counselling for delusions.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 09 Jan 19 11.53am

All valid points above. Just shows how we’ve settled for, or chosen an ex player to actually run football club matters seeing as how important these things are.

 


COYP

Bangell Flag Oxford 09 Jan 19 12.18pm

Showed a disgraceful lack of commitment in every game here. I hope the loan goes well for him, of course, so that we can hopefully get some of our money back when we sell him.

 

leejaneagles Flag 09 Jan 19 12.21pm

This is a bit of an odd take on the whole thing but did anybody watch the Netflix Documentary on Sunderland?

They were a team in complete disarray, no one wanted to join them because of the uncertainty of the Club's ownership, the Chairman didn't want to spend a penny (I don't mean Parish levels of tightness, I mean literally not put 1p into the club or even attend meetings or talk to the Clubs Manager's).

They were in the worst position imaginable and of course they got relegated that season. That said, the Scouting Team and combination of Grayson and Coleman, did highlight certain Strikers they wanted and nearly got them over the line. Some you could even say were relatively successful, Lewis Grabban on loan for first half of the season, identifying and promoting a youth Striker, missing out on Ross McCormack at the last minute.

What's my point? Well, I think arguably Grabban or McCormack or even their Youth Striker couldn't do any worse than Sorloth (I'm not saying they'd do better).

If Sunderland have a better Scout network in place with literally zero in the bank, shouldn't we immediately be trying to hire them or at least sack our lot and start recruiting elsewhere because we had 9 million pounds in the bank. I know that doesn't buy you a Benteke, I know it certainly doesn't buy you a Lukaku or Aguero but it's still a lot of money even in the Prem.

Either buy the top Championship striker or alternatively, go and find that gem in the second string of a Chelsa or Liverpool.

We have all been fooled into believing £9mil is nothing in the Premier League but even now that isn't true. It's certainly worth a lot LOT more than a Sorloth if you use some imagination and hard work scouting so I think it's time for a Face-lift of the Scouting team.

Thoughts? Fair?

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 09 Jan 19 12.58pm

Originally posted by leejaneagles

This is a bit of an odd take on the whole thing but did anybody watch the Netflix Documentary on Sunderland?

They were a team in complete disarray, no one wanted to join them because of the uncertainty of the Club's ownership, the Chairman didn't want to spend a penny (I don't mean Parish levels of tightness, I mean literally not put 1p into the club or even attend meetings or talk to the Clubs Manager's).

They were in the worst position imaginable and of course they got relegated that season. That said, the Scouting Team and combination of Grayson and Coleman, did highlight certain Strikers they wanted and nearly got them over the line. Some you could even say were relatively successful, Lewis Grabban on loan for first half of the season, identifying and promoting a youth Striker, missing out on Ross McCormack at the last minute.

What's my point? Well, I think arguably Grabban or McCormack or even their Youth Striker couldn't do any worse than Sorloth (I'm not saying they'd do better).

If Sunderland have a better Scout network in place with literally zero in the bank, shouldn't we immediately be trying to hire them or at least sack our lot and start recruiting elsewhere because we had 9 million pounds in the bank. I know that doesn't buy you a Benteke, I know it certainly doesn't buy you a Lukaku or Aguero but it's still a lot of money even in the Prem.

Either buy the top Championship striker or alternatively, go and find that gem in the second string of a Chelsa or Liverpool.

We have all been fooled into believing £9mil is nothing in the Premier League but even now that isn't true. It's certainly worth a lot LOT more than a Sorloth if you use some imagination and hard work scouting so I think it's time for a Face-lift of the Scouting team.

Thoughts? Fair?

Is that documentary any good? I might need to take a peep.

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 09 Jan 19 1.35pm

Originally posted by Bangell

Showed a disgraceful lack of commitment in every game here. I hope the loan goes well for him, of course, so that we can hopefully get some of our money back when we sell him.

It was strange to see his attitude, even s**** strikers can at least run around a bit like a headless chicken. I am thinking Wilbraham.

A truly terrible signing, in a truly amateur window. How are Rakip and Jach getting on.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

JRW2 Flag Dulwich 09 Jan 19 2.20pm

Originally posted by Glazier#1


Does anyone know if Jess Thorup is any relation to Borge Thorup who some old - timers may remember played for Palace all those years ago?

I don't know whether they're related. But I do remember Borge's Palace "career" - one appearance as a substitute in 1969. Blimey, that's fifty years ago.

 

Dannyh.V2 Flag Stone lickers 09 Jan 19 3.01pm

I've come full circle on this now and wish the useless lump all the best as long as he doesn't come back.

The much larger question and more worrying is who in the name of suffering fcuk told the club he was worth a 9 million punt in the first place, becuase whoever it was should be made to pay the 9 million back.

Then be sacked.

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 09 Jan 19 3.18pm

Originally posted by leejaneagles

This is a bit of an odd take on the whole thing but did anybody watch the Netflix Documentary on Sunderland?

They were a team in complete disarray, no one wanted to join them because of the uncertainty of the Club's ownership, the Chairman didn't want to spend a penny (I don't mean Parish levels of tightness, I mean literally not put 1p into the club or even attend meetings or talk to the Clubs Manager's).

They were in the worst position imaginable and of course they got relegated that season. That said, the Scouting Team and combination of Grayson and Coleman, did highlight certain Strikers they wanted and nearly got them over the line. Some you could even say were relatively successful, Lewis Grabban on loan for first half of the season, identifying and promoting a youth Striker, missing out on Ross McCormack at the last minute.

What's my point? Well, I think arguably Grabban or McCormack or even their Youth Striker couldn't do any worse than Sorloth (I'm not saying they'd do better).

If Sunderland have a better Scout network in place with literally zero in the bank, shouldn't we immediately be trying to hire them or at least sack our lot and start recruiting elsewhere because we had 9 million pounds in the bank. I know that doesn't buy you a Benteke, I know it certainly doesn't buy you a Lukaku or Aguero but it's still a lot of money even in the Prem.

Either buy the top Championship striker or alternatively, go and find that gem in the second string of a Chelsa or Liverpool.

We have all been fooled into believing £9mil is nothing in the Premier League but even now that isn't true. It's certainly worth a lot LOT more than a Sorloth if you use some imagination and hard work scouting so I think it's time for a Face-lift of the Scouting team.

Thoughts? Fair?

Difficult to say. Do you know how many bad buys they brought in? Seem to remember them buying some s**t over the years...agree we over paid for Sorloth though.

 

premier fan Flag BR4 09 Jan 19 3.36pm

Can't blame the player for not being up to prem standard - someone needs to get the sack over this one £10m? Was it Greedman?

Edited by premier fan (09 Jan 2019 3.37pm)

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 09 Jan 19 6.22pm

Originally posted by leejaneagles

This is a bit of an odd take on the whole thing but did anybody watch the Netflix Documentary on Sunderland?

They were a team in complete disarray, no one wanted to join them because of the uncertainty of the Club's ownership, the Chairman didn't want to spend a penny (I don't mean Parish levels of tightness, I mean literally not put 1p into the club or even attend meetings or talk to the Clubs Manager's).

They were in the worst position imaginable and of course they got relegated that season. That said, the Scouting Team and combination of Grayson and Coleman, did highlight certain Strikers they wanted and nearly got them over the line. Some you could even say were relatively successful, Lewis Grabban on loan for first half of the season, identifying and promoting a youth Striker, missing out on Ross McCormack at the last minute.

What's my point? Well, I think arguably Grabban or McCormack or even their Youth Striker couldn't do any worse than Sorloth (I'm not saying they'd do better).

If Sunderland have a better Scout network in place with literally zero in the bank, shouldn't we immediately be trying to hire them or at least sack our lot and start recruiting elsewhere because we had 9 million pounds in the bank. I know that doesn't buy you a Benteke, I know it certainly doesn't buy you a Lukaku or Aguero but it's still a lot of money even in the Prem.

Either buy the top Championship striker or alternatively, go and find that gem in the second string of a Chelsa or Liverpool.

We have all been fooled into believing £9mil is nothing in the Premier League but even now that isn't true. It's certainly worth a lot LOT more than a Sorloth if you use some imagination and hard work scouting so I think it's time for a Face-lift of the Scouting team.

Thoughts? Fair?

Also recall the meeting where they say that they'd profited on... I can't remember the exact number, something like 3 out of 40-something signings? Their scouts are just as bad as ours

 

pompeyeagle Flag Relocated to Shropshire 10 Jan 19 8.34am

Originally posted by JRW2

I don't know whether they're related. But I do remember Borge's Palace "career" - one appearance as a substitute in 1969. Blimey, that's fifty years ago.

I actually remember Borg Thorup so was pretty surprised when I found out he had made only one appearance as a substitute. I assumed he had played loads of games for us otherwise why would I remember him? Bit of a mystery.

 

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 10 Jan 19 12.00pm

Originally posted by pompeyeagle

I actually remember Borg Thorup so was pretty surprised when I found out he had made only one appearance as a substitute. I assumed he had played loads of games for us otherwise why would I remember him? Bit of a mystery.

Could Borg Thorup be the Norwegian Mick Hill?

 

nimblehippo Flag 10 Jan 19 1.27pm

I don't think he's that bad, he just doesn't suit our play and we don't play to strengths. He's good at link up play with back to goal, but doesn't offer us enough goals - would be fine if he was center point of 4-3-3. When I've seen him live, I kept on thinking that other palace players didn't trust him though, as they never really looked to play him in.

 

Glazier#1 Flag 10 Jan 19 6.57pm

I think Borge was memorable because of an unusual link with Scandinavian players via Scottish Greenock Morton.

At the time, before the European profile of the premier League, it was seen as newsworthy and 'exotic'.

 

Page 27 of 54 < 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Sorloth thread