You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Topic
November 16 2026 8.10am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Holmesdale Singing Section (LOCKED)


Page 27 of 71 < 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 >
Mapletree Flag Croydon 01 Nov 18 12.10pm

Originally posted by bicycle repair man

People worried about out of time chanting and drums ?
It beggars belief.
The football seems like a side show to some.

You are so right

The singing is much more fun than most of the football we have been playing

Sadly neither the football nor the singing is up to scratch at the moment

 

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 01 Nov 18 12.30pm

Originally posted by bicycle repair man

People worried about out of time chanting and drums ?
It beggars belief.
The football seems like a side show to some.

I sometimes wonder whether those HF lovers would rather have this, so called, fantastic atmosphere and see us lose than not much atmosphere and see us win.

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

turbohorsebox Flag Coulsdon 01 Nov 18 12.42pm

Originally posted by Willo

In my humble opinion, the HF made a calculated decision not to continue as before on the basis that their support would be missed by the club, giving them the leverage to get what they want.

The narrative appears to be that the HF have thrown toys out of pram by their actions,forced the hand of Steve Parish, got what they desired and as a result forced out loyal and long-standing season ticket holders and this whole matter has proved very divisive amongst our fan base.

I have to say, for once I think Willo has nailed it.

 


All good. Nothing bad.

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 01 Nov 18 1.30pm

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

I sometimes wonder whether those HF lovers would rather have this, so called, fantastic atmosphere and see us lose than not much atmosphere and see us win.

Football was never a sedentary sport. The Taylor report intended it to be, but it isn’t, and it can be safe without sitting still on your hands, or with some clappers in your hands.

 


COYP

PalacePhotoMan Flag Wallington 01 Nov 18 3.07pm

"Forced out", sonny Jim. Forced out.

As of yet we haven't been "shifted" anywhere. They don't know where they're shifting us to yet. They've not worked it out. 400 seats in a ground with 92% season ticket renewals isn't an easy one to fix, poor loves.

And I may sit in E Block but I don't yet have a "thermos and blanket". Or a prawn sandwich.

I don't blame the HF for this, there's only one man to blame, the first CPFC chairman to drive a wedge through Palace fans.

 


Zaha, Williams, Murray, Ambrose, Scannell.

A 5-man forward line who scored 3 goals in 10 minutes on 27th September 2011 at .......................

bicycle repair man 01 Nov 18 3.29pm

Originally posted by PalacePhotoMan

"Forced out", sonny Jim. Forced out.

As of yet we haven't been "shifted" anywhere. They don't know where they're shifting us to yet. They've not worked it out. 400 seats in a ground with 92% season ticket renewals isn't an easy one to fix, poor loves.

And I may sit in E Block but I don't yet have a "thermos and blanket". Or a prawn sandwich.

I don't blame the HF for this, there's only one man to blame, the first CPFC chairman to drive a wedge through Palace fans.


Yes there are a lot of cheap jibes from the HF mob,aimed at fellow Palace fans.
Parish has shown great weakness in caving in to their demands.
I wonder if he had turned them down what the HF would have done,would these diehard "fanatics" have flounced off completely.

 

Sansbup Flag Norfolk 01 Nov 18 4.46pm

I don't personally know any of the HF or any of the fans that may be displaced by the current initiative. What I do know is that our fans have never been noisier nor the atmosphere better at Selhurst since the HF started doing their thing. They are currently greatly missed, although last weekend's effort to organise fans in the Arthur was fairly good.

[Link]

When I watch videos such as this I'm very proud of what the fans have done, and I'm proud to be associated with this club. I've been going to Selhurst since 1967 and what the HF have achieved over the past few years is better by miles than anything previously. The displays are excellent and would not have happened without the HF, even though many others participate, obviously.

So I can see a great future ahead once the HF are relocated into the middle of the lower Holmesdale, as it's fair to assume that the displays will only get bigger and better. I think it's crazy to say that the HF are an embarrassment, other fans are just jealous of what we have (when it's good).

Yes, I do feel sorry for the fans that need to move to allow this development to happen, and the club needs to do everything it can to accommodate them wherever they wish to go, but nobody is forcing them out, just asking them to move. Or they can stay and join in with the HF.

 

bicycle repair man 01 Nov 18 5.18pm

Originally posted by Sansbup

I don't personally know any of the HF or any of the fans that may be displaced by the current initiative. What I do know is that our fans have never been noisier nor the atmosphere better at Selhurst since the HF started doing their thing. They are currently greatly missed, although last weekend's effort to organise fans in the Arthur was fairly good.

[Link]

When I watch videos such as this I'm very proud of what the fans have done, and I'm proud to be associated with this club. I've been going to Selhurst since 1967 and what the HF have achieved over the past few years is better by miles than anything previously. The displays are excellent and would not have happened without the HF, even though many others participate, obviously.

So I can see a great future ahead once the HF are relocated into the middle of the lower Holmesdale, as it's fair to assume that the displays will only get bigger and better. I think it's crazy to say that the HF are an embarrassment, other fans are just jealous of what we have (when it's good).

Yes, I do feel sorry for the fans that need to move to allow this development to happen, and the club needs to do everything it can to accommodate them wherever they wish to go, but nobody is forcing them out, just asking them to move. Or they can stay and join in with the HF.


"Just asking them to move"???
Like they have a choice.
I would dispute the fact Palace fans have never been noisier.There has been plenty of noise during our various play off campaigns, and relegation battles,pre HF.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 01 Nov 18 5.42pm

Originally posted by bicycle repair man


"Just asking them to move"???
Like they have a choice.
I would dispute the fact Palace fans have never been noisier.There has been plenty of noise during our various play off campaigns, and relegation battles,pre HF.

Play off campaigns are different and there isn’t one in this division, and may not be many if we do get relegated.

Relegation battles in our all seater Selhurst did not rival the noise started by the HF and everyone joining in. The loudest noise you got was ‘’Sidddaaaaaaan.’’

The Arthur enclosure had a great atmosphere. Once it was seated in August 1990 the atmosphere died at Selhurst. We had a great season after it was seated, starting with Chelsea midweek, and us finishing 3rd, because the team only needed 2-3 additions to make it really good. Ray, his brother, a few more and some others at the back tried but it wouldn’t rival Whyteleafe for noise. A few away fans would get a slap and a bl00dy face if they got too close but it wasn’t noisy.

All seated stadia need organised groups to get an atmosphere. They had it and a drum at Spurs if you didn’t know.

 


COYP

bicycle repair man 01 Nov 18 6.08pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Play off campaigns are different and there isn’t one in this division, and may not be many if we do get relegated.

Relegation battles in our all seater Selhurst did not rival the noise started by the HF and everyone joining in. The loudest noise you got was ‘’Sidddaaaaaaan.’’

The Arthur enclosure had a great atmosphere. Once it was seated in August 1990 the atmosphere died at Selhurst. We had a great season after it was seated, starting with Chelsea midweek, and us finishing 3rd, because the team only needed 2-3 additions to make it really good. Ray, his brother, a few more and some others at the back tried but it wouldn’t rival Whyteleafe for noise. A few away fans would get a slap and a bl00dy face if they got too close but it wasn’t noisy.

All seated stadia need organised groups to get an atmosphere. They had it and a drum at Spurs if you didn’t know.


You do have a tendency to ramble on,who on earth is Ray ? And what is Whyteleafe ?
And I don't need organising into a group, or someone to bang a drum to enhance my matchday experience,that all sounds so contrived.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 01 Nov 18 6.16pm

Originally posted by bicycle repair man


You do have a tendency to ramble on,who on earth is Ray ? And what is Whyteleafe ?
And I don't need organising into a group, or someone to bang a drum to enhance my matchday experience,that all sounds so contrived.

Each to their own, but loads do. If you want to sit there, ‘making a right racket, sat down’’, with your arms folded, good luck to you.

 


COYP

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 01 Nov 18 6.51pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Each to their own, but loads do. If you want to sit there, ‘making a right racket, sat down’’, with your arms folded, good luck to you.

who is Ray though. it's a fair question.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 01 Nov 18 8.09pm

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

who is Ray though. it's a fair question.

Who are you? The plod?

 


COYP

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 01 Nov 18 8.42pm

Originally posted by Willo

In my humble opinion, the HF made a calculated decision not to continue as before on the basis that their support would be missed by the club, giving them the leverage to get what they want.

The narrative appears to be that the HF have thrown toys out of pram by their actions,forced the hand of Steve Parish, got what they desired and as a result forced out loyal and long-standing season ticket holders and this whole matter has proved very divisive amongst our fan base.

I think this is about spot on Willo. They clearly are missed. Well done for them for being ballsy about it and giving up their season tickets. Clearly it will divide fans but for the long run it’s the best for the club. The majority are happy.

I for one can’t wait for next season. For what it’s worth, I’ve recently started a new job and one of the guys in the office is part of the HF (more fringe really). He tells me they are still attending but are spread out now. Effectively they’re supporting the team the same way as everyone else now.

 

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 01 Nov 18 11.00pm

Originally posted by Willo

In my humble opinion, the HF made a calculated decision not to continue as before on the basis that their support would be missed by the club, giving them the leverage to get what they want.

The narrative appears to be that the HF have thrown toys out of pram by their actions,forced the hand of Steve Parish, got what they desired and as a result forced out loyal and long-standing season ticket holders and this whole matter has proved very divisive amongst our fan base.

Which is pretty much what i said underneath what you had put in bold.

 


This was once a quality forum....

bicycle repair man 01 Nov 18 11.23pm

So it seems the Holmesdale Fanatics/Ultras
are only prepared to be Fanatics/Ultras if they get the best seats in the Lower Holmesdale.
And are happy to put Palace's current campaign at risk, because in their view the players really need the "atmosphere" they create to win points at Selhurst Park.So they are willing to risk Palace getting relegated to get their own way !
In my 50 years of attending Selhurst Park this is the most bizarre way of showing support for the Palace I have ever known.
Also I am curious as to how they can say they have the backing of the vast majority of supporters, where's the proof, apart from the comedy petition.

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 02 Nov 18 6.38am

Originally posted by bicycle repair man

So it seems the Holmesdale Fanatics/Ultras
are only prepared to be Fanatics/Ultras if they get the best seats in the Lower Holmesdale.
And are happy to put Palace's current campaign at risk, because in their view the players really need the "atmosphere" they create to win points at Selhurst Park.So they are willing to risk Palace getting relegated to get their own way !
In my 50 years of attending Selhurst Park this is the most bizarre way of showing support for the Palace I have ever known.
Also I am curious as to how they can say they have the backing of the vast majority of supporters, where's the proof, apart from the comedy petition.

Even the seriously compromised petition, taken at face value,like this and any other supporter's site, does not represent anything like the "majority of supporters". None of them represent anything more than a tiny minority (albeit more than the very tiny minority the HF represent) of the total support.

A survey by the club of existing ST holders would have been a more accurate gauge of real opinion, but Parish has demonstrated beyond doubt that he has no interest in the views of loyal supporters that don't fit with his own warped view of 'support'.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 02 Nov 18 6.40am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Who are you? The plod?

Barnacle Bill the sailor

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 02 Nov 18 7.00am

Parish has shown he can panic and get himself into an utter bind in trying to do what he thinks is best for the club. I bet he's full of private regret for the pig's ear he's made of it in terms of process, communication & fact finding.

I do believe a singing section -- next season -- would have majority support. But clearly nobody truly knows what most fans would like. And it would be excruciating for there to be a survey now.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 02 Nov 18 8.48am

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

Parish has shown he can panic and get himself into an utter bind in trying to do what he thinks is best for the club. I bet he's full of private regret for the pig's ear he's made of it in terms of process, communication & fact finding.

I do believe a singing section -- next season -- would have majority support. But clearly nobody truly knows what most fans would like. And it would be excruciating for there to be a survey now.

I believe the issue is not about whether a 'Singing section' has majority support, there is disquiet about the actions of the HF and the club.

I suspect the fact that they have decided not to continue in their current form in Block B is viewed as them throwing a strop and 'Going on strike' trying to force the hand of the club, getting what they want and in doing so resulting in scores of loyal season-ticket holders,having to give up their seats many of whom have probably had them for many a year.Not forgetting that those in adjacent blocks might have their sight lines affected by the persistent standing of the HF which is against ground regulations and which the club does not enforce in this instance.

There are many long-term season ticket holders at Selhurst Park and they cannot abide their fellow supporters having to be 'Evicted' in such circumstances.

I get the impression that perhaps many view the HF as attendees who have leapt on to a bandwagon and whose numbers would greatly decrease should the club be relegated whilst loyal supporters would continue to renew their tickets as they have done season on season.They might be wrong of course.

One suspects that supporters have no objection to parts of the ground where support is highly visible and vocal, they are simply in a lather about the circumstances surrounding the latest events for the reasons I have highlighted above.

Edited by Willo (02 Nov 2018 10.29am)

 

Page 27 of 71 < 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Topic