You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Gaza Strip 'invades' Israel.
November 21 2026 11.03pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Gaza Strip 'invades' Israel.


Page 27 of 140 < 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 >
Mapletree Flag Croydon 19 Oct 23 1.54pm

Originally posted by YT

It's not the first time it's happened, but it's a relatively new - and interesting - way to wage war. Basically bomb your own side, swear blind that the enemy did it and wait for the bigoted and the gullible to fall in line. It reminds me of Ed Norton's character beating himself up in 'Fight Club'.

This is feasible. Albeit I suspect cock-up not conspiracy. The story that it was a rocket launched by Islamic Jihad and not Hamas may have some truth. Or may not.

The idea that nobody got hurt etc. is just so laughable, all the mainstream media accept there was a major loss of life. It is awful that innocents get caught up in these things. The 'warriors' give little impression of caring on both sides.

I don't think people should be allowed to blaspheme on this hallowed site.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards georgenorman Flag 19 Oct 23 1.58pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

This is feasible. Albeit I suspect cock-up not conspiracy. The story that it was a rocket launched by Islamic Jihad and not Hamas may have some truth. Or may not.

The idea that nobody got hurt etc. is just so laughable, all the mainstream media accept there was a major loss of life. It is awful that innocents get caught up in these things. The 'warriors' give little impression of caring on both sides.

I don't think people should be allowed to blaspheme on this hallowed site.

Are there any images of the damaged hospital building rather than burned out cars in a car park?

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 19 Oct 23 1.59pm

Originally posted by YT

It's not the first time it's happened, but it's a relatively new - and interesting - way to wage war. Basically bomb your own side, swear blind that the enemy did it and wait for the bigoted and the gullible to fall in line. It reminds me of Ed Norton's character beating himself up in 'Fight Club'.

Great analogy! I'd consider it reminiscent of a child causing themselves harm before running to a parent to land a sibling in trouble.

If this is of course true, and I only say this as you can't be sure of anything these days, it demonstrates the extent to which individuals are willing to so nonchalantly dispose of human life to further a political or otherwise cause, even if the chance of success is minimal and the consequences as awful as you can imagine. Horrendous.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Stirlingsays Flag 19 Oct 23 2.02pm

Originally posted by YT

It's not the first time it's happened, but it's a relatively new - and interesting - way to wage war. Basically bomb your own side, swear blind that the enemy did it and wait for the bigoted and the gullible to fall in line. It reminds me of Ed Norton's character beating himself up in 'Fight Club'.

I know....I don't think Ukraine need any help personally because apparently Russia bombed its own pipeline, bombed its own dam and attacked its own nuclear installation.

Perhaps if we stay out of it the Russians will do the job themselves like the Judean People's Front, Suicide Squad from Life of Brian.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Mapletree Flag Croydon 19 Oct 23 2.09pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

I know....I don't think Ukraine need any help personally because apparently Russia bombed its own pipeline, bombed its own dam and attacked its own nuclear installation.

Perhaps if we stay out of it the Russians will do the job themselves like the Judean People's Front, Suicide Squad from Life of Brian.

But what of The People's Front of Judea?

It's important to remember that these groups represent two very different ideologies and that cohabitation or cooperation wasn't tangible in the long run. While they both strived for the total deconstruction of the imperialist Roman state and all its power structures, they vastly differed in their opinions on what the Romans really did for them. You could say that the PFJ was much more aware of the positive effects the Romans had on the Judean region. Don't be mistaken though, they truly hated the Romans. I mean, they didn't just hate them like everyone else, they hated them a lot. So despite their recognition of Roman improvements, they were still actively sabotaging the Roman government.

That being said, the PFJ explicitly recognized Roman improvements in various areas. One prime example were the aquaducts and sanitation. Unlike most members of the JPF, the leader of the PFJ clearly remembered what the city used to be like before the Romans came into power, suffice it to say that he never wavered on this particular point. It didn't stop there though, the roads go without saying, but there were many more Roman improvements that were actively recognized as such by the PFJ. They were also very vocal and positive about the Roman wine, medicine, public health and irrigation. Most of all, they recognized the fact that the Roman military was probably one of the only known organizations capable of maintaining public order in a place like that. However, despite all of this, they still hated the Romans a lot and often raised the question as to what the Romans had ever done for them.

In contrast, the JPF never even acknowledged these improvements and they were a lot more linear in their thinking. To them anything Roman was despicable. Both ideologies were very uncompromising and this ultimatly led to the split between both parties. You could say that the PFJ was a lot less radical in their ideology, even though their actions say otherwise.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 19 Oct 23 2.15pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

But what of The People's Front of Judea?

It's important to remember that these groups represent two very different ideologies and that cohabitation or cooperation wasn't tangible in the long run. While they both strived for the total deconstruction of the imperialist Roman state and all its power structures, they vastly differed in their opinions on what the Romans really did for them. You could say that the PFJ was much more aware of the positive effects the Romans had on the Judean region. Don't be mistaken though, they truly hated the Romans. I mean, they didn't just hate them like everyone else, they hated them a lot. So despite their recognition of Roman improvements, they were still actively sabotaging the Roman government.

That being said, the PFJ explicitly recognized Roman improvements in various areas. One prime example were the aquaducts and sanitation. Unlike most members of the JPF, the leader of the PFJ clearly remembered what the city used to be like before the Romans came into power, suffice it to say that he never wavered on this particular point. It didn't stop there though, the roads go without saying, but there were many more Roman improvements that were actively recognized as such by the PFJ. They were also very vocal and positive about the Roman wine, medicine, public health and irrigation. Most of all, they recognized the fact that the Roman military was probably one of the only known organizations capable of maintaining public order in a place like that. However, despite all of this, they still hated the Romans a lot and often raised the question as to what the Romans had ever done for them.

In contrast, the JPF never even acknowledged these improvements and they were a lot more linear in their thinking. To them anything Roman was despicable. Both ideologies were very uncompromising and this ultimatly led to the split between both parties. You could say that the PFJ was a lot less radical in their ideology, even though their actions say otherwise.

Splitter!

Edited by Stirlingsays (19 Oct 2023 2.54pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Sheks Crows Eye Flag Virginia 19 Oct 23 2.16pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Obviously I'm a harsh critic of that part of the world and cultures that I view as incompatible (outside of secular versions) with the west....well in terms of cheek by jowl anyway.

However, that doesn't mean I don't respect their right to practice their cultures within their own countries....I very much believe in 'when in Rome' as a matter of respect.

However, I want to address this idea that Arabs don't care about the Palestinians because actually....while some element of that is fair it's also very harsh when seen in its totality.

Look at what actually happened....Since before 48 the reality is that the Arab world has collectively taken millions of Palestinians as refugees from Palestine. They are still there now.....they couldn't go back.

Those people need to be feed and affected poor economies significantly. This isn't 'not caring'.

Also, the Arabs literally shed blood in three wars trying to take back a foreign land for the Palestinians. I don't really think it's fair to say to all those dead Arabs that they didn't care.

Lastly I'd make the point that the Palestinians are largely a radicalised people.....Egypt, a country which has a significant population of Palestinians, does not appreciate the problems caused by having a population that agitates against relations with Israel..even more than its own Muslims....all this affects many other aspects....they take money from the US for example....tourism matters...stability matters, because that's linked to investment...at the moment they are being pulled in all directions and it causes them significant internal problems.

Edited by Stirlingsays (19 Oct 2023 1.55pm)

Strong points and I'll add that Hamas is a Muslim brotherhood offshoot, which recently Egypt's military overthrew in the past decade after their first "free and fair" elections, since then many members of the Muslim Brotherhood were sentenced to death.

Totally agree on the radicalization comment as well, I recently read an old poll from 2013 which demonstrated this: [Link]

I don’t have a stunning conclusion to offer other than “peace in the Middle East seems like a hard problem.”

But even though that conclusion sounds banal, I do think it’s important. As it happens, Palestinian rights are defined in this discourse in a way that Israelis understand as being incompatible with the fundamental existence of their country. That makes the problem much thornier than if it were just a dispute about the exact borders of a Palestinian state. In the west, we frequently see a politics of pure position-taking around this.
You can become a good progressive ally by espousing certain slogans at the cost of alienating yourself from mainstream Jewish institutions or vice-versa. But none of that amounts to a practical strategy for resolving anything. All kinds of countries all over the world mount fierce resistance to the idea of dramatically revising their immigration policies to permit much larger uncontrolled inflows, over and above the specific historical factors at play. Of course if Israelis had totally different opinions from the opinions they actually hold, this might be a relatively easy problem to fix. And by the same token, if the nature of the Palestinian Cause were defined differently, then the problem of improving Palestinians’ lives and welfare would likely also be much easier to solve. Given the actual configuration of views, though, it’s a very challenging situation. And if you don’t acknowledge how hard the underlying problem is, you’re likely to end up underrating the behavior of various third parties — when in fact it really just is a hard issue.

I'll repeat what I said in a previous post from yesterday:

The recent attack by Hamas has shocked the current conflict out of the now default war of choice framework and made it clearly a war of necessity. I expect Israel to do whatever it takes to at the very least either dismantle Hamas or establish a buffer zone between itself and the people of Gaza. If it does not, the problem will fester, and the Israelis will find themselves in the exact same position a few years down the line. It would be nice to believe that the Palestinian conflict could be solved by the stronger side being more accommodating towards its enemy. But there is little in the history of warfare, and certainly nothing in the doctrine of Hamas, to suggest this is a viable path forward. The choice faced by Israel is a tragic one, no matter how much in denial those currently calling for restraint are about this fact.


Apologies for snark in previous posts towards one of the users, but when something has been debunked for 36 hours now, it is a little maddening.

 

Sheks Crows Eye Flag Virginia 19 Oct 23 2.38pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

But what of The People's Front of Judea?

It's important to remember that these groups represent two very different ideologies and that cohabitation or cooperation wasn't tangible in the long run. While they both strived for the total deconstruction of the imperialist Roman state and all its power structures, they vastly differed in their opinions on what the Romans really did for them. You could say that the PFJ was much more aware of the positive effects the Romans had on the Judean region. Don't be mistaken though, they truly hated the Romans. I mean, they didn't just hate them like everyone else, they hated them a lot. So despite their recognition of Roman improvements, they were still actively sabotaging the Roman government.

That being said, the PFJ explicitly recognized Roman improvements in various areas. One prime example were the aquaducts and sanitation. Unlike most members of the JPF, the leader of the PFJ clearly remembered what the city used to be like before the Romans came into power, suffice it to say that he never wavered on this particular point. It didn't stop there though, the roads go without saying, but there were many more Roman improvements that were actively recognized as such by the PFJ. They were also very vocal and positive about the Roman wine, medicine, public health and irrigation. Most of all, they recognized the fact that the Roman military was probably one of the only known organizations capable of maintaining public order in a place like that. However, despite all of this, they still hated the Romans a lot and often raised the question as to what the Romans had ever done for them.

In contrast, the JPF never even acknowledged these improvements and they were a lot more linear in their thinking. To them anything Roman was despicable. Both ideologies were very uncompromising and this ultimatly led to the split between both parties. You could say that the PFJ was a lot less radical in their ideology, even though their actions say otherwise.

This was very interesting, thank you for sharing.

 

Sheks Crows Eye Flag Virginia 19 Oct 23 2.39pm


Not promising.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 19 Oct 23 2.40pm

Originally posted by Sheks Crows Eye

Strong points and I'll add that Hamas is a Muslim brotherhood offshoot, which recently Egypt's military overthrew in the past decade after their first "free and fair" elections, since then many members of the Muslim Brotherhood were sentenced to death.

It's a good point.

To look wryly at it Egypt is a bit like Godfather 3, 'everytime i think i'm out they pull me back in'.

Originally posted by Sheks Crows Eye

Totally agree on the radicalization comment as well, I recently read an old poll from 2013 which demonstrated this: [Link]

I don’t have a stunning conclusion to offer other than “peace in the Middle East seems like a hard problem.”

But even though that conclusion sounds banal, I do think it’s important. As it happens, Palestinian rights are defined in this discourse in a way that Israelis understand as being incompatible with the fundamental existence of their country. That makes the problem much thornier than if it were just a dispute about the exact borders of a Palestinian state. In the west, we frequently see a politics of pure position-taking around this.
You can become a good progressive ally by espousing certain slogans at the cost of alienating yourself from mainstream Jewish institutions or vice-versa. But none of that amounts to a practical strategy for resolving anything. All kinds of countries all over the world mount fierce resistance to the idea of dramatically revising their immigration policies to permit much larger uncontrolled inflows, over and above the specific historical factors at play. Of course if Israelis had totally different opinions from the opinions they actually hold, this might be a relatively easy problem to fix. And by the same token, if the nature of the Palestinian Cause were defined differently, then the problem of improving Palestinians’ lives and welfare would likely also be much easier to solve. Given the actual configuration of views, though, it’s a very challenging situation. And if you don’t acknowledge how hard the underlying problem is, you’re likely to end up underrating the behavior of various third parties — when in fact it really just is a hard issue.

I'll repeat what I said in a previous post from yesterday:

The recent attack by Hamas has shocked the current conflict out of the now default war of choice framework and made it clearly a war of necessity. I expect Israel to do whatever it takes to at the very least either dismantle Hamas or establish a buffer zone between itself and the people of Gaza. If it does not, the problem will fester, and the Israelis will find themselves in the exact same position a few years down the line. It would be nice to believe that the Palestinian conflict could be solved by the stronger side being more accommodating towards its enemy. But there is little in the history of warfare, and certainly nothing in the doctrine of Hamas, to suggest this is a viable path forward. The choice faced by Israel is a tragic one, no matter how much in denial those currently calling for restraint are about this fact.


Apologies for snark in previous posts towards one of the users, but when something has been debunked for 36 hours now, it is a little maddening.

I think you correctly imply what most of us feel is going to be the end result.....a bloodbath in Gaza and who knows what the end result will be if Hezbollah and Iran and groups from the Arab world join in....because I'd be highly surprised if a few thousand haven't already traveled in for the confrontation.
If I were a Jew or Muslim in that land I'd want to be tooled up because none of us are sure how deep this will go.

Where will the civilians in Gaza go? Who is going to pay for it. No doubt all this has been discussed over the last week or so.

I feel genuine sadness over the whole thing.

Edited by Stirlingsays (19 Oct 2023 2.43pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

dreamwaverider Flag London 19 Oct 23 3.56pm

Originally posted by Sheks Crows Eye

Hamas simply has a much better propaganda game.

You can tell that Hamas understands what the useful idiots in the Western audience of academics, libs, and journos wants.

"This guy doesn’t get us. We don’t want someone clear or matter of fact. We’re numb and have boiled our brains. We want dopamine."

I thought Fentanyl was USA's number one brain cooler.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 19 Oct 23 3.57pm

Originally posted by silvertop

You have better arguments to run than that. 471 dead and counting. Do you think every government on the planet would be commenting if it was only a fire cracker in a car park.

Where do you get those numbers from?

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards georgenorman Flag 19 Oct 23 4.02pm

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

Where do you get those numbers from?

He probably got them from a seance with Yasser Arafat.

Edited by georgenorman (19 Oct 2023 4.02pm)

 

Stirlingsays Flag 19 Oct 23 4.57pm

Originally posted by georgenorman

He probably got them from a seance with Yasser Arafat.

Edited by georgenorman (19 Oct 2023 4.02pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

cryrst Flag The garden of England 19 Oct 23 6.07pm

Originally posted by glazedallover

along with 'when that's proven' numbnuts.

How’s the pie

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 19 Oct 23 6.11pm

Originally posted by cryrst

How’s the pie

 

Stirlingsays Flag 19 Oct 23 7.03pm

Israel is evacuating its diplomatic missions throughout the Middle East....including Turkey....it's coming soon boys.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stirlingsays Flag 19 Oct 23 7.33pm

They are definitely going in....Mind you....apparently the average age of a Gazan is 17. Half of them are children.

I couldn't do it, I wouldn't be killing children for nobody.

Edited by Stirlingsays (19 Oct 2023 7.34pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 19 Oct 23 7.56pm

I really hate the fact that we have to ally ourselves with these ruthless b******s, but the other 'team' would kill us all if they could.

Killing children? It's monstrous.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 19 Oct 23 8.01pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

I really hate the fact that we have to ally ourselves with these ruthless b******s, but the other 'team' would kill us all if they could.

Killing children? It's monstrous.


It's true, neither of them are our friends.

Palestinians are Arabs and their people.

But children.....How any of them kill children breaks me up.

All these murderers of innocents on both sides can go to hell.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Page 27 of 140 < 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Gaza Strip 'invades' Israel.