This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
Only the Biden administration would have been stupid enough to push Russia into China's arms.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Benz on the Ukraine/censorship/misinformation industry.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by imashed
We are so ill prepared if anything like that happened on our doorstep . We can't even stop a dingy no matter the Russian or Chinese army .
There's never been a threat of an invasion, what we are now at threat from is missile attack and/or terrorism....more expensive energy and food over time. Because apparently who owns the Donbas is really important to us and is our business... Edited by Stirlingsays (13 Jul 2024 11.49am)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Let’s indeed deal with the word “appeasement “ before it gets even more misrepresented here. The Cambridge Dictionary defines it as:- “ the act of giving the opposing side in an argument or war an advantage that they have demanded, in order to prevent further disagreement “. Dictionary.com is even clearer:- “ the policy of acceding to the demands of a potentially hostile nation in the hope of maintaining peace” So not negotiations during or after a war, or after a tactical withdrawal. It’s handing something to an opponent that they don’t deserve so as to avoid a fight. Something generally done before shots are fired, in response to threats. Cambridge uses this as an example:- “A policy of appeasement is counterproductive with dictators.” Think about that. They aren’t my words. No one wants to beat Russia. That’s a very stupid idea. They want to deter and contain Russian expansionism. No one is the west that I am aware of has any interest in occupying an inch of Russia. Appeasing Putin, which is exactly what is being suggested should have happened, would ultimately resulted in a very bad situation being even worse. Of course Ukraine could not have managed alone. Of course the cost has been very high. Pointing these things out doesn’t change the facts. Not liking the cost of having to restrain Putin is Trumplike thinking. It is short term expediency. Passing the bill onto those who follow, so you can stay in power today. It’s not leadership. It’s selfishness. It demonstrates the paucity of populism. There was always going to be an element of compromise unless Ukraine outright defeats Russia. That wouldn't be appeasement - it would be a way to end the war. Hopefully, largely accepted by both sides. What you're not taking into account is there are genuinely regions of Ukraine that would be majority Russian. And then there's the history of Sevastopol and the Crimea. I don't know how people in the Crimea tend to identify themselves but I get the feeling there's a large Russian population.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
There was always going to be an element of compromise unless Ukraine outright defeats Russia. That wouldn't be appeasement - it would be a way to end the war. Hopefully, largely accepted by both sides. What you're not taking into account is there are genuinely regions of Ukraine that would be majority Russian. And then there's the history of Sevastopol and the Crimea. I don't know how people in the Crimea tend to identify themselves but I get the feeling there's a large Russian population. No one is suggesting otherwise. It’s a negotiation. Appeasement involves just giving in to the threats. It’s being argued here as a tactic that would have avoided all the pain and suffering of the last 2 years, when the probability is that it would have resulted in the whole of Ukraine being occupied. Which Ukraine fiercely wanted to resist. That would then have threatened similar expansion into other countries and put the Russians on the border of Western Europe. Now we can negotiate, create agreed buffer zones with inspection obligations and keep the bear at arms length. It’s not ideal. It could fail. But it’s a better outcome than appeasement. With someone like Putin there cannot be certainty. The risk to us now being the highest since the Cuban crisis. None of that is in doubt. Nor though, it seems to me, is that trying to appease a dictator is counter productive. As to evidence of Putin’s unreliability you only have to look at his record. He sees compromise as weakness and weakness as opportunity to be exploited.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Putin's military in 2022 was significantly smaller than in 2024! So what does that prove? If there had been a settlement in 2022 it could well have been even bigger now, without suffering the losses imposed on it. We know it’s been costly. That’s neither doubted nor the right question. The right question is whether the ultimate cost would have been higher, or lower. Not the relatively short term one. Were DMZs on offer in 2022 or was Putin simply demanding control of the land east of the Dnipro? Maybe it was refused without an agreement for DMZs? From all I have read Putin was only prepared to deal on his terms. No one could accept that with Putin. To agree would have been 100% appeasement. So who really was responsible for those talks failing? It was just window dressing. Maybe now it will be different. Maybe not. A lot depends on what happens in the USA in November. It proves that if his intention was to invade multiple countries then he would have had to have a much larger force to succeed. Ukraine's army was already the largest in Europe at that time and had been fortifying with mainly US input since 2014. So the idea that Putin had other ambitions over Ukraine has zero evidence for it. He is essentially saying what he warned about back in 2008....Oliver Stone made a film about it. People just decide to memory hole it. Sure, both sides can build up after a settlement....but apparently you only see losses on one side? Once again, the question has to be put to you, who are these non Ukrainian troops that you think should be paying the blood price here? Because I have to be frank....the will to fight for the donbas isn't there lad. Maybe some Poles and heritage slavs, but most of them have gone there and many have died already. The deal out on offer is available if you want to look for it. Putin has stated those terms won't be available again....I guess with a Trump presidency we will see, but I can't see Ukraine getting any of the south and east back....the recent northern front, perhaps. Negotiations I imagine would be protracted though. Any peace with Russia should first come via a referendum in Ukraine....the first piece of democracy they would have been allowed...but Blinken will have to be gone first. The Russians are currently doing very well on the battlefield and Ukraine's army is mostly mobilised and civilian. As usual the media isn't being honest about the situation and only releases bits and pieces. No one seems to understand what it would take to significantly push back the Russians at this point. They are fully committed with a war economy and very little trust is going about. Edited by Stirlingsays (22 Jul 2024 11.18am)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
It proves that if his intention was to invade multiple countries then he would have had to have a much larger force to succeed. Ukraine's army was already the largest in Europe at that time and had been fortifying with mainly US input since 2014. So the idea that Putin had other ambitions over Ukraine has zero evidence for it. He is essentially saying what he warned about back in 2008....Oliver Stone made a film about it. People just decide to memory hole it. Sure, both sides can build up after a settlement....but apparently you only see losses on one side? Once again, the question has to be put to you, who are these non Ukrainian troops that you think should be paying the blood price here? Because I have to be frank....the will to fight for the donbas isn't there lad. Maybe some Poles and heritage slavs, but most of them have gone there and many have died already. The deal out on offer is available if you want to look for it. Putin has stated those terms won't be available again....I guess with a Trump presidency we will see, but I can't see Ukraine getting any of the south and east back....the recent northern front, perhaps. Negotiations I imagine would be protracted though. Any peace with Russia should first come via a referendum in Ukraine....the first piece of democracy they would have been allowed...but Blinken will have to be gone first. The Russians are currently doing very well on the battlefield and Ukraine's army is mostly mobilised and civilian. As usual the media isn't being honest about the situation and only releases bits and pieces. No one seems to understand what it would take to significantly push back the Russians at this point. They are fully committed with a war economy and very little trust is going about. Edited by Stirlingsays (22 Jul 2024 11.18am) And many over here or elsewhere in Europe rather than fighting for their own country.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
And many over here or elsewhere in Europe rather than fighting for their own country. True, though it should be remembered that Ukraine has always had a considerable amount of Russian influence. Some of those over here would be more more Putin than Zelensky. You have to believe in what you are fighting for....mobilised armies contain gang pressing. On the front if you don't fight and run off you have the risk of being shot. If you don't agree with a particular war it makes sense to avoid it. Nationalism in the west, even the concept of the nation state, has been deliberately attacked for decades. I have to say, it's almost amusing to now see western leaders in military uniform. What can they say to youth to sign up? What are they fighting for exactly? DEI? Yeah, that's not going to go well. Edited by Stirlingsays (22 Jul 2024 12.47pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Zelenski finally making noises about negotiations with russia and peace knowing full well the gravy train will end soon when trump gets into the white house.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.