You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Topic
November 22 2026 1.49am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

ukip (LOCKED)


Page 28 of 187 < 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 >
SloveniaDave Flag Tirana, Albania 15 May 14 10.05pm

Quote kangel at 15 May 2014 6.42pm

Quote SloveniaDave at 15 May 2014 6.22pm

Quote kangel at 15 May 2014 5.24pm

Quote SloveniaDave at 15 May 2014 3.24pm

Quote kangel at 15 May 2014 10.46am

Quote SloveniaDave at 15 May 2014 10.17am

Quote Penge Eagle at 15 May 2014 9.59am

Quote The White Horse at 14 May 2014 11.45pm

Quote Penge Eagle at 14 May 2014 11.42pm

I think White Horse and Nick totally miss the point, and as ever, move the goal posts.

The UKIP argument is that the UK should be in charge of controlling our borders, with an emphasis of quality, not quantity.

At the moment, having the EU in charge allows the opposite - which you clearly prefer! And it also disregards high quality professionals from places like India or Australia.

Edited by Penge Eagle (14 May 2014 11.44pm)

Lets compromise on a third option.

What do you think to nobody controlling our borders...

To White Horse, question for you...

Would you prefer to have totally unrestricted immigration and just limited to Europeans? All the rules made by bureaucrats in Belgium who have no real interest in the UK.

OR

Controlled immigration with people seeking asylum and immigrants who can fill certain job shortages that will benefit the country. Rules decided by our MPs in London and can easily held accountable. Having CONTROL ensures the balance between numbers and the impact on infrastructure and social aspects.

Edited by Penge Eagle (15 May 2014 10.00am)


The principle of the free movement of people, goods, services and money within the EU is a basic concept that has been agreed by all members, including the UK. It is not something made up by bureaucrats in Brussels. They only really get involved where member states do not comply.

Although this results in economic migration within the EU, which causes some problems, I am convinced that the overall benefits associated with it far outweigh the problems

The same principle which allows other EU nationals to come to the UK is also the one which allows the Nissan plant in Sunderland to export hundreds of thousands of cars throughout Europe with no restrictions.


What are the problems you are referring to?


You want me to explain what problems are associated with immigration? I would have thought that was fairly obvious in general terms.

There are a number, some of which are real, some perceived and some depend on the time and the way in which it happens.

As you admit that there a number of problems. If you could actually name them, then we could go on to discuss how big these problems need to become before the problems outweigh the benefits.

As for the Nissan plant in Sunderland, if they produce products that people want to buy, then they will still export hundreds of thousands of cars throughout Europe, whether we are in the EU or not.

Edited by kangel (15 May 2014 5.57pm)

My point is that you should not try to look at the problem in isolation but look at the bigger picture. Nissan will not sell UK-built cars in Europe if Europe puts up tariff barriers against us, in the same way that workers will not be able to move freely if we impose caps or restrictions.

The main problem with immigration in the UK, at the present time, is that people do not see the bigger picture and simply want to have their cake and eat it.

Not sure why you are so coy in not naming the 'number of problems' that you are aware of. Tariff barriers eventually fail as the market reasserts itself, people get fed up driving Moskvich-type cars produced in tariff-ridden 'planned' economies, when they could buy things they want. As for the 'bigger picture', I think many, many people in the UK are all too well aware of it, and will vote accordingly in the imminent EU elections (despite the undemocratic nature of these elections). We don't want the cake, we want control of the bakery back.


Edited by kangel (15 May 2014 7.04pm)


Nothing coy at all, I just assumed that everyone already knows what the issues are. The only question is the extent of their actual impact and then comparing them with other issues which flow from the free movement of people, goods, services and capital.

Of course you can try to go for a model which allows for the free movement of just goods and services but not people and capital but it would be a half-baked system which would not work in the long term so you have to decide if you want the full pie or none of it.

The problems with free movement of people is that you get economic migration. This has an impact on the receiving countries in terms of ethnic differences/tensions (including actual and latent racism but also very legitimate concerns about different cultures, religions and lifestyles), people prepared to work for less than the local population and overstretch on local services.

Are those problems actually that insoluble? No.

Are they actually major problems? Only if you choose to make them major.

Are they a price worth paying for all the other benefits? Absolutely

The option of course remains to leave the EU, pull up the drawbridge and act like little England. But if you raise your sights a little, realize that the UK has only become what it is now because we were the world's pre-eminent traders and migrators, then you accept that, on balance, migration and trade are a good thing and make the best of it.

 


Just because I don't care doesn't mean I don't understand!

My opinions may have changed, but not the fact that I am right.

(Member of the School of Optimism 1969-2016 inclusive)

TUX Flag redhill 15 May 14 10.12pm

I think the most worrying thing about the whole EU malarkey is the lack of real information rather than the half truths and misinformation put out by the press.
----------------------

Nick...................I think the most worrying thing is that non of the electorate vote for them. A saving grace if you happen to be N. Kinnock esq. (Along with many more I'm sure).

The whole thing is a complete farce.

 

matt_himself Flag Matataland 15 May 14 10.33pm

It is great to see that the left wing are respecting democracy...

[Link]

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

Stirlingsays Flag 15 May 14 10.41pm

Quote nickgusset at 15 May 2014 9.11pm

I'd vote for Windsor Davies.

Lovely Boy.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

kangel Flag 15 May 14 10.43pm

Quote SloveniaDave at 15 May 2014 10.05pm

Quote kangel at 15 May 2014 6.42pm

Quote SloveniaDave at 15 May 2014 6.22pm

Quote kangel at 15 May 2014 5.24pm

Quote SloveniaDave at 15 May 2014 3.24pm

Quote kangel at 15 May 2014 10.46am

Quote SloveniaDave at 15 May 2014 10.17am

Quote Penge Eagle at 15 May 2014 9.59am

Quote The White Horse at 14 May 2014 11.45pm

Quote Penge Eagle at 14 May 2014 11.42pm

I think White Horse and Nick totally miss the point, and as ever, move the goal posts.

The UKIP argument is that the UK should be in charge of controlling our borders, with an emphasis of quality, not quantity.

At the moment, having the EU in charge allows the opposite - which you clearly prefer! And it also disregards high quality professionals from places like India or Australia.

Edited by Penge Eagle (14 May 2014 11.44pm)

Lets compromise on a third option.

What do you think to nobody controlling our borders...

To White Horse, question for you...

Would you prefer to have totally unrestricted immigration and just limited to Europeans? All the rules made by bureaucrats in Belgium who have no real interest in the UK.

OR

Controlled immigration with people seeking asylum and immigrants who can fill certain job shortages that will benefit the country. Rules decided by our MPs in London and can easily held accountable. Having CONTROL ensures the balance between numbers and the impact on infrastructure and social aspects.

Edited by Penge Eagle (15 May 2014 10.00am)


The principle of the free movement of people, goods, services and money within the EU is a basic concept that has been agreed by all members, including the UK. It is not something made up by bureaucrats in Brussels. They only really get involved where member states do not comply.

Although this results in economic migration within the EU, which causes some problems, I am convinced that the overall benefits associated with it far outweigh the problems

The same principle which allows other EU nationals to come to the UK is also the one which allows the Nissan plant in Sunderland to export hundreds of thousands of cars throughout Europe with no restrictions.


What are the problems you are referring to?


You want me to explain what problems are associated with immigration? I would have thought that was fairly obvious in general terms.

There are a number, some of which are real, some perceived and some depend on the time and the way in which it happens.

As you admit that there a number of problems. If you could actually name them, then we could go on to discuss how big these problems need to become before the problems outweigh the benefits.

As for the Nissan plant in Sunderland, if they produce products that people want to buy, then they will still export hundreds of thousands of cars throughout Europe, whether we are in the EU or not.

Edited by kangel (15 May 2014 5.57pm)

My point is that you should not try to look at the problem in isolation but look at the bigger picture. Nissan will not sell UK-built cars in Europe if Europe puts up tariff barriers against us, in the same way that workers will not be able to move freely if we impose caps or restrictions.

The main problem with immigration in the UK, at the present time, is that people do not see the bigger picture and simply want to have their cake and eat it.

Not sure why you are so coy in not naming the 'number of problems' that you are aware of. Tariff barriers eventually fail as the market reasserts itself, people get fed up driving Moskvich-type cars produced in tariff-ridden 'planned' economies, when they could buy things they want. As for the 'bigger picture', I think many, many people in the UK are all too well aware of it, and will vote accordingly in the imminent EU elections (despite the undemocratic nature of these elections). We don't want the cake, we want control of the bakery back.


Edited by kangel (15 May 2014 7.04pm)


Nothing coy at all, I just assumed that everyone already knows what the issues are. The only question is the extent of their actual impact and then comparing them with other issues which flow from the free movement of people, goods, services and capital.

Of course you can try to go for a model which allows for the free movement of just goods and services but not people and capital but it would be a half-baked system which would not work in the long term so you have to decide if you want the full pie or none of it.

The problems with free movement of people is that you get economic migration. This has an impact on the receiving countries in terms of ethnic differences/tensions (including actual and latent racism but also very legitimate concerns about different cultures, religions and lifestyles), people prepared to work for less than the local population and overstretch on local services.

Are those problems actually that insoluble? No.

Are they actually major problems? Only if you choose to make them major.

Are they a price worth paying for all the other benefits? Absolutely

The option of course remains to leave the EU, pull up the drawbridge and act like little England. But if you raise your sights a little, realize that the UK has only become what it is now because we were the world's pre-eminent traders and migrators, then you accept that, on balance, migration and trade are a good thing and make the best of it.

May's 'elections' will see big losses for all pro-EU parties, ie the three major parties and hopefully, the Liberals in particular. Pro-EU remnants will then say that the answer is 'more Europe', whatever the economic reality and whatever the wishes of their constituents. For years, their policies have caused unemployment, deflation and emigration across Europe, while the IOUs pile up in the richer member states. Nothing makes them question their faith. No amount of suffering, no amount of debt moves them to admit that the single currency might have been a mistake. They are literally beyond argument - which raises the question, who are the real extremists here?

 

SloveniaDave Flag Tirana, Albania 15 May 14 11.04pm


[b]May's 'elections' will see big losses for all pro-EU parties, ie the three major parties and hopefully, the Liberals in particular. Pro-EU remnants will then say that the answer is 'more Europe', whatever the economic reality and whatever the wishes of their constituents. For years, their policies have caused unemployment, deflation and emigration across Europe, while the IOUs pile up in the richer member states. Nothing makes them question their faith. No amount of suffering, no amount of debt moves them to admit that the single currency might have been a mistake. They are literally beyond argument - which raises the question, who are the real extremists here?

Can't argue with the first point and there are certainly major problems with the single currency, although most are about how it was introduced, rather than the principle of it.

I don't see how the rest of your post makes much sense though. The debate is very much moving towards a 'smaller Europe', which I think is sensible, but to blame 'Europe' for unemployment and deflation is not supported by the facts.

I am not clear, from your posts, what you propose as an alternative though? Are you looking for an isolated, UKIP-style UK, a UK as the 51st state of the USA or the Socialist Republic of Britain?


Edited by SloveniaDave (15 May 2014 11.04pm)

 


Just because I don't care doesn't mean I don't understand!

My opinions may have changed, but not the fact that I am right.

(Member of the School of Optimism 1969-2016 inclusive)

Bert the Head Flag Epsom 15 May 14 11.28pm

Quote beagle at 29 Apr 2014 11.29pm

UKIP are only on the radar thanks to the blinkered arrogance and stupidity of the 'established' parties in not addressing grass roots concerns, but instead railroading policies that, whilst politically correct, ignored the aforementioned concerns because they were deemed somehow 'racist' .

Labour were the prime candidates, it has to be said. To busy consulting the PC manual, and not enough time spent listening.

Tapping in to the concerns about Job insecurity, low wages and competition for limited affordable housing are really what UKIP draw support from. These problems have all been exacerbated by Thatcher's (and the neo-conservative free market politicians) policies. Its ironic that if you support Thatcher - therefore free markets - that you are against immigration as free movement of labour fits in with the free market idea and non-state intervention of markets eg by applying immigration controls. But more ironic is that a party that is more Thatcherite than Thatcher gains from the insecurities that Thatcher's policies created.

The idea of a fair day's pay for a fair day's work, affordable housing and legislation to support workers against employers are left wing ideas. UKIP having nothing to offer at all here. But lazy people like easy targets...especially when their information system is the right wing press.

Edited by Bert the Head (15 May 2014 11.29pm)

Edited by Bert the Head (15 May 2014 11.29pm)

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 15 May 14 11.47pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 15 May 2014 9.34pm


By trotting out your tory central office mantra, you've missed the point of ukip. They already ARE delivering. All the main parties are running scared. Cameron came out on Andrew Marr last week saying stuff about a referendum he wouldn't have said in a million years if it weren't for ukip.

Hogwash.
UKIP couldn't deliver milk !

The party that are delivering are the Conservatives :

Cutting the EU budget for the first time in history saving the British taxpayer over £8BN.
Vetoing a new EU fiscal treaty that didn't guarantee a level "Playing field" for British businesses.
Getting Britain out of the Eurozone bailouts ETC ETC

Anyway, I'm off to bed now so goodnight one and all !


 

SloveniaDave Flag Tirana, Albania 15 May 14 11.52pm

Quote Bert the Head at 15 May 2014 11.28pm

Quote beagle at 29 Apr 2014 11.29pm

UKIP are only on the radar thanks to the blinkered arrogance and stupidity of the 'established' parties in not addressing grass roots concerns, but instead railroading policies that, whilst politically correct, ignored the aforementioned concerns because they were deemed somehow 'racist' .

Labour were the prime candidates, it has to be said. To busy consulting the PC manual, and not enough time spent listening.

Tapping in to the concerns about Job insecurity, low wages and competition for limited affordable housing are really what UKIP draw support from. These problems have all been exacerbated by Thatcher's (and the neo-conservative free market politicians) policies. Its ironic that if you support Thatcher - therefore free markets - that you are against immigration as free movement of labour fits in with the free market idea and non-state intervention of markets eg by applying immigration controls. But more ironic is that a party that is more Thatcherite than Thatcher gains from the insecurities that Thatcher's policies created.

The idea of a fair day's pay for a fair day's work, affordable housing and legislation to support workers against employers are left wing ideas. UKIP having nothing to offer at all here. But lazy people like easy targets...especially when their information system is the right wing press.

Edited by Bert the Head (15 May 2014 11.29pm)

Edited by Bert the Head (15 May 2014 11.29pm)


I don't see that. If you are pro free markets then you are pro the free movement of people. I don't recall Thatcher ever being against the free movement of people. She was against unaccountability and bureaucracy from Brussels but very much in favour of the single market.

 


Just because I don't care doesn't mean I don't understand!

My opinions may have changed, but not the fact that I am right.

(Member of the School of Optimism 1969-2016 inclusive)

Stirlingsays Flag 16 May 14 7.02am

Quote Willo at 15 May 2014 11.47pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 15 May 2014 9.34pm


By trotting out your tory central office mantra, you've missed the point of ukip. They already ARE delivering. All the main parties are running scared. Cameron came out on Andrew Marr last week saying stuff about a referendum he wouldn't have said in a million years if it weren't for ukip.

Hogwash.
UKIP couldn't deliver milk !

The party that are delivering are the Conservatives :

Cutting the EU budget for the first time in history saving the British taxpayer over £8BN.
Vetoing a new EU fiscal treaty that didn't guarantee a level "Playing field" for British businesses.
Getting Britain out of the Eurozone bailouts ETC ETC

Anyway, I'm off to bed now so goodnight one and all !



Is that what you're saying on the doorstep?

Was not the 'budget cut' a reduction in increase from the initial proposal and not an actual cut of the budget? The EU budget increased in size overall...Quite significantly.

Britain out of the bailouts? Talk about moving the deckchairs. Did we not increase our share to the IMF by ten billion in 2012? British money is most definitely bailing out the Euro-crises....every household is on the line for £1,600.

This country has a £40bn IMF exposure.

I hope you said that on the doorstep.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

kangel Flag 16 May 14 7.52am

Quote SloveniaDave at 15 May 2014 11.04pm


[b]May's 'elections' will see big losses for all pro-EU parties, ie the three major parties and hopefully, the Liberals in particular. Pro-EU remnants will then say that the answer is 'more Europe', whatever the economic reality and whatever the wishes of their constituents. For years, their policies have caused unemployment, deflation and emigration across Europe, while the IOUs pile up in the richer member states. Nothing makes them question their faith. No amount of suffering, no amount of debt moves them to admit that the single currency might have been a mistake. They are literally beyond argument - which raises the question, who are the real extremists here?

Can't argue with the first point and there are certainly major problems with the single currency, although most are about how it was introduced, rather than the principle of it.

I don't see how the rest of your post makes much sense though. The debate is very much moving towards a 'smaller Europe', which I think is sensible, but to blame 'Europe' for unemployment and deflation is not supported by the facts.

I am not clear, from your posts, what you propose as an alternative though? Are you looking for an isolated, UKIP-style UK, a UK as the 51st state of the USA or the Socialist Republic of Britain?


Edited by SloveniaDave (15 May 2014 11.04pm)


'Major problems' with the single currency - don't you mean the biggest disaster in financial history? (If only it had been 'introduced' better!!!! Then it would have been a roaring success?)

If we are 'isolated' from the whirlpool of the EU disappearing down its own plughole under the weight of its inherent contradictions - fine. 'Socialst Republic of Britain (you think I advocate that?) - the EU has far more in common with the various failed Communist 'systems' of the past with its ludicrous 'planning', 'controls' and rigged markets.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 16 May 14 8.14am

Quote Stirlingsays at 16 May 2014 7.02am

Is that what you're saying on the doorstep?

Britain out of the bailouts? Talk about moving the deckchairs.

It was Labour who signed up to the costly bail-outs !
Not withstanding this, it is the Conservatives who are renogiating Britain's relationship with Europe and there is still work to be done, however the process is underway.

What should be remembered is that Labour and the Liberal Democrats won’t give you a say. UKIP can’t give you a say. It’s only the Conservatives who can and will give you a say in an in-out referendum.

I am happy to report that the messages I have been receiving on the doorsteps are very positive indeed.
More door knocking and bell ringing today and over the weekend ! There are also Local elections in my area ! Busy time so I really don't have the time to get into a protracted debate on HOL much as I would like to !


Edited by Willo (16 May 2014 8.19am)

 

npn Flag Crowborough 16 May 14 8.27am

Quote Willo at 16 May 2014 8.14am

Quote Stirlingsays at 16 May 2014 7.02am

Is that what you're saying on the doorstep?

Britain out of the bailouts? Talk about moving the deckchairs.

It was Labour who signed up to the costly bail-outs !
Not withstanding this, it is the Conservatives who are renogiating Britain's relationship with Europe and there is still work to be done, however the process is underway.

What should be remembered is that Labour and the Liberal Democrats won’t give you a say. UKIP can’t give you a say. It’s only the Conservatives who can and will give you a say in an in-out referendum.

I am happy to report that the messages I have been receiving on the doorsteps are very positive indeed.
More door knocking and bell ringing today and over the weekend ! There are also Local elections in my area ! Busy time so I really don't have the time to get into a protracted debate on HOL much as I would like to !


Edited by Willo (16 May 2014 8.19am)


To be honest Willo, and this comes from someone who has voted Tory far more in the past than any other party, I just don't believe them!

I have completely lost all faith in politicians from all the three main parties - they have shown themselves time and time again to be completely untrustworthy, and in it for their own political careers, and whatever they can get out of it.

 

kangel Flag 16 May 14 8.30am

Quote Willo at 16 May 2014 8.14am

Quote Stirlingsays at 16 May 2014 7.02am

Is that what you're saying on the doorstep?

Britain out of the bailouts? Talk about moving the deckchairs.

It was Labour who signed up to the costly bail-outs !
Not withstanding this, it is the Conservatives who are renogiating Britain's relationship with Europe and there is still work to be done, however the process is underway.

What should be remembered is that Labour and the Liberal Democrats won’t give you a say. UKIP can’t give you a say. It’s only the Conservatives who can and will give you a say in an in-out referendum.

I am happy to report that the messages I have been receiving on the doorsteps are very positive indeed.
More door knocking and bell ringing today and over the weekend ! There are also Local elections in my area ! Busy time so I really don't have the time to get into a protracted debate on HOL much as I would like to !

-------------------------------------------------
"renegotiating Britain's relationship with Europe" is like haggling over the protection money you had to pay to the Kray twins. (It was Heath who set us on this sorry road in the first place.)

Edited by kangel (16 May 2014 8.31am)

 

SloveniaDave Flag Tirana, Albania 16 May 14 9.09am

Quote kangel at 16 May 2014 7.52am

Quote SloveniaDave at 15 May 2014 11.04pm


[b]May's 'elections' will see big losses for all pro-EU parties, ie the three major parties and hopefully, the Liberals in particular. Pro-EU remnants will then say that the answer is 'more Europe', whatever the economic reality and whatever the wishes of their constituents. For years, their policies have caused unemployment, deflation and emigration across Europe, while the IOUs pile up in the richer member states. Nothing makes them question their faith. No amount of suffering, no amount of debt moves them to admit that the single currency might have been a mistake. They are literally beyond argument - which raises the question, who are the real extremists here?

Can't argue with the first point and there are certainly major problems with the single currency, although most are about how it was introduced, rather than the principle of it.

I don't see how the rest of your post makes much sense though. The debate is very much moving towards a 'smaller Europe', which I think is sensible, but to blame 'Europe' for unemployment and deflation is not supported by the facts.

I am not clear, from your posts, what you propose as an alternative though? Are you looking for an isolated, UKIP-style UK, a UK as the 51st state of the USA or the Socialist Republic of Britain?


Edited by SloveniaDave (15 May 2014 11.04pm)


'Major problems' with the single currency - don't you mean the biggest disaster in financial history? (If only it had been 'introduced' better!!!! Then it would have been a roaring success?)

If we are 'isolated' from the whirlpool of the EU disappearing down its own plughole under the weight of its inherent contradictions - fine. 'Socialst Republic of Britain (you think I advocate that?) - the EU has far more in common with the various failed Communist 'systems' of the past with its ludicrous 'planning', 'controls' and rigged markets.


Not at all. I have been living and working in Eurozone countries (or countries who peg their currency to the Euro) for almost 10 years. The problem with the Euro is that it was not introduced with the full range of measures needed (i.e. countermeasures to allow for the fact that devaluation was no longer an option for weaker economies). As a result, when the financial crisis started, it was more vulnerable and the weaknesses showed.

I fully support the UK's decision to remain outside the Euro (both then and now, and for the foreseeable future) but that does not mean it is a bad thing for most of the counties who are members of it.

Edited by SloveniaDave (16 May 2014 9.10am)

Edited by SloveniaDave (16 May 2014 9.11am)

 


Just because I don't care doesn't mean I don't understand!

My opinions may have changed, but not the fact that I am right.

(Member of the School of Optimism 1969-2016 inclusive)

The White Horse Flag 16 May 14 9.56am

Quote Willo at 15 May 2014 11.47pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 15 May 2014 9.34pm


By trotting out your tory central office mantra, you've missed the point of ukip. They already ARE delivering. All the main parties are running scared. Cameron came out on Andrew Marr last week saying stuff about a referendum he wouldn't have said in a million years if it weren't for ukip.

Hogwash.
UKIP couldn't deliver milk !

The party that are delivering are the Conservatives :

Cutting the EU budget for the first time in history saving the British taxpayer over £8BN.
Vetoing a new EU fiscal treaty that didn't guarantee a level "Playing field" for British businesses.
Getting Britain out of the Eurozone bailouts ETC ETC

Anyway, I'm off to bed now so goodnight one and all !

Wasn't there a rebellion in the Commons on this issue? Didn't Cameron basically get shown up by Labour and his backbenchers? Not exactly bold and exciting leadership in the EU.

 


"The fox has his den. The bee has his hive. The stoat, has, uh... his stoat-hole... but only man chooses to make his nest in an investment opportunity.” Stewart Lee

kangel Flag 16 May 14 12.35pm

Quote SloveniaDave at 16 May 2014 9.09am

Quote kangel at 16 May 2014 7.52am

Quote SloveniaDave at 15 May 2014 11.04pm


[b]May's 'elections' will see big losses for all pro-EU parties, ie the three major parties and hopefully, the Liberals in particular. Pro-EU remnants will then say that the answer is 'more Europe', whatever the economic reality and whatever the wishes of their constituents. For years, their policies have caused unemployment, deflation and emigration across Europe, while the IOUs pile up in the richer member states. Nothing makes them question their faith. No amount of suffering, no amount of debt moves them to admit that the single currency might have been a mistake. They are literally beyond argument - which raises the question, who are the real extremists here?

Can't argue with the first point and there are certainly major problems with the single currency, although most are about how it was introduced, rather than the principle of it.

I don't see how the rest of your post makes much sense though. The debate is very much moving towards a 'smaller Europe', which I think is sensible, but to blame 'Europe' for unemployment and deflation is not supported by the facts.

I am not clear, from your posts, what you propose as an alternative though? Are you looking for an isolated, UKIP-style UK, a UK as the 51st state of the USA or the Socialist Republic of Britain?


Edited by SloveniaDave (15 May 2014 11.04pm)


'Major problems' with the single currency - don't you mean the biggest disaster in financial history? (If only it had been 'introduced' better!!!! Then it would have been a roaring success?)

If we are 'isolated' from the whirlpool of the EU disappearing down its own plughole under the weight of its inherent contradictions - fine. 'Socialst Republic of Britain (you think I advocate that?) - the EU has far more in common with the various failed Communist 'systems' of the past with its ludicrous 'planning', 'controls' and rigged markets.


Not at all. I have been living and working in Eurozone countries (or countries who peg their currency to the Euro) for almost 10 years. The problem with the Euro is that it was not introduced with the full range of measures needed (i.e. countermeasures to allow for the fact that devaluation was no longer an option for weaker economies). As a result, when the financial crisis started, it was more vulnerable and the weaknesses showed.

I fully support the UK's decision to remain outside the Euro (both then and now, and for the foreseeable future) but that does not mean it is a bad thing for most of the counties who are members of it.

Edited by SloveniaDave (16 May 2014 9.10am)

Edited by SloveniaDave (16 May 2014 9.11am)

"the full range of measures" EU-speak for useless 'controls' and 'planning' that try to buck the market - the sort of thing that is at the heart of most of the problems with the EU.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 16 May 14 2.09pm

Quote Willo at 16 May 2014 8.14am

Quote Stirlingsays at 16 May 2014 7.02am

Is that what you're saying on the doorstep?

Britain out of the bailouts? Talk about moving the deckchairs.

It was Labour who signed up to the costly bail-outs !
Not withstanding this, it is the Conservatives who are renogiating Britain's relationship with Europe and there is still work to be done, however the process is underway.

Edited by Willo (16 May 2014 8.19am)


IMF funding was increased by ten billion to forty billion in 2012 by George Osborne. Up by thirty three percent.....I hear what you are saying but it isn't borne out by the actual facts. Maybe you just choose to believe the party machine.

If what you are saying to people on the doorstep is similar to what you're posting here.....Well, it's cherry picking and advertising.

No wonder people are cynical.

Edited by Stirlingsays (16 May 2014 3.28pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Johnny Eagles Flag berlin 16 May 14 2.28pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 16 May 2014 2.09pm

Quote Willo at 16 May 2014 8.14am

Quote Stirlingsays at 16 May 2014 7.02am

Is that what you're saying on the doorstep?

Britain out of the bailouts? Talk about moving the deckchairs.

It was Labour who signed up to the costly bail-outs !
Not withstanding this, it is the Conservatives who are renogiating Britain's relationship with Europe and there is still work to be done, however the process is underway.

Edited by Willo (16 May 2014 8.19am)


IMF funding was increased by ten billion to forty billion in 2012 by George Osborne. Up by twenty five percent.....I hear what you are saying but it isn't borne out by the actual facts. Maybe you just choose to believe the party machine.

If what you are saying to people on the doorstep is similar to what you're posting here.....Well, it's cherry picking and advertising.

No wonder people are cynical.

Willo believing the party machine!?

Absolute HOGWASH!

 


...we must expand...get more pupils...so that the knowledge will spread...

Stuk Flag Top half 16 May 14 2.32pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 16 May 2014 2.09pm

Quote Willo at 16 May 2014 8.14am

Quote Stirlingsays at 16 May 2014 7.02am

Is that what you're saying on the doorstep?

Britain out of the bailouts? Talk about moving the deckchairs.

It was Labour who signed up to the costly bail-outs !
Not withstanding this, it is the Conservatives who are renogiating Britain's relationship with Europe and there is still work to be done, however the process is underway.

Edited by Willo (16 May 2014 8.19am)


IMF funding was increased by ten billion to forty billion in 2012 by George Osborne. Up by twenty five percent.....I hear what you are saying but it isn't borne out by the actual facts. Maybe you just choose to believe the party machine.

If what you are saying to people on the doorstep is similar to what you're posting here.....Well, it's cherry picking and advertising.

No wonder people are cynical.


33%

 


Optimistic as ever

Page 28 of 187 < 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Topic