Quote kangel at 15 May 2014 6.42pm
Quote SloveniaDave at 15 May 2014 6.22pm
Quote kangel at 15 May 2014 5.24pm
Quote SloveniaDave at 15 May 2014 3.24pm
Quote kangel at 15 May 2014 10.46am
Quote SloveniaDave at 15 May 2014 10.17am
Quote Penge Eagle at 15 May 2014 9.59am
Quote The White Horse at 14 May 2014 11.45pm
Quote Penge Eagle at 14 May 2014 11.42pm
I think White Horse and Nick totally miss the point, and as ever, move the goal posts.
The UKIP argument is that the UK should be in charge of controlling our borders, with an emphasis of quality, not quantity.
At the moment, having the EU in charge allows the opposite - which you clearly prefer! And it also disregards high quality professionals from places like India or Australia.
Edited by Penge Eagle (14 May 2014 11.44pm)
Lets compromise on a third option.
What do you think to nobody controlling our borders...
To White Horse, question for you...
Would you prefer to have totally unrestricted immigration and just limited to Europeans? All the rules made by bureaucrats in Belgium who have no real interest in the UK.
OR
Controlled immigration with people seeking asylum and immigrants who can fill certain job shortages that will benefit the country. Rules decided by our MPs in London and can easily held accountable. Having CONTROL ensures the balance between numbers and the impact on infrastructure and social aspects.
Edited by Penge Eagle (15 May 2014 10.00am)
The principle of the free movement of people, goods, services and money within the EU is a basic concept that has been agreed by all members, including the UK. It is not something made up by bureaucrats in Brussels. They only really get involved where member states do not comply.
Although this results in economic migration within the EU, which causes some problems, I am convinced that the overall benefits associated with it far outweigh the problems
The same principle which allows other EU nationals to come to the UK is also the one which allows the Nissan plant in Sunderland to export hundreds of thousands of cars throughout Europe with no restrictions.
What are the problems you are referring to?
You want me to explain what problems are associated with immigration? I would have thought that was fairly obvious in general terms.
There are a number, some of which are real, some perceived and some depend on the time and the way in which it happens.
As you admit that there a number of problems. If you could actually name them, then we could go on to discuss how big these problems need to become before the problems outweigh the benefits.
As for the Nissan plant in Sunderland, if they produce products that people want to buy, then they will still export hundreds of thousands of cars throughout Europe, whether we are in the EU or not.
Edited by kangel (15 May 2014 5.57pm)
My point is that you should not try to look at the problem in isolation but look at the bigger picture. Nissan will not sell UK-built cars in Europe if Europe puts up tariff barriers against us, in the same way that workers will not be able to move freely if we impose caps or restrictions.
The main problem with immigration in the UK, at the present time, is that people do not see the bigger picture and simply want to have their cake and eat it.
Not sure why you are so coy in not naming the 'number of problems' that you are aware of. Tariff barriers eventually fail as the market reasserts itself, people get fed up driving Moskvich-type cars produced in tariff-ridden 'planned' economies, when they could buy things they want. As for the 'bigger picture', I think many, many people in the UK are all too well aware of it, and will vote accordingly in the imminent EU elections (despite the undemocratic nature of these elections). We don't want the cake, we want control of the bakery back.
Edited by kangel (15 May 2014 7.04pm)
Nothing coy at all, I just assumed that everyone already knows what the issues are. The only question is the extent of their actual impact and then comparing them with other issues which flow from the free movement of people, goods, services and capital.
Of course you can try to go for a model which allows for the free movement of just goods and services but not people and capital but it would be a half-baked system which would not work in the long term so you have to decide if you want the full pie or none of it.
The problems with free movement of people is that you get economic migration. This has an impact on the receiving countries in terms of ethnic differences/tensions (including actual and latent racism but also very legitimate concerns about different cultures, religions and lifestyles), people prepared to work for less than the local population and overstretch on local services.
Are those problems actually that insoluble? No.
Are they actually major problems? Only if you choose to make them major.
Are they a price worth paying for all the other benefits? Absolutely
The option of course remains to leave the EU, pull up the drawbridge and act like little England. But if you raise your sights a little, realize that the UK has only become what it is now because we were the world's pre-eminent traders and migrators, then you accept that, on balance, migration and trade are a good thing and make the best of it.
Just because I don't care doesn't mean I don't understand!
My opinions may have changed, but not the fact that I am right.
(Member of the School of Optimism 1969-2016 inclusive)
|