You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > No more immigrants.
November 22 2026 1.18am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

No more immigrants.


Page 28 of 51 < 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 >
sickboy Flag Deal or Croydon 05 Sep 15 6.28pm

Quote Kermit8 at 05 Sep 2015 6.20pm

Quote sickboy at 05 Sep 2015 6.17pm

Quote Kermit8 at 05 Sep 2015 5.41pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 05 Sep 2015 5.35pm

Quote Kermit8 at 05 Sep 2015 5.19pm

The total population of northern western europe is 280million. If we all mucked in and took in 1million in total refugees from Syria then that is merely a 0.3% increase spread out over 6 or 7 countries.

We will cope. They cannot.


I don't want to 'muck in'.

Western Europe isn't a collective, despite how you like to see it.

It isn't just Britain saying no to this......And your figures aren't realistic anyway.....An open door will just mean countless more coming every year.

Besides....As far as I see, Germany and Sweden have open doors.....Let them live with there open door politics ....As you lefties say, it will even 'benefit' the country....Help the economy massively....They won't want to live without them.

Edited by Stirlingsays (05 Sep 2015 5.36pm)


Fortunately, you and your ilk - the unchristian [sic] - are seemingly in the minority.

Religeon is the cause of most if not all of the worlds ills, especially in the region in the region we are focusing on now.


You can have basic and kind 'Christian' values without believing in God or religion.


Pedantic/semantics but christian has religous connotations. I would argue that if we got rid of those beliefs that are not religous or political we would be better off. As someone once said start the day off with the mindset "try not to be a cvnt" and take it from there. ( would add smiley here but phone not having it)

 

sickboy Flag Deal or Croydon 05 Sep 15 6.41pm

Meant beliefs that are religous and political.&#128544;

 

Mr Palaceman Flag 05 Sep 15 6.44pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 05 Sep 2015 5.30pm

Quote Mr Palaceman at 05 Sep 2015 4.37pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 05 Sep 2015 3.55pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 05 Sep 2015 3.50pm

Matthew Pinsent nailed it

@matthewcpinsent: 80yrs ago Nicholas Winton organised trains to get children safely to the UK. We later knighted him. What the hell have we become?


Matthew Pinsent won't have to live with the problem.

I bet old Pinsent, who is directly descended from Thomas Howard, 2nd Duke of Norfolk.....who rowed for Eton, has a nice house to live in......I bet he doesn't compete for a job with immigrants. I bet he doesn't have to spend hours waiting for a GP appointment

The man enjoyed a life amongst the elites....Never had to muck it out.

Yeah, what have we become Matthew......Did you complain about having it better than over ninety percent of the country or did you just take the advantages.


Edited by Stirlingsays (05 Sep 2015 4.01pm)


We are all privileged in this country, even the poorest are a lot better off here than in many other countries.

As a teacher, do you have to compete with migrants for your job? (Genuine question, not a dig).

Also I can't remember time last time I couldn't get an appointment to see a doctor the same day if I call up in the morning and if I call in the afternoon I can get an appointment for the following morning, despite the current "crisis" in the NHS.

The irony for me is that I would not get any appointment if it was not for the work that foreign doctors and nurses do in the NHS. I would love us to train more doctors and nurses so we wouldn't have to rely on migrants coming into the NHS but for whatever reason and there are many that is not the reality.

Either we cannot attract to right people to the jobs, we are not able to pay enough or people are just not interested in doing such a hard and demanding job. I wouldn't want to do it.

I have followed this and the other "migrant" threads on the site and I think that there are very good points on both sides. We can't have unrestricted migration into the country, It's just not feasible but it's clear that we can do a lot more than we do to help.

I must say that my heart was warmed by the scenes in Munich. I am pleased that ordinary people still give a damn. For me the world is in a poor state because people just don't care about other people and not because of those people that do care and spend their time to help.


That privilege is meant to come with a 'birthright'. That's the point of having a nationality. You are subject to that country. Foreigners aren't, and in my view, outside of asylum, marriage, students and work permits I don't want anyone here who hasn't an allegiance to this country.

I'd probably like to deport people like Seymour too.

To answer your question of course I don't have to compete with migrants. That's the point. Unlike Pinsent, I care about the affect on this country's working class....I grew up on a council estate and fought my way up. Immigration in this country has already been hundreds of thousands too many for over a decade. Outside of asylum houses in this country should, by and large, go to the British.

I see many of these Syrians as looking to come to the EU for a life upgrade. People like me and most others were shocked by that little boy's death....Even though countless children have died in the med now...Even so, when you learn about the story of the father who was living in Turkey not escaping from Syria....Tell you everything right there.

There are an awful high number of single young men......Stay in your country and fight for it.....Like I would.

This country is already helping money wise....More than most countries. I agree with helping a reasonable amount, but I'm not going to support this state taking responsibility for foreigners outside of a set number on asylum.

As to birthright and nationality, a country should look after it's own but in terms of allegiance. I would argue that those arriving in Germany would certainly have an allegiance and desire to do well and to be seen to do well in their new home.

Your point about the father and his family being in Turkey, There are reports that there are up to 2 million refuges in Turkey already in various "camps". They can't cope with that any more than anyone else could. I can't blame him for wanting to leave there and go to family that he has in Canada.

There are many young men, whether they are single or just those members of their families that can get away, I don't know but I see as many women and children in the reports and don't just think that it's a question of young single men alone.

Personally, I would like to think that I could stay and fight for my home, I'm sure that many are staying and doing just that and dying in the process. I don't think that losing a massive portion of the middle class is good for any country, let alone having to endure nearly 5 years of civil war.

We can't do everything for everyone and solve all the worlds ills, we have our own problems but even though it cannot be said that we do nothing, the British people are no strangers to charity, we can do more IMO.

Should we as a nation not at least aspire to want for others what we would want for ourselves. That may mean that there has to be a level a sacrifice on our part greater than we are offering at the moment but I accept that not everyone would be so willing to help.

Nationality is important for a country's view of itself and a common identity. Common values and goals move a nation forward but I have travelled a lot and have found that people, even of different cultures, religions and races want the same thing, a safe and secure home for their families to grow and prosper. I tend to put nationality second to the human aspect of this crisis.

What is clear for me is that there needs to be a proper debate amongst EU leaders as to how we can solve this problem and save life in the first instance.

But to be honest, although I am normally an optimistic chap, I don't believe that any of our leaders have the will to make a difference above their own personal or national interest.

 


"You can lead a horse to water but a pencil must be lead"

Stan Laurel

-TUX- Flag Alphabettispaghetti 05 Sep 15 6.56pm

Quote sickboy at 05 Sep 2015 6.17pm

Quote Kermit8 at 05 Sep 2015 5.41pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 05 Sep 2015 5.35pm

Quote Kermit8 at 05 Sep 2015 5.19pm

The total population of northern western europe is 280million. If we all mucked in and took in 1million in total refugees from Syria then that is merely a 0.3% increase spread out over 6 or 7 countries.

We will cope. They cannot.


I don't want to 'muck in'.

Western Europe isn't a collective, despite how you like to see it.

It isn't just Britain saying no to this......And your figures aren't realistic anyway.....An open door will just mean countless more coming every year.

Besides....As far as I see, Germany and Sweden have open doors.....Let them live with there open door politics ....As you lefties say, it will even 'benefit' the country....Help the economy massively....They won't want to live without them.

Edited by Stirlingsays (05 Sep 2015 5.36pm)


Fortunately, you and your ilk - the unchristian [sic] - are seemingly in the minority.

Religeon is the cause of most if not all of the worlds ills, especially in the region in the region we are focusing on now.


Religion is built on unquestioning trust.

The real Puppet Masters have been p-ssing themselves for centuries.

 


Time to move forward together.

pefwin Flag Where you have to have an English ... 05 Sep 15 7.07pm

Quote Kermit8 at 05 Sep 2015 6.20pm


You can have basic and kind 'Christian' values without believing in God or religion.


Unless you solely believe in the old Testament.

 


"Everything is air-droppable at least once."

"When the going gets tough, the tough call for close air support."

leggedstruggle Flag Croydon 05 Sep 15 7.51pm

Quote Tom-the-eagle at 05 Sep 2015 6.14pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 05 Sep 2015 6.06pm

Quote Kermit8 at 05 Sep 2015 5.19pm

The total population of northern western europe is 280million. If we all mucked in and took in 1million in total refugees from Syria then that is merely a 0.3% increase spread out over 6 or 7 countries.

We will cope. They cannot.

The total population of arab countries is 389 million. If they all mucked in and took in 1 million in total of refugees from Syria then that is a mere 0.25% increase spread out over about 22 countries.

They will cope. We cannot.

But as you and I know Legged, its not about going to a SAFE country - its about going to a RICH country.

Many arab countries are rich - Qatar is considered to be the richest in the world.

 


mother-in-law is an anagram of woman hitler

leggedstruggle Flag Croydon 05 Sep 15 7.53pm

Quote Kermit8 at 05 Sep 2015 6.16pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 05 Sep 2015 6.06pm

Quote Kermit8 at 05 Sep 2015 5.19pm

The total population of northern western europe is 280million. If we all mucked in and took in 1million in total refugees from Syria then that is merely a 0.3% increase spread out over 6 or 7 countries.

We will cope. They cannot.

The total population of arab countries is 389 million. If they all mucked in and took in 1 million in total of refugees from Syria then that is a mere 0.25% increase spread out over about 22 countries.

They will cope. We cannot.


Let's not copy their nasty, inhumane example, shall we? I would hope we are better than that.

Are you actually British btw? Why do I have this feeling you were born overseas? Be honest. I won't hold it against you in future debates. Just genuinely curious.

Born in Mayday Hospital mate!

 


mother-in-law is an anagram of woman hitler

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 05 Sep 15 8.38pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 05 Sep 2015 7.51pm

Quote Tom-the-eagle at 05 Sep 2015 6.14pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 05 Sep 2015 6.06pm

Quote Kermit8 at 05 Sep 2015 5.19pm

The total population of northern western europe is 280million. If we all mucked in and took in 1million in total refugees from Syria then that is merely a 0.3% increase spread out over 6 or 7 countries.

We will cope. They cannot.

The total population of arab countries is 389 million. If they all mucked in and took in 1 million in total of refugees from Syria then that is a mere 0.25% increase spread out over about 22 countries.

They will cope. We cannot.

But as you and I know Legged, its not about going to a SAFE country - its about going to a RICH country.

Many arab countries are rich - Qatar is considered to be the richest in the world.


In that case replace RICH with GENEROUS

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

-TUX- Flag Alphabettispaghetti 05 Sep 15 8.55pm

Since when has being ''generous'' been a bad thing?

 


Time to move forward together.

sickboy Flag Deal or Croydon 05 Sep 15 9.07pm

Quote Tom-the-eagle at 05 Sep 2015 6.14pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 05 Sep 2015 6.06pm

Quote Kermit8 at 05 Sep 2015 5.19pm

The total population of northern western europe is 280million. If we all mucked in and took in 1million in total refugees from Syria then that is merely a 0.3% increase spread out over 6 or 7 countries.

We will cope. They cannot.

The total population of arab countries is 389 million. If they all mucked in and took in 1 million in total of refugees from Syria then that is a mere 0.25% increase spread out over about 22 countries.

They will cope. We cannot.

But as you and I know Legged, its not about going to a SAFE country - its about going to a RICH country.


This is true. Why do people choose to ignore it.

 

corkery Flag Cork City 05 Sep 15 9.39pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 05 Sep 2015 7.51pm

Quote Tom-the-eagle at 05 Sep 2015 6.14pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 05 Sep 2015 6.06pm

Quote Kermit8 at 05 Sep 2015 5.19pm

The total population of northern western europe is 280million. If we all mucked in and took in 1million in total refugees from Syria then that is merely a 0.3% increase spread out over 6 or 7 countries.

We will cope. They cannot.

The total population of arab countries is 389 million. If they all mucked in and took in 1 million in total of refugees from Syria then that is a mere 0.25% increase spread out over about 22 countries.

They will cope. We cannot.

But as you and I know Legged, its not about going to a SAFE country - its about going to a RICH country.

Many arab countries are rich - Qatar is considered to be the richest in the world.


Why should Qatar take them? They didn't bring 'Freedom' to the Middle East.

 


We'll never die

dannyboy1978 Flag 05 Sep 15 9.47pm

Quote serial thriller at 05 Sep 2015 4.33pm

Quote dannyh at 05 Sep 2015 4.28pm

Quote serial thriller at 05 Sep 2015 4.18pm

Quote dannyboy1978 at 05 Sep 2015 4.08pm

Quote serial thriller at 05 Sep 2015 3.41pm

Quote sickboy at 05 Sep 2015 3.29pm

Quote dannyboy1978 at 05 Sep 2015 2.41pm

Quote sa_eagle at 05 Sep 2015 10.26am

He had a name...


So did the 2 million in Sudan who have been killed but we don't hear about them!

This boy was in Turkey, a safe country so the father has blood on his hands!

I have to agree. Cucking made a great point the other day. Once you reach a safe haven as a refugee and decide to move on to somewhere that you favour or may be profitable you become a migrant. That changes your status on the political landscape. Also why risk your families lives to move on from a safe country like Turkey.


So do you think it's right for Lebanon - a country of under 5 million, with incredible domestic issues relating to poverty and infrastructure already - to have to take in another 1, maybe 2 million refugees just because of their geographical location?

Surely if you have fled a war which began a few years ago and you have a family, your aspirations are going to be a bit higher than living in a tent eating gruel for a decade?

What about Tunisia, Turkey, Morocco? Is it because the EU is richer, perhaps?


Firstly, Morocco is thousands of miles from either Syria or Libya, thus this whole argument about first port of call becomes null when discussing them.

Of course it's about money! People are after security and a place to bring up their kids, they're hardly all going to be steaming down to Sudan are they? Being a refugee essentially means you are citizenless, and being citizenless in a Capitalist society means you have no secure means of gaining money, which gains you food, housing, etc. It is therefore likely that, in seeking social securities, refugees will pursue capital, just as we do to a lesser degree in this country (London doesn't have 20 times the number of people living in it than Sunderland because it has nicer churches and parks).


I'm sorry I thought it was about persecuted families fleeing for their lives ?

Now it's all about cash at least you now admit that much.


Come on Danny, as a father would you be happy letting your kids grow up in a refugee camp all their lives or would you not attempt to find a better life for them?

Governments look nationally not individually just like our government does with austerity so refugess should be no different to British citizens.

 

-TUX- Flag Alphabettispaghetti 05 Sep 15 10.31pm

Quote dannyboy1978 at 05 Sep 2015 9.47pm

Quote serial thriller at 05 Sep 2015 4.33pm

Quote dannyh at 05 Sep 2015 4.28pm

Quote serial thriller at 05 Sep 2015 4.18pm

Quote dannyboy1978 at 05 Sep 2015 4.08pm

Quote serial thriller at 05 Sep 2015 3.41pm

Quote sickboy at 05 Sep 2015 3.29pm

Quote dannyboy1978 at 05 Sep 2015 2.41pm

Quote sa_eagle at 05 Sep 2015 10.26am

He had a name...


So did the 2 million in Sudan who have been killed but we don't hear about them!

This boy was in Turkey, a safe country so the father has blood on his hands!

I have to agree. Cucking made a great point the other day. Once you reach a safe haven as a refugee and decide to move on to somewhere that you favour or may be profitable you become a migrant. That changes your status on the political landscape. Also why risk your families lives to move on from a safe country like Turkey.


So do you think it's right for Lebanon - a country of under 5 million, with incredible domestic issues relating to poverty and infrastructure already - to have to take in another 1, maybe 2 million refugees just because of their geographical location?

Surely if you have fled a war which began a few years ago and you have a family, your aspirations are going to be a bit higher than living in a tent eating gruel for a decade?

What about Tunisia, Turkey, Morocco? Is it because the EU is richer, perhaps?


Firstly, Morocco is thousands of miles from either Syria or Libya, thus this whole argument about first port of call becomes null when discussing them.

Of course it's about money! People are after security and a place to bring up their kids, they're hardly all going to be steaming down to Sudan are they? Being a refugee essentially means you are citizenless, and being citizenless in a Capitalist society means you have no secure means of gaining money, which gains you food, housing, etc. It is therefore likely that, in seeking social securities, refugees will pursue capital, just as we do to a lesser degree in this country (London doesn't have 20 times the number of people living in it than Sunderland because it has nicer churches and parks).


I'm sorry I thought it was about persecuted families fleeing for their lives ?

Now it's all about cash at least you now admit that much.


Come on Danny, as a father would you be happy letting your kids grow up in a refugee camp all their lives or would you not attempt to find a better life for them?

Governments look nationally not individually just like our government does with austerity so refugess should be no different to British citizens.


Austerity. The poor paying for the (deliberate?) mistakes of the rich.
Govts do nothing other than..............see above.

 


Time to move forward together.

oldcodger Flag 05 Sep 15 11.05pm

Good to see the warm welcome, applause even, received by refugees arriving in Austria and Germany.

 

leggedstruggle Flag Croydon 06 Sep 15 12.08am

Quote corkery at 05 Sep 2015 9.39pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 05 Sep 2015 7.51pm

Quote Tom-the-eagle at 05 Sep 2015 6.14pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 05 Sep 2015 6.06pm

Quote Kermit8 at 05 Sep 2015 5.19pm

The total population of northern western europe is 280million. If we all mucked in and took in 1million in total refugees from Syria then that is merely a 0.3% increase spread out over 6 or 7 countries.

We will cope. They cannot.

The total population of arab countries is 389 million. If they all mucked in and took in 1 million in total of refugees from Syria then that is a mere 0.25% increase spread out over about 22 countries.

They will cope. We cannot.

But as you and I know Legged, its not about going to a SAFE country - its about going to a RICH country.

Many arab countries are rich - Qatar is considered to be the richest in the world.


Why should Qatar take them? They didn't bring 'Freedom' to the Middle East.

So we are responsible for the Syrian civil war? Rule 1 - never underestimate the stupidity of the left.

 


mother-in-law is an anagram of woman hitler

ZIGnZAG Flag Stoke 06 Sep 15 1.12am

Quote Kermit8 at 05 Sep 2015 6.13pm

Quote ZIGnZAG at 05 Sep 2015 6.04pm

Quote Kermit8 at 05 Sep 2015 5.33pm

A long time ago there was a worldwide picture of a naked teenage girl running with US napalm burning her body.

It helped end the Vietnam War.

The picture of the kid was necessary to give a symbolic slap around the face to those in power to do something. it seems to be working to an extent.

Zig - you are missing the positive points such images can have.

The Belsen film is another. Shocking but also truth home-hitting. Like the little boy.

Edited by Kermit8 (05 Sep 2015 5.33pm)


Sorry sir, but I am not talking about famous pictures.
I am merely trying to highlight how wrong it is to have such little respect for a dead child, or any dead person.
It's wrong, simple as that.
There is no positive in the image of that little boy, what so ever. So please stop trying to make yourself feel better by pretending there is. Stop trying to convince yourself that that image is actually ok because it is going to help change the world, because it's not.
It simply highlights how sick/ disrespectful most people are.


So you must disagree with the Belsen newsreels.

But how else are the folks thousands of miles away going to know exactly what is going on out there? Sometimes words just aren't enough. It's the visual that makes everyone take notice.

The famine of '84. Another example.

I would say they -the journalists - are showing respect to those dying or have died by making sure the outside world knew of their plight.

You may not like it but tbh who cares if it helps to save other kids from the same date.


There ya go. A Childs died, who the fcuk cares.
Not you.
Not the woman who felt the financial urge to photograph his body.
Not his dad, who put him in that situation in the first place, then chose to save himself before his family.
Not all the Brits and the rest of Europe crying out to open up the borders and let these poor people in.

There are poor homeless people already here, in our 'great' country.
They are desperate for help, shelter and food. Yet you are all doing sweet FA to help them.
You really could help them, but you haven't
Are our own homeless not worthy.
Are there not enough pictures of them dying for you to give a sh!t.

You sir are probably the first, and only person, in the world, to say that journalists show respect.

Please do keep giving yourself excuses to look at dead children, if that helps make it all 'worthwhile' for you.
I almost, almost pity you more than I do that poor little boy.

 

oldcodger Flag 06 Sep 15 6.01am

Quote ZIGnZAG at 05 Sep 2015 6.04pm

Quote Kermit8 at 05 Sep 2015 5.33pm

A long time ago there was a worldwide picture of a naked teenage girl running with US napalm burning her body.

It helped end the Vietnam War.

The picture of the kid was necessary to give a symbolic slap around the face to those in power to do something. it seems to be working to an extent.

Zig - you are missing the positive points such images can have.

The Belsen film is another. Shocking but also truth home-hitting. Like the little boy.

Edited by Kermit8 (05 Sep 2015 5.33pm)


Sorry sir, but I am not talking about famous pictures.
I am merely trying to highlight how wrong it is to have such little respect for a dead child, or any dead person.
It's wrong, simple as that.
There is no positive in the image of that little boy, what so ever. So please stop trying to make yourself feel better by pretending there is. Stop trying to convince yourself that that image is actually ok because it is going to help change the world, because it's not.
It simply highlights how sick/ disrespectful most people are.


I'm not sure what that means. How does a photograph become famous without someone actually taking it in the first place? This picture is famous too now.

On top of that, the rights or wrongs of a picture being taken is different from what it comes to symbolise once its released, which in turn is often different from its individual circumstances.

 

oldcodger Flag 06 Sep 15 6.08am

Quote ZIGnZAG at 06 Sep 2015 1.12am

Quote Kermit8 at 05 Sep 2015 6.13pm

Quote ZIGnZAG at 05 Sep 2015 6.04pm

Quote Kermit8 at 05 Sep 2015 5.33pm

A long time ago there was a worldwide picture of a naked teenage girl running with US napalm burning her body.

It helped end the Vietnam War.

The picture of the kid was necessary to give a symbolic slap around the face to those in power to do something. it seems to be working to an extent.

Zig - you are missing the positive points such images can have.

The Belsen film is another. Shocking but also truth home-hitting. Like the little boy.

Edited by Kermit8 (05 Sep 2015 5.33pm)


Sorry sir, but I am not talking about famous pictures.
I am merely trying to highlight how wrong it is to have such little respect for a dead child, or any dead person.
It's wrong, simple as that.
There is no positive in the image of that little boy, what so ever. So please stop trying to make yourself feel better by pretending there is. Stop trying to convince yourself that that image is actually ok because it is going to help change the world, because it's not.
It simply highlights how sick/ disrespectful most people are.


So you must disagree with the Belsen newsreels.

But how else are the folks thousands of miles away going to know exactly what is going on out there? Sometimes words just aren't enough. It's the visual that makes everyone take notice.

The famine of '84. Another example.

I would say they -the journalists - are showing respect to those dying or have died by making sure the outside world knew of their plight.

You may not like it but tbh who cares if it helps to save other kids from the same date.


There ya go. A Childs died, who the fcuk cares.
Not you.
Not the woman who felt the financial urge to photograph his body.
Not his dad, who put him in that situation in the first place, then chose to save himself before his family.
Not all the Brits and the rest of Europe crying out to open up the borders and let these poor people in.

There are poor homeless people already here, in our 'great' country.
They are desperate for help, shelter and food. Yet you are all doing sweet FA to help them.
You really could help them, but you haven't
Are our own homeless not worthy.
Are there not enough pictures of them dying for you to give a sh!t.

You sir are probably the first, and only person, in the world, to say that journalists show respect.

Please do keep giving yourself excuses to look at dead children, if that helps make it all 'worthwhile' for you.
I almost, almost pity you more than I do that poor little boy.

So because you don't like what someone is saying your argument has come down to 'I care that this boy died but you don't'? It's like a depraved version of 'my dads bigger than your dad' and as silly at that other blokes "I'm marrying an immigrant, what are you doing'? Is any of this helping anyone?


Edited by oldcodger (06 Sep 2015 6.10am)

 

ffsalan Flag Croydon 06 Sep 15 6.33am

Quote serial thriller at 05 Sep 2015 3.23pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 05 Sep 2015 12.04pm

The picture of that little boy unset me considerably, despite the knowledge that I and anyone opposed to completely unrealistic immigration provision had nothing to do with that child's death.

That child's death was all to do with the stupidity and recklessness of the boy's father.

It is frankly disgusting but typical of certain people to suggest otherwise.

The west owns no one a house and a job....We can't even house our own. The point of a state is to look after its own.....Not others.

Help is reasonable, and we are already correctly contributing to providing to this crises by providing UN funds that are feeding and housing people.

We should take what our government considers reasonable asylum.

What Germany thinks....matters nothing......They and Sweden are partly responsble for this mad dash in the first place.

Let them take them.


Edited by Stirlingsays (05 Sep 2015 12.06pm)


Stirling, I think pointing the finger at a father who a) you have never met, b) has gone through unimaginable struggle and hardship and c) may not even be alive/may have died years ago is pretty sickening.

I'm not criticising your views as such, it just reads as though you are so defensive about your insular position that you are pointing the finger at anyone else, even if they are a conveniently abstracted figure absent from reality.

As for your claim that 'the point of a state is to look after its own', that is just factually inaccurate. Every state in history has had a foreign policy, be it an aggressive one or a benevolent one, and particularly as we move in to an era in which capital is increasingly mobile, in which climate change and war are displacing millions of people and in which resources are growing scarcer and scarcer, viewing nations as separated from each other appears to me a bit silly.

In a way, the tragic story of the little boy washed up on the shore is a metaphor for this whole sorry episode.

His avoidable death was the direct result of his father's desire for the "better life" in Europe at any cost. Not happy with his job in Turkey, he decides to make a new life for himself and family (and thus becomes an economic migrant, not a refugee fleeing a war-torn country). He handed 5000 euros (probably enough for 1st class plane tickets to anywhere in Europe, were he allowed to travel within the law) under cover of darkness to transport his family without lifejackets, knowing full well they couldn't swim.

Why? Because he wanted dental treatment in Europe:

[Link]

[Link]

This child was three years old. He had been living with his family in Turkey for 3 years. Rather than go through the proper channels, or indeed continue a process (appeals or otherwise) of attempting settlement with his sister in Canada, his father decided to take a risk and break international law.

It is the rampant media, engorged on the body counts, the human tragedy, the drama, that are deliberately misleading the public (go compare the BBC footage of the family on the train tracks to the full footage). Obfuscating, hushing up, avoiding. To paint a narrative that has got the liberals so worked up, Europe is now flinging it's doors open to limitless migration. Utter lunacy.

The pull-factor in migration is now enormous. Germany (suspending the EU law it holds so sacred) has intercepted several packages containing fake Syrian passports. I'll leave it to you to question why they were sent.

 

sickboy Flag Deal or Croydon 06 Sep 15 7.10am

Quote ffsalan at 06 Sep 2015 6.33am

Quote serial thriller at 05 Sep 2015 3.23pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 05 Sep 2015 12.04pm

The picture of that little boy unset me considerably, despite the knowledge that I and anyone opposed to completely unrealistic immigration provision had nothing to do with that child's death.

That child's death was all to do with the stupidity and recklessness of the boy's father.

It is frankly disgusting but typical of certain people to suggest otherwise.

The west owns no one a house and a job....We can't even house our own. The point of a state is to look after its own.....Not others.

Help is reasonable, and we are already correctly contributing to providing to this crises by providing UN funds that are feeding and housing people.

We should take what our government considers reasonable asylum.

What Germany thinks....matters nothing......They and Sweden are partly responsble for this mad dash in the first place.

Let them take them.


Edited by Stirlingsays (05 Sep 2015 12.06pm)


Stirling, I think pointing the finger at a father who a) you have never met, b) has gone through unimaginable struggle and hardship and c) may not even be alive/may have died years ago is pretty sickening.

I'm not criticising your views as such, it just reads as though you are so defensive about your insular position that you are pointing the finger at anyone else, even if they are a conveniently abstracted figure absent from reality.

As for your claim that 'the point of a state is to look after its own', that is just factually inaccurate. Every state in history has had a foreign policy, be it an aggressive one or a benevolent one, and particularly as we move in to an era in which capital is increasingly mobile, in which climate change and war are displacing millions of people and in which resources are growing scarcer and scarcer, viewing nations as separated from each other appears to me a bit silly.

In a way, the tragic story of the little boy washed up on the shore is a metaphor for this whole sorry episode.

His avoidable death was the direct result of his father's desire for the "better life" in Europe at any cost. Not happy with his job in Turkey, he decides to make a new life for himself and family (and thus becomes an economic migrant, not a refugee fleeing a war-torn country). He handed 5000 euros (probably enough for 1st class plane tickets to anywhere in Europe, were he allowed to travel within the law) under cover of darkness to transport his family without lifejackets, knowing full well they couldn't swim.

Why? Because he wanted dental treatment in Europe:

[Link]

[Link]

This child was three years old. He had been living with his family in Turkey for 3 years. Rather than go through the proper channels, or indeed continue a process (appeals or otherwise) of attempting settlement with his sister in Canada, his father decided to take a risk and break international law.

It is the rampant media, engorged on the body counts, the human tragedy, the drama, that are deliberately misleading the public (go compare the BBC footage of the family on the train tracks to the full footage). Obfuscating, hushing up, avoiding. To paint a narrative that has got the liberals so worked up, Europe is now flinging it's doors open to limitless migration. Utter lunacy.

The pull-factor in migration is now enormous. Germany (suspending the EU law it holds so sacred) has intercepted several packages containing fake Syrian passports. I'll leave it to you to question why they were sent.


Brilliant post.

 

Page 28 of 51 < 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > No more immigrants.