You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Who’s at fault - Hodgson or the board?
November 16 2026 7.42am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Who’s at fault - Hodgson or the board?


Page 28 of 44 < 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 >
Bangell Flag Oxford 24 Dec 18 8.18pm

Apparently Parish tried to stop us signing Jimmy Mac [Link]

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 24 Dec 18 9.50pm

I don’t believe he tried to stop it but fvck about at the death I can.

 

Bald---Eagle Flag 25 Dec 18 10.46am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Tip Hat To Roy?' by bexleydave

Have to tip me hat to Roy. After all the clowns and half decent triers we've had managing CPFC since we last got promoted, he has clearly excelled them all.
That performance by Palace was streets ahead of anything before Roy, and that wasn't the only match. I think back of the amateurish long hoofing style we once played, the crazy subs by various managers, the silly talk in interviews by some, the dancing of one when we hadn't won an FA cup yet (cough), and compare that to the classy Roy and the classy football we now see. And we tried so hard to avoid him didn't we? Happy Christmas Roy and thank you. Tip yer hat if you agree.

 

eagle180 Flag Croydon 25 Dec 18 12.25pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Tip Hat To Roy?' by bexleydave

Hat tipped.
Let's hope Santa sends him a striker.

 


Twitter @DelMay

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 25 Dec 18 12.52pm

It was not that long ago when Hodgson was being pilloried on here for his use of substitutes etc etc and the very title of this thread is indicative of the mood music at the time.

A sensational win at Man C has changed the mood and he is being lauded - a defeat or even a draw at home to Cardiff and I suspect the negativity towards our manager will return.The peaks and troughs of being a football manager.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 25 Dec 18 3.28pm

Originally posted by Willo

It was not that long ago when Hodgson was being pilloried on here for his use of substitutes etc etc and the very title of this thread is indicative of the mood music at the time.

A sensational win at Man C has changed the mood and he is being lauded - a defeat or even a draw at home to Cardiff and I suspect the negativity towards our manager will return.The peaks and troughs of being a football manager.

The win at Manchester City had very little to do with Roy's use of substitues

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 25 Dec 18 5.05pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

The win at Manchester City had very little to do with Roy's use of substitues

I appreciate that.

The point I was making (Probably not very well !) was that Hodgson is now being lauded after that magnificent victory but not so long ago was being pilloried,so really contrasting emotions highlighting the peaks and troughs of football management.One minute he is being criticised and the next he is way up that 'Totem pole'.If we don't win tomorrow he might well slide down that pole.

Edited by Willo (25 Dec 2018 5.07pm)

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 25 Dec 18 6.37pm

Originally posted by Willo

I appreciate that.

The point I was making (Probably not very well !) was that Hodgson is now being lauded after that magnificent victory but not so long ago was being pilloried,so really contrasting emotions highlighting the peaks and troughs of football management.One minute he is being criticised and the next he is way up that 'Totem pole'.If we don't win tomorrow he might well slide down that pole.

Edited by Willo (25 Dec 2018 5.07pm)

Not by all. He is not immune to criticism when due but overall has done a brilliant job with the players available

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 25 Dec 18 6.56pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

Not by all. He is not immune to criticism when due but overall has done a brilliant job with the players available

Saving us from the dreaded drop last season is worthy of the utmost praise.A truly magnificent achievement.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 25 Dec 18 7.03pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

The win at Manchester City had very little to do with Roy's use of substitues

Precisely, he only uses them if he feels they are necessary, not as an obligation.

 

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 25 Dec 18 7.37pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

On the pitch as I mentioned we are and possibly with the new stand built and being placed in London we definitely are on a par with them....yesterday and today's result only backs me up.

nowhere near fella...nowhere near

their average signing now is £30m and are having a spangly new ground built on yhe docks with billionaire owners willing to invest.

in todays market we are the same size as watford / bournmouth / southampton

and theres nowt wrong with that, aslong as we dont get above out station and expect things that simply arnt going to happen.

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 25 Dec 18 7.45pm

Originally posted by braunstoneagle

nowhere near fella...nowhere near

their average signing now is £30m and are having a spangly new ground built on yhe docks with billionaire owners willing to invest.

in todays market we are the same size as watford / bournmouth / southampton

and theres nowt wrong with that, aslong as we dont get above out station and expect things that simply arnt going to happen.

I concur with these sentiments.

I believe that Everton have been in the top flight since 1954 and regularly get crowds of around 39,000.Their net spend in the summer was around £70 Mill.They have always been considered a bigger club than us.

Edited by Willo (25 Dec 2018 7.48pm)

 

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 25 Dec 18 8.34pm

I try to compare us to ourselves, have we gotten better is the only question i ask myself.

i'm not interested in other clubs, ofcourse it's nice to be able to attract a player or two that maybe we felt would opt else where - but i do feel we are an attractive club - purely down to london and the quality of the clubs around and those players - you got mates at chelsea, palace is good as an example.

Roy has been tremendous, i have seen us play some excellent football and ofcourse bad, but a lot of clubs we are blinkered too, also do.

I only wish they had significantly backed roy this summer.

 


This was once a quality forum....

steve1984 25 Dec 18 8.37pm

Originally posted by braunstoneagle

in todays market we are the same size as watford / bournmouth / southampton

..and probably smaller than Villa, Sunderland and Nottingham Forest.

Seems to me that there are only 7 clubs who are assured of a place in the PL. 2 in Liverpool, 2 in Manchester and 3 in London. We're a long way off joining that group.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 26 Dec 18 1.07pm

Originally posted by Willo

It was not that long ago when Hodgson was being pilloried on here for his use of substitutes etc etc and the very title of this thread is indicative of the mood music at the time.

A sensational win at Man C has changed the mood and he is being lauded - a defeat or even a draw at home to Cardiff and I suspect the negativity towards our manager will return.The peaks and troughs of being a football manager.

This is all now getting a little confusing. Look at the highlights, we should have been absolutely hammered. Instead we score the goal of the century, and have some belief. Went on to play with heart, and BELIEF!

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 27 Dec 18 11.16pm

I only meant to suggest how underachieving we have been and that the difference between the two clubs talents on the pitch is very very small and nothing about our history, our consistent performances (not results of course) warrant us a similar placing to a club like Everton's, this is what I meant.

 

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 28 Dec 18 12.50am

Originally posted by steve1984

..and probably smaller than Villa, Sunderland and Nottingham Forest.

Seems to me that there are only 7 clubs who are assured of a place in the PL. 2 in Liverpool, 2 in Manchester and 3 in London. We're a long way off joining that group.

It's interesting - what makes a 'big' club?

for me, it's a little bit of everything - it's their history, the fan base. Bournemouth are a successful club and doing better than us, are they bigger than us, no!

We're doing better than Newcastle, are we bigger, no. I think it boils down to fanbase, as that is always there and the potential revenue a club can make through sponsorship etc in a way.

 


This was once a quality forum....

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 28 Dec 18 8.56am

Originally posted by Vaibow

It's interesting - what makes a 'big' club?

for me, it's a little bit of everything - it's their history, the fan base. Bournemouth are a successful club and doing better than us, are they bigger than us, no!

We're doing better than Newcastle, are we bigger, no. I think it boils down to fanbase, as that is always there and the potential revenue a club can make through sponsorship etc in a way.

I appreciate that there were Brad C supporters at the game but Sunderland attracted over 46,000 on Boxing Day.

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 28 Dec 18 9.10am

I think that Parish has built a lot of good credit with the fans and rightly so; 2010 saved the club and steered us to the premier league. That said, there has been one particular oversight which, for me, is completely unacceptable: the relative failure of the club to produce quality youth players. AWB is the only premier league standard player for over 6 seasons, yet we (did) have a renowned setup, good history of producing talent and a huge and diverse catchment area.

For me, the job Nicola Cortese did at Southampton should be the model for clubs like palace: invest in youth and use it to build squads and increase revenue through selling on. Instead, we have a massive wage bill for average players, an inability to strengthen without horse trading, and no strength in depth.

Add to all this an obsession with the 'history' of the club centering around the early 90s team which smacks of jobs for the boys and the stadium saga (I personally don't believe we'll ever see a new stand; it'll keep being put back until we're relegated and then binned off) and you've got an unsustainable model based on just doing enough to stay in the division season by season which we've seen with the likes of Fulham and Stoke in the past will always run out eventually.
Roy has his flaws, but is his job the envy of the footballing world? Who is there better, and would they be backed?

Until the setup changes and the model adjusted, any manager that can tread water is in truth doing a fantastic job given the circumstances and, more dishearteningly, is hitting his boardroom targets.

 

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 29 Dec 18 5.33am

Originally posted by ChrisGC

I think that Parish has built a lot of good credit with the fans and rightly so; 2010 saved the club and steered us to the premier league. That said, there has been one particular oversight which, for me, is completely unacceptable: the relative failure of the club to produce quality youth players. AWB is the only premier league standard player for over 6 seasons, yet we (did) have a renowned setup, good history of producing talent and a huge and diverse catchment area.

For me, the job Nicola Cortese did at Southampton should be the model for clubs like palace: invest in youth and use it to build squads and increase revenue through selling on. Instead, we have a massive wage bill for average players, an inability to strengthen without horse trading, and no strength in depth.

Add to all this an obsession with the 'history' of the club centering around the early 90s team which smacks of jobs for the boys and the stadium saga (I personally don't believe we'll ever see a new stand; it'll keep being put back until we're relegated and then binned off) and you've got an unsustainable model based on just doing enough to stay in the division season by season which we've seen with the likes of Fulham and Stoke in the past will always run out eventually.
Roy has his flaws, but is his job the envy of the footballing world? Who is there better, and would they be backed?

Until the setup changes and the model adjusted, any manager that can tread water is in truth doing a fantastic job given the circumstances and, more dishearteningly, is hitting his boardroom targets.

Apart from is in bold, everything else you wrote is a negative and a big negative and i agree with you.

So let's focus on the bold - as the saving grace of Parish. 2010 did indeed buy the club, but at the final hour to get the best deal - Jordan openly spoke about this. Some say shrewd business, others say exploiting the club - it's open for debate.

Steered us to the premier league - hardly. Parish himself said we got promoted sooner than expected - what was it, in his second full season as chairman? Burley sacked, Freedman in, got a rollocking in the carpark, then had a streak then went to Bolton. Holloway came in, we got promoted then he walked/shoved out.

Parish has been nothing but a chancer, masquerading as a shrewd businessman as a lot fo your post shows.

 


This was once a quality forum....

Page 28 of 44 < 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Who’s at fault - Hodgson or the board?