This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
MPs blame Boris Johnson’s ‘poison’ after protesters mob Keir Starmer.
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
AFAIK this group has nothing to do with BLM and were not approved by the electoral commission anyway. I would rather people understand that fact to avoid them getting riled up on inaccurate information regarding this demographic being approved as a political party and white people not, when that appears to be untrue. I won't speak to motivation for your comments. Quote
'Explicitly exclude the wider electorate?' I could see some sense in objections if a party explicitly said, 'no jews' or whatever identity. However that isn't what has happened as the constitution of the largest dissident group doesn't say that....I couldn't speak for the black Christian group mentioned....but I would pretty much doubt it. Once the electoral commission enter the domain of making announcements upon what they consider acceptable political positions they are no longer objective and are acting as political gate keepers. That's creating pressure and steam without a form of release. In the constitution I looked at I couldn't see that much difference from a Ukip one and all these groups contain socially conservative homosexuals and non whites anyway.....probably my go to chap at the moment on the dissident right is half Iranian. You don't have to be a pure European or even European to be against the great replacement. The previous group you were into specifically wanted non whites who were born here to leave the country. How is that a group with wide appeal (even amongst whites actually? Any pretense at a broad church is contrived by these groups to legitimise them. As for this black Christian group, well on the surface it could be benign, but I know little about its motivation. If they're genuinely only interested in black rights or black Christians and everyone else is either omitted or tagged on out of necessity then no I'm not interested in groups like this being able to become political parties. By virtue of what they represent they would be unable to govern or represent the people.
|
|
|
Originally posted by BlueJay
The previous group you were into specifically wanted non whites who were born here to leave the country. How is that a group with wide appeal (even amongst whites actually? Any pretense at a broad church is contrived by these groups to legitimise them. As for this black Christian group, well on the surface it could be benign, but I know little about its motivation. If they're genuinely only interested in black rights or black Christians and everyone else is either omitted or tagged on out of necessity then no I'm not interested in groups like this being able to become political parties. By virtue of what they represent they would be unable to govern or represent the people. Edited by BlueJay (07 Feb 2022 9.22pm) On what basis does a party have to have 'wide appeal' to stand for election? It only has to be non violent and represent the national demographic who wish to vote for it. Most political parties don't have 'wide appeal'. And it's quite something for you to proclaim that a 'broad church' doesn't exist when you actually don't know a thing about it. Your criteria for standing seems to be a politicised one in my view and against representing real demographics who exist in the country who currently aren't being represented.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
On what basis does a party have to have 'wide appeal' to stand for election? It only has to be non violent and represent the national demographic who wish to vote for it. Most political parties don't have 'wide appeal'. And it's quite something for you to proclaim that a 'broad church' doesn't exist when you actually don't know a thing about it. Your criteria is a politicised one and is the non legitimate opinion in my view. Edited by Stirlingsays (07 Feb 2022 10.04pm) Well certainly for some of these more fringe groups, claims to non violence are questionable to begin be. Claims of non violence have to be weighed against the reality of what groups represent and who they are in lockstep with or attract. It's my contention that groups that are clearly based around race (however much 'pussyfooting' is done) are not electable, and beyond that are not able to represent the electorate. I don't want any party that is hoping to boot people of other races out of my country in power thanks, or to look at people from birth (black or white) as 'other than'. It's hardly some kind of affront to decency to hold that view. You can think it's 'quite something' or a 'non legitimate opinion' all you want. You have the out there views. Ironically I tolerate those, and you're the one aghast at mine. An unhealthy detachment from society and community. Edited by BlueJay (07 Feb 2022 10.21pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by BlueJay
Well certainly for some of these more fringe groups, claims to non violence are questionable to begin be. Claims of non violence have to be weighed against the reality of what groups represent and who they are in lockstep with or attract. It's my contention that groups that are clearly based around race (however much 'pussyfooting' is done) are not electable, and beyond that are not able to represent the electorate. I don't want any party that is hoping to boot people of other races out of my country in power thanks, or to look at people from birth (black or white) as 'other than'. It's hardly some kind of affront to decency to hold that view. You can think it's 'quite something' or a 'non legitimate opinion' all you want. You have the out there views. Ironically I tolerate those, and you're the one aghast at mine. An unhealthy detachment from society and community. Edited by BlueJay (07 Feb 2022 10.21pm) All that matters is the history of the group in question....I'm not aware of groups interested in violence because I've never sought them. Tell me where is the evidence for you to say it's 'questionable' that a particular group isn't against using violence? When it states it is and has no history of it. Your opinion that you don't think groups against the great replacement should be allowed to compete for votes is noted.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by BlueJay
Quote Your opinion that you don't think groups against the great replacement should be allowed to compete for votes is noted.
You appear to have invented another opinion for me. I stated that: "It's my contention that groups that are clearly based around race are not electable, and beyond that are not able to represent the electorate. I don't want any party that is hoping to boot people of other races (due to their race) out of my country in power thanks, or to look at people from birth (black or white) as 'other than'. It's hardly some kind of affront to decency to hold that view. You can think it's 'quite something' or a 'non legitimate opinion' all you want." I dare say the vast majority of people would agree with that view. A party should compete for our votes based on their merits of their policies. Not look to point an exit sign for British born babies they don't like the look of.
Well, as you like to characterise the opinions of others to your own perceptions of them....for example 'violence' I should think you'd approve of me inventing opinions for you....it seems to be something you like. Again, I can only say that I note your position that you wish this group to receive no democratic representation. Personally I think your position is short sighted and regrettable but that's just my view.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
I think it is almost impossible to create a successful new party. Back in the eighties Labour were unelectable this lead to the SDP and then Lib Dems however as soon as a moderate left party started to make traction the Labour Party reacted. Labour kicked out some of the more odious members rebranded itself as cuddly New Labour and the public accepted that bye bye SDP / Liberals as an election force. The Tories did the same with UKIP once Nigel started to win votes they had to react the best way to do that is to adopt your competitors clothes.* Now that Labour and the Tory part have seen off the threat from their rivals they just revert to their natural state and ignore the voters. *Remoaners often complain that the Tories should never have allowed a referendum but they reacted exactly the same way as Labour did under john Smith and then Tony Blair. The difference being that Labour was in opposition when they made their changes. So In summary anytime a new party appears whichever one it threatens just adopts its policies until the public lose interest. Both Tory and Labour adopted Green policies to some extent when they started to gain traction. One thing for sure is that if a new party does emerge it wont be Gina Miller's Edited by Badger11 (07 Feb 2022 8.11am) We aren't though talking about the likelihood, or not, of electoral success. Only whether it could be registered. Nothing that Gina Miller would have in her constitution would run foul of the law, would it?
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Well, as you like to characterise the opinions of others to your own perceptions of them....for example 'violence' I should think you'd approve of me inventing opinions for you....it seems to be something you like. Again, I can only say that I note your position that you wish this group to receive no democratic representation. Personally I think your position is short sighted and regrettable but that's just my view. Who exactly is saying you approve of violence? I've certainly not ever said you do. I purposefully didn't reply to that part of the message to begin with because it just ends up publicising these groups. Said in a general sense, noteworthy white identity and indeed muslim groups have been prescribed due to threat of violence and murder. Often when this happens some members gravitate towards other groups. As stated identity groups inevitably state that they are non violent. Many are, some aren't, some ultimately likely don't even know what they are themselves. If indeed they are non violent then fair play. If they are and multiple members end up locked up for racial or religious violence than that will become clear too. It's a problem that solves itself. A better argument than rose tinted glasses would be to argue that marginalised groups inevitable attract more of a 'mixed bag' than mainstream parties. This is a distraction from the main point anyway. I was simply stating why I have very significant reservations about 'black' or 'white' political parties and why I'm not so emotionally addled that I decree the national value or worth of a child as soon as it emerges from the womb. You seem to have been in some kind of perpetual grump mode in the face of sensible replies today. Try cheering up. Edited by BlueJay (07 Feb 2022 11.47pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by BlueJay
Who exactly is saying you approve of violence? I've certainly not ever said you do. No, I never thought you said that, I was referring to the idea that we should question violence from groups that stand against actual violence to reach political aims. Originally posted by BlueJay
I purposefully didn't reply to that part of the message to begin with because it just ends up publicising these groups. Said in a general sense, noteworthy white identity and indeed muslim groups have been prescribed due to threat of violence and murder. Often when this happens some members gravitate towards other groups. As stated all any any identity groups inevitably state that they are non violent. Many are, some aren't, some ultimately likely don't even know what they are themselves. If indeed they are non violent then fair play. If they aren't and multiple members end up locked up for racial or religious violence than that will become clear too. A better argument than rose tinted glasses would be to argue the marginalised groups inevitable attract more of a 'mixed bag' than mainstream parties. This is a distraction from the main point anyway. I was simply stating why I have very significant reservations about 'black' or 'white' political parties and why I'm not so emotionally dead that I decree the value or worth of a child as soon as it emerges from the womb. You seem to have been in some kind of perpetual grump mode in the face or sensible replies today. Try cheering up. Edited by BlueJay (07 Feb 2022 11.39pm)
Am I grumpy? I have some internalised anger over what's happened to my country and what's happening globally....but I also think I've grown disconnected to it, like an outside observer of a stage play whose ending is obvious and very sad. Anyway you certainly have more energy than I have to write about this stuff at the moment....I'm sleepy.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
All that matters is the history of the group in question....I'm not aware of groups interested in violence because I've never sought them. Tell me where is the evidence for you to say it's 'questionable' that a particular group isn't against using violence? When it states it is and has no history of it. Your opinion that you don't think groups against the great replacement should be allowed to compete for votes is noted. Edited by Stirlingsays (07 Feb 2022 10.39pm) Any potential party with this as part of its purpose is going to run into trouble. Not with the Electoral Commission itself but with the obligations placed upon it. This is how the "Great Replacement Theory" is described by "The Counter Extremism Project":- This is the page from the Electoral Commission's site dealing with how applications are made and assessed:- This extract is pertinent:- "Registration is not automatic. The Commission assesses whether the party’s application and identity marks meet the criteria set out in electoral law, as well as legal obligations under equality laws" So, like everything else, a new political party must be lawful, which the attitudes espoused by The Great Replacement Theory do not appear to be.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Am I grumpy? I have some internalised anger over what's happened to my country and what's happening globally....but I also think I've grown disconnected to it, like an outside observer of a stage play whose ending is obvious and very sad. Anyway you certainly have more energy than I have to write about this stuff at the moment....I'm sleepy. Okay, maybe you're not then and I imagined it haha. I'm not sure that any of us live long enough to truly work any of this out anyway. And there are so many curveballs and issues that present themselves that are often outside of our own sense of identity being central to it. All complicated by the fact that in a connected world (online and off) ten years this way or that people often have very different lives and viewpoints, no matter what tune we're intent on whistling. A record we love to play, when even those we care about may well end up holding dear a different tune. As is life.
|
|
|
Originally posted by HKOwen
Labour had Lammy doing the TV yesterday, I always thought he was black, my bad. Mr Steeleye, your silence is deafening. So it was either Conservatives not playing the race card or Labour doing the same thing, you can't have it both ways.
Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance. |
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
MPs blame Boris Johnson’s ‘poison’ after protesters mob Keir Starmer. The reaction to this looks as though it could be the "coup de grâce" for Johnson. I had not heard of this MP, but her words cut to the core:- "Labour’s Rosena Allin-Khan told BBC Radio 4's Today programme the prime minister “should not be looking in the dark corners of the internet for lies to smear his opponents, but standing up for a better public discourse based on fact, not fiction”. In a fierce attack on Boris Johnson, the shadow minster for mental health called on the PM to come to Parliament “and apologise unreservedly for his smears”. “Words have consequences,” she said, echoing many of her Labour colleagues on Tuesday morning. “We need to have responsible leaders who fight fake news and conspiracy theories - not promote them.” “This is straight out of the Trumpian playbook. Boris Johnson has come in to public office to seize power and smear any person, or group, who stands in his way. “There is no barrel he won’t scrape.”"
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
Yes, this thread was migrating into an interesting debate that has little to do with the OP. Again. Meanwhile, that attack on Starmer was something of a storm in a teacup; but it is the fact that it was OBVIOUSLY incited by the PM that is significant. He denies that it was down to him! How? Not only that, but he said he is far too busy to apologise. Thus a neat combination of scurrilous, spineless and unscrupulous. You may love the guy, you may not want harm to your party or government, but surely this is indefensible and beyond the pale? He's supposed to be the PM, leading from the front. What message does this send to the people and the world? How do you not cringe that he has sought to appeal to the absolute lowest base? I think what Johnson said about Starmer on Saville was unfortunate. Apologising though....That probably weakens him further. The left frequently stir their base up against Tories you don't see them being all morally self reflective about it. Their base loves it. The stuff said about Thatcher makes what Johnson said so milk toast in comparison....but now it matters? Edited by Stirlingsays (08 Feb 2022 10.07am)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I think what Johnson said about Starmer on Saville was unfortunate. Apologising though....That probably weakens him further. The left frequently stir their base up against Tories you don't see them being all morally self reflective about it. Their base loves it. The stuff said about Thatcher makes what Johnson said so milk toast in comparison....but now it matters? Edited by Stirlingsays (08 Feb 2022 10.07am) Whataboutism is irrelevant. What is relevant is how, and when, the Tory MPs react and what they are getting from their constituents. Johnson has sent most of the MPs home this week, prior to a 10-day recess, in the hope he can weather the storm and re-establish control. The next couple of days could be interesting.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
The reaction to this looks as though it could be the "coup de grâce" for Johnson. I had not heard of this MP, but her words cut to the core:- "Labour’s Rosena Allin-Khan told BBC Radio 4's Today programme the prime minister “should not be looking in the dark corners of he internet for lies to smear his opponents, but standing up for a better public discourse based on fact, not fiction”. In a fierce attack on Boris Johnson, the shadow minster for mental health called on the PM to come to Parliament “and apologise unreservedly for his smears”. “Words have consequences,” she said, echoing many of her Labour colleagues on Tuesday morning. “We need to have responsible leaders who fight fake news and conspiracy theories - not promote them.” “This is straight out of the Trumpian playbook. Boris Johnson has come in to public office to seize power and smear any person, or group, who stands in his way. “There is no barrel he won’t scrape.”" Comedy hour on the HOL.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Any potential party with this as part of its purpose is going to run into trouble. Not with the Electoral Commission itself but with the obligations placed upon it. This is how the "Great Replacement Theory" is described by "The Counter Extremism Project":- This is the page from the Electoral Commission's site dealing with how applications are made and assessed:- This extract is pertinent:- "Registration is not automatic. The Commission assesses whether the party’s application and identity marks meet the criteria set out in electoral law, as well as legal obligations under equality laws" So, like everything else, a new political party must be lawful, which the attitudes espoused by The Great Replacement Theory do not appear to be. Theory? So do tell us all how you think this obvious eventuality will be reversed.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.