This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Wilesy01
Oh goodie a man who uses social media to amplify hateful lies and pour misery onto bereaved parents (and endanger them in the process due to morons believing his rants and targeting them) has been let back onto Twitter. Just days before the anniversary of Sandy Hook no less. Great work, Elon! Good, kudos to Elon. You use social media to amplify hate....it's just the hate you agree with. Alex Jones was wrong on Sandy Hook and deserved pushback and criticism. However, he apologized years ago and said he was wrong but your crew of hate has made him bankrupt for having unpopular opinions. But it's people like you who can't accept an apology. But times are changing now and progressives are losing power and it's the best thing that's happened for a long time. Free speech is not about protecting the speech what you agree with.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Good, kudos to Elon. You use social media to amplify hate....it's just the hate you agree with. Alex Jones was wrong on Sandy Hook and deserved pushback and criticism. However, he apologized years ago and said he was wrong but your crew of hate has made him bankrupt for having unpopular opinions. But it's people like you who can't accept an apology. But times are changing now and progressives are losing power and it's the best thing that's happened for a long time. Free speech is not about protecting the speech what you agree with.
If you bothered to watch his trial you'd have seen him row back and forth as to whether or not he believed Sandy Hook was a conspiracy. And perhaps one would argue that if he felt any legitimate remorse he'd have turned up to the final judgement and show contrition rather than broadcast live online from miles away mocking the whole process. Therefore no, I can't accept his apology. Also reference he only offered a meek apology when he knew he was going to be sued for defamation. What a stand up guy, eh? As to your word soup about me personally using social media for hate - nope, can't say I do. My expectation is that social media platforms take a view on disallowing those who make up/repudiate vile lies and target individuals as it can lead to incredibly negative outcomes. People mistake using an internet website as their right to total free speech no matter what they say. Many, including this one, have rules stating the contrary. And I can't say the Hol has ever infringed my freedom of speech!
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wilesy01
If you bothered to watch his trial you'd have seen him row back and forth as to whether or not he believed Sandy Hook was a conspiracy. And perhaps one would argue that if he felt any legitimate remorse he'd have turned up to the final judgement and show contrition rather than broadcast live online from miles away mocking the whole process. Therefore no, I can't accept his apology. Also reference he only offered a meek apology when he knew he was going to be sued for defamation. What a stand up guy, eh? As to your word soup about me personally using social media for hate - nope, can't say I do. My expectation is that social media platforms take a view on disallowing those who make up/repudiate vile lies and target individuals as it can lead to incredibly negative outcomes. People mistake using an internet website as their right to total free speech no matter what they say. Many, including this one, have rules stating the contrary. And I can't say the Hol has ever infringed my freedom of speech! You literally just gave an opinion that demonised hate onto Alex Jones - who you hate - and then in the next paragraph say that social media should not allow hateful speech. Like here, describing Jones's apology as false and opportunistic. As if you have some kind of insight into whether anyone other than yourself is sincere about an apology or not. I been hearing Jones make apologies for Sandy Hook for years. But apparently you have a magical insight. So no, I don't accept your demonsied characterisation because it doesn't come from a place of balance. You are exactly what I described. You are fine with the hate you agree with and find it hard to accept opinions that disagree with you. You aren't interested in allowing speech you disagree with......So you end up creating the very thing you claim to oppose. Here's an idea, if you don't like someone just don't listen to them. However, don't decide for others what ideas they can decide on. Like I say, it's a good thing that people like yourself are losing power now. Unlike you, we won't stop you from speaking though....But it'll always be remembered that your type abused power when they had it. Edited by Stirlingsays (10 Dec 2023 8.11pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
You literally just gave an opinion that demonised hate onto Alex Jones - who you hate - and then in the next paragraph say that social media should not allow hateful speech. Like here, describing Jones's apology as false and opportunistic. As if you have some kind of insight into whether anyone other than yourself is sincere about an apology or not. I been hearing Jones make apologies for Sandy Hook for years. But apparently you have a magical insight. So no, I don't accept your demonsied characterisation because it doesn't come from a place of balance. You are exactly what I described. You are fine with the hate you agree with and find it hard to accept opinions that disagree with you. You aren't interested in allowing speech you disagree with......So you end up creating the very thing you claim to oppose. Here's an idea, if you don't like someone just don't listen to them. However, don't decide for others what ideas they can decide on. Like I say, it's a good thing that people like yourself are losing power now. Unlike you, we won't stop you from speaking though....But it'll always be remembered that your type abused power when they had it. Edited by Stirlingsays (10 Dec 2023 8.11pm) This makes for some rather painful reading. As stated if you watch clips from his trial he goes back and forth on his opinion of Sandy Hook. He states he's apologised to the parents whom his conspiracies targeted but then states he still thinks it was all a hoax and that he won't apologise again. Now call me cynical but that doesn't really sound like an apology does it? Note he also livestreamed Info Wars whilst the trials verdict was being delivered. He mocked the process and didn't show an ounce of contrition for what he'd done. I haven't, not have I ever made anything up about him. Both of the above are facts and in the public domain so I welcome you to do your own research. Note I have also never encouraged others to do anything bad to him so I really can't take any of your criticism seriously.
|
|
|
Oh the irony.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I want to address the point that a certain poster makes about free speech. He of course supports significant speech restrictions on opinions he doesn't agree with. I don't, short of the old traditional norms known in America....it's far from perfect but it avoids authoritarianism and is a safeguard against tyranny. The Biden administration seek to manipulate and disregard that law when it favours their side of course....being the type of people they are. Nevertheless people have mocked and criticised the powerful in both America and the UK since I can remember and long before it....So his point doesn't hold true....it's only now with the sickness of the politics he supports that this picture is changing. So to accuse me of not supporting free speech when he's far worse is typical of the guy. Regardless, I don't know what he's referring to in the Orban situation, where people's ability to speech is restricted so I can hardly comment. As for the situation in Russia I have criticised that several times. However, the same situation exists in Ukraine, yet that strangely goes without criticism so I regard this concern as pretty selective. I heard the other day that more people were arrested for comments online in Britain than in Russia...So if I heard that correctly it speaks to the somewhat rose tinted glasses some people wear.....Let's not forget that a woman was arrested for praying silently outside an abortion centre in this country....an act he fully supported on here....as he did all the civil liberty restrictions imposed during lockdowns....people literally not being allowed to meet in a park. So forgive me for regarding his comments on anything to do with freedoms as little more than a poor taste joke.
I won't speak up for Alex Jones but I don't believe that private social media companies should get to decide who has free speech or not. If people don't like what they hear they can either turn off or sue in the courts which has happened to Jones and he deserved it.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
I won't speak up for Alex Jones but I don't believe that private social media companies should get to decide who has free speech or not. If people don't like what they hear they can either turn off or sue in the courts which has happened to Jones and he deserved it.
Of course social media companies shouldn’t decide who has free speech or not. That’s not their role. It’s ours, via our elected representatives. The role of the social media companies is to abide by any laws that our representatives enact. Requiring the social media companies to monitor content to ensure it is lawful is a necessary requirement in today’s world. You cannot just allow a free for all and leave it to individuals to sue. The court system is already clogged to breaking point. It is also so costly that many otherwise worthwhile cases don’t reach court simply because of the cost. The only effective way to establish any kind of regulation is at source. Then if people feel they are being unreasonably excluded they can sue, or find an alternative platform.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
I won't speak up for Alex Jones but I don't believe that private social media companies should get to decide who has free speech or not. If people don't like what they hear they can either turn off or sue in the courts which has happened to Jones and he deserved it.
I'm sorry to hear you feel that way.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by georgenorman
Street preachers have been arrested, a woman was arrested for silently praying. "The further a society drifts from truth the more it will hate those who speak it." [Orwell] No she wasn’t. She was arrested for deliberately breaking a very restricted exclusion order which was issued to protect the rights of others. It was done only after many warnings and followed several similar instances. She was not arrested for silently praying. She could do that anywhere where there were no restrictions.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Let me be very clear. I don’t support “significant restrictions on speech I don’t agree with”. Such speech I want to see defeated by better speech. I don’t want to see this argument banned. I want it defeated by a better argument. What I accept and understand is that an absolute right to free speech is a myth. Not because of any views of mine but because of the views of us. We have decided, because of the need for a functioning society, to restrict the expression of certain things in certain places. Libel, slander and hate speech being examples. Bringing in “the Biden administration “ into this argument, alongside every other is nonsensical. They will be cited as the reason we have lost 4 times on the bounce at home next! Mocking and criticising the powerful is perfectly ok. Indeed it is important to do so. Just so long as it doesn’t slander, libel, incite or otherwise break the law. Freedoms only exist under the law. Nothing is above it. Claiming not to understand the reference to Orban is either disingenuous or ill informed. Take your pick. Journalists and others have suffered in many ways. Ukraine wasn’t mentioned because Ukraine hasn’t been defended. I have no idea how many people have been arrested for online comments in Britain, but it cannot be many as I cannot recall a report. Nor how many in Russia but I suspect that’s either because such information is suppressed by the state controlled media or that transgressors receive rather more severe punishment. Of course I supported the arrest of a woman who deliberately disobeyed a limited restriction order in order to gain publicity for a cause. Much like I support the arrest of Yaxley-Lennon for doing exactly the same thing. Such orders are issued reluctantly and only when the rights of others are under threat. So forgive me for regarding his comments as hypocritical nonsense. Freedom of speech is alive and well. Provided it remains lawful. Laws being things that we decide as a society and, once decided, apply to us all. Why the constant need to refer to "Yaxley-Lennon"? The same convention didn't apply to Mary O'Leary or indeed Dazet Zaha.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
Freedom of speech is the freedom to speak within the limitations imposed upon you by those with power. It is therefore oxymoronic and something I've long held umbrage with. The likes of Alex Jones fall victim where a populous is so devastatingly idiotic, considerable portions of it are likely to be encouraged to action by whatever they hear, or even that they may disastrously misinterpret. As opposed to tackling anything dangerous or just downright nuts, it is perhaps safer and far more effective to nullify the source so as to prevent or mitigate anarchy and worse. The issue with the above comes where the determination of what is necessary to be nullified falls to a small faction of a society, in this case politicians. The downright ludicrous and easily debunked stance that these people act purely in the interest of the society they serve is not only ignorant of the human condition but completely laughable. As things stand, the socio-political landscape means that there probably are numerous things where their promulgation does need to be nullified, such as that which incites terrorist activity or threatens the safety of the populous. The issue remains however that equally, anything that is deemed to threaten the law makers or powers that be can be incorporated into this bracket to serve their interests, with the right narrative behind it. This therefore means that the justification of, and mechanisms for nullifying the dangerous can be utilised to nullify political opposition. They get to decide that which constitutes a danger and providing ambiguous categorisations such as 'hate speech', WTF does that really mean anyway, allow them to do this. This also allows them to 'green light' anything that may equally pose a danger to the population, but again, serves their interests. That's why today we have those with any grievance against the likes of immigration, the promotion of the alphabet soup, the mutilation of children, the Orwellian state etc being branded as 'far-right', nomenclature the powers that be know will cast a black mark upon such entities and thus a narrative that will justify their suppression within what can perhaps more easily be described as a 'far-left' socio-political landscape. We never hear that though, do we? That though is democracy. If enough vote for change then change will happen. I don’t see politicians acting to protect themselves. If they did I would expect a media outcry to quickly stop it. I am glad though that you acknowledge the need for some reasonable and necessary restrictions, when they are clearly in the public interest. Whatever people brand you is irrelevant. I have been branded many things here, but I just ignore them. People are entitled to their opinions and to express them freely. I am unaware of anyone’s freedom of speech being threatened over that, whether they are from the right or the left. All that’s needed is a tough skin and nothing will touch you. It’s different if you are part of a previously marginalised or excluded group for which direct intervention is currently considered necessary. You can freely argue against that intervention but whilst it exists you are obliged to respect it.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.