You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Bedroom tax
November 22 2026 1.33am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Bedroom tax


Page 3 of 7 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >
Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 21 Feb 13 3.04pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 21 Feb 2013 2.54pm

It does make me wonder what the hell politicians get up to all day when they come up with rubbish like this. All this pointless tinkering around the edges, coming up with micro-wheezes which, even if they do get implemented, don't make a blind bit of difference anyway. And all because they're terrified of offending anyone and losing a few votes.

Stop piddling around. Just cut all benefits in half for, say, the last six months of 2013. Wallop. 35 billion saved in one. Sure, people would moan and kick up a stink. Tough titties, benefits'll go back to normal at the start of 2014, it's free money anyway so stop moaning.

Edited by Johnny Eagles (21 Feb 2013 2.55pm)


i take your point Johnny. It is free money indeed.
But by the same token MP's have subsidised meals and can put housing and transport (amongst other items) on expenses.
I can't help but feel the 'working class' are the only ones paying into the system. At the bottom end we have the scroungers, and at the top are the exploitative rich, and both are being played-off against the other.

Sooner the revolution comes, the better. eh nick ?

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

Stuk Flag Top half 21 Feb 13 3.11pm

MPs are c***s, don't try and use that to justify not making changes elsewhere. I don't know anyone that wouldn't happily see them have their perks end expenses withdrawn but it ain't gonna happen.

You're getting less free money, no tax involved whatsoever and it's also pull at the heartstrings bollocks, just like Ed Milliband and his story of the twin boys serving in the forces.

 


Optimistic as ever

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 21 Feb 13 3.14pm

Quote Stuk at 21 Feb 2013 3.11pm

MPs are c***s, don't try and use that to justify not making changes elsewhere. I don't know anyone that wouldn't happily see them have their perks end expenses withdrawn but it ain't gonna happen.

You're getting less free money, no tax involved whatsoever and it's also pull at the heartstrings bollocks, just like Ed Milliband and his story of the twin boys serving in the forces.


But isn't any report of someone unjustifiably losing out big time because of 'cuts' going to be a pull on the heartstrings story?

 

Johnny Eagles Flag berlin 21 Feb 13 3.34pm

Quote nickgusset at 21 Feb 2013 3.14pm

Quote Stuk at 21 Feb 2013 3.11pm

MPs are c***s, don't try and use that to justify not making changes elsewhere. I don't know anyone that wouldn't happily see them have their perks end expenses withdrawn but it ain't gonna happen.

You're getting less free money, no tax involved whatsoever and it's also pull at the heartstrings bollocks, just like Ed Milliband and his story of the twin boys serving in the forces.


But isn't any report of someone unjustifiably losing out big time because of 'cuts' going to be a pull on the heartstrings story?

No.

It doesn't have to be. Ed Miliband is a smart man. He knows that when making decisions which affect millions of people you can't take into account every last individual. Going on about the women with the soldier sons is pure political opportunism and he knows it.

The Tories would do EXACTLY the same if they were in opposition. And for as long as the idiot public laps it up they're not going to stop.

It's been the same for decades. Thatcher did the same with free milk. The tabloids quickly labelled her a "milk snatcher" label and the idiot public lapped it up, going round chanting "think of the children" like the sheep in Animal Farm.

You act like butter wouldn't melt either, as though all you care about is poor little innocent children. Pull the other one. You have a political agenda, a strong personal interest in a tax-and-spend dirigiste state, which is why you constantly go on about all these issues.

Edited by Johnny Eagles (21 Feb 2013 3.37pm)

 


...we must expand...get more pupils...so that the knowledge will spread...

Stuk Flag Top half 21 Feb 13 3.40pm

Quote nickgusset at 21 Feb 2013 3.14pm

Quote Stuk at 21 Feb 2013 3.11pm

MPs are c***s, don't try and use that to justify not making changes elsewhere. I don't know anyone that wouldn't happily see them have their perks end expenses withdrawn but it ain't gonna happen.

You're getting less free money, no tax involved whatsoever and it's also pull at the heartstrings bollocks, just like Ed Milliband and his story of the twin boys serving in the forces.


But isn't any report of someone unjustifiably losing out big time because of 'cuts' going to be a pull on the heartstrings story?


No. It must include the words "disabled", "pensioners" or "serving".

And it is a justifiable reduction, nothing "big time"!

 


Optimistic as ever

Baldfella Flag Wigan 21 Feb 13 3.42pm

But surely if you are living in free or subsidised accommodation then you should consider yourself lucky you have that much !

I I think it's a bit harsh over one spare room but 2 or more and people should be moved on !

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 21 Feb 13 3.46pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 21 Feb 2013 3.34pm

Quote nickgusset at 21 Feb 2013 3.14pm

Quote Stuk at 21 Feb 2013 3.11pm

MPs are c***s, don't try and use that to justify not making changes elsewhere. I don't know anyone that wouldn't happily see them have their perks end expenses withdrawn but it ain't gonna happen.

You're getting less free money, no tax involved whatsoever and it's also pull at the heartstrings bollocks, just like Ed Milliband and his story of the twin boys serving in the forces.


But isn't any report of someone unjustifiably losing out big time because of 'cuts' going to be a pull on the heartstrings story?

No.

It doesn't have to be. Ed Miliband is a smart man. He knows that when making decisions which affect millions of people you can't take into account every last individual. Going on about the women with the soldier sons is pure political opportunism and he knows it.

The Tories would do EXACTLY the same if they were in opposition. And for as long as the idiot public laps it up they're not going to stop.

It's been the same for decades. Thatcher did the same with free milk. The tabloids quickly labelled her a "milk snatcher" label and the idiot public lapped it up, going round chanting "think of the children" like the sheep in Animal Farm.

You act like butter wouldn't melt either, as though all you care about is poor little innocent children. Pull the other one. You have a political agenda, a strong personal interest in a tax-and-spend dirigiste state, which is why you constantly go on about all these issues.

Edited by Johnny Eagles (21 Feb 2013 3.37pm)

Not quite true Johnny me old mucker. Yes I do find it difficult to digest when I read that 30% of children in Leicester and a quarter of all children in Bristol are living below the poverty line. See [Link] so I do care about the 'poor little children' particularly in my line of work where poverty is one of the chief reasons behind poor educational achievement.

My only political agenda is that those who are worst off through no fault of their own are not penalized by those who don't have a frucking clue what it is like to be poor. It seems to me that the current lot in power are doing more to exacerbate the problem than previous regimes.

 

Johnny Eagles Flag berlin 21 Feb 13 3.47pm

The minute anyone starts throwing children into the debate, you just know it's propaganda. Cult of sentimentality has taken over.

 


...we must expand...get more pupils...so that the knowledge will spread...

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 21 Feb 13 3.48pm

Quote Stuk at 21 Feb 2013 3.40pm

Quote nickgusset at 21 Feb 2013 3.14pm

Quote Stuk at 21 Feb 2013 3.11pm

MPs are c***s, don't try and use that to justify not making changes elsewhere. I don't know anyone that wouldn't happily see them have their perks end expenses withdrawn but it ain't gonna happen.

You're getting less free money, no tax involved whatsoever and it's also pull at the heartstrings bollocks, just like Ed Milliband and his story of the twin boys serving in the forces.


But isn't any report of someone unjustifiably losing out big time because of 'cuts' going to be a pull on the heartstrings story?


No. It must include the words "disabled", "pensioners" or "serving".

And it is a justifiable reduction, nothing "big time"!

Justifiable in the sense that those living in accommodation that is too big for them to make way for those that need a bigger place. However, the scheme is ill thought out and affects far more people negatively than it should do.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 21 Feb 13 3.49pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 21 Feb 2013 3.47pm

The minute anyone starts throwing children into the debate, you just know it's propaganda. Cult of sentimentality has taken over.


You use the propaganda and sentimentality line every time you cannot really justify what the coalition are doing. Still it's a move on from blame Gordon.

 

Johnny Eagles Flag berlin 21 Feb 13 3.52pm

Quote nickgusset at 21 Feb 2013 3.49pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 21 Feb 2013 3.47pm

The minute anyone starts throwing children into the debate, you just know it's propaganda. Cult of sentimentality has taken over.


You use the propaganda and sentimentality line every time you cannot really justify what the coalition are doing. Still it's a move on from blame Gordon.

Why should I want to justify what the coalition are doing? I think they're next to useless!

I use the propaganda and sentimentality line whenever someone throws propaganda and sentimentality into the debate.

You want to have a grown up talk about politics, let's do so. But engaging on the level of "think of the poor little children!" is just yet more sentimental imagine-your-grandad-locked-in-a-cupboard bollocks.

 


...we must expand...get more pupils...so that the knowledge will spread...

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 21 Feb 13 3.55pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 21 Feb 2013 3.52pm

Quote nickgusset at 21 Feb 2013 3.49pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 21 Feb 2013 3.47pm

The minute anyone starts throwing children into the debate, you just know it's propaganda. Cult of sentimentality has taken over.


You use the propaganda and sentimentality line every time you cannot really justify what the coalition are doing. Still it's a move on from blame Gordon.

Why should I want to justify what the coalition are doing? I think they're next to useless!

I use the propaganda and sentimentality line whenever someone throws propaganda and sentimentality into the debate.

You want to have a grown up talk about politics, let's do so. But engaging on the level of "think of the poor little children!" is just yet more sentimental imagine-your-grandad-locked-in-a-cupboard bollocks.

Labour (much as I deplore them) did a lot t get thousands of children out of poverty. This is being reversed by the current lot.
The bedroom 'tax' is going to affect children and the disabled, yet according to you, this cannot be mentioned in a debate about the effects because it is sentimental and devalues the argument. How can one argue against something with you Johnny if they are not allowed to mention the people it directly affects?

 

UnbornShaitan Flag Too close to Penge for my liking 21 Feb 13 3.59pm

How many more times does someone have to say it. It's not a tax

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 21 Feb 13 4.01pm

Quote UnbornShaitan at 21 Feb 2013 3.59pm

How many more times does someone have to say it. It's not a tax


Can you tell the newspapers this please.

 

Stuk Flag Top half 21 Feb 13 4.05pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 21 Feb 2013 3.47pm

The minute anyone starts throwing children into the debate, you just know it's propaganda. Cult of sentimentality has taken over.

s*** I forgot "Children" in my heartstrings bingo.

It is absolute bollocks that 25-30% of the children anywhere in the UK are in actual poverty, not the lack of PC/Broadband/Sky definition, the actual unclean, unclothed and unfed definition. Why do you swallow such nonsense, nick?

 


Optimistic as ever

UnbornShaitan Flag Too close to Penge for my liking 21 Feb 13 4.06pm

Quote nickgusset at 21 Feb 2013 4.01pm

Quote UnbornShaitan at 21 Feb 2013 3.59pm

How many more times does someone have to say it. It's not a tax


Can you tell the newspapers this please.

This is a discussion with you. You started the thread with a title Bedroom Tax. It is by no definition a tax. The newspapers know this. Ed millibandwagon knows this, and you know this. But you and the press and millibandwagon and chums continue to use it to give someone a kicking. Because you know full well by saying it's a tax people will get upset and it may swing their vote. It is far less likely if you told them the truth. We expect mp's to lie. We expect the press to lie. We even expect estate agents to lie. What is your reason?

Edited by UnbornShaitan (21 Feb 2013 4.08pm)

Edited by UnbornShaitan (21 Feb 2013 4.08pm)

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 21 Feb 13 4.11pm

This bill is not the smartest way to cut benefits / save money but what really grinds my gears Nick is that you always seem to want to punish people who have done well.

If I get to a stage in life where I can afford more than one house (unlikely as at the age of 48 I currently live in a flat) then I would hope that I would be free to do what the hell I want with it. Compulsory purchase? pathetic!!

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 21 Feb 13 4.12pm

Quote UnbornShaitan at 21 Feb 2013 4.06pm

Quote nickgusset at 21 Feb 2013 4.01pm

Quote UnbornShaitan at 21 Feb 2013 3.59pm

How many more times does someone have to say it. It's not a tax


Can you tell the newspapers this please.

This is a discussion with you. You started the thread with a title Bedroom Tax. It is by no definition a tax. The newspapers know this. Ed millibandwagon knows this, and you know this. But you and the press and millibandwagon and chums continue to use it to give someone a kicking. Because you know full well by saying it's a tax people will get upset and it may swing their vote. It is far less likely if you told them the truth. We expect mp's to lie. We expect the press to lie. We even expect estate agents to lie. What is your reason?

Edited by UnbornShaitan (21 Feb 2013 4.08pm)

Edited by UnbornShaitan (21 Feb 2013 4.08pm)


As happened with the "Poll Tax"

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Stuk Flag Top half 21 Feb 13 4.13pm

Quote nickgusset at 21 Feb 2013 3.48pm

Quote Stuk at 21 Feb 2013 3.40pm

Quote nickgusset at 21 Feb 2013 3.14pm

Quote Stuk at 21 Feb 2013 3.11pm

MPs are c***s, don't try and use that to justify not making changes elsewhere. I don't know anyone that wouldn't happily see them have their perks end expenses withdrawn but it ain't gonna happen.

You're getting less free money, no tax involved whatsoever and it's also pull at the heartstrings bollocks, just like Ed Milliband and his story of the twin boys serving in the forces.


But isn't any report of someone unjustifiably losing out big time because of 'cuts' going to be a pull on the heartstrings story?


No. It must include the words "disabled", "pensioners" or "serving".

And it is a justifiable reduction, nothing "big time"!

Justifiable in the sense that those living in accommodation that is too big for them to make way for those that need a bigger place. However, the scheme is ill thought out and affects far more people negatively than it should do.

Justifiable in that they're not paying for it so they should be grateful for what they do get/haev got, rather than moaning about losing a bit.

They should count themselves lucky that those that can afford to own or rent privately, but have been raised in or at one time required free/subsidised housing, aren't being kicked out on a wholesale basis.

 


Optimistic as ever

UnbornShaitan Flag Too close to Penge for my liking 21 Feb 13 4.21pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 21 Feb 2013 4.12pm

Quote UnbornShaitan at 21 Feb 2013 4.06pm

Quote nickgusset at 21 Feb 2013 4.01pm

Quote UnbornShaitan at 21 Feb 2013 3.59pm

How many more times does someone have to say it. It's not a tax


Can you tell the newspapers this please.

This is a discussion with you. You started the thread with a title Bedroom Tax. It is by no definition a tax. The newspapers know this. Ed millibandwagon knows this, and you know this. But you and the press and millibandwagon and chums continue to use it to give someone a kicking. Because you know full well by saying it's a tax people will get upset and it may swing their vote. It is far less likely if you told them the truth. We expect mp's to lie. We expect the press to lie. We even expect estate agents to lie. What is your reason?

Edited by UnbornShaitan (21 Feb 2013 4.08pm)

Edited by UnbornShaitan (21 Feb 2013 4.08pm)


As happened with the "Poll Tax"

Do you really need a history lesson here or are you just trying to get a rise. You know full well the Poll tax is a tax as opposed to this engineered non tax the Bedroom tax. Also the Poll tax (and riots in 90) saw the end of Thatcher (which a poll showed only 12% supported) and Major announced immediately that it was scrapped. And more importantly pillock Kinnock was leader of Labour at the time which needs no explanation attatched. Also the tories did lose seats and a small percentage of the vote at the next election (although more people voted for them and in general at that election).

 

Page 3 of 7 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Bedroom tax