Quote braunstoneagle at 17 Jan 2014 9.25am
maybe it does, maybe it doesnt syd.
but im pleased they make the final decisions and not us fans.
QPR spent 70m on transfer fees over 2 seasons in the PL, and probably promised the same in contracts for these players.
as much as i would love top see steven taylor marshalling our defence, im pleased weve got a wage structure to abide to.
at the minute we are holding onto the coat tails of the rest of the league, and fighting our corner on what is essentially a poor squad. usually in jan theres a team marooned to the bottom, and were not, on a squad that cost less than 20m to put together!
to put it into context youve got WHU 1 point ahead of us and our entire squad cost the same as andy carroll.
take sunderland...giaccherini & altidore cost the same as our squad put together.
take cardiff city...cornelius & medel cost more than our entire squad put together
take norwich...van wolfswinkel, fer & hooper cost the same as our squad put together
all those teams are within 3 points of us, plucky palace...so is spending money left right & center to try and survive the answer?
personally...right now...considering what weve spend, and how underprepared we were for the league i dont think we could have asked for much more after 21 league games...and im actually over the moon at how its going so far.
obviously there are things i wouldav changed, but im not the manager or owner so weve just got to pipe down and see what happens.
To address your points:
1. Your pleased the four owners make the final decisions and not us fans.
It's sort of a redundant statement but with that said, the ideal person to make a decision is the person best equipped to make the right one. In so far as it's likely the four members of CPFC 2010 have better track record running businesses than the average fan, I agree with you. But it's also at least possible that there are fans of Palace who are even better equipped to run the club than they are, but choose not to get involved. My point is, whoever makes the final decisions should expect to be held accountable by the supporters. That is all that is happening here. The fact that your statement is basically correct doesn't mean it's wrong for us to question them.
2. QPR spent 70m on transfer fees over 2 seasons in the PL, and probably promised the same in contracts for these players.
So what? They had the wrong business model and then executed it poorly, thereby adding insult to injury. That doesn't mean it's wrong to sign a few expensive players and give them decent contracts. There is a halfway house between Loftus Road and Selhurst.
3. as much as i would love top see steven taylor marshalling our defence, im pleased weve got a wage structure to abide to.
I'm not. Wage structures (indeed, any other kind of corporate or business structures) are there to guide you. They are very rarely there to be adhered to with iron discipline no matter what because if you do that, you take risks in the same way as if you ignore the structures altogether. A good owner (of any business) stays within guidelines as a rule, and breaks them when a key employee needs to brought into the fold. I am not saying Steven Taylor is that employee, but I am saying that guidelines only have any value when you occasionally work around them. Otherwise, they simply become destructive. That is happening here and now at Palace. We are cutting our nose to spite our face.
4. at the minute we are holding onto the coat tails of the rest of the league, and fighting our corner on what is essentially a poor squad. usually in jan theres a team marooned to the bottom, and were not, on a squad that cost less than 20m to put together!
No, we're not. But that is more luck than judgment, combined with absolutely brilliant management since November. It is foolish to expect that to continue through the second half of the season and even Pulis himself has said this ("we NEED reinforcements." ) What's the point of hiring a fantastic manager and then ignoring his advice? That doesn't sound like good ownership to me.
5. to put it into context youve got WHU 1 point ahead of us and our entire squad cost the same as andy carroll....all those teams are within 3 points of us, plucky palace...so is spending money left right & center to try and survive the answer?
No, but your evidence doesn't make it the wrong answer, either. The question you're really asking here is "will expenditure guarantee success?" Of course, the answer is "no". In life, there aren't any guarantees. However, if you adjust the question to "will the combination of expenditure plus a top class manager dramatically increase the chances of success?" then I would argue yes. To the extent of buying maybe two top notch players and stretching our wage structure to accommodate them, I would say that is a risk worth taking and I would also say it would not turn us into QPR overnight.
6. personally...right now...considering what weve spend, and how underprepared we were for the league i dont think we could have asked for much more after 21 league games...and im actually over the moon at how its going so far.
So am I. And now I want to invest to cement the deal and do everything possible to ensure we stay up.
7. obviously there are things i wouldav changed, but im not the manager or owner so weve just got to pipe down and see what happens.
If the supporters are the moral guardians of the club then we have a duty to pipe up, not pipe down. It is not only "our club" when owners are doing something that all of us dislike. It's our club, and our responsibility to speak when things are going relatively well too.
Edited by sydtheeagle (17 Jan 2014 6.03pm)
Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.
|