You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Parish on club's accounts
November 16 2026 1.24pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Parish on club's accounts


Page 3 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
Icepick Tony Flag Chester 17 Jan 14 12.11pm

Quote braunstoneagle at 17 Jan 2014 9.25am

Quote sydtheeagle at 15 Jan 2014 8.04pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 15 Jan 2014 7.58pm

He and his fellow investors pick up the tab.....They can say what they like.

And by extension, you support the right of the Hull owner to change the club's name irrespective of what anyone else thinks. Same cause and effect after all.

Don't be a prat. Picking up the tab doesn't make it sensible to say what you like.


maybe it does, maybe it doesnt syd.

but im pleased they make the final decisions and not us fans.

QPR spent 70m on transfer fees over 2 seasons in the PL, and probably promised the same in contracts for these players.

as much as i would love top see steven taylor marshalling our defence, im pleased weve got a wage structure to abide to.

at the minute we are holding onto the coat tails of the rest of the league, and fighting our corner on what is essentially a poor squad. usually in jan theres a team marooned to the bottom, and were not, on a squad that cost less than 20m to put together!

to put it into context youve got WHU 1 point ahead of us and our entire squad cost the same as andy carroll.

take sunderland...giaccherini & altidore cost the same as our squad put together.

take cardiff city...cornelius & medel cost more than our entire squad put together

take norwich...van wolfswinkel, fer & hooper cost the same as our squad put together


all those teams are within 3 points of us, plucky palace...so is spending money left right & center to try and survive the answer?

personally...right now...considering what weve spend, and how underprepared we were for the league i dont think we could have asked for much more after 21 league games...and im actually over the moon at how its going so far.

obviously there are things i wouldav changed, but im not the manager or owner so weve just got to pipe down and see what happens.

Very well put.

 


"They got his own song 'He's just too good for you', it's quite unbelievable but when you see it and he's facing up someone - I actually feel sorry for them, 'Cos he actually is" - Ian Holloway

Jenny Taylier Flag Thornton Heath 17 Jan 14 1.10pm

"Parish said: "I made assurances to our investors that we would be careful with what we spent and that is what we have done"."


£16.26m on players? 50% increase in salaries (£11.7m to £18.75)? £4.6m promotion bonuses? That sounds like my wife's version of careful spending, Steve!

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 17 Jan 14 2.11pm

Quote Jenny Taylier at 17 Jan 2014 1.10pm

"Parish said: "I made assurances to our investors that we would be careful with what we spent and that is what we have done"."


£16.26m on players? 50% increase in salaries (£11.7m to £18.75)? £4.6m promotion bonuses? That sounds like my wife's version of careful spending, Steve!


It's all relative though isn't it? That £30mil total there (which is what a lot us thought would be wages & salaries only), is half of the £60mil TV money. There's still another £50mil of parachute money spread over 4 seasons and a squad with some worth to it.

Sure we have operating losses in the Champ of approx £5mil before player trading and we have to manage ourselves accordingly if we go down, but plenty of the Championship team are still CPFC players with yo-yo contracts and the 3 newer bigger earners are on-loan (using up our loan quota hamstrings us a bit adding to them short-term).

SP has played it as well as can be so far, apart from nobody senior to plan for Summer Prem transfer activity. We are now at stick or twist. I think most in the know know that we are unlikely to see one transfer in until we've played Stoke, and possibly not another or 2 in total until after Hull.

A new signing wouldn't make any difference to the Stoke game for us IMO so we shall see what we do. I think that also ties in with SP being on holiday precisely now.

 


COYP

est1905 Flag 17 Jan 14 5.06pm

Quote Rudi Hedman at 17 Jan 2014 2.11pm

Quote Jenny Taylier at 17 Jan 2014 1.10pm

"Parish said: "I made assurances to our investors that we would be careful with what we spent and that is what we have done"."


£16.26m on players? 50% increase in salaries (£11.7m to £18.75)? £4.6m promotion bonuses? That sounds like my wife's version of careful spending, Steve!


It's all relative though isn't it? That £30mil total there (which is what a lot us thought would be wages & salaries only), is half of the £60mil TV money. There's still another £50mil of parachute money spread over 4 seasons and a squad with some worth to it.

Sure we have operating losses in the Champ of approx £5mil before player trading and we have to manage ourselves accordingly if we go down, but plenty of the Championship team are still CPFC players with yo-yo contracts and the 3 newer bigger earners are on-loan (using up our loan quota hamstrings us a bit adding to them short-term).

SP has played it as well as can be so far, apart from nobody senior to plan for Summer Prem transfer activity. We are now at stick or twist. I think most in the know know that we are unlikely to see one transfer in until we've played Stoke, and possibly not another or 2 in total until after Hull.

A new signing wouldn't make any difference to the Stoke game for us IMO so we shall see what we do. I think that also ties in with SP being on holiday precisely now.

I disagree, A quality striker that can put the ball in the net would make a hell of a difference for the Stoke game. Even if he came straight into the team and only met his new team mates that morning.
I keep banging on about him (or someone like him) but a loan of Demba Ba on around £80k a week would be money well spent if the player scored significant goals to keep us up. You are talking about £1.6m in wages (with say a bonus agreement we pay Chelsea £1m if we stay up) making the whole package just over £2.5m balanced against the £60m we WONT get if we go down? For me, its a no brainer. We are talking about a third of what we are reportedly said to have paid for a Championship striker that cant get a start at the moment because Jerome (who cant hit a cows backside with a banjo) is keeping him out the team (except for tomorrow of course.


 

Stirlingsays Flag 17 Jan 14 6.00pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 17 Jan 2014 8.45am

Quote Stirlingsays at 17 Jan 2014 4.56am

Quote sydtheeagle at 15 Jan 2014 8.04pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 15 Jan 2014 7.58pm

He and his fellow investors pick up the tab.....They can say what they like.

And by extension, you support the right of the Hull owner to change the club's name irrespective of what anyone else thinks. Same cause and effect after all.

Don't be a prat. Picking up the tab doesn't make it sensible to say what you like.


If you are going to call me a prat then I'm going to call you an idiot for suggesting that the people who pays the bills don't get to say what they like.

You are a idiot to say that because I support the right for him to express opinions means that I also support that opinion. Sometimes I will, sometimes I won't.

I won't criticise them for speaking their mind while they are the guys paying our way.


Edited by Stirlingsays (17 Jan 2014 5.03am)

First, you are welcome to call me an idiot, but do it for the right reason and not by badly misquoting me.

I wrote: "Don't be a prat. Picking up the tab doesn't make it sensible to say what you like."

To which you replied: "If you are going to call me a prat then I'm going to call you an idiot for suggesting that the people who pays the bills don't get to say what they like."

You will note that I did NOT say that people who paid the bills did not get to say what they liked. Of course they bloody do. People who don't pay the bills get to say what they like as well (as HOL proves.) What I said was that it is NOT SENSIBLE for people who pay the bills to say what they like...it is very rarely sensible to ever simply say what you think, without any self discipline or thought to how it will sound in public. Thus, I thought Parrish's comment "We will do what we want" (or whatever it was exactly) was churlish and immature. In my view, it was NOT a smart thing to say. If you quote me, or call me an idiot, do it accurately.

As for speaking their minds, I will criticise someone who says something I think is stupid regardless of whether they are paying the bills or not. Money doesn't but my silence or my respect.

How on earth you can accuse another person of being churlish and immature after the tosh you have written on this thread is almost beyond me.

Here you want to suddenly be concerned about exact word play and meanings.....Well, that's also quite amusing considering you decided to suggest that me saying that Parish had a right to say what he wants due to his investment meant that I'd also accept him and investors changing the club's name.

And there is you get all worried about me being inaccurate with the exactness of your meaning....How cute.

Sure you can say what you want. But your opinion of Crystal Palace football club means very little in the scheme of things outside of this thread. Whereas Parish and co's opinion does matter to many people.

We all have rights but opinions carry different weights depending upon who they come from.

If you choose to criticise Parish for.....basically bugger all, as you have done here..... Then you deserve criticism yourself......Which I am glad to give you.

Edited by Stirlingsays (17 Jan 2014 6.02pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

sydtheeagle Flag England 17 Jan 14 6.01pm

Quote braunstoneagle at 17 Jan 2014 9.25am

maybe it does, maybe it doesnt syd.

but im pleased they make the final decisions and not us fans.

QPR spent 70m on transfer fees over 2 seasons in the PL, and probably promised the same in contracts for these players.

as much as i would love top see steven taylor marshalling our defence, im pleased weve got a wage structure to abide to.

at the minute we are holding onto the coat tails of the rest of the league, and fighting our corner on what is essentially a poor squad. usually in jan theres a team marooned to the bottom, and were not, on a squad that cost less than 20m to put together!

to put it into context youve got WHU 1 point ahead of us and our entire squad cost the same as andy carroll.

take sunderland...giaccherini & altidore cost the same as our squad put together.

take cardiff city...cornelius & medel cost more than our entire squad put together

take norwich...van wolfswinkel, fer & hooper cost the same as our squad put together

all those teams are within 3 points of us, plucky palace...so is spending money left right & center to try and survive the answer?

personally...right now...considering what weve spend, and how underprepared we were for the league i dont think we could have asked for much more after 21 league games...and im actually over the moon at how its going so far.

obviously there are things i wouldav changed, but im not the manager or owner so weve just got to pipe down and see what happens.

To address your points:

1. Your pleased the four owners make the final decisions and not us fans.

It's sort of a redundant statement but with that said, the ideal person to make a decision is the person best equipped to make the right one. In so far as it's likely the four members of CPFC 2010 have better track record running businesses than the average fan, I agree with you. But it's also at least possible that there are fans of Palace who are even better equipped to run the club than they are, but choose not to get involved. My point is, whoever makes the final decisions should expect to be held accountable by the supporters. That is all that is happening here. The fact that your statement is basically correct doesn't mean it's wrong for us to question them.

2. QPR spent 70m on transfer fees over 2 seasons in the PL, and probably promised the same in contracts for these players.

So what? They had the wrong business model and then executed it poorly, thereby adding insult to injury. That doesn't mean it's wrong to sign a few expensive players and give them decent contracts. There is a halfway house between Loftus Road and Selhurst.

3. as much as i would love top see steven taylor marshalling our defence, im pleased weve got a wage structure to abide to.

I'm not. Wage structures (indeed, any other kind of corporate or business structures) are there to guide you. They are very rarely there to be adhered to with iron discipline no matter what because if you do that, you take risks in the same way as if you ignore the structures altogether. A good owner (of any business) stays within guidelines as a rule, and breaks them when a key employee needs to brought into the fold. I am not saying Steven Taylor is that employee, but I am saying that guidelines only have any value when you occasionally work around them. Otherwise, they simply become destructive. That is happening here and now at Palace. We are cutting our nose to spite our face.

4. at the minute we are holding onto the coat tails of the rest of the league, and fighting our corner on what is essentially a poor squad. usually in jan theres a team marooned to the bottom, and were not, on a squad that cost less than 20m to put together!

No, we're not. But that is more luck than judgment, combined with absolutely brilliant management since November. It is foolish to expect that to continue through the second half of the season and even Pulis himself has said this ("we NEED reinforcements." ) What's the point of hiring a fantastic manager and then ignoring his advice? That doesn't sound like good ownership to me.

5. to put it into context youve got WHU 1 point ahead of us and our entire squad cost the same as andy carroll....all those teams are within 3 points of us, plucky palace...so is spending money left right & center to try and survive the answer?

No, but your evidence doesn't make it the wrong answer, either. The question you're really asking here is "will expenditure guarantee success?" Of course, the answer is "no". In life, there aren't any guarantees. However, if you adjust the question to "will the combination of expenditure plus a top class manager dramatically increase the chances of success?" then I would argue yes. To the extent of buying maybe two top notch players and stretching our wage structure to accommodate them, I would say that is a risk worth taking and I would also say it would not turn us into QPR overnight.

6. personally...right now...considering what weve spend, and how underprepared we were for the league i dont think we could have asked for much more after 21 league games...and im actually over the moon at how its going so far.

So am I. And now I want to invest to cement the deal and do everything possible to ensure we stay up.

7. obviously there are things i wouldav changed, but im not the manager or owner so weve just got to pipe down and see what happens.

If the supporters are the moral guardians of the club then we have a duty to pipe up, not pipe down. It is not only "our club" when owners are doing something that all of us dislike. It's our club, and our responsibility to speak when things are going relatively well too.

Edited by sydtheeagle (17 Jan 2014 6.03pm)

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 17 Jan 14 6.56pm

syd...to adress your counterpoints...

1...But it's also at least possible that there are fans of Palace who are even better equipped to run the club than they are, but choose not to get involved.

if those people have (lets say) £70m to buy the club then i suppose they can run the club as they like in a better way than cpfc2010...as it stands 2010 own the club, and can do as they wish.

2...of your you are correct there is a halfway house between loftus road and selhurst park...its probably somehwere around the fulham/sunderland mark, which isnt proving that successful and they probably pay somewhere around £40m+ per annum in wages... more than double what we do.

3...to a certain extent i agree with you there...the ideal singing you would break the structure for would be somebody like tom ince who will at least have a high sell on fee in the future so you get your outlay back.

4/5/6...cant disagree...theres a line i believe between how much you have to spend to really give yourself the upper hand above the teams around you, dont forget even if we spend 10m then the teams around us will probably still have better squads, so were realistically spending money to balance the scales, not balance it in our favour.

7...but are we "moral custodians"? we are simply customers of a buisness...if you go to the cinema and watch oceans 11/12/13 your a customer but you dont and wont have any imput into how oceans 14 pans out do you?

i get what your saying but in reality its not our money that brought the club and were not running it! We simply have to accept that...and all the moaning on the forums aint going to change a thing...we are fans/customers of a buisness, and thats the harsh reality. we would all like the buisness to spend £20m on the best talent around but id rather we were sensible.

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


est1905 Flag 17 Jan 14 8.49pm

Quote braunstoneagle at 17 Jan 2014 6.56pm

syd...to adress your counterpoints...

1...But it's also at least possible that there are fans of Palace who are even better equipped to run the club than they are, but choose not to get involved.

if those people have (lets say) £70m to buy the club then i suppose they can run the club as they like in a better way than cpfc2010...as it stands 2010 own the club, and can do as they wish.

2...of your you are correct there is a halfway house between loftus road and selhurst park...its probably somehwere around the fulham/sunderland mark, which isnt proving that successful and they probably pay somewhere around £40m+ per annum in wages... more than double what we do.

3...to a certain extent i agree with you there...the ideal singing you would break the structure for would be somebody like tom ince who will at least have a high sell on fee in the future so you get your outlay back.

4/5/6...cant disagree...theres a line i believe between how much you have to spend to really give yourself the upper hand above the teams around you, dont forget even if we spend 10m then the teams around us will probably still have better squads, so were realistically spending money to balance the scales, not balance it in our favour.

7...but are we "moral custodians"? we are simply customers of a buisness...if you go to the cinema and watch oceans 11/12/13 your a customer but you dont and wont have any imput into how oceans 14 pans out do you?

i get what your saying but in reality its not our money that brought the club and were not running it! We simply have to accept that...and all the moaning on the forums aint going to change a thing...we are fans/customers of a buisness, and thats the harsh reality. we would all like the buisness to spend £20m on the best talent around but id rather we were sensible.

Sorry to wade in on this but football fans are not just customers of a business. Our loyalty sets us far apart from any other business type. If M&S don't sell the chicken Kiev you like any more you go elsewhere without a second thought. If your football club does something you are not keen on you moan, a lot sometimes but you never ever think of jumping ship to support someone else. Why? Loyalty, commitment, love even.
That's why we have a right to air our views. Some of us have given our disposable income over the turnstiles to this club for a life time. If that doesn't give you the right to speak your mind and .even criticise when you feel the need then what is the point of even having a message board to debate these issues in the first place?


 

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 17 Jan 14 9.05pm

Quote est1905 at 17 Jan 2014 8.49pm

Quote braunstoneagle at 17 Jan 2014 6.56pm

syd...to adress your counterpoints...

1...But it's also at least possible that there are fans of Palace who are even better equipped to run the club than they are, but choose not to get involved.

if those people have (lets say) £70m to buy the club then i suppose they can run the club as they like in a better way than cpfc2010...as it stands 2010 own the club, and can do as they wish.

2...of your you are correct there is a halfway house between loftus road and selhurst park...its probably somehwere around the fulham/sunderland mark, which isnt proving that successful and they probably pay somewhere around £40m+ per annum in wages... more than double what we do.

3...to a certain extent i agree with you there...the ideal singing you would break the structure for would be somebody like tom ince who will at least have a high sell on fee in the future so you get your outlay back.

4/5/6...cant disagree...theres a line i believe between how much you have to spend to really give yourself the upper hand above the teams around you, dont forget even if we spend 10m then the teams around us will probably still have better squads, so were realistically spending money to balance the scales, not balance it in our favour.

7...but are we "moral custodians"? we are simply customers of a buisness...if you go to the cinema and watch oceans 11/12/13 your a customer but you dont and wont have any imput into how oceans 14 pans out do you?

i get what your saying but in reality its not our money that brought the club and were not running it! We simply have to accept that...and all the moaning on the forums aint going to change a thing...we are fans/customers of a buisness, and thats the harsh reality. we would all like the buisness to spend £20m on the best talent around but id rather we were sensible.

Sorry to wade in on this but football fans are not just customers of a business. Our loyalty sets us far apart from any other business type. If M&S don't sell the chicken Kiev you like any more you go elsewhere without a second thought. If your football club does something you are not keen on you moan, a lot sometimes but you never ever think of jumping ship to support someone else. Why? Loyalty, commitment, love even.
That's why we have a right to air our views. Some of us have given our disposable income over the turnstiles to this club for a life time. If that doesn't give you the right to speak your mind and .even criticise when you feel the need then what is the point of even having a message board to debate these issues in the first place?


You are quite possibly correct and maybe my comparison was a bit leftfield.

but my point really was that considering the owners have been subsidising losses of lets say an average of £6m a season from their own pockets since they've taken over then what right do we as fans have to demand they spend more money during their one chance to make/save some money for the club.

In reality we have f*** all right...yes we may spend hundreds, maybe thousands a year supporting the team...but to put it into perspective they spend millions every season just to keep our heads above water.

I understand Syd is annoyed at the lack of signings thusfar this January...we would all love decent signings...but in reality, say we spend £5m this window would it really make that much of a difference to our chances of staying up? To really tip the scales in our favour over our rivals we would have to spend another 15m on the team...something I really can't see happening whether I want it to or not.

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 17 Jan 14 9.54pm

He/they can run the finances however he/they want. It is his/their business. They are Palace fans, devoted to the club. I prefer possible relegation to the other options. Namely Administration or bought by a multi-billionaire who treats us as a toy. Just my opinion.

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

reginald_maudling Flag 17 Jan 14 10.30pm

eventually the supporters in this country will wake up to the fact that "their" club isn't really theirs at all and then they will demand a "50 plus one" type rule of club ownership similar to the Bundesliga - to get to that point there will have to be a big crash (eg several top clubs folding) and/or a great loss of interest from the next generations, both of which are very possible over the next twenty years or so

we are currently in a transition time during which the new owners of the top football clubs treat what they own as businesses but still the fans don't act like true customers or consumers and go elsewhere if the "product" doesn't give them "value for money"

the supporters coming through the gate have progressively become less important compared to the TV viewers/gamblers/merchandise buyers not only in the UK/Europe but also in the Far East and other areas of the world - it can be argued these are the new customers the owners are more interested in

the next generation of fans in this country won't be so "loyal" (or some might say "mugs" from a consumer perspective)

CPFC2010 are a throwback to a different era of local businessmen made good and they at least seem (from what can be seen) to like and understand football and the fans' passion and they seem to care about Palace and the survival of the club

the reality is no club can compete and survive in the PL right now unless they have billionaire backing and the billionaire backing for clubs is not going to be for the long-term - its short termism with profit motive foremost and hence look at the vulnerability of clubs like Cardiff Hull and Southampton who don't have a global brand

far better to have relegation again this season than put the club at risk again - we can hold our heads high if we continue to make a fight of it and at least the Linekers and Savages and Hansens are being denied the chance to gloat every week as they thought they would at the start of the season

 

Ninjas Headband Flag Biggleswade 17 Jan 14 11.27pm

Quote Ian J at 16 Jan 2014 8.09am

Quote Ninjas Headband at 16 Jan 2014 6.56am

Don't these type of news stories come out towards the end of every transfer window, ie, Parish is letting everyone know that we aren't going to pay silly money for our transfer targets. Seems sensible to me.

I disagree as I have been saying for quite a while that I wish Parish would keep a lower profile and leave it up to his manager to do the talking.

Pulis is bullish and comes out with quotes like the fact that he originally agreed with Parish that the club would buy loads of new players in January but having seen the squad perform he now realises that they don't need anywhere near that many and perhaps just a couple will do.

Parish on the other hand only ever comes out with can't pay or won't pay and it does absolutely nothing for other's perception of the club as they just see us as a small town club enjoying our season in the sun before we revert back to where we belong.

By all means run the club on a shoestring to safeguard it's future but it isn't necessary to broadcast the fact to all and sundry as it does us no favours whatsoever.


Firstly it's not the job of the manager to discuss the finances of the club. That can have the potential of conflict between owners and manager.

Secondly the club will have a clear budget for new signings. The club is not working on a shoe string but it is being realistic to our situation which is currently much healthier than most other clubs in this country. Long may this continue.

 


Quality photos of Palace on Flickr; [Link]

Midlands Eagle Flag 18 Jan 14 7.17am

Quote braunstoneagle at 17 Jan 2014 9.05pm

my point really was that considering the owners have been subsidising losses of lets say an average of £6m a season from their own pockets since they've taken over then what right do we as fans have to demand they spend more money during their one chance to make/save some money for the club.

In reality we have f*** all right...yes we may spend hundreds, maybe thousands a year supporting the team...but to put it into perspective they spend millions every season just to keep our heads above water.

That isn't true for two reasons. Firstly the club isn't loss making every year as it made a profit last year and will probably do so again this year.

Secondly, as you say the supporters may spend thousands a year supporting the team which is money that they will never see again whilst the directors don't actually spend anything as they invest their money in the club.

Unlike the supporters the directors only lend the money to the club and hope one day that it will be repaid (possibly with interest) The first thing that they did when providing the loan capital was to secure their investments by way of four individual charges against the assets of the company so that if anything where to happen they would have first dibs on the assets and would recover their investments that way.

Secondly the directors are now sitting on a huge potential profit as the company is worth way more than when they bought it due partly to the acquisition of Selhurst Park at the same time and partly to the success of the team on the field

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 18 Jan 14 7.21am

Quote Ninjas Headband at 17 Jan 2014 11.27pm

Firstly it's not the job of the manager to discuss the finances of the club. That can have the potential of conflict between owners and manager.

How often do you see the chairman of Arsenal pontificating about anything to do with the club and I wouldn't mind betting that many people wouldn't even know who the chairman of Arsenal was

 

Stirlingsays Flag 18 Jan 14 8.43am

Quote Ian J at 18 Jan 2014 7.17am

Quote braunstoneagle at 17 Jan 2014 9.05pm

my point really was that considering the owners have been subsidising losses of lets say an average of £6m a season from their own pockets since they've taken over then what right do we as fans have to demand they spend more money during their one chance to make/save some money for the club.

In reality we have f*** all right...yes we may spend hundreds, maybe thousands a year supporting the team...but to put it into perspective they spend millions every season just to keep our heads above water.

That isn't true for two reasons. Firstly the club isn't loss making every year as it made a profit last year and will probably do so again this year.

Secondly, as you say the supporters may spend thousands a year supporting the team which is money that they will never see again whilst the directors don't actually spend anything as they invest their money in the club.

Unlike the supporters the directors only lend the money to the club and hope one day that it will be repaid (possibly with interest) The first thing that they did when providing the loan capital was to secure their investments by way of four individual charges against the assets of the company so that if anything where to happen they would have first dibs on the assets and would recover their investments that way.

Secondly the directors are now sitting on a huge potential profit as the company is worth way more than when they bought it due partly to the acquisition of Selhurst Park at the same time and partly to the success of the team on the field


Our chairmen can't win.

I truly hope they never get to see your post. It would suck the the energy and life out of genuine intent to see their motivations brought into question or seen cynically like you have done.

It's fine to question but all of the business practices you have mentioned are completely necessary to act as owners of the club. Owning our ground rather than renting it is a no brainer quite frankly....Cor blimey.

When these owners took over we were a badly struggling club hotly tipped to drop a division....Hardly a money making prospect....Many had turned us down.

These chairmen didn't invest massively but instead provided capital to allow the club to stay in the division on a competitive level....We spent mid table wages on wages.....They did not invest enough money to realistically expect a Premiership promotion....That was very unexpected.

That being the case that our owners didn't do a Cardiff or Hull and invest massively in loss making risks to gain promotion means that the future for Palace was most likely to mean a three to five million loss every year.

For every Hull there are plenty more Birminghams/ Portsmouths/Blackburns.....Investment indeed....Stupid business venture more like....There are far more sensible investments our there.

They knew this was the cost of their investment to keep Palace up and in the championship....With a small chance of glory...But that looked miles away when they came in.

They did what they did out of love.....Not sensible business practice....They have....And we have got lucky.

Edited by Stirlingsays (18 Jan 2014 9.18am)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Midlands Eagle Flag 18 Jan 14 9.11am

I’m not trying to be rude but your post is the view of a schoolteacher whilst my background is in finance and banking and I think that I know more about business practices than you do.

Whilst the job that CPFC2010 has done has been admirable it hasn’t been from purely altruistic motives as the more naïve supporters seem to think as there was always the opportunity there to make money or at the very least not to lose it as successful entrepreneurs first of all and Crystal Palace supporters secondarily.

If they were purely altruistic they would have helped to bankroll the club under Simon Jordan as asked instead of which they waited until it collapsed and even then played brinksmanship to drive the price down as low as possible. They admitted at the time that they wouldn’t buy the club if they couldn’t acquire the freehold of Selhurst Park and it looked for a long time that their bid to purchase the football club was going to fail as the company that owned the freehold wouldn’t sell and it was only thanks to serendipity that they acquired the freehold as the owners also went bust at the same time and the Administrators wanted to sell the assets.

You state that “Our chairmen can't win.....People ask them to communicate with the fans and give their views and when they do fans like you'd rather they didn't.”
What fans ask them to communicate? Certainly not this one and in view of the fact that all of Steve Parish’s interviews seem to be of a negative nature I would rather he didn’t and just left Tony Pulis to talk football to the media


Edited by Ian J (18 Jan 2014 9.12am)

 

Stirlingsays Flag 18 Jan 14 9.37am

Quote Ian J at 18 Jan 2014 9.11am

I’m not trying to be rude but your post is the view of a schoolteacher whilst my background is in finance and banking and I think that I know more about business practices than you do.

Whilst the job that CPFC2010 has done has been admirable it hasn’t been from purely altruistic motives as the more naïve supporters seem to think as there was always the opportunity there to make money or at the very least not to lose it as successful entrepreneurs first of all and Crystal Palace supporters secondarily.

If they were purely altruistic they would have helped to bankroll the club under Simon Jordan as asked instead of which they waited until it collapsed and even then played brinksmanship to drive the price down as low as possible. They admitted at the time that they wouldn’t buy the club if they couldn’t acquire the freehold of Selhurst Park and it looked for a long time that their bid to purchase the football club was going to fail as the company that owned the freehold wouldn’t sell and it was only thanks to serendipity that they acquired the freehold as the owners also went bust at the same time and the Administrators wanted to sell the assets.

You state that “Our chairmen can't win.....People ask them to communicate with the fans and give their views and when they do fans like you'd rather they didn't.”
What fans ask them to communicate? Certainly not this one and in view of the fact that all of Steve Parish’s interviews seem to be of a negative nature I would rather he didn’t and just left Tony Pulis to talk football to the media


Edited by Ian J (18 Jan 2014 9.12am)


The days when having a background in finance meant that your views within those matters meant a significant amount.... have rather taken a knock.

Still, referring to you post I'm would counter what you imply as cynical business practice as pure common sense. Not looking for the lowest price reduces the amount of financial outlay that these investors were prepared to risk in the first place.

Regardless of the price they got for this club they were spending and had to spend millions just to keep us afloat in the division.....With no realistic future saying that the investment was going to pay off.

Also you can't say that they wouldn't have blinked first with Lloyds, it's not knowable. They left it late but we just don't know. Public statements aren't necessarily to be taken as gospel when you know others are gauging your business intentions...That's obvious....The last minute phone call could have happened we will never know.

You state that bank rolling Jordan would have been altruistic....Well yes it certainly would have. They would have got to provide all the cash and have no say in how it was spent. These owners were prepared to lose money keeping Palace in business but not backing someone who would freeze them out or loose their cash being rash.

These owners never wanted to get involved in the first place and their actions suggested that. They only got involved when the club looked like going out of business.

Backing Crystal Palace FC was not a sensible business investment....There were probably many better ones.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Midlands Eagle Flag 18 Jan 14 10.02am

Quote Stirlingsays at 18 Jan 2014 9.37am

These owners never wanted to get involved in the first place and their actions suggested that. They only got involved when the club looked like going out of business.

Backing Crystal Palace FC was not a sensible business investment....There were probably many better ones.

They only got involved when they knew that they could acquire the freehold on the basis that if it all went horribly wrong they could make a killing selling the ground for housing development.

I very much doubt whether any of the four investors has managed to increase their investment as many times in three years as they have with CPFC2010 which is now worth a tidy sum of money

 

Plane Flag Bromley 18 Jan 14 10.14am

Quote Ian J at 18 Jan 2014 10.02am

Quote Stirlingsays at 18 Jan 2014 9.37am

These owners never wanted to get involved in the first place and their actions suggested that. They only got involved when the club looked like going out of business.

Backing Crystal Palace FC was not a sensible business investment....There were probably many better ones.

They only got involved when they knew that they could acquire the freehold on the basis that if it all went horribly wrong they could make a killing selling the ground for housing development.

I very much doubt whether any of the four investors has managed to increase their investment as many times in three years as they have with CPFC2010 which is now worth a tidy sum of money

You know this information - how?

Your attitude really just smacks of someone who is envious of our owners and their wealth. You're constantly telling half truths and accusing the owners of having some hidden agenda.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 18 Jan 14 10.18am

Quote Plane at 18 Jan 2014 10.14am

Quote Ian J at 18 Jan 2014 10.02am

Quote Stirlingsays at 18 Jan 2014 9.37am

These owners never wanted to get involved in the first place and their actions suggested that. They only got involved when the club looked like going out of business.

Backing Crystal Palace FC was not a sensible business investment....There were probably many better ones.

They only got involved when they knew that they could acquire the freehold on the basis that if it all went horribly wrong they could make a killing selling the ground for housing development.

I very much doubt whether any of the four investors has managed to increase their investment as many times in three years as they have with CPFC2010 which is now worth a tidy sum of money

You know this information - how?

Your attitude really just smacks of someone who is envious of our owners and their wealth. You're constantly telling half truths and accusing the owners of having some hidden agenda.

You are well aware that I won't respond to any of your posts and this time is no different

 

Page 3 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Parish on club's accounts