You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Parish vs Pulis
November 16 2026 1.24pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Parish vs Pulis


Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
Plane Flag Bromley 19 Jan 14 12.13pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 19 Jan 2014 12.04pm

Quote Plane at 19 Jan 2014 11.49am

You didn't raise any. As I said, you are only interested in promoting your conspiracy theories and you still didn't spell Parish's name correctly, you're either ignorant or you're trying to goad someone, it isn't me btw.

Now that is a stupid thing to say.

I don't mind being disliked or disagreed with but to say that what I wrote earlier does not contain any valid points is absolutely idiotic. I have a lot of time for many of my adversaries, but I have no respect for you if you cannot even engage in a reasoned debate.

A third of that diatribe was about you, so I won't massage your ego for you. Because I won't engage in your conspiracy theories, I'm an idiot, have you ever thought that not everyone wants to spend their entre day 'engaging in reasoned debate'? It isn't reasoned anyway, as you've just proved, because if someone doesn't play the game the way you like it to be played, they are labelled as an idiot, I may be an idiot but at least I'm not a boring idiot.

Edited by Plane (19 Jan 2014 12.14pm)

 

manwitheagletattoo Flag Somewhere in England 19 Jan 14 12.17pm

I really do think that most of these so called reporters make stories up just to fill spaces in their papers. They put two and two together and come up with 12 in some cases it's just sensationalism. If this report was true why is the Sunday mirror the only paper to print this article. If this was a story that had any creditability wouldn't other reporters be spreading this news.

 


South London & Proud
Sometimes I really wonder if family are really worth it.
Because it doesn’t matter how time and affection you give
It’s never enough

Hansy Flag 19 Jan 14 12.17pm

The Mirror is just putting 2+2 together and making 5.

Because we haven't been signing anyone and because of this whole Parish Holiday thing. They are trying to put it altogether as in Pulis doesn't get on with Moody or Parish.

Moody doesn't handle Transfers. Pulis decides with players he would like if available, and Moody does his research and enquiries.

There is no secret that Moody and Pulis have been attended Championship games together. If there was a rift I doubt that would happen.

 

sydtheeagle Flag England 19 Jan 14 12.20pm

Quote Plane at 19 Jan 2014 12.13pm

A third of that diatribe was about you, so I won't massage your ego for you. Because I won't engage in your conspiracy theories, I'm an idiot, have you ever thought that not everyone wants to spend their entre day 'engaging in reasoned debate'? It isn't reasoned anyway, as you've just proved, because if someone doesn't play the game the way you like it to be played, they are labelled as an idiot, I may be an idiot but at least I'm not a boring idiot.

Edited by Plane (19 Jan 2014 12.14pm)


Well, obviously that's me told.

By the way, how can anyone have an opinion about anything that isn't shaped by personal experience? Of course, when I weigh up what is happening at Palace (which, in the end, is just a business that is run by human beings like any other business), I turn to my own experience to interpret things. I mean what the hell else are you supposed to do?

I refer to my experience in my posts occasionally not because I want to talk about myself, but because I want to explain to the reader what my experience is, and why it leads me to the conclusions it does. I think that is relevant. I'm middle-aged, moderately successful, have followed Palace for almost 40 years, and I think there is some substance (or I hope there is) to what I write. If you find me dull or self-obsessed, then so be it, but I am using the examples I use out of respect for the reader...so that agree or disagree they can see that I have reached my conclusions based on something real; I'm not just letting off steam.

I would say there is something about me that clearly irritates you just, ironically, as there is something about Parrish that clearly irritates me. But you are being quite unreasonable in your criticism above and far less honest than I am. Even I have given Parrish credit where it is due.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 19 Jan 14 12.23pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 19 Jan 2014 12.20pm

I refer to my experience in my posts occasionally not because I want to talk about myself, but because I want to explain to the reader what my experience is, and why it leads me to the conclusions it does. I think that is relevant. .

I concur with these sentiments and I understand where you are coming from.


 

Plane Flag Bromley 19 Jan 14 12.30pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 19 Jan 2014 12.20pm

Quote Plane at 19 Jan 2014 12.13pm

A third of that diatribe was about you, so I won't massage your ego for you. Because I won't engage in your conspiracy theories, I'm an idiot, have you ever thought that not everyone wants to spend their entre day 'engaging in reasoned debate'? It isn't reasoned anyway, as you've just proved, because if someone doesn't play the game the way you like it to be played, they are labelled as an idiot, I may be an idiot but at least I'm not a boring idiot.

Edited by Plane (19 Jan 2014 12.14pm)


Well, obviously that's me told.

By the way, how can anyone have an opinion about anything that isn't shaped by personal experience? Of course, when I weigh up what is happening at Palace (which, in the end, is just a business that is run by human beings like any other business), I turn to my own experience to interpret things. I mean what the hell else are you supposed to do?

I refer to my experience in my posts occasionally not because I want to talk about myself, but because I want to explain to the reader what my experience is, and why it leads me to the conclusions it does. I think that is relevant. I'm middle-aged, moderately successful, have followed Palace for almost 40 years, and I think there is some substance (or I hope there is) to what I write. If you find me dull or self-obsessed, then so be it, but I am using the examples I use out of respect for the reader...so that agree or disagree they can see that I have reached my conclusions based on something real; I'm not just letting off steam.

I would say there is something about me that clearly irritates you just, ironically, as there is something about Parrish that clearly irritates me. But you are being quite unreasonable in your criticism above and far less honest than I am. Even I have given Parrish credit where it is due.

Again, it's all about you.

You've spelt Parish's name wrong again, please come clean, is that mean to wind me up?

On another thread I've just read, you say "succinct is best", I wish you would adhere to that as I find most of your posts long winded and boring but Willo loves ya, so all is cool

Edited by Plane (19 Jan 2014 12.45pm)

 

Plane Flag Bromley 19 Jan 14 12.32pm

Quote Hansy at 19 Jan 2014 12.17pm

The Mirror is just putting 2+2 together and making 5.

Because we haven't been signing anyone and because of this whole Parish Holiday thing. They are trying to put it altogether as in Pulis doesn't get on with Moody or Parish.

Moody doesn't handle Transfers. Pulis decides with players he would like if available, and Moody does his research and enquiries.

There is no secret that Moody and Pulis have been attended Championship games together. If there was a rift I doubt that would happen.

Yup or they read these very boards and come up with a story based on what's written on here.

 

Andy_G Flag Wimbledon 19 Jan 14 12.34pm

Pulis' job is to keep us in the Premier League and Parish's is to keep us within our budget restrictions. The transfer window tests both of these and I'd be surprised if there weren't a bit of tension. That is ok as long as a working relationship is maintained and so far I have not read or heard anything to suggest that has broken down but the next 2 weeks are big if we want to stay in the Premier league.

 


The ups and downs of Palace have left me older than my years

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 19 Jan 14 1.08pm

Quote Andy_G at 19 Jan 2014 12.34pm

Pulis' job is to keep us in the Premier League and Parish's is to keep us within our budget restrictions. The transfer window tests both of these and I'd be surprised if there weren't a bit of tension. That is ok as long as a working relationship is maintained and so far I have not read or heard anything to suggest that has broken down but the next 2 weeks are big if we want to stay in the Premier league.


Absolutely.

And the Mirror story is either a manipulation of the media by TP, sheer malicious gossip etc.

But there really shouldn't be an opportunity for this speculation to arise.

TP took the job - it would seem - aware of both the constraints and what would be available come the transfer window.

From SP's perspective, why hire a manager and then break your word. Or, why hire a manager to do a specific job and then dictate the terms under which he can operate.

If the manager - the ' expert ' - says our requirement is experienced players, then telling him he has to recruit a different type of player suggests that this relationship is destined to be a difficult one.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

geoff Flag Midhurst 19 Jan 14 1.45pm

Firstly I want to say I am a big fan of SP and the rest of the owners.
I would rather see more comments from Moody and TP than SP to be honest. SP is guilty of perhaps trying too hard. After Moody's appointment and the shotgun approach that didn't particularly work in the last window I would have thought he would have been only too happy to take a step back.
I know in the last window we got some good players in like Bannan, MC etc but we wasted quite a lot of money on some dross, Grandin to name but one.
I think the squad is doing extremely well and punching above our weight really, but the squad is thin on quality and 2 or 3 astute purchases could make a huge difference to a team with a great spirit and work ethic.
If Pulis was promised £x amount to spend in this window then let him have it. He can't be told to keep us up with the owners saying oh yeah and try and do that with only players we apporve of. TP knows the wage structure and has to stick to it but let him get the players in he wants if one of his objectives is to keep us up as long as he stays within the transfer and wage budget. Moody and TP work your magic, SP manage the long term finances and stability.

 

essetwentyone Flag london 19 Jan 14 2.38pm

If you buy and read that rag then you obviously will believe any old cr@p. Buy a decent paper !!!!!!

 

Hambo Flag Crawley 19 Jan 14 2.57pm

For all those advocating truth in that article - it states that Steve Parish has been in Barbados for 10 days. He has not, that was Steve Browett.

It's a basic detail that can easily be checked by asking a question, yet they haven't bothered - which tells you all you need to know about the motivation for the piece.

It's f***ing obvious Pulis wanted players in quicker - he said so. Steve P and Steve B have also said so. It is also clear that TP understands why that has not happened.

The sad thing is, there is actually more factual information in the public domain than in this article yet people will choose to believe it.

 


HOL Radio Lead Presenter and sampler of processed meats

HOL radio - Sunday nights [Link]
HOL Radio Twitter:


My Twitter:

davehuggins Flag 19 Jan 14 3.19pm

I can not believe this story as surely when TP took the job all this would have been discussed and agreed on. SP & TP are both intelligent people and I am sure nobody wants to put the club at risk again, TP will I am sure understand this. We now have a great manager who I am sure is going to take us forward slowly but surely.

 

est1905 Flag 19 Jan 14 3.29pm

Quote Alexi_the_Eagle at 19 Jan 2014 8.46am

7 words. The Mirror is talking bulls**t as usual.


And you know this how?
As Alex Ferguson said recently, the written press can frustrate but it's not in their interest to report lies. Tends to discredit them and eventually nobody will buy their paper will they?

 

Qwijibo Flag Bournemouth 19 Jan 14 3.57pm

Quote est1905 at 19 Jan 2014 3.29pm

Quote Alexi_the_Eagle at 19 Jan 2014 8.46am

7 words. The Mirror is talking bulls**t as usual.


And you know this how?
As Alex Ferguson said recently, the written press can frustrate but it's not in their interest to report lies. Tends to discredit them and eventually nobody will buy their paper will they?


The Mirror reported QPR's interest in Warnofk, which turned out to be true

 

Alexi_the_Eagle Flag Newton-le-Willows 19 Jan 14 3.59pm

Quote est1905 at 19 Jan 2014 3.29pm

Quote Alexi_the_Eagle at 19 Jan 2014 8.46am

7 words. The Mirror is talking bulls**t as usual.


And you know this how?
As Alex Ferguson said recently, the written press can frustrate but it's not in their interest to report lies. Tends to discredit them and eventually nobody will buy their paper will they?

So everything the Mirror preaches is gospel? Pull the other one, anything they spew rarely makes sense. It's just hyperbole to shift more copies.

 


"Look at that. Accident blackspot? These aren't accidents! They're throwing themselves into the road gladly! Throwing themselves into the road to escape all this hideousness!"

eaglesmad Flag Tonbridge with all the other mad c... 19 Jan 14 4.14pm

It's a case of the reporter putting 2 & 2 together and coming up with 10, Pulis wants signings parish on holiday I know what I can write Derrrrrrrrrrr!

 


and now Fred Davis will try for the pink, for those watching in black n white its just behind the green..........

BangholeLee Flag West Wickham 19 Jan 14 4.31pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 19 Jan 2014 11.26am

Quote braunstoneagle at 19 Jan 2014 10.52am

parish said that moody was brought in as he had a better knowledge of transfer dealings/certain aspects of football than he did.

he acknowledged a weakness in his own skillset and plugged the hole by employing moody.

Fair enough, but surely in that case Parrish should give Moody a clear budget and leave him alone to get on with his job. Why is Parrish even commenting on transfers in the media, or involved in any way? As you've just said, it's not his skill set. And please don't give me the line that "he's the owner. He can do what he wants." That's a business model for failure...not success.

When I ran a department of a corporation, I didn't expect my CEO to answer questions about the performance of that department, nor did he have any inclination to do so. If I did well, I got a pat on the back. If I did poorly, I was fired. But at board meetings (and media interviews), I answered for my work. Parrish -- if this is indeed why Moody has been brought in -- would do well to limit his comments to the realm of financial performance and annual reports which are the domain of the CEO. Not transfer activity, for which he's recruited someone to do the job.

From where I sit you have three people not on the same page at all. Parrish has brought Moody in as you explain above, but he's undermining him with his constant media comments about purse strings and wage structures. Moody probably has his ideas about what to do but it's important to remember that he's standing on his own two feet for the first time, no longer working for a friend in an environment in which he feels secure (Malky, Cardiff) and furthermore having to report to a massive ego (Parrish) and satisfy someone with a world of experience (Pulis). In truth, Moody is young and inexperienced. He's really only done the job for a couple of years. And Pulis probably thinks he knows better than both (and he's right; he does) and is frustrated that he's got not one fool but two between him and the squad he wants.

Sounds like what our American friends call a clusterf*&k to me. All I can say is that while no manager's history in the transfer market is perfect and Pulis has certainly made his mistakes, when it comes to making the moves needed to keep us up, I know damn well who I'd prefer in the driver's seat and it's not Parrish or Moody.

Shakespeare Sydney,
Parish & Moody, fools?
Read some of your comments & look up the word, fool.
Do you actually go to games & contribute anything towards the club?
You seem to spend half your life on this site.
Moody`s appointment a very shrewd appointment by Parish & Co, who would you have preferred, Sydney, Joe Kinnear?
If you read the so called rumours, Pulis wants Crouch & Etherington, both in the 30`s & on big wages & Parish doesn`t want those sort of players, yes paper talk.
So Sydney, who do you want & expect us to sign?
Who is out there, who will come to us, because we aren`t really an attractive proposition are we?
I await your reply, Sydney...............

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 19 Jan 14 4.45pm

Quote BangholeLee at 19 Jan 2014 4.31pm


Shakespeare Sydney,
Parish & Moody, fools?
Read some of your comments & look up the word, fool.
Do you actually go to games & contribute anything towards the club?
You seem to spend half your life on this site.
Moody`s appointment a very shrewd appointment by Parish & Co, who would you have preferred, Sydney, Joe Kinnear?
If you read the so called rumours, Pulis wants Crouch & Etherington, both in the 30`s & on big wages & Parish doesn`t want those sort of players, yes paper talk.
So Sydney, who do you want & expect us to sign?
Who is out there, who will come to us, because we aren`t really an attractive proposition are we?
I await your reply, Sydney...............


Bunghole - Why do you keep calling him Sydney?

 

radsyrendot Flag From Coventry now in Leicester 19 Jan 14 4.50pm

Quote essetwentyone at 19 Jan 2014 2.38pm

If you buy and read that rag then you obviously will believe any old cr@p. Buy a decent paper !!!!!!


What ....like the sun

no-one like us and we don't care

Edited by radsyrendot (19 Jan 2014 4.53pm)

 

Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Parish vs Pulis