You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace Jews
November 16 2026 1.24pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Palace Jews


Page 3 of 7 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >
Frickin Saweet Flag South Cronx 21 Jan 14 1.35pm

Quote Ian J at 21 Jan 2014 6.32am

Quote Elpis at 20 Jan 2014 10.29pm

Anyone in football would know that clubs have their own ways , chants and 'terms of endearment' that those outside of the game endeavour to find offensive . The fans of the hotspurs from Tottingham are no exception .
Your friends should maybe go and support a club that is inclusive of minority and odd jobs and those who make a living of being offended . The poofters at Brighton may be their calling .

The word yid is as offensive to Jews as the word ****** is to black people. As we have a number of black players and supporters at Palace would you think it's acceptable that we refer to ourselves as ******s then - as a term of endearment of course

Unless you're a Yid or black (or both, a 'blid' you're not really in a position to know whether that's true or not. I have heard anecdotes from Spurs supporting friends of Jewish people that are not in the slightest bit offended by the term when used at their ground. It's about context. As much as the N word is used by some black people.

 

legaleagle Flag 21 Jan 14 2.13pm

Context is all.


The Y word was historically in this country the abusive term used by Mosley's fascist supporters to refer to Jews.

Re Zionism and anti-semitism,of course the two are not identical.But to think there is not some crossover is naive even though many anti-zionists are fervent opponents of anti-semitism.

In Alelka's case,the salute is known as being a kind of reverse Nazi salute and his "comedian" pal who popularised it in France recently referred to a Jewish journalist in terms of gassing;nice guy and of course anti-zionist without any possible whiff of anti-semitism.

Also,there seems to be some misunderstanding as to what anti-zionism is.It is by definition to be opposed to any Jewish homeland in the middle east since thats what Zionism essentially advocates.Opposing the Israeli government's policies and expansion into the occupied territories is in itself not actually anti-zionism but anti-Israeli government policies and practices.

 

phillanth Flag London 21 Jan 14 2.13pm

Incorrect. Anti-zionism objects to a Jewish state which encompasses in it's entirety the region described historically as various things, e.g. the promised/holy land/Palestine etc. Especially if this means the displacement of the people already living there.

Anti-zionism does not (to my knowledge) object to the existence or establishment of a Jewish state as such.

I wouldn't describe myself as an anti-zionist, but I do think that it was a mistake in 1948 to establish a Jewish state in such a volatile and historically sensitive region, simply because it was promised in a book of middle age desert lore. Surely it would have been better to carve an additional bit off Germany and establish a Jewish state there, or do it in a largely unoccupied part of the world? Just my opinion, anyway. I support completely the right of Jewish self determination.

Zionism is a political movement that believes that Jews cannot co-exist with non Jews and that they therefore require their own separate state. Not all Jews are Zionists. In fact before the Holocaust, Zionism was a minority movement amongst Jews.

To be anti-Zionist is not to be anti semitic, it just means to be opposed to the politics of Zionism not to be be hostile to Jews.

Personally I do not support the Zionist project in Israel because the Zionist state was been built at the expense of the Arab population. There will only be peace in the region when there is a multinational secular state within the historic borders of Palestine with equal rights for Jews and Arabs.

That does not make me anti semitic. I think Anelka's gesture was anti-semitic and offensive and that therefore he should treated in the same way as Terry and Suarez. Anyone who thinks that the Holocaust can be the subject of banter between football fans is an ignorant moron.


 

phillanth Flag London 21 Jan 14 2.15pm

Sorry only this bit is mine:

Zionism is a political movement that believes that Jews cannot co-exist with non Jews and that they therefore require their own separate state. Not all Jews are Zionists. In fact before the Holocaust, Zionism was a minority movement amongst Jews.

To be anti-Zionist is not to be anti semitic, it just means to be opposed to the politics of Zionism not to be be hostile to Jews.

Personally I do not support the Zionist project in Israel because the Zionist state was been built at the expense of the Arab population. There will only be peace in the region when there is a multinational secular state within the historic borders of Palestine with equal rights for Jews and Arabs.

That does not make me anti semitic. I think Anelka's gesture was anti-semitic and offensive and that therefore he should treated in the same way as Terry and Suarez. Anyone who thinks that the Holocaust can be the subject of banter between football fans is an ignorant moron.


 

legaleagle Flag 21 Jan 14 2.17pm

Wrong my friend,plain and simple.I am personally Jewish and not a zionist.But,it is important to define terms correctly.Zionism is essentially as per I set it out.

It is fine to be against what Israel does or has done,but it is important not to misrepresent terms.

 

legaleagle Flag 21 Jan 14 2.18pm

Was replying to your first rather than second posting...

 

Jonny_Johnson Flag Tel Aviv 21 Jan 14 2.19pm

Quote the_mcanuff_stuff at 21 Jan 2014 1.24pm

Quote Jonny_Johnson at 21 Jan 2014 12.53pm

Quote the_mcanuff_stuff at 21 Jan 2014 10.45am

Quote sydtheeagle at 21 Jan 2014 10.34am

Quote the_mcanuff_stuff at 21 Jan 2014 10.17am

Going back to the Quenelle (Anelka's gesture), is it actually antisemitic?

I've looked into it a bit and it seems that it is sometimes (but not always) used as an anti-zionist symbol. But I've seen nothing to suggest it is antisemitic.

If it is simply anti-zionist, I can't see the problem. That is not at all the same as antisemitism. I'm guessing that pro-zionist groups are simply shouting "antisemitism" because they don't like it!

I'm happy to be corrected on this, if anyone knows more about this than I do.

It's smoke and fire, isn't it? I doubt anyone can prove anything about the meaning of the gesture beyond a reasonable doubt, but from the general reaction (particularly in France) it seems safe to conclude that the quenelle is a gesture that does have political connotations of one colour or another, and that someone plying his trade in the media frontline really should have known better. If you want to see that as palliating liberal bed-wetters that's up to you; I'd call it using common sense. Given Anelka's personal history, he tends not to invite being given the benefit of the doubt.

What's really unfortunate is that West Brom didn't quickly step in and take control of the situation. Very poor management on their part. Had they reacted with an immediate two game ban for making political gestures and said no more than that (which would have been reasonable) the whole situation might have been instantly defused.

I agree on that point. Footballers shouldn't be making political gestures on pitch.

I just find it interesting that something which to me appears to be anit-zionist has seemingly been casually classed as antisemitic, as if the two were inseparable. It's fair to say that antisemites would be anti-zionist, but the reverse doesn't hold true. Lots of people I know (many of them liberal bedwetters, as per your term!) who are strongly anti-zionist, but most certainly not antisemitic or racist. The opposite in fact.

You say there is no smoke without fire. But someones anti-zionist views are not an indication of antisemitism and I find that an unfair and serious allegation to make. edit: I'm not saying that you are making such an allegation!

Edited by the_mcanuff_stuff (21 Jan 2014 10.46am)


I think that most right-minded people are in agreement that political gestures have no place on the pitch or in sport, in general.

On a separate issue however - there does seem a great deal of misplaced opinion on the matter of anti-Zionism and anti-Semitism.

Whilst you are right to suggest that anti-Semites would be anti-Zionist; it is also fair to say that the opposite is true, albeit I believe it is used unwittingly.

Anti-Zionism is the opinion that the Jewish people should be dispossessed, against their will, of a fundamental right that they currently enjoy: namely, the right of self-determination. Whatever one believes about whether the Jewish people had a moral right to self-determine in 1948, this right is now a fact of international law, which states that 'all peoples have the right freely to [self-]determine.' Therefore, the selective deprival of fundamental rights is the essence of discrimination.

The boycott industry, which has proved largely successful, has succeeded in diluting and dividing the matter. Most people I believe use the term anti-Zionism ignorantly and as a reactionary term against perceived Israeli intransigence. The wider comunity would rightly be up in arms if it were suggested that Muslims were not entitled to their own nations.

Incorrect. Anti-zionism objects to a Jewish state which encompasses in it's entirety the region described historically as various things, e.g. the promised/holy land/Palestine etc. Especially if this means the displacement of the people already living there.

Anti-zionism does not (to my knowledge) object to the existence or establishment of a Jewish state as such.
I wouldn't describe myself as an anti-zionist, but I do think it was a mistake in 1948 to establish a Jewish state in such a volatile and historically sensitive region, simply because it was promised in a book of middle age desert lore. Surely it would have been better to carve an additional bit off Germany and establish a Jewish state there, or do it in a largely unoccupied part of the world? Just my opinion, anyway. I support completely the right of Jewish self determination.


It is true that it encompasses the territory defined as the Land of Israel, and this explains precisely why anti-Zionism rejects the notion of a Jewish state altogether: because Zionism is predicated solely on a return to the Land of Israel - the recognised Jewish homeland.

Personally speaking, having lived in Israel I can completely empathise with the Jewish predicament. Israel is the size of Wales; it comprises a fraction of a percent of the rest of the Middle East; it is, whether one accepts it or not, the birthplace of Judaism, where Jews lived for millennia peacefully. They do not want to be a nomadic people again (as anti-Zionists demand) because it leaves them further open to genocide. Self-determination is the self-fulfilment of the Jewish people. It is a romantic notion for them to return there (being football supporters we all understand romanticism).

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 21 Jan 14 2.20pm

Quote Frickin Saweet at 21 Jan 2014 1.35pm

Quote Ian J at 21 Jan 2014 6.32am

Quote Elpis at 20 Jan 2014 10.29pm

Anyone in football would know that clubs have their own ways , chants and 'terms of endearment' that those outside of the game endeavour to find offensive . The fans of the hotspurs from Tottingham are no exception .
Your friends should maybe go and support a club that is inclusive of minority and odd jobs and those who make a living of being offended . The poofters at Brighton may be their calling .

The word yid is as offensive to Jews as the word ****** is to black people. As we have a number of black players and supporters at Palace would you think it's acceptable that we refer to ourselves as ******s then - as a term of endearment of course

Unless you're a Yid or black (or both, a 'blid' you're not really in a position to know whether that's true or not. I have heard anecdotes from Spurs supporting friends of Jewish people that are not in the slightest bit offended by the term when used at their ground. It's about context. As much as the N word is used by some black people.

Some of the comments in this thread get more and more unbelievable

 

bubble wrap Flag Carparks in South East London 21 Jan 14 3.42pm

Couldn't give a Monkies,
Not being racist with that comment either.
Black,White,Jew,Gay,Straight,Indian,Willo,Muslim,Neo-Nazi we all s*** the same so who cares..

 

Seth Flag On a pale blue dot 21 Jan 14 3.44pm

Quote legaleagle at 21 Jan 2014 2.17pm

Wrong my friend,plain and simple.I am personally Jewish and not a zionist.But,it is important to define terms correctly.Zionism is essentially as per I set it out.

It is fine to be against what Israel does or has done,but it is important not to misrepresent terms.


You defined anti-Zionism as, "...to be opposed to any Jewish homeland in the middle east..."

In your post above you say you are "...Jewish and not a zionist."

So are you saying you are opposed to the existence of a Jewish state in the middle east, ie Israel?

Genuine question btw, not trying to trip you up.

 


"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down"
FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16

Seth Flag On a pale blue dot 21 Jan 14 3.45pm

Quote bubble wrap at 21 Jan 2014 3.42pm

Couldn't give a Monkies,
Not being racist with that comment either.
Black,White,Jew,Gay,Straight,Indian,Willo,Muslim,Neo-Nazi we all s*** the same so who cares..


You don't care if people are neo-Nazis?

 


"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down"
FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16

sydtheeagle Flag England 21 Jan 14 4.03pm

Quote Seth at 21 Jan 2014 3.45pm

Quote bubble wrap at 21 Jan 2014 3.42pm

Couldn't give a Monkies,
Not being racist with that comment either.
Black,White,Jew,Gay,Straight,Indian,Willo,Muslim,Neo-Nazi we all s*** the same so who cares..


You don't care if people are neo-Nazis?

Or monkies (sic), apparently.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

the_mcanuff_stuff Flag Caterham 21 Jan 14 4.08pm

Quote Jonny_Johnson at 21 Jan 2014 2.19pm

It is true that it encompasses the territory defined as the Land of Israel, and this explains precisely why anti-Zionism rejects the notion of a Jewish state altogether: because Zionism is predicated solely on a return to the Land of Israel - the recognised Jewish homeland.

I'm sorry, but this makes absolutely no sense to me.

Zionism is all about jews moving to where the first jews came from (call it the holy land, palestine, whatever). And Anti-zionism opposes it.

I would say that explains precisely why anti-Zionism does not reject the notion of a Jewish state altogether! Simply the notion of a jewish state in those particular borders.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 21 Jan 14 4.36pm

Quote Ketteridge at 21 Jan 2014 6.51am

When Spurs still get songs about gas chambers then I think the intention is honourable.

Annefrankly I find jokes about the holocaust unacceptable.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

SE9 EAGLE Flag 21 Jan 14 4.36pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 21 Jan 2014 10.00am

Quote SE9 EAGLE at 21 Jan 2014 9.15am

Another minority for the liberal bed wetters to fawn over.Pathetic.....

I'd have loved to see you say that to Mark Lazarus' face. I suspect he'd have beaten the living s*** out of you.


What a ridiculous comment.Being a man of his times Lazarus would have wanted to fight his own battles and not be nannied by a load of do-gooders who seek out prejudice where none exists and who draw unwanted attention to minorities who neither request it or need it....

 

Eagles-Mad Flag Romford Essex 21 Jan 14 5.00pm

The amount of Politically Correct do gooders in this country is unbearable.

 

paperhat Flag croydon 21 Jan 14 5.04pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 21 Jan 2014 4.03pm

Quote Seth at 21 Jan 2014 3.45pm

Quote bubble wrap at 21 Jan 2014 3.42pm

Couldn't give a Monkies,
Not being racist with that comment either.
Black,White,Jew,Gay,Straight,Indian,Willo,Muslim,Neo-Nazi we all s*** the same so who cares..


You don't care if people are neo-Nazis?

Or monkies (sic), apparently.


The Monkies were Neo-Nazis?

My god, I didn't see that one coming.

 


Clinton is Clinton. I have known him for a long time, I know his mother... Simon Jordan


SE9 EAGLE Flag 21 Jan 14 5.05pm

Quote Eagles-Mad at 21 Jan 2014 5.00pm

The amount of Politically Correct do gooders in this country is unbearable.


And Im afraid we have got more than our fair share at Palace.I would actually feel sorry for them if their views werent so corrosive to our national interest....

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 21 Jan 14 5.07pm

Quote SE9 EAGLE at 21 Jan 2014 5.05pm

Quote Eagles-Mad at 21 Jan 2014 5.00pm

The amount of Politically Correct do gooders in this country is unbearable.


And Im afraid we have got more than our fair share at Palace.I would actually feel sorry for them if their views werent so corrosive to our national interest....

I suppose that's about par for the course from someone who feels like you do:-

Quote SE9 EAGLE at 20 Jan 2014 5.11pm

Nothing else in any other sport compares to a goal either for or against.And the there is the singing,extreme language and punch ups!

 

TomThePalaceFanatic Flag 21 Jan 14 5.11pm

Quote Ian J at 21 Jan 2014 2.20pm

Quote Frickin Saweet at 21 Jan 2014 1.35pm

Quote Ian J at 21 Jan 2014 6.32am

Quote Elpis at 20 Jan 2014 10.29pm

Anyone in football would know that clubs have their own ways , chants and 'terms of endearment' that those outside of the game endeavour to find offensive . The fans of the hotspurs from Tottingham are no exception .
Your friends should maybe go and support a club that is inclusive of minority and odd jobs and those who make a living of being offended . The poofters at Brighton may be their calling .

The word yid is as offensive to Jews as the word ****** is to black people. As we have a number of black players and supporters at Palace would you think it's acceptable that we refer to ourselves as ******s then - as a term of endearment of course

Unless you're a Yid or black (or both, a 'blid' you're not really in a position to know whether that's true or not. I have heard anecdotes from Spurs supporting friends of Jewish people that are not in the slightest bit offended by the term when used at their ground. It's about context. As much as the N word is used by some black people.

Some of the comments in this thread get more and more unbelievable

It's true though. People are offended on other peoples behalf

 

Page 3 of 7 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace Jews