You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Rumour: Pulis To Quit In The Summer
November 16 2026 1.25pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Rumour: Pulis To Quit In The Summer


Page 3 of 17 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >
collier row eagle Flag romford essex via another galaxy 26 Jan 14 8.45am

Quote Ian J at 26 Jan 2014 8.38am

Quote laddo at 26 Jan 2014 7.53am

It is obvious Tony Pulis has done a great job since coming in. However, if he wants Matthew Etherington (32) and Peter Crouch (33+) then I for one applaud the board for not sanctioning those transfers.

Pulis would have been reassured about having money to spend. I absolutely believe that side of the story. However, the board have consistently said that they would only buy players with sell on value. They will also not be put over a barrel regarding wages. That ladies and gentlemen is sensible, long term, sound financial management. I amazes me that given our history some on this board demand we gamble our future.

If I have one criticism there may well indeed be too many chiefs at the moment. However Pulis knew that structure was in place when he joined. If he is grumpy about it now then quite frankly he has no reason to be.

The one thing that we don’t know is the nitty gritty of the discussions between Parish and Pulis that led to Tony Pulis accepting a job that he clearly had reservations about.

There was an agreement that the board would make available funding in January for new purchases but was Tony Pulis told that whilst he was being employed for his skills in football management the board who had no footballing background at all would hold the power of veto over players that met his budgetary requirements.

Have the board actually come out and said that they would only buy players with a sell on value as if so I think that it’s a ridiculous idea as we are a football club and not commodity traders. Was the huge fee paid for Dwight Gayle paid on the basis that he would have a sell on value as whilst he undoubtedly does, it’s nowhere near what we paid for him and he isn’t good enough to play in the Premiership but that’s what you get when you have the commodity traders mindset in a football club

Not being put over a barrel in terms of wages is a sound idea and good business practice but it depends on what they view as a decent wage level. It appears from all of the players that turned us down (allegedly) in both the closed season and in the January window that our wage scale is not a Premiership wage scale at all but is set (probably) at The Championship.

It’s a bit like joining the most expensive golf club in the area and then constantly complaining about the costs of membership.

Your comment about there being too many chiefs is interesting as whilst the structure may have been explained to Tony Pulis before he took the job we don’t know that the supposed structure is actually working. Dor a start Iain Moody is supposed to be negotiating with the players on Tony Pulis’s wanted list but I suspect that isn’t happening and secondly with the best will in the world I don’t suppose he realised that the club’s chairman wanted to have the last word on almost everything.

A common question asked on this forum is surely you would rather have our owners than those that own Cardiff or Hull. Well my answer is that I’m not sure that I do as Hull and Cardiff may have issues with their colours and strips but both owners have backed their club and it’s managers fully with the necessary funding and don’t interfere with the running of the clubs


Edited by Ian J (26 Jan 2014 8.40am)

A couple. Of good posts from you Ian, couldn't disagree with any of it.

 

Sparky Flag Southampton 26 Jan 14 8.49am

Isn't this from the same paper that was reporting a few days ago that Pulis wasn't happy that Parish was going on holiday? That story was exposed as bullsh*t so now they've gone from saying that Parish wasn't involved enough to reporting that he's too involved. More very poor, lazy journalism.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 26 Jan 14 8.50am

Quote collier row eagle at 26 Jan 2014 8.45am

A couple. Of good posts from you Ian, couldn't disagree with any of it.

Thank you but many will


 

Midlands Eagle Flag 26 Jan 14 8.53am

Quote Sparky at 26 Jan 2014 8.49am

More very poor, lazy journalism.

It always is when the story doesn't show Palace in a good light but it's only when the stories are positive that the journalists know what they are talking about


 

Alexi_the_Eagle Flag Newton-le-Willows 26 Jan 14 8.54am

I'm amazed that people are still believing this rumour. If push ever does come to shove in the summer, god forbid we dont get lumbered with a manager who spends our parachute payments on crap.

 


"Look at that. Accident blackspot? These aren't accidents! They're throwing themselves into the road gladly! Throwing themselves into the road to escape all this hideousness!"

Sparky Flag Southampton 26 Jan 14 9.02am

Quote Ian J at 26 Jan 2014 8.53am

Quote Sparky at 26 Jan 2014 8.49am

More very poor, lazy journalism.

It always is when the story doesn't show Palace in a good light but it's only when the stories are positive that the journalists know what they are talking about


For me it's not so much about the bias of the story, more that it pretty much directly contradicts what they've previously printed. Both pieces appear to be completely speculative with no indication of any evidence on which they've been written. Hence my reference to lazy journalism.

 

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 26 Jan 14 9.04am

if he quits then we dont have to pay up his contract...thats fine by me.

i know he is doing a good job,but i still prefer the owners choice of player signings over his.

at the end of the day...this is the 1st time in my lifetime (bar el tel) that weve actually had a big name manager at the club, its good, but you are bound to have more situations like this as a by product of employing such manager.

if he wants to bitch & moan then let him...in a weeks time he cant do anything about it and has to get on with his job for the rest of the season.

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


MonsterMunch Flag Cambridge 26 Jan 14 9.17am

Quote braunstoneagle at 26 Jan 2014 9.04am

if he quits then we dont have to pay up his contract...thats fine by me.

i know he is doing a good job,but i still prefer the owners choice of player signings over his.

at the end of the day...this is the 1st time in my lifetime (bar el tel) that weve actually had a big name manager at the club, its good, but you are bound to have more situations like this as a by product of employing such manager.

if he wants to bitch & moan then let him...in a weeks time he cant do anything about it and has to get on with his job for the rest of the season.

Crazy. Over TP, an experienced PL Manager. I fear this rings true though, SP has far too much input into the players TP wants. Have a budget for transfer fees and wages and let him get in with it. If TP does not get players in he feels are the ones he wants and not the closing down sales SP visited last time then TP will be gone anyway IMO

 

The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 26 Jan 14 9.20am

Its the Mirror...no more needs to be said, however Pulis appointment and what he has managed to do in a short space of time has given us a great chance of actually pulling off an unlikely survival and he deserves backing financially to achieve it.

 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

AussiePalace Flag Melbourne, Australia 26 Jan 14 9.23am

Quote The Sash at 26 Jan 2014 9.20am

Its the Mirror...no more needs to be said, however Pulis appointment and what he has managed to do in a short space of time has given us a great chance of actually pulling off an unlikely survival and he deserves backing financially to achieve it.


This.

 


Executive Junior Assistant's Vice President's P.A - CPFC Melbourne Supporters Club

[Link]

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 26 Jan 14 9.27am

Quote MonsterMunch at 26 Jan 2014 9.17am

Quote braunstoneagle at 26 Jan 2014 9.04am

if he quits then we dont have to pay up his contract...thats fine by me.

i know he is doing a good job,but i still prefer the owners choice of player signings over his.

at the end of the day...this is the 1st time in my lifetime (bar el tel) that weve actually had a big name manager at the club, its good, but you are bound to have more situations like this as a by product of employing such manager.

if he wants to bitch & moan then let him...in a weeks time he cant do anything about it and has to get on with his job for the rest of the season.

Crazy. Over TP, an experienced PL Manager. I fear this rings true though, SP has far too much input into the players TP wants. Have a budget for transfer fees and wages and let him get in with it. If TP does not get players in he feels are the ones he wants and not the closing down sales SP visited last time then TP will be gone anyway IMO


the owners have a blueprint on how they want to take the club forward.

and signing (for example) crouch & etherington for big money & massive wages isnt a wise move surely? youve gotta imagine crouch is on (easily) in excess of 50k per week, and etherington maybe 40k a week.

so you pay maybe 8m for the pair...then somewhere near 100k a week in wages on the 2 players and then in 18months time youve got nothing to sell to make any money back!

it makes no sense! none whatsoever...i cant see how buying peter crouch gives us a better chance of survival.

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


Gary St.Andrews Flag Kenley 26 Jan 14 9.35am

I would be amazed if that was the case, but then again i was amazed at what happened to IH.

What manager doesn't get frustrated from time to time with restrictions on how much they have to spend on players, unless you are Man City of course. I hate this transfer window as it all smacks of desperation and the teams that are struggling at the foot of the table panic buy to try and get themselves out of the predicament.

Do we want to do a fat Sam at West Ham and sign players that don't want to be here let alone roll their sleeves up and fight for the team and club?

Lets hope West Ham go down and we stay up based on the fact that we acted within the clubs financial constraints, and just to show what a good appointment TP was. At the time i had my reservations about TP, but i have got to admit i was wrong and he is the right man for the job, so lets hope he still keeps his record intact of not getting a team relegated.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 26 Jan 14 9.48am

Quote braunstoneagle at 26 Jan 2014 9.04am

if he quits then we dont have to pay up his contract...thats fine by me.

i know he is doing a good job,but i still prefer the owners choice of player signings over his.

Then why not get rid of Tony Pulis and let Steve Parish manage instead

 

premier fan Flag BR4 26 Jan 14 9.48am

I'd rather stick with what we got that take on Crouch at his age. Glen Murray due back soon and he would be in my squad.

I think money is available but SP and the board have to be able to reserve the right to stop a deal if they feel its right to do so.

TP might be frustrated but he's an employee and on a huge salary and needs to get on with the job in hand. If he goes at the end of the season so be it but as we know its in his interests to stay and keep us in the PL as he will will make huge bonuses.

Our club should always be bigger than one individual.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 26 Jan 14 9.49am

Quote Gary St.Andrews at 26 Jan 2014 9.35am

I would be amazed if that was the case, but then again i was amazed at what happened to IH.

What manager doesn't get frustrated from time to time with restrictions on how much they have to spend on players,

The difference here is that Tony Pulis has only been at the club for a couple of months and it seems that he took a lot of persuading to join in the first place and only did after receiving promises of funds to buy new players in January

 

slubglurge Flag welling 26 Jan 14 9.50am

You don't sense the warmth between Pulis and Parish as there was with Ollie. It beginning to look as though the transfer nonsense in the last window was not the whole fault of IH.

 

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 26 Jan 14 9.53am

Quote Ian J at 26 Jan 2014 9.48am

Quote braunstoneagle at 26 Jan 2014 9.04am

if he quits then we dont have to pay up his contract...thats fine by me.

i know he is doing a good job,but i still prefer the owners choice of player signings over his.

Then why not get rid of Tony Pulis and let Steve Parish manage instead


premier fan has summed up that question in the post underneath yours quite well.

the manager cannot dictate how much the club spend and how much they pay on wages!

like others have said, he is an employee, and a very well paid one at that.

managers only give the list of players they want to the relevant people...they dont negotiate fees/wages with other clubs!

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


Midlands Eagle Flag 26 Jan 14 9.54am

Quote premier fan at 26 Jan 2014 9.48am

TP might be frustrated but he's an employee and on a huge salary and needs to get on with the job in hand. If he goes at the end of the season so be it but as we know its in his interests to stay and keep us in the PL as he will will make huge bonuses.

Perhaps not everyone is motivated purely by money. Tony Pulis has an excellent reputation as a manager and he won't want to lose that because of a chairman who promises him the earth to get him to join then breaks his promises once the ink is dry on the contract.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 26 Jan 14 9.57am

Quote slubglurge at 26 Jan 2014 9.50am

You don't sense the warmth between Pulis and Parish as there was with Ollie. It beginning to look as though the transfer nonsense in the last window was not the whole fault of IH.

I don't doubt that for one minute. You may recall that Holloway was asked about a player in one of the pre season games and he said that he didn't know who he was as the chairman had brought him down for a trial


 

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 26 Jan 14 9.59am

Quote Ian J at 26 Jan 2014 9.54am

Quote premier fan at 26 Jan 2014 9.48am

TP might be frustrated but he's an employee and on a huge salary and needs to get on with the job in hand. If he goes at the end of the season so be it but as we know its in his interests to stay and keep us in the PL as he will will make huge bonuses.

Perhaps not everyone is motivated purely by money. Tony Pulis has an excellent reputation as a manager and he won't want to lose that because of a chairman who promises him the earth to get him to join then breaks his promises once the ink is dry on the contract.


do you know thats the case?

i wouldav imagined (neither of us know) that there was a ballpark figure on money available for transfers, not an agreement to buy certain players.

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


Page 3 of 17 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Rumour: Pulis To Quit In The Summer