You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Is there room for sentiment in football ?
November 16 2026 1.13pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Is there room for sentiment in football ?


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
irishbren Flag Cliftonville. Kent. 02 Feb 14 10.22am

I listened to the excellent 'Transfer Podcast' on Friday.
Near the end, Jel Holyoake spoke (it seemed with some sadness.) about sentiment, or the lack of it, in professional football today.
He mentioned specifically how he 'felt' for Peter Ramage, who had worked so hard with the team, to help us win promotion. And was so excited, and really looking forward to getting the chance to play in the Premier League.
He happily signed a new contract, only to be excluded from Holloway's 25 man squad, and then be loaned out to Barnsley for the season.
So...Is there room for sentiment in football ?
I can recall clearly, our brief Premier League stay in 1997/98. Carlo Nash was desperate to play a Premier League match, in goal for Palace.
But even after relegation was assured, Steve Coppell did not give him a game.
He finally got his wish with Man City in 2000/01.
Outside Palace, I can go back to the 1966 World Cup. Jimmy Greaves got injured, and Alf Ramsey brought in Geoff Hurst for the Quarter Final. Greaves was fit for the Final. Nearly every football fan in the country (outside West Ham.) were calling for the re-instatement of Greaves. Ramsey ignored all that, and played Hurst....The rest, as they say, is history....
The famous photograph of Jimmy Greaves standing in the tunnel,in his suit, while England paraded the World Cup around Wembley, is one of THE saddest football pictures.(Check it out.)
Let's move to a more recent event....
The London Olympics...
David Beckham (And I'm no fan of his.) had put in so much time and effort into helping London secure the 2012 Olympics. He stated how keen he was to be in the Great Britain Football Squad. He was overlooked.
Surely Stuart Pearce could have found a spot for him, in the squad at least ?
Maybe you can re-call an instance when sentiment came into play, and backfired ?
Anyway, have anyone got an opinion on this ?
Will the 'Sentiment issue' become a hot topic over the coming weeks/months regarding Speroni and Hennessey ?
Your thoughts would be interesting.
IS THERE ROOM FOR SENTIMENT IN FOOTBALL ?

 

Plane Flag Bromley 02 Feb 14 10.58am

In short, no

 

Tinhat Flag west wickham 02 Feb 14 11.04am

Ramage carried himself with a lot of grace, I would have been furious that after playing a significant part in out promotion season, signing a new contract and then being left out for Injured Paddy Mac to be in the 25 who played no part.
But, if we bring in better players than we have got already than can only be a better thing for the club providing the players are committed.

 

adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 02 Feb 14 11.08am

Quote irishbren at 02 Feb 2014 10.22am

I listened to the excellent 'Transfer Podcast' on Friday.
Near the end, Jel Holyoake spoke (it seemed with some sadness.) about sentiment, or the lack of it, in professional football today.
He mentioned specifically how he 'felt' for Peter Ramage, who had worked so hard with the team, to help us win promotion. And was so excited, and really looking forward to getting the chance to play in the Premier League.
He happily signed a new contract, only to be excluded from Holloway's 25 man squad, and then be loaned out to Barnsley for the season.
So...Is there room for sentiment in football ?
I can recall clearly, our brief Premier League stay in 1997/98. Carlo Nash was desperate to play a Premier League match, in goal for Palace.
But even after relegation was assured, Steve Coppell did not give him a game.
He finally got his wish with Man City in 2000/01.
Outside Palace, I can go back to the 1966 World Cup. Jimmy Greaves got injured, and Alf Ramsey brought in Geoff Hurst for the Quarter Final. Greaves was fit for the Final. Nearly every football fan in the country (outside West Ham.) were calling for the re-instatement of Greaves. Ramsey ignored all that, and played Hurst....The rest, as they say, is history....
The famous photograph of Jimmy Greaves standing in the tunnel,in his suit, while England paraded the World Cup around Wembley, is one of THE saddest football pictures.(Check it out.)
Let's move to a more recent event....
The London Olympics...
David Beckham (And I'm no fan of his.) had put in so much time and effort into helping London secure the 2012 Olympics. He stated how keen he was to be in the Great Britain Football Squad. He was overlooked.
Surely Stuart Pearce could have found a spot for him, in the squad at least ?
Maybe you can re-call an instance when sentiment came into play, and backfired ?
Anyway, have anyone got an opinion on this ?
Will the 'Sentiment issue' become a hot topic over the coming weeks/months regarding Speroni and Hennessey ?
Your thoughts would be interesting.
IS THERE ROOM FOR SENTIMENT IN FOOTBALL ?

Never, Palace could end up with a poor tream of no-hopers

 

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 02 Feb 14 11.18am

If you want to improve NO.
But then you are banking on the skills of the Manager at the time.
EG I would have kept all of lasts years squad and NOT blown them out so soon.
Which was nearly our downfall so early.
We now must wait and see if the 4 NEW lads get into the first 11 and make the TEAM better.

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

hedgie Flag Flitwick 02 Feb 14 11.29am

Perhaps there can be a case for it when there really isn't anything else to choose between two players, but how often does that happen?

If we'd been sentimental, then Nigel Martyn wouldn't have replaced Perry Suckling, and we'd probably have gone down in 1990 without a cup final appearance.

However, with Kevin Miller I thought that replacing Carlo Nash was always just justification for the transfer, and that Carlo was actually the better player.

I don't know enough about Hennessey to know how he compares with Julian but I do think he is here to be his replacement, just not sure whether it is meant to be now or over time, perhaps at the end of the season when Jules contract ends.

If they are close on ability then I do think it would be unfair on Julian on his current form to drop him, but if Hennessey is clearly the better player then there can't be room for sentiment. Then again, hopefully Hennessey won't just be played to justify the transfer, either.

 

The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 02 Feb 14 11.50am

There isn't but there should be...its how a club keeps its soul

 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 02 Feb 14 11.52am

Quote The Sash at 02 Feb 2014 11.50am

There isn't but there should be...its how a club keeps its soul


I think there is a little but not enough. It's about how situations are handled as much as anything.

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

SE9 EAGLE Flag 02 Feb 14 11.54am

We must be sentimentalists supporting Palace.

 

7@burnley79 Flag Battersea 02 Feb 14 12.09pm

I'd like to think there is a little bit of sentiment behind the scenes at Palace, if not then we should of won more than we have.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 02 Feb 14 12.12pm

Quote alaneagle1 at 02 Feb 2014 11.18am

you are banking on the skills of the Manager at the time.
EG I would have kept all of lasts years squad and NOT blown them out so soon.

Yet most people on here said before the season started that Delaney and Gabbidon weren't up to Premiership standard and should be jettisoned before the season started.


 

bertshead Flag Castlederg 02 Feb 14 12.36pm

There's no sentiment in football or loyalty in my opinion.
Of the Ramage situation I was not best pleased to hear that he wasn't in the 25 and somehow McCarthy got in so god knows how he felt when told he was going to Barnsley.

 

babylonjohn Flag St Leonards-on-Sea 02 Feb 14 12.48pm

No....players and managers are there to do a job and get paid extremely well to do that job. The sentiment in football is generated by us the fans who give our clubs unconditional devotion.

 

FinchleyEagle Flag 02 Feb 14 1.12pm

Quote The Sash at 02 Feb 2014 11.50am

There isn't but there should be...its how a club keeps its soul

Like everything in life, you need a balance - I'd suggest some sentiment but mostly what's best for the club.

 


You'll be forever in my family's memories and it was an honor and privilege to play and lead in the red and blue
Yours sincerely
Mile Jedinak

Stirlingsays Flag 02 Feb 14 1.51pm

Not with the first team no.

For the fans yes.

There should be sentiment for the club in helping players and business connected with the club...Youth players for example....Helping the ones who don't make it....ie being a 'family club'.....Yes.....It's the right thing to do and it actually helps the club out in the long run in terms of reputation and cohesion.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 02 Feb 14 3.25pm

Quote SE9 EAGLE at 02 Feb 2014 11.54am

We must be sentimentalists supporting Palace.

Ill give you mentalists


 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

paperhat Flag croydon 07 Feb 14 11.10am

I was listening to something akin to this on Talksh1te a few days back and it was being said that modern day football has no room for sentimentalism, the fan was far lower down the priority list now than ever before and that big, modern clubs were more a brand and advertising cash cow than anything else.

Winning is everything, financially more so than ever and just becasue Billy is really happy that he's been at No Hope FC for the alst 20 years should be no reason to keep him if Carlos Lob-a-ball can come in , generate interest and revenue and do the same job. Blimey, look at Berbatov for example.

 


Clinton is Clinton. I have known him for a long time, I know his mother... Simon Jordan


timmyb Flag Banstead 07 Feb 14 11.33am

The board bringing back Steve Kember was a touch of class. Not the same as retaining a player, but showed they understood the value of sterling service.

 

Part Time James Flag 07 Feb 14 11.41am

I think there is room for a tiny bit of sentiment. I genuinely think some of the banter between Moritz, Delaney and Ramage in the promotion season had a genuine bearing on their performance on the pitch. It might seem a strange thing to say, but when they all grew moustaches for Movember and were taking the mickey out of each other it seemed to coincide with one of their best runs of form (if I remember correctly).

Of course I am not dumb enough to attribute all of our success to off pitch camaraderie but I think it helped. So whilst some players might not quite be up to the standard of first XI, as squad players they actually could provide something to the overall team morale. Ramage, for me, seemed to give the impression of being a key component of the winning mentality we had and I don't think would be SO far off the Premier League standard that he couldn't cut it as a squad player on that basis.

By the way, not advocating really pants players staying in the squad just to keep the spirits high. Just ones who are around about good enough.

Edited by Part Time James (07 Feb 2014 11.51am)

 




Bignormous Flag 07 Feb 14 12.35pm

Sentimentality for its own sake? No.

However, if a player thinks that achieving success (promotion) will result in his being excluded from some of the results of that success (loaned out to Barnsley) then you can build a motivation problem if you do not manage it carefully. This is particularly so if a large component of that success is based on team spirit and the player concerned is important to that. I suspect that was true of our promotion last season,

It might seem like sentimentality but I think I would have recognised Ramage's value to the team beyond his immediate playing attributes. This may be why McCarthy made the 25 and perhaps why we kept Millen when Pulis would probably have wanted his own man all things being equal.

I wonder what Ramage would have made of being told that he was being kept in the squad out of sentimentality.

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Is there room for sentiment in football ?