You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Goalkeeper
November 16 2026 1.13pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Goalkeeper


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
kinky1960 Flag Hampshire 02 Feb 14 7.33pm

I may be shot down for posting this, but I expect Hennessey to be in goal against WBA.

Imo TP bought him in because of his height/reach and I wonder if he would have saved the second goal.

I like Speroni and think he has been a great servant but I will be surprised if he isnt replaced sooner than later.

 



Thank you CPFC2010 for keeping me interested in football, for me no Palace no football either. Come on you Eagles.

Icepick Tony Flag Chester 02 Feb 14 7.39pm

Whilst I agree about the height etc of Hennessey and I fully expect him to replace Jules sooner, rather than later, it was a hard shot along the ground and actually more suited to a smaller keeper as getting to the ground is easier. I think Speroni will be unhappy he didn't keep it out.

 


"They got his own song 'He's just too good for you', it's quite unbelievable but when you see it and he's facing up someone - I actually feel sorry for them, 'Cos he actually is" - Ian Holloway

Mr Fenandes Flag 02 Feb 14 7.56pm

Defending 100% to blame for both goals surely.

I would say the tactics were to gamble on defending very deep, not conceding and it didn't work out. Speroni was going to be very busy as a result.

I think we showed Arsenal just that little bit too much respect at the end of the day.

Edited by Mr Fenandes (02 Feb 2014 7.56pm)

 


Check out our Croydon-based football comedy series 'Road to F.A. Cup'!
All episodes available FREE here: [Link]

premier fan Flag BR4 02 Feb 14 7.57pm

Hope not. Someone told me recently that he's been sun sports most consistent goalkeeper on the points gained.

 

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 02 Feb 14 7.58pm

Quote kinky1960 at 02 Feb 2014 7.33pm

I may be shot down for posting this, but I expect Hennessey to be in goal against WBA.

Imo TP bought him in because of his height/reach and I wonder if he would have saved the second goal.

I like Speroni and think he has been a great servant but I will be surprised if he isnt replaced sooner than later.


I think the shot was too powerful to have kept out with one hand, to be honest. I'd be very surprised if he walked straight in on Saturday.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

muffinbrucie Flag london 02 Feb 14 8.12pm

Tend to agree. had a seat in the north bank and you could tell by his immediate reaction he knew he should have saved it

 


its a town full of losers, i,m pulling outta here to win

merganser Flag 02 Feb 14 8.29pm

I thought Jules did more than enough to keep his place. He made a few really good saves in the first half and was left hopelessly exposed for the 2 goals which o-c took really well.

 

jimmyc Flag 02 Feb 14 8.45pm

Yea, I think he will be disappointed about the second goal. 9 out of 10 times he would save it. And he had a hell of a save from the free kick in the first half.

 

est1905 Flag 02 Feb 14 9.03pm

Quote kinky1960 at 02 Feb 2014 7.33pm

I may be shot down for posting this, but I expect Hennessey to be in goal against WBA.

Imo TP bought him in because of his height/reach and I wonder if he would have saved the second goal.

I like Speroni and think he has been a great servant but I will be surprised if he isnt replaced sooner than later.


While I personally would stick with Jules you do not pay £3m for a player let alone a goal keeper if you don't intend to play him and soon.
Pulis said recently that Jules will be offered a new contract but I have a feeling he will be made aware that he is no longer first choice and because of that, sadly I think Jules may look to move on. Football is a short career. At his age he wants to be playing

 

The Saint Flag Burnham,Buckinghamshire 02 Feb 14 9.46pm

Unsure on this one.

I was surprised as anyone when we signed Hennessey, who is a decent keeper for a large amount of money.

This leads me to believe either

1) Speroni is going to move on, whether by TP or maybe he wants another challenge elsewhere

2) Lewis Price AND Neil Alexander are both on their way out, as they are not competing with Jules for the Number 1 spot (i.e. Jules aint being displaced and they have had long enough to prove themselves)

TP will not damage the spirit of the players who are already here by shoe-horning these signings straight in. I think he is going to give everyone a fair crack to train this week to see who wants it the most against WBA. This will either push the players who are still here, or push them out of the 1st eleven.

I think Jules will still be there - as to change the keeper with the recognised back four might lead to more mistakes than less. If Scott Dann, Wayne Hennessey and Paddy McCarthy all came in for the WBA game, I cannot see how we will perform better at the back.

So, for me, Jules stays in and Hennessey will have to wait.

 


"A man may fight for many things. His country, his friends, his principles, the glistening tear on the cheek of a golden child. But personally, I'd mud-wrestle my own mother for a ton of cash, an amusing clock and a sack of French porn."

merganser Flag 02 Feb 14 10.48pm

On that second goal, would have Jules done better simply to have stuck out his left leg? It would have been untidy, but it might have sent the ball spinning out for a corner.

Re the first goal, sky suggested he might have gone down too soon?
Is that the case? Or did he have little option?

Can any goalie clarifiy?

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 02 Feb 14 11.00pm

He'd have seen that late, and it would have been difficult to get down to and get enough on. It would have been a great save to pull off, and sometimes a keeper does, and sometimes he doesn't.

I wouldn't blame the defence, they were outstanding today, but when you're up against a squad of players of that quality, at several points they're going to get chances.

It should be remembered that our defence were up against some of the best players in the world. Our defence cost a fraction of their attacking force, and they didn't walk all over us.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Eagles-Mad Flag Romford Essex 02 Feb 14 11.03pm

Quote merganser at 02 Feb 2014 10.48pm

On that second goal, would have Jules done better simply to have stuck out his left leg? It would have been untidy, but it might have sent the ball spinning out for a corner.

Re the first goal, sky suggested he might have gone down too soon?
Is that the case? Or did he have little option?

Can any goalie clarifiy?


Have to admit it I was on Charltons books as a keeper when I was younger, didn't cut it because truth is I just didn't grow tall enough. The first goal Jules had no chance, OC went to shoot low and Jules went down to save it however OC had disguised his touch and chipped it over Jules. The second goal you could argue maybe. However it was a low and hard shot Jules was completely exposed so he done well in my opinion to even get a hand to it, but he felt he should of done better so maybe he could of. But you cannot really blame Jules, Ward was at fault for both goals however because people don't want to criticise Ward because he is super man, they need a different scapegoat for the goals IE Jules.

 

merganser Flag 02 Feb 14 11.31pm

Thanks for that insight - and sorry to hear you didn't get your chance at the big time.

 

cpj Flag Kent 02 Feb 14 11.43pm

Quote Icepick Tony at 02 Feb 2014 7.39pm

Whilst I agree about the height etc of Hennessey and I fully expect him to replace Jules sooner, rather than later, it was a hard shot along the ground and actually more suited to a smaller keeper as getting to the ground is easier. I think Speroni will be unhappy he didn't keep it out.


Not as unhappy as I am!

 

Seth Flag On a pale blue dot 03 Feb 14 1.27am

Quote merganser at 02 Feb 2014 11.31pm

Thanks for that insight - and sorry to hear you didn't get your chance at the big time.


You must have misread, he said he was on Charlton's books.

 


"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down"
FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16

sprites Flag Auckland 03 Feb 14 1.46am

Hennesey will have to wait.

 

thebob Flag Tatebayashi (from Croydon) 03 Feb 14 3.21am

Quote Seth at 03 Feb 2014 1.27am

Quote merganser at 02 Feb 2014 11.31pm

Thanks for that insight - and sorry to hear you didn't get your chance at the big time.


You must have misread, he said he was on Charlton's books.


Who?

 

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 03 Feb 14 9.58am

No reason to blame JS for the goals. OC was alone on both occasions. But Chamach ballwatching for the first one and Bolassie seems to have no idea where to position himself. Surely he must have some defensive tasks as well? Would like to see Ince and Puncheon on the wings against WBA, and Ledley on for KD (who played remarkably well after such a long lay-off).

 

bodge Flag 03 Feb 14 11.15am

I think you may be right i hope not as Jules is a fine keeper and has made very few mistakes.

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Goalkeeper