You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Cham's pen
November 16 2026 1.03pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Cham's pen


Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
Plane Flag Bromley 09 Feb 14 2.58pm

Quote StainesPalace at 09 Feb 2014 9.01am

Keeper clearly won the ball was never a penalty. Great finish tho. I think we'll end up playing Chamakh and Murray up front.


Getting a minute touch on ball as the keeper takes out the forward does not mean he played the ball. -.-'

 

Joeberto Flag Streatham Hill 09 Feb 14 3.05pm

Quote Plane at 09 Feb 2014 2.58pm

Quote StainesPalace at 09 Feb 2014 9.01am

Keeper clearly won the ball was never a penalty. Great finish tho. I think we'll end up playing Chamakh and Murray up front.


Getting a minute touch on ball as the keeper takes out the forward does not mean he played the ball. -.-'

Yep, Foster did get a touch but if he hadn't slid through and brought Cham down he would have strode on and knocked it into an empty net! Pen all the way.

 

Plane Flag Bromley 09 Feb 14 3.12pm

Quote Joeberto at 09 Feb 2014 3.05pm

Quote Plane at 09 Feb 2014 2.58pm

Quote StainesPalace at 09 Feb 2014 9.01am

Keeper clearly won the ball was never a penalty. Great finish tho. I think we'll end up playing Chamakh and Murray up front.


Getting a minute touch on ball as the keeper takes out the forward does not mean he played the ball. -.-'

Yep, Foster did get a touch but if he hadn't slid through and brought Cham down he would have strode on and knocked it into an empty net! Pen all the way.


Agreed.

 

palace99 Flag New Mills 10 Feb 14 10.46am

Quote StainesPalace at 09 Feb 2014 9.01am

Keeper clearly won the ball was never a penalty. Great finish tho. I think we'll end up playing Chamakh and Murray up front.

I'm glad you said that as from my view in Homesdale B and confirmed on TV keeper definitely touches ball first and then momentum takes him into Chamakh. You could argue that ball didn't get pushed too far away and Chamakh might have still got to it but i think we definitely got lucky there.

Whislt really pleased with the result and 3 goals i think the pen disguised a really poor 2nd half performance. WBA controled the half and but for an amazing save from Jules would have equalised. We offered very little in second half and could have paid the price.

 

Hambo Flag Crawley 10 Feb 14 12.50pm

Quote matthau at 09 Feb 2014 9.16am

Obviously hes tood good for us if we go down.

but I am becoming more confident daily that we'll stay up.

I hope and prey cham is an eagle next season. Murray and him I beleive would make a prem class strike force.


cham may not have been title winning class but he damn sure is upper prem class. We are lucky to have him.


Keeping him happy and settled within the squad and making him feel wanted offers the best chance of him hanging around IMO. We're doing a good job of that so far and it's clear for all to see that his once-shattered confidence is well on the way to being restored.

I'm not sure a new deal would be the right way to go for either party right now (as a fan, it absolutely is) - not whilst things are going so well. I think both sides sitting down when we know where we'll be and what the club can offer will be appealing to him and us. That way we're not over-stretching in the event of relelgation and he's not over committing in the same situation.

 


HOL Radio Lead Presenter and sampler of processed meats

HOL radio - Sunday nights [Link]
HOL Radio Twitter:


My Twitter:

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 10 Feb 14 12.59pm

Now that his stock is rising again there is always the chance a biggish euro club may come in and be able to offer him Europa or even Champions League footy next season.

I don't think he will move to another UK club but someone like Lille or Fiorentina and the extra quality of life might sway him and why not?

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 10 Feb 14 1.04pm

Quote Joeberto at 09 Feb 2014 3.05pm

Quote Plane at 09 Feb 2014 2.58pm

Quote StainesPalace at 09 Feb 2014 9.01am

Keeper clearly won the ball was never a penalty. Great finish tho. I think we'll end up playing Chamakh and Murray up front.


Getting a minute touch on ball as the keeper takes out the forward does not mean he played the ball. -.-'

Yep, Foster did get a touch but if he hadn't slid through and brought Cham down he would have strode on and knocked it into an empty net! Pen all the way.

From the referees angle I don't think he'd have seen it. Its took me a few replays to see that it might not have been a penalty. Managers have the benefit of bias and replays to make their decision, but the referee has to call it.

The manager complaining that if it was a penalty the keeper should have been sent off is absurd. The Referee I think made a good call. Penalty and no card.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Mapletree Flag Croydon 10 Feb 14 1.16pm

Quote keith whitfield at 09 Feb 2014 7.23am

When he bore down on goal, it looked to me as if he lacked the confidence to shoot and knew he was going to go for the penalty.

Class finish though.


Yup, no doubt. And that was the worrying part about this. He was one on one and should have buried it rather than playing for the pen.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 10 Feb 14 1.16pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 10 Feb 2014 1.04pm

Quote Joeberto at 09 Feb 2014 3.05pm

Quote Plane at 09 Feb 2014 2.58pm

Quote StainesPalace at 09 Feb 2014 9.01am

Keeper clearly won the ball was never a penalty. Great finish tho. I think we'll end up playing Chamakh and Murray up front.


Getting a minute touch on ball as the keeper takes out the forward does not mean he played the ball. -.-'

Yep, Foster did get a touch but if he hadn't slid through and brought Cham down he would have strode on and knocked it into an empty net! Pen all the way.

From the referees angle I don't think he'd have seen it. Its took me a few replays to see that it might not have been a penalty. Managers have the benefit of bias and replays to make their decision, but the referee has to call it.

The manager complaining that if it was a penalty the keeper should have been sent off is absurd. The Referee I think made a good call. Penalty and no card.



OK, he was moving away from goal a little but surely should have been a yellow?

 

madcap_v2 Flag SE25 / Ibiza 10 Feb 14 1.29pm

Definitely wasn't a penalty IMO but regardless, the ref gave it and it was stuck away very well by Chammers

 


La la la your mum

Plane Flag Bromley 10 Feb 14 1.34pm

Quote madcap_v2 at 10 Feb 2014 1.29pm

Definitely wasn't a penalty IMO but regardless, the ref gave it and it was stuck away very well by Chammers


You're basically saying that any player can up end another as long as the player making the tackle at least gets a touch on the ball, then that's legal?

 

paperhat Flag croydon 10 Feb 14 1.37pm

I'd naively assumed that if you follow through and tak eout a player, it doesnt matter if you touch the ball or not first, its still a foul?

What I don't get is what happened with this on sat. If Chamakh dive, he should have been given a yellow, if Foster took him out then he should have had a yellow or red. Either way , there should have been a card given?

 


Clinton is Clinton. I have known him for a long time, I know his mother... Simon Jordan


Plane Flag Bromley 10 Feb 14 1.40pm

Quote paperhat at 10 Feb 2014 1.37pm

I'd naively assumed that if you follow through and tak eout a player, it doesnt matter if you touch the ball or not first, its still a foul?

What I don't get is what happened with this on sat. If Chamakh dive, he should have been given a yellow, if Foster took him out then he should have had a yellow or red. Either way , there should have been a card given?

Of course you're correct.

I agree, it should have been a yellow for the keeper.

 

palace99 Flag New Mills 10 Feb 14 2.58pm

Quote Plane at 10 Feb 2014 1.40pm

Quote paperhat at 10 Feb 2014 1.37pm

I'd naively assumed that if you follow through and tak eout a player, it doesnt matter if you touch the ball or not first, its still a foul?

What I don't get is what happened with this on sat. If Chamakh dive, he should have been given a yellow, if Foster took him out then he should have had a yellow or red. Either way , there should have been a card given?

Of course you're correct.

I agree, it should have been a yellow for the keeper.


so extending your logic every slide tackle must be a foul as you always take out the man afterwards as he will always fall over your extended leg.

A foul for me is if you don't take the ball first and/or you go in in a dangerous way.

I don't think Foster was particularly dangerous and he definitely touched the ball first, hence it was a fortunate penalty imho.

Would you have been happy if Jules had conceded one in the same circumstances??

 

Arthur Blackpudding Flag 10 Feb 14 3.57pm

Seeing it from the Holmesdale I said straight away I didn't think it was a penalty.

However when you see it from different angles on MOTD I can see why it was awarded.

To me if you get the ball first, it's a good tackle.

I'd have been very pissed off if we conceded a penalty like that.

 

Hoof Hearted 10 Feb 14 4.34pm

The keeper did touch the ball, but by up ending Chamakh prevented him from collecting the ball afterwards, which he would have done easily.

Penalty all day long.

 

Plane Flag Bromley 10 Feb 14 6.09pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 10 Feb 2014 4.34pm

The keeper did touch the ball, but by up ending Chamakh prevented him from collecting the ball afterwards, which he would have done easily.

Penalty all day long.


Agreed Hoof, and if memory serves me you're a qualified ref?

 

bodge Flag 10 Feb 14 6.44pm

It was a pen he did not get the ball clear of Chamakh so it was a foul.

 

Stuk Flag Top half 10 Feb 14 7.18pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 10 Feb 2014 4.34pm

The keeper did touch the ball, but by up ending Chamakh prevented him from collecting the ball afterwards, which he would have done easily.

Penalty all day long.


That's how I see it.

 


Optimistic as ever

Ljb Flag Sutton 10 Feb 14 7.37pm

When I saw it in the game I couldn't believe the ref had given it as it looked like he clearly got the ball first. Still think it was a bit of a soft penalty, but not going to complain and can see why it was given

 

Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Cham's pen