You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > New Stadium. Is it still on the cards?
November 16 2026 1.03pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

New Stadium. Is it still on the cards?


Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3
est1905 Flag 13 Feb 14 8.40pm

Quote silvertop at 12 Feb 2014 11.45am

40k? Yes, it would be nice if we were a permanent fixture in the top flight. However, that we would only fill the ground to capacity for the London derbies, big teams, major cup games and, who knows, the odd tryst in Europe [?] is not the issue.

Planning is central. When Noades tried to increase capacity to 42k, the Council considered our application and approved a major rebuild which would have added a whopping 600 [SIX HUNDRED] seats to the current capacity. Obviously, Noades baulked at the idea of rebuilding the ground for just six hundred measly seats and the plan was shelved.

Access for such large numbers, parking, policing, public transport etc were, I suspect, foremost on the minds of the planners. Yeah, I know, there are 40k + grounds in other parts of the country set in equally densely poulated urban areas. However, what they decide in Merseyside etc. is what they decide there. Croydon have their own criteria and, I suspect, the desires of a football club and their fans may not feature highly. Or else, that was their position back then.

With the development of Croydon still politically hot, perhaps the political landscape has changed? However, the Club will, I suspect, still need to sweeten any deal that enables a sizeable expansion of capacity with a heavily weighted "section 106 Agreement". This is the deal with the Council whereby the Club developes the ground; but, in return, it also builds a school, improves the local transport infrastructure to accomodate the larger numbers, invests in community projects, undertakes landscaping to improve the public realm, builds underground parking facilities, pays to re-house any residents whose properties may need to be demolished and any other capital expense that would address the changes from a larger improved ground. Obviously, that may collossally add to the cost and delay the completion date of any project. Also, the larger the size of the ground, I suspect the more the add-ons the Council would demand as a quid pro quo for granting consent.

The point is, once we get a plan to expand the ground approved by the Club, that is when the difficult bit begins. We could then be locked in discussions with the Council for some time [possibly years] before a mutually acceptable section 106 deal is struck. Obviously, if the Club bring the Council into their plans from the earliest moment and use decent planning consultants and associated professionals, this may reduce the time and cost of getting an approved plan up and running.

As an aside, these conditions are normal and not some form of illicit back-hander. Every time you see a new housing development or supermarket built, it is Crest Homes or Sainsbury's who had to pay for all that landscaping, the children's play park and the new access roads.

Thanks for that Silvertop. Informative, complex and depressing!
I live in hope we will some day in the next few years actually have a new stadium. Right now other clubs will struggle to take us seriously as a Premiership club (even if we stay up) if we don't even have Championship standard facilities

 

rob1969 Flag Banstead Surrey 13 Feb 14 9.50pm

Appreciate this not going to happen but has anyone any ideas as to the probable comparative cost of fully redeveloping SP into a modern 30K+ stadium against building a brand new stadium - assuming no land cost involved - do a land swop deal with Council.
I wonder if cost would be similar bearing in mind a new stadium wouldn't require any reduction in capacity at SP during its construction.

 

corkery Flag Cork City 13 Feb 14 9.54pm

Hopefully not. If it's not in the Crystal Palace park, it'll be in the middle of nowhere. Clubs like Bolton, Reading, Brighton have build modern souless bowls on the outskirts. I don't want a stadium on the M23 with no pubs in sight.

 


We'll never die

Catfish Flag Burgess Hill 13 Feb 14 10.01pm

We need to persuade Network Rail to vacate Selhurst Depot. Perfect spot that could be linked direct to Selhurst Station.

 


Yes, I am an agent of Satan but my duties are largely ceremonial

Aj's_Magic_Hat Flag Las Palmas 13 Feb 14 11.43pm

Quote Catfish at 13 Feb 2014 10.01pm

We need to persuade Network Rail to vacate Selhurst Depot. Perfect spot that could be linked direct to Selhurst Station.


Been saying that for years.

 

adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 14 Feb 14 12.01pm

Quote Catfish at 11 Feb 2014 3.43pm

The idea of seeing a 40,000+ crowd in Selhurst again is very appealing, (what an atmosphere it was). However, we have never, in our entire history, averaged crowds above 30,000. Is it worth having a stadium that you can fill only five times a season when all the other games have yawning gaps in the stands? And realistically if we go back to the Championship any time we are likely to have a lot of empty space. In the medium term I think 35,000 would be more than enough.


Palace did once average gates in excess of 35,000, and often more for a short time. Croydon is the biggest borough in London, and therefore UK. So we need to be confident Palace will fill a 40,000 stadium. Unless we accept Palace will never be a really top club. Not sure I want to do that!

 

est1905 Flag 14 Feb 14 5.35pm

Quote adrian b at 14 Feb 2014 12.01pm

Quote Catfish at 11 Feb 2014 3.43pm

The idea of seeing a 40,000+ crowd in Selhurst again is very appealing, (what an atmosphere it was). However, we have never, in our entire history, averaged crowds above 30,000. Is it worth having a stadium that you can fill only five times a season when all the other games have yawning gaps in the stands? And realistically if we go back to the Championship any time we are likely to have a lot of empty space. In the medium term I think 35,000 would be more than enough.

Agree,
Derby County are a perfect example of 'If you build it, they will come'. Their gates were only around 15/18k at the time they left the baseball ground. That gate shot up (admittedly temporarily) to nearly the 40k capacity on a regular bases. Top flight football kept it there for a while too. isn't that part of our owners plans? Inevitably their gates have dwindled due to poor football, relegation, poor management, etc but they have still stabilised at a higher average than before they moved.
I believe (if Palace remained in the top flight and established itself in the top division as a mid table team, couple that with a better matchday experience because of better facilities (no cues for the toilet, better food outlets, bars, seating, better view, etc, etc) I don't see any reason at all with the catchment area Palace has why we cant realistically double our average gate.


Palace did once average gates in excess of 35,000, and often more for a short time. Croydon is the biggest borough in London, and therefore UK. So we need to be confident Palace will fill a 40,000 stadium. Unless we accept Palace will never be a really top club. Not sure I want to do that!


 

rob1969 Flag Banstead Surrey 14 Feb 14 6.00pm

Quote corkery at 13 Feb 2014 9.54pm

Hopefully not. If it's not in the Crystal Palace park, it'll be in the middle of nowhere. Clubs like Bolton, Reading, Brighton have build modern souless bowls on the outskirts. I don't want a stadium on the M23 with no pubs in sight.[/quot

Sure a pub would soon be built - near to a 30K capacity football stadium !


 

rob1969 Flag Banstead Surrey 14 Feb 14 6.27pm

Quote Aj's_Magic_Hat at 13 Feb 2014 11.43pm

Quote Catfish at 13 Feb 2014 10.01pm

We need to persuade Network Rail to vacate Selhurst Depot. Perfect spot that could be linked direct to Selhurst Station.


Been saying that for years.


Would be ideal but don't see Network Rail vacating their Selhurst Depot.
CP Park, or any other site within 2-4 miles of SP, with improved access/transport links,would be equally good.

 

doublesuited77 Flag London (Camden) 17 Feb 14 3.47am

Quote Barcelona Based Fan at 10 Feb 2014 6.33pm

Quote dannyboy1978 at 10 Feb 2014 4.51pm

I would put up with going to another stadium for one season whilst building work was going on !! If it meant an even better stadium then why not???


Wonder if Charlton would return the favour and allow us to share the Valley for a season or two?

If we play for an extended period of time at any ground that isn't selhurst, it will be the olympic stadium


 


Be Loud, Be Proud, Be Palace

doublesuited77 Flag London (Camden) 17 Feb 14 3.48am

Quote adrian b at 11 Feb 2014 2.37pm

The way I see it, the only point in getting a new stadium is to increase capacity. It cannot be a coincidence the top clubs have the biggest grounds and those clubs that ought to be be there have the same facility, (Sheff Wed, Leeds). I suppose if you want the best players you need to pay the best wages. Income provides for that. A 40,000 capacity must be the very least for Palace to develop.

If we can get to 35-40k, we would likely sell some much cheaper upper level seats.

Agree at current prices it isn't realistic, but remember there are lots of blue collars who are currently priced out and can only afford a few games per year.


 


Be Loud, Be Proud, Be Palace

Johnny Byrne Flag Pinner 17 Feb 14 9.38am

I like the idea of a new ground at CP Park on the old National Athletics Stadium. Overground station is a modest walk away. I went to the World Cup in 2006 and saw England v Sweden in Cologne. Their stadium was in the middle of a forest outside town. Fantastic and good facilities to enter and exit. However, realistically, Selhurst Park redevelopment is most likely, and it is OUR HOME.

 

jwigs Flag 20 Feb 14 3.50pm

Has anyone thought of South Norwoods Recreational Ground? Or the allotments just north of Selhurst Depot?

Both are next to Norwood Junction or Selhurst Station so very easy to get to

Not a lot of space there either but worth exploring?

 

sydtheeagle Flag England 20 Feb 14 6.07pm

Quote Johnny Byrne at 17 Feb 2014 9.38am

I like the idea of a new ground at CP Park on the old National Athletics Stadium. Overground station is a modest walk away. I went to the World Cup in 2006 and saw England v Sweden in Cologne. Their stadium was in the middle of a forest outside town. Fantastic and good facilities to enter and exit. However, realistically, Selhurst Park redevelopment is most likely, and it is OUR HOME.

Actually, it's not. Our home is more or less what you just mentioned. The National Sports Centre. Look it up. And after that, our home is the Selhurst Rail Depot at it's now known, but was formerly The Nest. Selhurst is only our latest home. It's not our original one.


 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

Catfish Flag Burgess Hill 20 Feb 14 6.31pm

Quote adrian b at 14 Feb 2014 12.01pm

Quote Catfish at 11 Feb 2014 3.43pm

The idea of seeing a 40,000+ crowd in Selhurst again is very appealing, (what an atmosphere it was). However, we have never, in our entire history, averaged crowds above 30,000. Is it worth having a stadium that you can fill only five times a season when all the other games have yawning gaps in the stands? And realistically if we go back to the Championship any time we are likely to have a lot of empty space. In the medium term I think 35,000 would be more than enough.


Palace did once average gates in excess of 35,000, and often more for a short time. Croydon is the biggest borough in London, and therefore UK. So we need to be confident Palace will fill a 40,000 stadium. Unless we accept Palace will never be a really top club. Not sure I want to do that!


We have never averaged 35,000 over a season.

 


Yes, I am an agent of Satan but my duties are largely ceremonial

dingdong Flag bognor regis 20 Feb 14 7.49pm

yeah we have, 79/80

 

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 20 Feb 14 7.54pm

We struggle to sell out now with the A/B Policy.

Edited by alaneagle1 (20 Feb 2014 8.12pm)

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

Catfish Flag Burgess Hill 20 Feb 14 8.04pm

Quote dingdong at 20 Feb 2014 7.49pm

yeah we have, 79/80

[Link]

Then the information on this site is wrong.

 


Yes, I am an agent of Satan but my duties are largely ceremonial

It's only a game Flag Praa Sands 20 Feb 14 9.14pm

Quote alaneagle1 at 20 Feb 2014 7.54pm

We struggle to sell out now with the A/B Policy.

Edited by alaneagle1 (20 Feb 2014 8.12pm)


Spurs might have had the same problem with the AVB policy.

Edited by It's only a game (20 Feb 2014 9.14pm)

 


A stockbroker urged me to buy a stock that would triple its value every year. I told him, at my age, I don't even buy green bananas!


Stirlingsays Flag 20 Feb 14 9.37pm

We should be returning to our original location.....Sodding vested interests.

It's where anyone new to the area would expect the club to be.....Proper links, far better sited.

I'll say again....Proxy vested interests....When we finally have the money they don't want to know.

Edited by Stirlingsays (20 Feb 2014 9.38pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > New Stadium. Is it still on the cards?