You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Chamakh Penalty
November 16 2026 1.03pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Chamakh Penalty


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
GJDCPFC Flag Calgary 22 Feb 14 7.45pm

not that one but the one we should of had in the 1st half


Watching on Tv in Calgary but wanted to see what people thought who were at selhurst. Looked like Cham headed it then mata kicked him in the chest. No reference to it from the very very pro manure canadian tv channel.

 

bertshead Flag Castlederg 22 Feb 14 7.48pm

Not a pen for me, Chamakh dipped into the ball as much as anything.

 

adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 22 Feb 14 7.49pm

I6t's what to expect. If Utd had lost it would have been how poorly they played, nothing about the effort of the other team involved. According to my grandchildren there are only 56 teams in the Prem.

 

GJDCPFC Flag Calgary 22 Feb 14 7.52pm

I'm use to it having been here for 5 years. 35mins of preview and they didn't mention us once!!

 

askyourself Flag 22 Feb 14 7.54pm

British commo, Lee Dixon (ex-Arse) thought it was a pen and made a point of saying so.
Perhaps our players showed too much respect for the oppo by not making a big thing of it ????

 


We move in the direction of our thoughts.
Just think a little.

elgrande Flag bedford 22 Feb 14 7.58pm

Think Vidic all over Jedi at every set piece was more worrying.......and the Ref warned him about it,and still gave nothing.

 


always a Norwood boy, where ever I live.

merganser Flag 22 Feb 14 8.15pm


IMO Chamakh played really well. Oozed class and battled for everything - shame his enthusiasm got the better of him. It was just one of those things - and nothing Jules could have done to save RVP's spot-kick

 

Jimmy Flag Balham 22 Feb 14 11.31pm

Quote elgrande at 22 Feb 2014 7.58pm

Think Vidic all over Jedi at every set piece was more worrying.......and the Ref warned him about it,and still gave nothing.

Mate, you have that the wrong way round, Jedi played that perfectly....

 


Happy happy JOY, JOY!

stanzerman Flag Hastings 23 Feb 14 12.52am

Quote Jimmy at 22 Feb 2014 11.31pm

Quote elgrande at 22 Feb 2014 7.58pm

Think Vidic all over Jedi at every set piece was more worrying.......and the Ref warned him about it,and still gave nothing.

Mate, you have that the wrong way round, Jedi played that perfectly....

Yep, Jedi was 'marking' their keeper at corners, a tactic often used against us but something we ourselves dont normally do. Vidic was trying to stop Jedi standing in front of their keeper. Jedi did this really well. The ref couldn't give anything against Vidic as you cannot give a pen wnen the ball isn't in play. the pushing and shoving was happpening before the corner was taken.

 


Stanzerman

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 23 Feb 14 4.14am

OK u can not award a penalty when the ball is not played, but what about a yellow and then a red card? This wrestling on corners has got to stop or else it ruins the game (together with shirtpulling and diving).

 

daverave69 Flag Kent 23 Feb 14 7.10am

Simulation really windes me up

Janazi and RVP went down in the scond half like he had been shot

Then gets up


This needs to stop mean arnt they pros

 


PALACE 5-0 BRIGHTON
LIVING THE DREAM

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 23 Feb 14 11.01am

Probably should have been a penalty, outside the box the referee gives that as a foul. It doesn't matter that Chamakh leant into it, he got the ball and the contact was after that.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 23 Feb 14 11.03am

Quote merganser at 22 Feb 2014 8.15pm


IMO Chamakh played really well. Oozed class and battled for everything - shame his enthusiasm got the better of him. It was just one of those things - and nothing Jules could have done to save RVP's spot-kick

Chamakh was excellent, and looked like him and Murray were on the same wavelength. They'll make a good partnership. Even Jerome looked good, and forced a really good save moments after coming on.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Leicestershireeagle Flag South Leicestershire 23 Feb 14 11.06am

Quote stanzerman at 23 Feb 2014 12.52am

Quote Jimmy at 22 Feb 2014 11.31pm

Quote elgrande at 22 Feb 2014 7.58pm

Think Vidic all over Jedi at every set piece was more worrying.......and the Ref warned him about it,and still gave nothing.

Mate, you have that the wrong way round, Jedi played that perfectly....

Yep, Jedi was 'marking' their keeper at corners, a tactic often used against us but something we ourselves dont normally do. Vidic was trying to stop Jedi standing in front of their keeper. Jedi did this really well. The ref couldn't give anything against Vidic as you cannot give a pen wnen the ball isn't in play. the pushing and shoving was happpening before the corner was taken.

The best bit was Jedi, as mentioned, played it perfectly and generally had a look of "I'm just standing here, I'm not doing anything wrong". It wasn't as bad as I have seen that tactic used, like Celtic against Barca in the group stages.

 


RED AND BLUE ARMY!

Bert's Boys Flag 23 Feb 14 9.20pm

Chamakh got 4/10 in the paper and I thought that was generous! He's lightweight, falls over, can't pass and made a suicide tackle for the penalty.

 

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 23 Feb 14 9.34pm

Quote Bert's Boys at 23 Feb 2014 9.20pm

Chamakh got 4/10 in the paper and I thought that was generous! He's lightweight, falls over, can't pass and made a suicide tackle for the penalty.

Wrong!

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 23 Feb 14 9.49pm

Quote Bert's Boys at 23 Feb 2014 9.20pm

Chamakh got 4/10 in the paper and I thought that was generous! He's lightweight, falls over, can't pass and made a suicide tackle for the penalty.


You got 1 out of 4. It was a clumsy tackle.

Edited by EverybodyDannsNow (23 Feb 2014 9.50pm)

 

FinchleyEagle Flag 23 Feb 14 10.46pm

Quote Dangermouse at 23 Feb 2014 9.34pm

Quote Bert's Boys at 23 Feb 2014 9.20pm

Chamakh got 4/10 in the paper and I thought that was generous! He's lightweight, falls over, can't pass and made a suicide tackle for the penalty.

Wrong!

Right !

 


You'll be forever in my family's memories and it was an honor and privilege to play and lead in the red and blue
Yours sincerely
Mile Jedinak

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 23 Feb 14 11.00pm

Quote EverybodyDannsNow at 23 Feb 2014 9.49pm

Quote Bert's Boys at 23 Feb 2014 9.20pm

Chamakh got 4/10 in the paper and I thought that was generous! He's lightweight, falls over, can't pass and made a suicide tackle for the penalty.


You got 1 out of 4. It was a clumsy tackle.

Edited by EverybodyDannsNow (23 Feb 2014 9.50pm)

Strikers challenge, Evra was looking for it really. An experienced midfielder or defender in that position usually won't make the mistake. But when you have a forward defending, its always a risk.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

sidman Flag London 24 Feb 14 8.30am

Clumsy, but was never a penalty as it was outside the box and if you look at Evra after his 100th turn he slows down and looks at the ref.

Once again Man Utd have to cheat.

[Link]

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Chamakh Penalty