You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Team for Swansea
November 16 2026 1.03pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Team for Swansea


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
WelshEagle Flag London 24 Feb 14 5.36pm

Been agonising over this for most of the day.

I think we need goals so Punch, Ince and Murray start. Midfield worries me. I'd like us to up our possession a little as I feel we are capable. Against Swansea we will need to crowd the midfield so I'd go for a trio of Jedi and Ward holding with Ledley further forward. Mariappa to right back.

Jules
Mariappa
Delaney
Dann
Parr
Jedi
Ward
Ledley
Ince
Puncheon
Murray

 

adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 24 Feb 14 5.51pm

Can see KG getting in there to kill the midfield with Jedi. We need revenge on ther Swans as they well and truely showed us how to play last time.

 

WelshEagle Flag London 24 Feb 14 5.54pm

Quote adrian b at 24 Feb 2014 5.51pm

Can see KG getting in there to kill the midfield with Jedi. We need revenge on ther Swans as they well and truely showed us how to play last time.


It may well be KG - wouldn't mind particularly but would favour Ward. I'm loathe to drop Chamakh but think we need to accommodate the others because of goal threat.

 

sprites Flag Auckland 24 Feb 14 6.27pm

Ledley was anonymous against united.

Speroni

Ward
Gabbidon
Delaney
Parr

Jedinak
Bannan

Punch
Chamakh
Ince

Murray

 

Keeley97 Flag 24 Feb 14 6.38pm

Speroni
Ward Dann Delaney Parr
Jedinak ledley
Ince chamakh bannan
murray

Let's be honest glenn's main chance of storing is from crosses so if you play him you have to play good crossers, which is why I've gone for bannan and ince the two best crossers at the club.I highly doubt Bannan will start though far more likely to be puncheon.

 

tonymikejoe Flag UK 24 Feb 14 7.02pm

What's great is that we actually have some options and can debate the starting XI.

Agreed, the Swans gave us a footballing lesson at Selhurst, but that was under the failing Holloway regime that was destined to finish rock bottom.

My XI:

Speroni

Ward Gabbidon Delaney Parr

Jedinak Ledley

Bolassie Ince Puncheon

Chaamakh

Can't bring myself to drop Gabbo, he's been huge, and I'm not going to drop our top scorer for Murray because he's been out 9 months and never scored in the top flight.

 

JeffBourne Flag 24 Feb 14 7.05pm

Quote Keeley97 at 24 Feb 2014 6.38pm

Speroni
Ward Dann Delaney Parr
Jedinak ledley
Ince chamakh bannan
murray

Let's be honest glenn's main chance of storing is from crosses so if you play him you have to play good crossers, which is why I've gone for bannan and ince the two best crossers at the club.I highly doubt Bannan will start though far more likely to be puncheon.

Good call

 


A new era of total football is on the way to Selhurst Park!!

pstrutt Flag Busselton, WA 24 Feb 14 7.54pm

Quote sprites at 24 Feb 2014 6.27pm

Ledley was anonymous against united.

Speroni

Ward
Gabbidon
Delaney
Parr

Jedinak
Bannan

Punch
Chamakh
Ince

Murray


Glad I'm not the only one who thought that. Mind you Bannan was fairly anonymous in his last game.

Edited by pstrutt (24 Feb 2014 7.56pm)

 


So I manage a Workshop which provides a safe learning environment for blokes struggling with PTSD and other mental health issues. Being a Palace fan isn't listed yet.

blind eagle Flag Covington.Tennessee 26 Feb 14 4.37pm

Speroni - Parr and Ward - Delaney and Gabbidon - Jedinak and Puncheon, - Ince and Bannan - Chamakh and Gayle. Subs. Hennessey,Moxey,Dann,Ledley,Mariappa,Jerome and Okeefe.

 

Part Time James Flag 26 Feb 14 4.45pm

Speroni

Ward
Gabbidon (although I expect Dann will get picked again)
Delaney
Parr

Jedinak
Ledley

Ince
Puncheon

Chamakh

Murray

Which I realise is virtually the lineup against Manchester United...


Edited by Part Time James (26 Feb 2014 4.46pm)

 




Mystery Man Flag Willingdon 26 Feb 14 4.49pm

Speroni
Ward Dann Delaney Parr
Jedinak
Puncheon Bolasie
Ince
Murray Chamakh


Hennesey
Gabbidon
Ledley
Williams
Gayle
Jerome

 


Kyle De Silva, Reise Allassani, Michael Chambers, Jerome Williams, Jake Gray, Gus Sow, Ryan Innis. The Kids are alright!

Twitter @petecmsmith1977

speroni2 Flag London 26 Feb 14 4.53pm

5 subs thought there was supposed to 7

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 26 Feb 14 5.04pm

Jules
Ward
Delaney
Dann
Parr
Jedi
Ledley
Ince
Puncheon
Chamakh
Jerome

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Jordan555x Flag Bromley 26 Feb 14 5.05pm

Speroni
Ward Dann Delaney Parr
Puncheon Ledley Jedinak Ince
Chamakh Murray

I think a 442 is needed to nullify their possession, they are a possession team obviously so we will need to break up play often.

 

ChamackForGood Flag Salisbury 26 Feb 14 9.36pm

Speroni
Ward Dann Delaney Parr
Puncheon Ledley Jedinak Bolasie
Ince
Chamack

This is how I'd like us to set up, although I feel Pulis will favour Ince on the wing and Murray up top with Chamack like at United. Hopefully Pulis' will give Murray a rest and let Ince have a more central role, simply because Swansea are a more beatable side than United and it could be more beneficial to play a more positive side, let someone like Ince with fresh legs grab us an early goal before subbing on Murray and slowing the game down.

 


Whatever I said, whatever I did, I didn't mean it, I just want Chamack for good.

Skinster Flag 27 Feb 14 1.24am

Murray needs to be resigned to the bench, he aint quick enough particularly when not fully match fit.

Speroni
Ward Delaney Gabbidon Parr

Ledley Jedinak

Bolasie Bannon Ince

Chamakh

Bannon is by far the most creative midfielder we have had this year and his set pieces are the best, Bolasie scares the f*** out of defences and makes sure the fullbacks dont push on, and Ince needs another game but looks dangerous in the box when with the ball.

 

sprites Flag Auckland 27 Feb 14 1.35am

Quote Skinster at 27 Feb 2014 1.24am

Murray needs to be resigned to the bench, he aint quick enough particularly when not fully match fit.

Speroni
Ward Delaney Gabbidon Parr

Ledley Jedinak

Bolasie Bannon Ince

Chamakh

Bannon is by far the most creative midfielder we have had this year and his set pieces are the best, Bolasie scares the f*** out of defences and makes sure the fullbacks dont push on, and Ince needs another game but looks dangerous in the box when with the ball.


Couldn't disagree more. What Murray needs right now is games. You don't get match fit by sitting on the bench.

And it's Bannan.

 

Skinster Flag 27 Feb 14 1.45am

Quote sprites at 27 Feb 2014 1.35am

Quote Skinster at 27 Feb 2014 1.24am

Murray needs to be resigned to the bench, he aint quick enough particularly when not fully match fit.

Speroni
Ward Delaney Gabbidon Parr

Ledley Jedinak

Bolasie Bannon Ince

Chamakh

Bannon is by far the most creative midfielder we have had this year and his set pieces are the best, Bolasie scares the f*** out of defences and makes sure the fullbacks dont push on, and Ince needs another game but looks dangerous in the box when with the ball.


Couldn't disagree more. What Murray needs right now is games. You don't get match fit by sitting on the bench.

And it's Bannan.


we dont have time to give someone a pre season, im assuming you dont see many games, but against United Murray was off the pace, we looked a much better side when we had Jerome and Bolasie on the pitch. Murray needs a few more games with u21s, he hasnt played since May and never in the Premiership , too many unknowns for this critical time of the season. stick with what got us to where we are now.
Not doubting his ability just his ability to hit the ground running!

 

sprites Flag Auckland 27 Feb 14 2.15am

Quote Skinster at 27 Feb 2014 1.45am

Quote sprites at 27 Feb 2014 1.35am

Quote Skinster at 27 Feb 2014 1.24am

Murray needs to be resigned to the bench, he aint quick enough particularly when not fully match fit.

Speroni
Ward Delaney Gabbidon Parr

Ledley Jedinak

Bolasie Bannon Ince

Chamakh

Bannon is by far the most creative midfielder we have had this year and his set pieces are the best, Bolasie scares the f*** out of defences and makes sure the fullbacks dont push on, and Ince needs another game but looks dangerous in the box when with the ball.


Couldn't disagree more. What Murray needs right now is games. You don't get match fit by sitting on the bench.

And it's Bannan.


we dont have time to give someone a pre season, im assuming you dont see many games, but against United Murray was off the pace, we looked a much better side when we had Jerome and Bolasie on the pitch. Murray needs a few more games with u21s, he hasnt played since May and never in the Premiership , too many unknowns for this critical time of the season. stick with what got us to where we are now.
Not doubting his ability just his ability to hit the ground running!


Bad assumption - i've seen every game this season. Most of them twice.

I don't actually think he looked that far off the pace at all. He might not do as much aimless running around as Jerome does....but then that's largely because aimless running around is all Jerome's got. The best strikers don't have to run around a lot as it's all about making the right runs and being in the right position. Murray's volleyed effort against united was class...that's all i needed to see.

I'm perfectly happy to agree to disagree, by the way So all is good.

 

TomThePalaceFanatic Flag 27 Feb 14 8.51am

Quote sprites at 27 Feb 2014 2.15am

Quote Skinster at 27 Feb 2014 1.45am

Quote sprites at 27 Feb 2014 1.35am

Quote Skinster at 27 Feb 2014 1.24am

Murray needs to be resigned to the bench, he aint quick enough particularly when not fully match fit.

Speroni
Ward Delaney Gabbidon Parr

Ledley Jedinak

Bolasie Bannon Ince

Chamakh

Bannon is by far the most creative midfielder we have had this year and his set pieces are the best, Bolasie scares the f*** out of defences and makes sure the fullbacks dont push on, and Ince needs another game but looks dangerous in the box when with the ball.


Couldn't disagree more. What Murray needs right now is games. You don't get match fit by sitting on the bench.

And it's Bannan.


we dont have time to give someone a pre season, im assuming you dont see many games, but against United Murray was off the pace, we looked a much better side when we had Jerome and Bolasie on the pitch. Murray needs a few more games with u21s, he hasnt played since May and never in the Premiership , too many unknowns for this critical time of the season. stick with what got us to where we are now.
Not doubting his ability just his ability to hit the ground running!


Bad assumption - i've seen every game this season. Most of them twice.

I don't actually think he looked that far off the pace at all. He might not do as much aimless running around as Jerome does....but then that's largely because aimless running around is all Jerome's got. The best strikers don't have to run around a lot as it's all about making the right runs and being in the right position. Murray's volleyed effort against united was class...that's all i needed to see.

I'm perfectly happy to agree to disagree, by the way So all is good.

Against United, someone to properly hassle the defenders like Jerome could have worked, we saw how shaky they were in the Champions League.


 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Team for Swansea