You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > acab...!
November 16 2026 12.53pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

acab...!


Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
Mapletree Flag Croydon 27 Feb 14 12.50pm

Quote Mapletree at 27 Feb 2014 12.47pm

The one thing I will say again is that those FEW idiots who throw stuff, fight up town, run on the pitch, smash up seats, interfere with stewards, light bangers or whatever, even that odd person with the knife etc etc, they don't exactly do the rest of us any favours do they!? Unfortunately unless these things stop, however minor some people may regard them, I don't think things are going to change much.

As for the HF, well I generally feel a bit sorry for them. They do a good job, but again a few idiots (members, non members, tag alongs, people in the same block, whatever you want to call them), keep letting them and the club down with their stupid behaviour.

-------------------------------------
Can't argue with that Johnny, people in glass houses. But I would also say that bung 25k people off the streets together anywhere and you will have a proportion who are d*cks. And in fact it seems to me that football supporters are generally reasonably self-regulating, they don't appear worse to me that any other group. So that brings us back to the question - why are they picked on?

The answer given here, with which I totally agree, is that is because they are an easy target that those in authority have been able to demonize. And if we do nothing about that it is likely to get worse not better until we are all sitting throughout every match, probably with seat belts and crash helmets on. Look at how long it's taking to get safe standing ffs. You can stand at a concert, you can stand in some theatres but you can't stand at football which is where you really want to. Just make sure tickets apply to specific sections and control access, job done. But of course, fans can't be trusted....

Edited by Mapletree (27 Feb 2014 12.47pm)

And by the way, have you ever been in a mosh pit. Ten times worse than the bad old days of footie.

 

EastEndPalace Flag WithHardNutsCosImAHardBastard 27 Feb 14 2.23pm

The way some people go on in these types of threads I almost like nobody is allowed to enjoy themselves. No beer, No banter, No standing and if you say you like to do all this the best response the bellends that we have on here can conjure up is. "f*** off and support Millwall" and please don't read my post looking for spelling mistakes or missing punctuation seeing as I think people who do that are snobs and expect everyone else to be as intellectual as them.

 

Johnny D Flag Beckenham 27 Feb 14 9.27pm

Quote Lyons550 at 27 Feb 2014 10.41am

Quote Johnny D at 25 Feb 2014 11.42pm

Or just don't act like a t*** in the first place and you'll never be arrested and never end up in the legal system to begin with!

Your subject title is hypocritical as well, isn't it? Talking about 'all being regarded as criminals' and then calling 'all coppers b******s'.

Just a bit sad that is.

based on your comments it appears that you didnt read the article in its entirety and instead made an assumption on what it contained. If you had then you certainly missed the points being made.

.............

Not wishing to drag this out much more, but yes I did read the article and no I haven't missed its points. There were clearly some valid examples in there of how genuine fans fall victim of police methods and how people are treated differently just because they are football fans. He's got evidence to support a view which is more than a lot of journalists manage!

My initial comments you've quoted above were basically a brief response to the pretty harsh, but perhaps casual, 'ACAB' title and the 'you're all criminals in the eyes of the law' summary he derived from the link (mine being that most police are alright and don't be a knob at Palace and you should be ok). I should have used the quote marks and highlighted perhaps. Then i have just given my opinion back across about the police at football in general since (in a nutshell that there's always a few hooligans/idiots and that's the cause of police being there in the first place, not like the ruggers where they're all best mates with each other shaking hands after!), so if the topic on the whole wasn't clear straight away, I'm sure it was after.

We've clearly got different opinions on it all, so like I said to the other guy about what you could realistically 'get done' for these days, I think I'm going have to just agree to disagree with him on some of this!

 

blanksight Flag Thornton heath 27 Feb 14 9.42pm

The point has been made enough times before, but pissed up lads in Croydon (or any other) town centre cause alot more havoc than Palace fans ever do, yet there's never more than a van of coppers sat outside Tiger Tiger and they never do anything until AFTER it's kicked off

When I was at school there were prolonged battles between large groups of lads with little or no police presence ever deemed neccessary.

Yet at Palace there has been:

a lad taken to court for throwing a flare at Police with no CCTV evidence and no witnesses except 2 coppers, despite there being over 20000 people in attendance

A lad arrested at a train station and mauled by a dog whilst being pinned to the ground, then denied medication for 9 hrs. The case was dropped because the CCTV was missing.

Police attempting to revoke the licence of a pub because "hooligans have marked it as their own" despite there being no one Piece of evidnece that football violence has happened in the pub or with anyone associated with it.

Police TSG holding the HF on Holmesdale road for 1HR before a game under the anti terror act and then not allowing them entry unless they submitted to a search and gave their name and details. Other Palace fans were allowed to make their way freely to the game. Nothing was found on any HF member. Police claimed (if I remember rightly) that they do not identify or target specific groups of fans.

As well as that there is lots of stories you hear on matchdays of the minor things they have done, and I'm sure many have seen their attempts to wind up fans and get a reaction. I witnessed an officer (who shall, for legal reasons remain nameless) on one particular occasion asking a Lad "why didn't I see you at Brighton?" "were you too much of a pussy to go there and fight?" and "guess you're just scared of them" in an attempt to get a rise.

I agree that cordens and other arrangements are sometimes neccessary, but i fail to see how any of the incidents above are justified by the risks posed.

 


I'd rather be a FREE MAN in my grave
than living as a PUPPET or a SLAVE

Breamy11 Flag 27 Feb 14 9.56pm

Can someone fill me in on how to say acab please? A.C.A.B OR EY-cab or a-cab

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 27 Feb 14 10.09pm

Quote EastEndPalace at 27 Feb 2014 2.23pm

The way some people go on in these types of threads I almost like nobody is allowed to enjoy themselves. No beer, No banter, No standing and if you say you like to do all this the best response the bellends that we have on here can conjure up is. "f*** off and support Millwall" and please don't read my post looking for spelling mistakes or missing punctuation seeing as I think people who do that are snobs and expect everyone else to be as intellectual as them.


Think you're on the wrong thread mate. This one is bemoaning the way fans get abused. Nobody knocking having fun unless you count ripping out seats as a fine way to support your team.

 

Johnny D Flag Beckenham 27 Feb 14 10.23pm

Quote Breamy11 at 27 Feb 2014 9.56pm

Can someone fill me in on how to say acab please? A.C.A.B OR EY-cab or a-cab


Not sure if you're serious there, but if so, maybe you should ask the families of those two poor girls who got murdered in Manchester when they were tricked into thinking they were responding to a burglar? Just saying, you know. 99.9% of them are regular people just trying to do a good job, with a few who shouldn't be there, just like 99.9% of Palace fans are decent people, with just a few idiots who we could all do without. You always get a few, but it is only ever just a few.

 

Stuart_Eagle Flag Kent 28 Feb 14 12.48pm

Quote Johnny D at 27 Feb 2014 10.23pm

Quote Breamy11 at 27 Feb 2014 9.56pm

Can someone fill me in on how to say acab please? A.C.A.B OR EY-cab or a-cab


Not sure if you're serious there, but if so, maybe you should ask the families of those two poor girls who got murdered in Manchester when they were tricked into thinking they were responding to a burglar? Just saying, you know. 99.9% of them are regular people just trying to do a good job, with a few who shouldn't be there, just like 99.9% of Palace fans are decent people, with just a few idiots who we could all do without. You always get a few, but it is only ever just a few.


I have to say I get the irony in your point. Fans saying don't judge us while stereotyping them back is very ironic.

There are serious issues that need to be dealt with at a high level regards how the police treat us fans. But we shouldn't tar them all with the same brush and vice versa.
I have had varying encounters with them but one positive was 2-3 police officers talking and joking with me at the emex bar exit after our 3-1 win on the 27th september 2011 .
Great night, Zaha, Ambrose, Murray......going off topic here

 


we're the Arthur, we're the Arthur, we're the Arthur over here!

Positive! Proud & Palace - W block, AW

soulboy Flag Lewisham 28 Feb 14 1.16pm

Quote Johnny D at 27 Feb 2014 10.23pm

Quote Breamy11 at 27 Feb 2014 9.56pm

Can someone fill me in on how to say acab please? A.C.A.B OR EY-cab or a-cab


Not sure if you're serious there, but if so, maybe you should ask the families of those two poor girls who got murdered in Manchester when they were tricked into thinking they were responding to a burglar? Just saying, you know. 99.9% of them are regular people just trying to do a good job, with a few who shouldn't be there, just like 99.9% of Palace fans are decent people, with just a few idiots who we could all do without. You always get a few, but it is only ever just a few.

JD, you're beginning to sound like the official police spokesperson on HOL!! Yes, there are some jokers on here who think it clever to use the ACAB acronym, however there are also a number of valid posts that provide informed and personal insight into police treatment of football fans, suggesting the police approach is at times heavy handed, disproportionate and yes, corrupt. These views alone seriously challenge your position which appears to be 'you have nothing to fear from the police at football matches because even if you are arrested it won't go anywhere, because they (police) need evidence'. However, the clear message from some of us is that it is often the police alone who produce the necessary evidence for the Crown Prosecution Service, by providing witness statements corroborating one another! This policy is in the usual course of events fine but at football matches where police (according to testimonies here) are arguably biased and disproportionate in their actions, the ramifications for the 'ordinary fan' can be devastating!!

 


"Deviance is a freedom enjoyed in a city of lightly engaged strangers"

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 28 Feb 14 1.50pm

Quote Mapletree at 27 Feb 2014 12.50pm

Quote Mapletree at 27 Feb 2014 12.47pm

The one thing I will say again is that those FEW idiots who throw stuff, fight up town, run on the pitch, smash up seats, interfere with stewards, light bangers or whatever, even that odd person with the knife etc etc, they don't exactly do the rest of us any favours do they!? Unfortunately unless these things stop, however minor some people may regard them, I don't think things are going to change much.

As for the HF, well I generally feel a bit sorry for them. They do a good job, but again a few idiots (members, non members, tag alongs, people in the same block, whatever you want to call them), keep letting them and the club down with their stupid behaviour.

-------------------------------------
Can't argue with that Johnny, people in glass houses. But I would also say that bung 25k people off the streets together anywhere and you will have a proportion who are d*cks. And in fact it seems to me that football supporters are generally reasonably self-regulating, they don't appear worse to me that any other group. So that brings us back to the question - why are they picked on?

The answer given here, with which I totally agree, is that is because they are an easy target that those in authority have been able to demonize. And if we do nothing about that it is likely to get worse not better until we are all sitting throughout every match, probably with seat belts and crash helmets on. Look at how long it's taking to get safe standing ffs. You can stand at a concert, you can stand in some theatres but you can't stand at football which is where you really want to. Just make sure tickets apply to specific sections and control access, job done. But of course, fans can't be trusted....

Edited by Mapletree (27 Feb 2014 12.47pm)


The same applies to the police surely?

Edited by EverybodyDannsNow (28 Feb 2014 1.50pm)

 

adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 28 Feb 14 3.36pm


A really good and open thread this. Anyone who has been stopped and breatherlysed for driving out of a pub car park for no other reason than where they have come from, can see the point being made here. You would hope that the boys in blue might use their training, experience and common sense in these circunstances, but more often than not their action is based on steriotyping drivers and pub goers. The same very much goes for football fans, as far as ol' bill is concerned.

 

Johnny D Flag Beckenham 28 Feb 14 7.06pm

Quote soulboy at 28 Feb 2014 1.16pm

Quote Johnny D at 27 Feb 2014 10.23pm

Quote Breamy11 at 27 Feb 2014 9.56pm

Can someone fill me in on how to say acab please? A.C.A.B OR EY-cab or a-cab


Not sure if you're serious there, but if so, maybe you should ask the families of those two poor girls who got murdered in Manchester when they were tricked into thinking they were responding to a burglar? Just saying, you know. 99.9% of them are regular people just trying to do a good job, with a few who shouldn't be there, just like 99.9% of Palace fans are decent people, with just a few idiots who we could all do without. You always get a few, but it is only ever just a few.

JD, you're beginning to sound like the official police spokesperson on HOL!! Yes, there are some jokers on here who think it clever to use the ACAB acronym, however there are also a number of valid posts that provide informed and personal insight into police treatment of football fans, suggesting the police approach is at times heavy handed, disproportionate and yes, corrupt. These views alone seriously challenge your position which appears to be 'you have nothing to fear from the police at football matches because even if you are arrested it won't go anywhere, because they (police) need evidence'. However, the clear message from some of us is that it is often the police alone who produce the necessary evidence for the Crown Prosecution Service, by providing witness statements corroborating one another! This policy is in the usual course of events fine but at football matches where police (according to testimonies here) are arguably biased and disproportionate in their actions, the ramifications for the 'ordinary fan' can be devastating!!

A spokesperson wouldn't give any form of opinion at all! But that's all I'm doing here. That last post was only in response to the one before. Only a joke he may feel, or perhaps he is actually ignorant or just naive enough to actually believe that. But like that other guy said, it's kind of ironic to use it when he's very likely to be one of the ones who feels 'football fans are treated harshly and all labelled as the same troublemakers by the police'.

Knowing a few Old Bill, I think the majority would much rather be doing what they signed up for, directly helping people by catching the bad guys (probably in a fast car!), those ones burgling your houses and mugging your grans - Not standing outside a football ground in the cold and rain on a Saturday afternoon when it's supposed to be their day off! But like I said before, football definitely isn't rugby or cricket where all the fans sit together and generally get along is it, so they have a need to be there.

Anyway, my responses to you, 'mapletree' and 'lyons550' yesterday were more relevant to what we've been going on about, if you haven't seen them. From the last thing you've said today, i can only add that I don't think that being at football would be regarded by an officer as a differentiating factor (in terms of when you've mentioned writing their statements about what happened and how the person behaved etc). By that I mean, if a person acted the very same way outside a nightclub or a shop, they'd be writing almost exactly the same thing about it all.

Now whether that person eventually pleaded/got found guilty and then got treated differently by the courts, just because it happened to be at a football match or was 'football related', perhaps they would. Is that fair? Perhaps not. Perhaps it depends in the factors, such as a pre-organised football fight could be seen as worse than a completely sporadic one in a Town Centre, even if they ended up as the same type of fight (because of the planning involved and prior intent to be violent in public). Just a random example of how they could see things differently to another, I'm not saying I necessarily agree it should matter.

You seem knowledgable, but I think a lot of people forget that the police are separate to the justice system. They don't make the rules and of course aren't the ones who decide who's guilty or what punishment they get. I'm sure they, just like most law abiding citizens and decent people, would rather see the real criminals getting much longer sentences than what they do. Like this week, the guy who was already a known criminal out on a 'suspended sentence' who punched and killed that completely innocent guy and only got 4 1/2 years - in the words of the victims' family, "An absolutely joke!" I did hear it's being looked into for a review of the sentence though.

So I was saying yesterday that we're going around in circles a bit here. It's a huge subject and I understand the points you've made and do sympathise with those who genuinely have been treated unfairly before. I just have a different opinion on a lot of it than you, mainly that I blame those who cause trouble at football in the first place for a lot of the consequences for others that follow. It's a Friday night and it may not sound like it the way I ramble on, but again I'm just going to have to suggest agreeing to disagree on a lot of this now. If a haven't bored to death, feel free to keep it going or have the last word though mate!......

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 28 Feb 14 7.24pm

Quote Johnny D at 28 Feb 2014 7.06pm

Quote soulboy at 28 Feb 2014 1.16pm

Quote Johnny D at 27 Feb 2014 10.23pm

Quote Breamy11 at 27 Feb 2014 9.56pm

Can someone fill me in on how to say acab please? A.C.A.B OR EY-cab or a-cab


Not sure if you're serious there, but if so, maybe you should ask the families of those two poor girls who got murdered in Manchester when they were tricked into thinking they were responding to a burglar? Just saying, you know. 99.9% of them are regular people just trying to do a good job, with a few who shouldn't be there, just like 99.9% of Palace fans are decent people, with just a few idiots who we could all do without. You always get a few, but it is only ever just a few.

JD, you're beginning to sound like the official police spokesperson on HOL!! Yes, there are some jokers on here who think it clever to use the ACAB acronym, however there are also a number of valid posts that provide informed and personal insight into police treatment of football fans, suggesting the police approach is at times heavy handed, disproportionate and yes, corrupt. These views alone seriously challenge your position which appears to be 'you have nothing to fear from the police at football matches because even if you are arrested it won't go anywhere, because they (police) need evidence'. However, the clear message from some of us is that it is often the police alone who produce the necessary evidence for the Crown Prosecution Service, by providing witness statements corroborating one another! This policy is in the usual course of events fine but at football matches where police (according to testimonies here) are arguably biased and disproportionate in their actions, the ramifications for the 'ordinary fan' can be devastating!!

A spokesperson wouldn't give any form of opinion at all! But that's all I'm doing here. That last post was only in response to the one before. Only a joke he may feel, or perhaps he is actually ignorant or just naive enough to actually believe that. But like that other guy said, it's kind of ironic to use it when he's very likely to be one of the ones who feels 'football fans are treated harshly and all labelled as the same troublemakers by the police'.

Knowing a few Old Bill, I think the majority would much rather be doing what they signed up for, directly helping people by catching the bad guys (probably in a fast car!), those ones burgling your houses and mugging your grans - Not standing outside a football ground in the cold and rain on a Saturday afternoon when it's supposed to be their day off! But like I said before, football definitely isn't rugby or cricket where all the fans sit together and generally get along is it, so they have a need to be there.

Anyway, my responses to you, 'mapletree' and 'lyons550' yesterday were more relevant to what we've been going on about, if you haven't seen them. From the last thing you've said today, i can only add that I don't think that being at football would be regarded by an officer as a differentiating factor (in terms of when you've mentioned writing their statements about what happened and how the person behaved etc). By that I mean, if a person acted the very same way outside a nightclub or a shop, they'd be writing almost exactly the same thing about it all.

Now whether that person eventually pleaded/got found guilty and then got treated differently by the courts, just because it happened to be at a football match or was 'football related', perhaps they would. Is that fair? Perhaps not. Perhaps it depends in the factors, such as a pre-organised football fight could be seen as worse than a completely sporadic one in a Town Centre, even if they ended up as the same type of fight (because of the planning involved and prior intent to be violent in public). Just a random example of how they could see things differently to another, I'm not saying I necessarily agree it should matter.

You seem knowledgable, but I think a lot of people forget that the police are separate to the justice system. They don't make the rules and of course aren't the ones who decide who's guilty or what punishment they get. I'm sure they, just like most law abiding citizens and decent people, would rather see the real criminals getting much longer sentences than what they do. Like this week, the guy who was already a known criminal out on a 'suspended sentence' who punched and killed that completely innocent guy and only got 4 1/2 years - in the words of the victims' family, "An absolutely joke!" I did hear it's being looked into for a review of the sentence though.

So I was saying yesterday that we're going around in circles a bit here. It's a huge subject and I understand the points you've made and do sympathise with those who genuinely have been treated unfairly before. I just have a different opinion on a lot of it than you, mainly that I blame those who cause trouble at football in the first place for a lot of the consequences for others that follow. It's a Friday night and it may not sound like it the way I ramble on, but again I'm just going to have to suggest agreeing to disagree on a lot of this now. If a haven't bored to death, feel free to keep it going or have the last word though mate!......


I didn't actually understand Breany's point, it didn't seem nasty to me but I guess it was a whoosh as far as I am concerned

Yes, going round in circles. I have worked for two Constabularies. Generally the top brass were sharp as hell, the rest less so.

I think the concern of many of us is that, in plenty of circumstances, the Police also act as judge and jury. Sometimes it's best to take a Police caution than take a risk on going to Magistrates Court and let's face it many Magistrates aren't that great either. The Police certainly do back each other up so that justice is not always served. Maybe not in Crown Court but who ends up there?

What really crawls up my nose and dies is the tin hitlers, as it appears the two that are involved with the HF and Portmanor issues must be. All I have seen suggests there is absolutely no reason for the pressure being put on the Portmanor except it's the HF pub, largely the HF has done little wrong but it's a worry because it's hard to control. So these guardians of our souls take it upon themselves to bear down unreasonably on a group.

We should all support that group, they are important to us. And if there are one or two idiots surely we can forgive them that as long as they aren't too wild.

 

kevpofcpfc Flag 28 Feb 14 7.40pm

My girlfrinds a Copper....-.-'

But she insists she's strawberry blonde...-.-'

Ginger innit

 

PsychoPaul Flag 01 Mar 14 1.59am

Quote kevpofcpfc at 28 Feb 2014 7.40pm

My girlfrinds a Copper....-.-'

But she insists she's strawberry blonde...-.-'

Ginger innit


No offence to everyone else but this is the best response to my thread :-)

 

PsychoPaul Flag 05 Mar 14 7.46pm

[Link]


A coach full of troublemakers, including disabled and kids.

According to some of the previous posters they must have deserved it and guilty of something else the police would have left them alone.

 

PsychoPaul Flag 05 Mar 14 7.47pm

I guess I have to be careful by assuming a Daily Mail story is true thou eh!

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 05 Mar 14 8.33pm

Quote PsychoPaul at 05 Mar 2014 7.47pm

I guess I have to be careful by assuming a Daily Mail story is true thou eh!


Hey PsychoPaul, why aren't you on the BBC3 thread showing your support to Cartoon Head?

 

turbohorsebox Flag Coulsdon 06 Mar 14 1.17pm

Quote adrian b at 28 Feb 2014 3.36pm


A really good and open thread this. Anyone who has been stopped and breatherlysed for driving out of a pub car park for no other reason than where they have come from, can see the point being made here. You would hope that the boys in blue might use their training, experience and common sense in these circunstances, but more often than not their action is based on steriotyping drivers and pub goers. The same very much goes for football fans, as far as ol' bill is concerned.

A very good analogy. If you haven't been drinking theres nothing to worry about and you're on your way in a couple of minutes. If you have you deserve a ban.

And yes, I like to drink way too much, but I know not to drive afterwards. Same with knowing how to behave at football.

 


All good. Nothing bad.

PsychoPaul Flag 06 Mar 14 10.37pm

Quote Mapletree at 05 Mar 2014 8.33pm

Quote PsychoPaul at 05 Mar 2014 7.47pm

I guess I have to be careful by assuming a Daily Mail story is true thou eh!


Hey PsychoPaul, why aren't you on the BBC3 thread showing your support to Cartoon Head?


Had to google that! I don't watch much telly, looks good thou. The psycho bit is due to psychobilly music and my psycho tendencies ;-)

 

Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > acab...!