You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Puncheon
November 16 2026 12.25pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Puncheon


Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 12 Mar 14 11.32pm

But it was a stupid mistake combined with a useless performance. U expect more from a player up against his old club: maybe scoring the winner not serve them on a plate.

 

banstead Flag sydney 13 Mar 14 5.19am

puncheon got to go i dont know why we paid 175m for a sulker he seems to have a brain problem and no personality he will get us relagated with games like tottenham and southhamton mistakes

 

dannyh Flag wherever I lay my hat....... 13 Mar 14 7.49am

Talented lad no doubt, but goes missing to often, and for long periods. We simply can not afford passengers if we are to stay up, and for me Ince is rapidly falling into that category as well.

Bolaise and Bannan should start out wide, and will someone please explain how KG is any where near the first team on current form.

 


"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"

dannyh Flag wherever I lay my hat....... 13 Mar 14 7.51am

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 12 Mar 2014 9.41pm

Footballer made loads of mistakes and goes missing when we need him.

Must be hung drawn and quartered.

Edited for accuracy


 


"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"

silvertop Flag Portishead 13 Mar 14 8.53am

NVG against the top half teams. Invaluable aginst the bottom feeders. In other words, his level is our level. I am sorry if that makes uncomfortable reading.

Btw, I also prefer Bannan.

 

paperhat Flag croydon 13 Mar 14 8.56am

Quote silvertop at 13 Mar 2014 8.53am

NVG against the top half teams. Invaluable aginst the bottom feeders. In other words, his level is our level. I am sorry if that makes uncomfortable reading.

Btw, I also prefer Bannan.


nearly.

He's championship and happy to be that level, whilst we are (just) in the prem and striving to stay there. BIg Big difference

 


Clinton is Clinton. I have known him for a long time, I know his mother... Simon Jordan


victor43 Flag St. Albans 13 Mar 14 9.24am

He didn't play well Saturday but I'm pretty sure he has won us on his own more points than any other player this season. 1 vs Norwich, 3 vs Hull, and 3 vs Stoke. 7 points from one player is pretty good going. I agree sometimes he does slow the play down a bit too much, but he has that quality in front of goal and on the ball that a lot of our players are lacking. But I see no problem with rotating a bit, perhaps putting Bannan in behind Murray on Saturday, but I heard when Bannan played under Pulis this season he was pretty poor in that position...

 


Blog: Andy Johnson's Magic Hat [Link]

Twitter:

peterg Flag Anerley 13 Mar 14 10.43am

Quote merganser at 09 Mar 2014 12.05am

Unfair to blame puncheon for soton goal. He was entitled to expect better cover behind him. Where was the rest of the defence?

Wouldn't blame Jules either. He was a fractional inch away from making what would have been the best tackle ever made at selhurst park

IMO, Jules did well to make the challenge without getting himself sent off.

Disagree entirely with fowler 's motd comment.

But what does TP think? Will he use the incident as an excuse to replace speroni with Hennessy?

The rest of the defence was pushing up, in line with TP's decision to be more attacking in the first half. Ironic given that his tactic was to be ultra-defensive in the first half of the two previous matches.

 


The right place at the right time

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 13 Mar 14 1.45pm

I can forgive him that 'header', on the basis that there are a few games where he effectively earned the 3 points. He's a frustrating player, sometimes he just pops up and wins a game. Othertimes he scuffs a penalty and provides the otherside with an assist.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 13 Mar 14 1.56pm

Quote paperhat at 13 Mar 2014 8.56am

Quote silvertop at 13 Mar 2014 8.53am

NVG against the top half teams. Invaluable aginst the bottom feeders. In other words, his level is our level. I am sorry if that makes uncomfortable reading.

Btw, I also prefer Bannan.


nearly.

He's championship and happy to be that level, whilst we are (just) in the prem and striving to stay there. BIg Big difference


He's played 4 out of the last 5 seasons in the Premiership. Not sure how that makes him a championship player.

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 13 Mar 14 1.58pm

Quote Gallery3 at 10 Mar 2014 12.19pm

Quote south coast eagle at 09 Mar 2014 5.45am

What are these good games Puncheon has had ????

How he get s a start most weeks is beyond me, as much as i think Bannon is better in CM he is definitely better than Puncheon out wide.


I agree. If we go down by one point it is entirely due to that game. He is not my kind of player at all.

What a ridiculous accusation. Individual mistakes from all over the squad have cost us numerous points this season, to isolate one and label that as solely responsible is just ridiculous. Scapegoating at it's finest.

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 13 Mar 14 1.59pm

I'd like to see his goal/assist stats alongside the much loved Bannan and Bolasie. Would certainly surprise a few people.

 

paperhat Flag croydon 13 Mar 14 2.29pm

Quote EverybodyDannsNow at 13 Mar 2014 1.56pm

Quote paperhat at 13 Mar 2014 8.56am

Quote silvertop at 13 Mar 2014 8.53am

NVG against the top half teams. Invaluable aginst the bottom feeders. In other words, his level is our level. I am sorry if that makes uncomfortable reading.

Btw, I also prefer Bannan.


nearly.

He's championship and happy to be that level, whilst we are (just) in the prem and striving to stay there. BIg Big difference


He's played 4 out of the last 5 seasons in the Premiership. Not sure how that makes him a championship player.

his quality of play, decision making and overall desire shown on the pitch seem to show him as a championship player, one albeit emlpoyed by a premiership club.

 


Clinton is Clinton. I have known him for a long time, I know his mother... Simon Jordan


EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 13 Mar 14 2.42pm

Quote paperhat at 13 Mar 2014 2.29pm

Quote EverybodyDannsNow at 13 Mar 2014 1.56pm

Quote paperhat at 13 Mar 2014 8.56am

Quote silvertop at 13 Mar 2014 8.53am

NVG against the top half teams. Invaluable aginst the bottom feeders. In other words, his level is our level. I am sorry if that makes uncomfortable reading.

Btw, I also prefer Bannan.


nearly.

He's championship and happy to be that level, whilst we are (just) in the prem and striving to stay there. BIg Big difference


He's played 4 out of the last 5 seasons in the Premiership. Not sure how that makes him a championship player.

his quality of play, decision making and overall desire shown on the pitch seem to show him as a championship player, one albeit emlpoyed by a premiership club.


Well 5 different managers clearly disagree with you.

 

Mstrobez Flag 13 Mar 14 4.32pm

I've never understood the constant bitching and hate ensued upon Puncheon from the day he arrived. He's one of our more quality players no doubt whatsoever. Bolasie can run and gives his all but has no end product anywhere and sometimes I feel is just running like a headless chicken. Jerome Thomas - well just no. Bannan is quality but will not play under TP so may as well just get over it.

I think other than potentially Ince he is our best wide player - he's no Lionel Messi but this whole assumption that he "doesn't give a s***" is frustrating, you ever spoke to him? He seemed rather gutted after that penalty miss at Spurs and am sure he does care about how he plays, he's not a Berbatov player who can just walk into any team and not give a monkeys and still produce moments of magic so why would he not give a s***?

Big conspiracy if you ask me - I've always said he is one of the more quality players we have and has scored some big goals (well taken at that) that could prove huge at the end of season.

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

A89M Flag Streatham 13 Mar 14 4.54pm

Quote Mstrobez at 13 Mar 2014 4.32pm

I've never understood the constant bitching and hate ensued upon Puncheon from the day he arrived. He's one of our more quality players no doubt whatsoever. Bolasie can run and gives his all but has no end product anywhere and sometimes I feel is just running like a headless chicken. Jerome Thomas - well just no. Bannan is quality but will not play under TP so may as well just get over it.

I think other than potentially Ince he is our best wide player - he's no Lionel Messi but this whole assumption that he "doesn't give a s***" is frustrating, you ever spoke to him? He seemed rather gutted after that penalty miss at Spurs and am sure he does care about how he plays, he's not a Berbatov player who can just walk into any team and not give a monkeys and still produce moments of magic so why would he not give a s***?

Big conspiracy if you ask me - I've always said he is one of the more quality players we have and has scored some big goals (well taken at that) that could prove huge at the end of season.

I agree! He's the only player in the squad that looks like he can create something out of nothing.

He clearly does care, hell.. he started crying after the Stoke game. What more do you want :P


Edited by A89M (13 Mar 2014 4.55pm)

 

paperhat Flag croydon 13 Mar 14 5.04pm

Quote A89M at 13 Mar 2014 4.54pm

Quote Mstrobez at 13 Mar 2014 4.32pm

I've never understood the constant bitching and hate ensued upon Puncheon from the day he arrived. He's one of our more quality players no doubt whatsoever. Bolasie can run and gives his all but has no end product anywhere and sometimes I feel is just running like a headless chicken. Jerome Thomas - well just no. Bannan is quality but will not play under TP so may as well just get over it.

I think other than potentially Ince he is our best wide player - he's no Lionel Messi but this whole assumption that he "doesn't give a s***" is frustrating, you ever spoke to him? He seemed rather gutted after that penalty miss at Spurs and am sure he does care about how he plays, he's not a Berbatov player who can just walk into any team and not give a monkeys and still produce moments of magic so why would he not give a s***?

Big conspiracy if you ask me - I've always said he is one of the more quality players we have and has scored some big goals (well taken at that) that could prove huge at the end of season.

I agree! He's the only player in the squad that looks like he can create something out of nothing.

He clearly does care, hell.. he started crying after the Stoke game. What more do you want :P


Edited by A89M (13 Mar 2014 4.55pm)


blood , possibly an amputation?

 


Clinton is Clinton. I have known him for a long time, I know his mother... Simon Jordan


EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 13 Mar 14 5.18pm

Quote paperhat at 13 Mar 2014 5.04pm

Quote A89M at 13 Mar 2014 4.54pm

Quote Mstrobez at 13 Mar 2014 4.32pm

I've never understood the constant bitching and hate ensued upon Puncheon from the day he arrived. He's one of our more quality players no doubt whatsoever. Bolasie can run and gives his all but has no end product anywhere and sometimes I feel is just running like a headless chicken. Jerome Thomas - well just no. Bannan is quality but will not play under TP so may as well just get over it.

I think other than potentially Ince he is our best wide player - he's no Lionel Messi but this whole assumption that he "doesn't give a s***" is frustrating, you ever spoke to him? He seemed rather gutted after that penalty miss at Spurs and am sure he does care about how he plays, he's not a Berbatov player who can just walk into any team and not give a monkeys and still produce moments of magic so why would he not give a s***?

Big conspiracy if you ask me - I've always said he is one of the more quality players we have and has scored some big goals (well taken at that) that could prove huge at the end of season.

I agree! He's the only player in the squad that looks like he can create something out of nothing.

He clearly does care, hell.. he started crying after the Stoke game. What more do you want :P


Edited by A89M (13 Mar 2014 4.55pm)


blood , possibly an amputation?


Some one here would still ask for more!

Does Bolasie have any goals or assists this season? Genuine question.

 

Master Coin Flag 13 Mar 14 5.52pm

Player - Games - Goals - Assists
Jason Puncheon - 22(3) - 3 - 1
Yannick Bolasie - 13(6) - 0 - 1
Barry Bannan - 13(1) - 1 - 1

None are exactly setting the house afire on the stat front (which you'd expect given how goal shy we've been all season) but Punch is comfortably the best.

And before anybody plays the "he's started more games than anybody else" card, his average goals per game is better than both the other two by a fair distance as well.

Edited by Master Coin (13 Mar 2014 5.52pm)

 

bodge Flag 13 Mar 14 8.43pm

I do not know about the stats but my eyes tell me he gets caught in possession too much and is too inconsistent i would have JW in my team ahead of him. No doubt he is a good player but i would have preferred JW to get games in the premier not get loaned out.

 

Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Puncheon