You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Is Pulis interested in good football?
November 16 2026 12.53pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Is Pulis interested in good football?


Page 3 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
ragatony Flag orpington 15 Mar 14 8.13pm

the sash
To be honest if this is what it takes to be a botton half premier League team then I seriously don't want it
-------------------------------------------------------
And to be honest what's the point? Money and.........?

 

The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 15 Mar 14 8.17pm

Quote ragatony at 15 Mar 2014 8.13pm

the sash
To be honest if this is what it takes to be a botton half premier League team then I seriously don't want it
-------------------------------------------------------
And to be honest what's the point? Money and.........?


Money is about it - it hopefully safeguards the club if used wisely..no other reason

 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

big_palace_fan Flag 15 Mar 14 8.27pm

Are we getting slightly picky?

One of the best opporunities to have consecutive premier league season in the clubs history and we're worrying about short term playing style

Its not pretty, we all know that

But can we not give up that want for 9 games for another season in the PL?

I sounds slightly defeatist but were only Crystal Palace, Prmeier League survival would never we easy, and here, we can't have our cake and eat it.

Long term, i do really see the need for Bannan Williams etc to be integrated though but lets cross that bridge when it comes

 

RainhamEagle Flag Bermondsey 15 Mar 14 8.31pm

I wish I still had enough interest to care about the football being played. I'm not gunna lie, my interest in this season died months ago. It sounds strange, but it doesn't even feel like a Palace team this year, despite having so many players from last year still playing.

I debated with a lot of people on here when Pulis was appointed and I did indeed say that the style of football wasn't an issue for me, my concerns were more about progressing beyond relegation candidates and the neglect of our youth players, who lets be honest, excite us when they break through, even if it is because of their connection to the club.

I think the people that expect us to sign more technically gifted players if we survive need to wake up, Pulis has never and will never change his ways, he will always want big men accompanied by direct wingers and a handy set-piece taker, it's his way and it has worked for him until now atleast. He kept Stoke up numerous times but never even showed intentions in progressing the style of football or players.

Sadly, Pulis is our best chance of survival right now and probably longer term, if you want Premier League football regardless then that's great. However, if you want excitement, rollercoaster seasons, attacking football and exciting youth graduates then prepare yourselves for a loss of love for the game/Palace.

Stoke fans became completely disillusioned with the game and that's why they wanted a change, despite the rest of the footballing world thinking they were ungrateful and mad. They still have the utmost respect for him but he was killing their interest in Stoke, they were bored and needed something fresh, even if it meant a relegation battle, aslong as they tried to take forward steps.

At the end of the day it all comes down to personal preference.

 

The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 15 Mar 14 8.32pm

Quote big_palace_fan at 15 Mar 2014 8.27pm

Are we getting slightly picky?

One of the best opporunities to have consecutive premier league season in the clubs history and we're worrying about short term playing style

Its not pretty, we all know that

But can we not give up that want for 9 games for another season in the PL?

I sounds slightly defeatist but were only Crystal Palace, Prmeier League survival would never we easy, and here, we can't have our cake and eat it.

Long term, i do really see the need for Bannan Williams etc to be integrated though but lets cross that bridge when it comes

Its not about the style as such for me - I don't believe this style is the magic bullet that will help us stay up

 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

Petereagle Flag Brockley 15 Mar 14 8.34pm

Quote big_palace_fan at 15 Mar 2014 8.27pm

Are we getting slightly picky?

One of the best opporunities to have consecutive premier league season in the clubs history and we're worrying about short term playing style

Its not pretty, we all know that

But can we not give up that want for 9 games for another season in the PL?

I sounds slightly defeatist but were only Crystal Palace, Prmeier League survival would never we easy, and here, we can't have our cake and eat it.

Long term, i do really see the need for Bannan Williams etc to be integrated though but lets cross that bridge when it comes

A really good post, excellent common sense. We are also realising how much we miss Chamakh. When we see him back and linking up play, we might even see a tad more real football!

 

big_palace_fan Flag 15 Mar 14 8.36pm

Quote The Sash at 15 Mar 2014 8.32pm

Quote big_palace_fan at 15 Mar 2014 8.27pm

Are we getting slightly picky?

One of the best opporunities to have consecutive premier league season in the clubs history and we're worrying about short term playing style

Its not pretty, we all know that

But can we not give up that want for 9 games for another season in the PL?

I sounds slightly defeatist but were only Crystal Palace, Prmeier League survival would never we easy, and here, we can't have our cake and eat it.

Long term, i do really see the need for Bannan Williams etc to be integrated though but lets cross that bridge when it comes

Its not about the style as such for me - I don't believe this style is the magic bullet that will help us stay up

Do you want me to regurgitate the stats we've all heard a million times over about points under open playing Holloway and tight, defensive Pulis?

If you were offered at the start of the season that after 29 games we would be 6 points off the top half we all know what your answer wouldve been

 

The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 15 Mar 14 8.46pm

Quote big_palace_fan at 15 Mar 2014 8.36pm

Quote The Sash at 15 Mar 2014 8.32pm

Quote big_palace_fan at 15 Mar 2014 8.27pm

Are we getting slightly picky?

One of the best opporunities to have consecutive premier league season in the clubs history and we're worrying about short term playing style

Its not pretty, we all know that

But can we not give up that want for 9 games for another season in the PL?

I sounds slightly defeatist but were only Crystal Palace, Prmeier League survival would never we easy, and here, we can't have our cake and eat it.

Long term, i do really see the need for Bannan Williams etc to be integrated though but lets cross that bridge when it comes

Its not about the style as such for me - I don't believe this style is the magic bullet that will help us stay up

Do you want me to regurgitate the stats we've all heard a million times over about points under open playing Holloway and tight, defensive Pulis?

If you were offered at the start of the season that after 29 games we would be 6 points off the top half we all know what your answer wouldve been


Nope we all know that and but for Holloway we would be healthier BUT everyone keeps banging on about Norwich have such and such, Sunderland have such and such and most seem to have us a nailed on 3 points at Fulham..this casual reliance blindly refuses to see we play for the vast majority of games on our own 18 yard line and allow opportunity after opportunity to whoever we play, whether homr or away - Sunderland, a poor side still managed to have chances today which in reality should have gone in whilst we offered nothing going forward

To my eyes our negativity for virtually 90 minutes will not be enough - we are playing not to lose, others are playing to win

A draw is all well and good but if like today WBA and Fulham both pick up 3 points, we then have to find 3 draws to match that result, whilst they will have other oppos for 3 points whilst we go out to defend and then see what happens

We have limitations of course and man for man we are poor in comparison but to go down like this is painful amd if we do how many on here will change their tune and wonder 'what if' we had gone for it more at Sunderland, Cardiff or Fulham ??????

 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

big_palace_fan Flag 15 Mar 14 8.50pm

Quote The Sash at 15 Mar 2014 8.46pm

Quote big_palace_fan at 15 Mar 2014 8.36pm

Quote The Sash at 15 Mar 2014 8.32pm

Quote big_palace_fan at 15 Mar 2014 8.27pm

Are we getting slightly picky?

One of the best opporunities to have consecutive premier league season in the clubs history and we're worrying about short term playing style

Its not pretty, we all know that

But can we not give up that want for 9 games for another season in the PL?

I sounds slightly defeatist but were only Crystal Palace, Prmeier League survival would never we easy, and here, we can't have our cake and eat it.

Long term, i do really see the need for Bannan Williams etc to be integrated though but lets cross that bridge when it comes

Its not about the style as such for me - I don't believe this style is the magic bullet that will help us stay up

Do you want me to regurgitate the stats we've all heard a million times over about points under open playing Holloway and tight, defensive Pulis?

If you were offered at the start of the season that after 29 games we would be 6 points off the top half we all know what your answer wouldve been


Nope we all know that and but for Holloway we would be healthier BUT everyone keeps banging on about Norwich have such and such, Sunderland have such and such and most seem to have us a nailed on 3 points at Fulham..this casual reliance blindly refuses to see we play for the vast majority of games on our own 18 yard line and allow opportunity after opportunity to whoever we play, whether homr or away - Sunderland, a poor side still managed to have chances today which in reality should have gone in whilst we offered nothing going forward

To my eyes our negativity for virtually 90 minutes will not be enough - we are playing not to lose, others are playing to win

A draw is all well and good but if like today WBA and Fulham both pick up 3 points, we then have to find 3 draws to match that result, whilst they will have other oppos for 3 points whilst we go out to defend and then see what happens

We have limitations of course and man for man we are poor in comparison but to go down like this is painful amd if we do how many on here will change their tune and wonder 'what if' we had gone for it more at Sunderland, Cardiff or Fulham ??????

Fair point, yet historical evidence points to the conclusion that the teams that survive relegation are those that concede the fewest, not score the most.

See this article here: [Link]

 

premier fan Flag BR4 15 Mar 14 8.53pm

I think if we stay up TP will have a massive clear out of players. We're just not good enough. If we stay up it will be because of all the farcical managerial merry go rounds going on that we have been able to take advantage of.

 

billtheglazier Flag twickenham 15 Mar 14 8.58pm

I posted this 3 months ago and still stand by it......Pulis is doing his stuff and IMO it aint pretty and is what many of us anticipated when he was appointed.
At half time I observed Barry B and Jonny W passing the ball to each other going through the motions with Dwight Gayle standing there looking somewhat dejected...It does sadden me cos I feel these are probably out 3 most creative and exciting players other than yannick,who due to their physical stature probably dont have much of a future at Selhurst.I sincerely hope I'm wrong but i ask myself do I really want to watch this week in week out just to stay in the premiership? Last season was some of the most attractive and enjoyable stuff we've seen at Selhurst for years.Yes its nice to see us out of the bottom three,albeit temporarily but im not sure this is bearable indefinitely.

 


[Link]
Following The Palace since 1956,
Rocking the Blues since 68.!!

Andy_G Flag Wimbledon 15 Mar 14 9.08pm

Interesting reading, particularly about whether it's worth this terrible style just to stay in the league. I'll except it this season though currently I don't see how we can win a game but not if this time next year we are still playing the same boring football.

 


The ups and downs of Palace have left me older than my years

Dman Palace Flag Brixton 15 Mar 14 9.10pm

.

Edited by Dman Palace (15 Mar 2014 9.12pm)

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 15 Mar 14 9.23pm

Came away from games against West Ham, Stoke and Hull telling friends we were rubbish and the game lacked any quality but at least we scraped a win. Similar the game against West Brom.

Now we're playing even more negatively.

Irrespective of what division we're in it's s*** to watch and sincerely hope Pulis is not around next season.

 

Palace15eagle Flag London 15 Mar 14 9.45pm

Stop moaning and get behind the team and management for this run-in because they need us!

 


Your HOL best newcomer of the year 2013.

My twitter account: [Link]

neverforgivejoeroyle Flag eastbourne 15 Mar 14 9.47pm

Unfortunately i don't get the chance to go to many games but the ones I have seen at Selhurst have been poor in quality, if not entertainment. We all knew what we were getting from Pulis, and if we do happen to stay up we all know we will play exactly the same way next season, with the same type of players.
Personally the best thing about the PL year has actually been off the pitch, yes you lot, and that remains whether we are in the PL or championship. Yes if we go down we will lose the glory hunters but the heart of the club will remain. That said if that style of play continues in the championship it will test the patience of many, and crowds will drop like a stone.

Personally, irrespective of what happens at the end of he season I think we should thank Pulis for his efforts and look towards the future with a manager and team where players like Williams are welcomed and cherished. Im sure Parish feels this too, in his heart.

 

EastEndPalace Flag WithHardNutsCosImAHardBastard 15 Mar 14 9.53pm

Some "supporters" sicken me. Be careful what you wish for. Going on about entertainment. Passing the ball on the floor and losing at home 4 1 to Fulham is not entertainment yet some are focussed on the style of football with deadwood s*** that Pulis has inherited. Not his fault. Stoke were defensive but were very good in the final third and if we stay up that is how we will be. I look forward to the day when we attack with pace and power and heart in the premier league like Stoke did, but to even get this opportunity we have to scrape through with the s*** we currently have.

 

EastEndPalace Flag WithHardNutsCosImAHardBastard 15 Mar 14 9.54pm

Quote neverforgivejoeroyle at 15 Mar 2014 9.47pm

Unfortunately i don't get the chance to go to many games but the ones I have seen at Selhurst have been poor in quality, if not entertainment. We all knew what we were getting from Pulis, and if we do happen to stay up we all know we will play exactly the same way next season, with the same type of players.
Personally the best thing about the PL year has actually been off the pitch, yes you lot, and that remains whether we are in the PL or championship. Yes if we go down we will lose the glory hunters but the heart of the club will remain. That said if that style of play continues in the championship it will test the patience of many, and crowds will drop like a stone.

Personally, irrespective of what happens at the end of he season I think we should thank Pulis for his efforts and look towards the future with a manager and team where players like Williams are welcomed and cherished. Im sure Parish feels this too, in his heart.[/quote]

What exactly has Williams done to merit a place in our starting 11.

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 15 Mar 14 10.06pm

Support the team and don't moan at the games East End. Just expressing an opinion about the football.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 15 Mar 14 10.13pm

Quote billtheglazier at 15 Mar 2014 8.58pm

I posted this 3 months ago and still stand by it......Pulis is doing his stuff and IMO it aint pretty and is what many of us anticipated when he was appointed.
At half time I observed Barry B and Jonny W passing the ball to each other going through the motions with Dwight Gayle standing there looking somewhat dejected...It does sadden me cos I feel these are probably out 3 most creative and exciting players other than yannick,who due to their physical stature probably dont have much of a future at Selhurst.I sincerely hope I'm wrong but i ask myself do I really want to watch this week in week out just to stay in the premiership? Last season was some of the most attractive and enjoyable stuff we've seen at Selhurst for years.Yes its nice to see us out of the bottom three,albeit temporarily but im not sure this is bearable indefinitely.

I thought Williams was playing for Ipswich today?


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Page 3 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Is Pulis interested in good football?