You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Stoke fan in Peace.
November 16 2026 12.53pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Stoke fan in Peace.


Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
1steino Flag Stoke 19 Mar 14 2.45pm

Quote FinchleyEagle at 19 Mar 2014 1.39pm

Firstly to the OP - mate thank you for coming on here and sharing - really interesting to hear your views and they pretty much match what I would expect. Seems like you have enough experience with message boards to ignore the keyboard warriors too.

I have discussed our woeful goals for column with my boss who's an Arsenal purist. While he would never want to watch a game even he concedes that TP was (and still is) the only manager who could keep us up. He thinks we should bin him in the summer but that's a very naive comment as the club as a whole needs to 'get used' to being in the prem.

I also think our current lack of goals has as much to do with the fact that we have literally no premier league goalscorers so he has to be mindful of that when planning his tactics. He cannot guarantee a goal so works on trying to ensure we don't concede. Makes sense to me, and as a fan of many years and being more circumspect these days I'm happy to ensure we stay in the PL for a few seasons before we look for more flair - the trapdoor doesn't go away - just ask Charlton or Fulham who both had several seasons in the prem before going down. As Fulham surely will this year.

Interesting comment about playing players out of position and wingers who will defend. Rings very true.

Thanks again and good luck - think Stoke and Palace have a lot in common as clubs.

Edited by FinchleyEagle (19 Mar 2014 1.41pm)

TP's problem is the way he sets his team up. He doesnt create many goal scoring opportunities and because of the direct style his teams dont retain possesion very often. Stoke always had the lowest possesion figures in the league and lowest goal scorers in the football league for 4 of the 5 permier league years. We only ever had James Beattie who you would class as a goal scorer and he got headbutted by TP. Goal Scorers in this league cost a lot of money and he struggles to attract them because of the direct style.

Id be surprised if Gayle played up front for you due to his size. You may see him playing out wide if hes willing to do the defensive side also.

Like i say, im interested to see if he does anything different. At first he seemed like he was but hes starting to revert back to old habbits.

 

FinchleyEagle Flag 19 Mar 14 11.11pm

Quote 1steino at 19 Mar 2014 2.45pm

Quote FinchleyEagle at 19 Mar 2014 1.39pm

Firstly to the OP - mate thank you for coming on here and sharing - really interesting to hear your views and they pretty much match what I would expect. Seems like you have enough experience with message boards to ignore the keyboard warriors too.

I have discussed our woeful goals for column with my boss who's an Arsenal purist. While he would never want to watch a game even he concedes that TP was (and still is) the only manager who could keep us up. He thinks we should bin him in the summer but that's a very naive comment as the club as a whole needs to 'get used' to being in the prem.

I also think our current lack of goals has as much to do with the fact that we have literally no premier league goalscorers so he has to be mindful of that when planning his tactics. He cannot guarantee a goal so works on trying to ensure we don't concede. Makes sense to me, and as a fan of many years and being more circumspect these days I'm happy to ensure we stay in the PL for a few seasons before we look for more flair - the trapdoor doesn't go away - just ask Charlton or Fulham who both had several seasons in the prem before going down. As Fulham surely will this year.

Interesting comment about playing players out of position and wingers who will defend. Rings very true.

Thanks again and good luck - think Stoke and Palace have a lot in common as clubs.

Edited by FinchleyEagle (19 Mar 2014 1.41pm)

TP's problem is the way he sets his team up. He doesnt create many goal scoring opportunities and because of the direct style his teams dont retain possesion very often. Stoke always had the lowest possesion figures in the league and lowest goal scorers in the football league for 4 of the 5 permier league years. We only ever had James Beattie who you would class as a goal scorer and he got headbutted by TP. Goal Scorers in this league cost a lot of money and he struggles to attract them because of the direct style.

Id be surprised if Gayle played up front for you due to his size. You may see him playing out wide if hes willing to do the defensive side also.

Like i say, im interested to see if he does anything different. At first he seemed like he was but hes starting to revert back to old habbits.

Not a chance this season, he doesn't have the tools to do the job, so will stick to what he knows. He really likes Ward and has played him at CM and LB when he is a RB, and definitely seen our wingers (Puncheon & Bolasie) tracking back hard a lot.

Getting Ince on loan seems to go against his type, so that was surprising. Currently we've had some tough games and there has been plenty of angst about the defensive tactics but I see he has had little choice - when we can attack with more confidence against lower opposition under TP, we have, so I expect more in the games against West Ham, Cardiff, Fulham and Villa. The rest will be about trying to nick a point and we are certainly very difficult to break down. Very low goals against figure for where we are and plenty were shipped before TP. I imagine if he'd been here from day 1 we'd be safe already.

How does Hughes compare ?

 


You'll be forever in my family's memories and it was an honor and privilege to play and lead in the red and blue
Yours sincerely
Mile Jedinak

palace chick Flag South Croydon 19 Mar 14 11.20pm

Quote peterg at 19 Mar 2014 11.31am

He's doing his best and trying all he knows but his biggest handicap is our lack of strikers who can magic goals. Most of our rivals have at least one of those which is why they get unexpected results against top-half teams. Believe as we might, we can never expect the unexpected from our set of strikers. The one who did have the magic is Murray but he is still struggling to get back where he was in the first part of last season, when he was scoring for us from all angles. Gayle's winning goal against Hull is the one exception to all this but he's not even making the starting line-up.


I don't think Murray is struggling. It's more to do with not having supply / support from the wings or an attacking midfielder. We rely on our defence which doesn't help him at all.

 

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 19 Mar 14 11.55pm

For my part the football is horrendous and I know it won't change next season.

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

goodersgold Flag Hastings 20 Mar 14 10.45am

Quote Dangermouse at 19 Mar 2014 11.55pm

For my part the football is horrendous and I know it won't change next season.


The football has been horrendous for years other than that run we had before Xmas in the championship ,
Even under Dougie we were awful to watch and rarely attacked including the Cardiff Semi final year.

 


The world was a mess but his hair was perfect!

1steino Flag Stoke 20 Mar 14 11.34am

Not a chance this season, he doesn't have the tools to do the job, so will stick to what he knows. He really likes Ward and has played him at CM and LB when he is a RB, and definitely seen our wingers (Puncheon & Bolasie) tracking back hard a lot.

Getting Ince on loan seems to go against his type, so that was surprising. Currently we've had some tough games and there has been plenty of angst about the defensive tactics but I see he has had little choice - when we can attack with more confidence against lower opposition under TP, we have, so I expect more in the games against West Ham, Cardiff, Fulham and Villa. The rest will be about trying to nick a point and we are certainly very difficult to break down. Very low goals against figure for where we are and plenty were shipped before TP. I imagine if he'd been here from day 1 we'd be safe already.
How does Hughes compare ?

Hughes is Tony Pulis without the frustrations. He still has the physical side with a big lad up fron ie crouch. We arent conceeding a lot of goals and go long when we need to. He plays players on form and in their correct position. Tries to win every game and not to not lose. He doesnt talk other teams up only ever talks about his own club. He gives licence to midfielders to go forward and espress themselves as long as one sits. Full backs get forward too.

Whether we will be different next season i dont know. I dont if we go long at times because crouch is really all we have or if thats how he likes to play. We play a lot more to win which is all we asked, we knew we could of played a lot more under tone but hed never let the shackles off.

The back 4 hasnt changed much other than we signed Pieters at left back so i think them working with Tone for 5 years has halped, we can still defend really well.

 

FinchleyEagle Flag 20 Mar 14 1.30pm

Quote 1steino at 20 Mar 2014 11.34am

Not a chance this season, he doesn't have the tools to do the job, so will stick to what he knows. He really likes Ward and has played him at CM and LB when he is a RB, and definitely seen our wingers (Puncheon & Bolasie) tracking back hard a lot.

Getting Ince on loan seems to go against his type, so that was surprising. Currently we've had some tough games and there has been plenty of angst about the defensive tactics but I see he has had little choice - when we can attack with more confidence against lower opposition under TP, we have, so I expect more in the games against West Ham, Cardiff, Fulham and Villa. The rest will be about trying to nick a point and we are certainly very difficult to break down. Very low goals against figure for where we are and plenty were shipped before TP. I imagine if he'd been here from day 1 we'd be safe already.
How does Hughes compare ?

Hughes is Tony Pulis without the frustrations. He still has the physical side with a big lad up fron ie crouch. We arent conceeding a lot of goals and go long when we need to. He plays players on form and in their correct position. Tries to win every game and not to not lose. He doesnt talk other teams up only ever talks about his own club. He gives licence to midfielders to go forward and espress themselves as long as one sits. Full backs get forward too.

Whether we will be different next season i dont know. I dont if we go long at times because crouch is really all we have or if thats how he likes to play. We play a lot more to win which is all we asked, we knew we could of played a lot more under tone but hed never let the shackles off.

The back 4 hasnt changed much other than we signed Pieters at left back so i think them working with Tone for 5 years has halped, we can still defend really well.

Interesting, always thought Hughes was a rubbish manager although both Fulham and Wales did well with him. Good luck for the rest of the season

 


You'll be forever in my family's memories and it was an honor and privilege to play and lead in the red and blue
Yours sincerely
Mile Jedinak

1steino Flag Stoke 20 Mar 14 3.59pm

Quote FinchleyEagle at 20 Mar 2014 1.30pm

Quote 1steino at 20 Mar 2014 11.34am

Not a chance this season, he doesn't have the tools to do the job, so will stick to what he knows. He really likes Ward and has played him at CM and LB when he is a RB, and definitely seen our wingers (Puncheon & Bolasie) tracking back hard a lot.

Getting Ince on loan seems to go against his type, so that was surprising. Currently we've had some tough games and there has been plenty of angst about the defensive tactics but I see he has had little choice - when we can attack with more confidence against lower opposition under TP, we have, so I expect more in the games against West Ham, Cardiff, Fulham and Villa. The rest will be about trying to nick a point and we are certainly very difficult to break down. Very low goals against figure for where we are and plenty were shipped before TP. I imagine if he'd been here from day 1 we'd be safe already.
How does Hughes compare ?

Hughes is Tony Pulis without the frustrations. He still has the physical side with a big lad up fron ie crouch. We arent conceeding a lot of goals and go long when we need to. He plays players on form and in their correct position. Tries to win every game and not to not lose. He doesnt talk other teams up only ever talks about his own club. He gives licence to midfielders to go forward and espress themselves as long as one sits. Full backs get forward too.

Whether we will be different next season i dont know. I dont if we go long at times because crouch is really all we have or if thats how he likes to play. We play a lot more to win which is all we asked, we knew we could of played a lot more under tone but hed never let the shackles off.

The back 4 hasnt changed much other than we signed Pieters at left back so i think them working with Tone for 5 years has halped, we can still defend really well.

Interesting, always thought Hughes was a rubbish manager although both Fulham and Wales did well with him. Good luck for the rest of the season


Yeh he wasnt my choice or a lot of stoke fans tbh. He did really well at Blackburn as well.

Good luck to you boys as well. Hope im on this board next season discussing our up and coming games.

 

est1905 Flag 20 Mar 14 8.09pm

Quote goodersgold at 20 Mar 2014 10.45am

Quote Dangermouse at 19 Mar 2014 11.55pm

For my part the football is horrendous and I know it won't change next season.


The football has been horrendous for years other than that run we had before Xmas in the championship ,
Even under Dougie we were awful to watch and rarely attacked including the Cardiff Semi final year.


I would argue the football was far worse under Freedman. For me the last time we played attractive free flowing attacking football that had an end product was under Steve Bruce! That was over 12 years ago.

 

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 20 Mar 14 8.41pm

Quote est1905 at 20 Mar 2014 8.09pm

Quote goodersgold at 20 Mar 2014 10.45am

Quote Dangermouse at 19 Mar 2014 11.55pm

For my part the football is horrendous and I know it won't change next season.


The football has been horrendous for years other than that run we had before Xmas in the championship ,
Even under Dougie we were awful to watch and rarely attacked including the Cardiff Semi final year.


I would argue the football was far worse under Freedman. For me the last time we played attractive free flowing attacking football that had an end product was under Steve Bruce! That was over 12 years ago.

I know we've been a long ball team for years and it's nothing I'm proud of. The semi final against Cardiff where we just decided to park the bus was an embarrassment, but apart from the brief spell under Dougie at least we tried to win games. I'm not asking for us to play like Arsenal, but no one else in this division is just giving the opposition the ball and just putting nine behind the ball.
Sometimes you have spells where nothing seems to go in and you say "One day soon a team is gonna get a real spanking, when it all falls into place." Well it works both ways and one day soon if TP's tactic goes wrong we, are gonna get a right spanking from someone.
Just my opinion.

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

goodersgold Flag Hastings 21 Mar 14 7.35am

Quote Dangermouse at 20 Mar 2014 8.41pm

Quote est1905 at 20 Mar 2014 8.09pm

Quote goodersgold at 20 Mar 2014 10.45am

Quote Dangermouse at 19 Mar 2014 11.55pm

For my part the football is horrendous and I know it won't change next season.


The football has been horrendous for years other than that run we had before Xmas in the championship ,
Even under Dougie we were awful to watch and rarely attacked including the Cardiff Semi final year.


I would argue the football was far worse under Freedman. For me the last time we played attractive free flowing attacking football that had an end product was under Steve Bruce! That was over 12 years ago.

I know we've been a long ball team for years and it's nothing I'm proud of. The semi final against Cardiff where we just decided to park the bus was an embarrassment, but apart from the brief spell under Dougie at least we tried to win games. I'm not asking for us to play like Arsenal, but no one else in this division is just giving the opposition the ball and just putting nine behind the ball.
Sometimes you have spells where nothing seems to go in and you say "One day soon a team is gonna get a real spanking, when it all falls into place." Well it works both ways and one day soon if TP's tactic goes wrong we, are gonna get a right spanking from someone.
Just my opinion.


I see where you are coming from DM although as we all know TP job is too keep CP out of the bottom 3 and at the moment we are he sees the best way of doing that is playing 10 behind the ball working hard at shutting all space down in our half.
It's working but only just ....it's a fine line between us getting something and losing comfortably at the moment .

 


The world was a mess but his hair was perfect!

FinchleyEagle Flag 21 Mar 14 9.11am

Quote est1905 at 20 Mar 2014 8.09pm

Quote goodersgold at 20 Mar 2014 10.45am

Quote Dangermouse at 19 Mar 2014 11.55pm

For my part the football is horrendous and I know it won't change next season.


The football has been horrendous for years other than that run we had before Xmas in the championship ,
Even under Dougie we were awful to watch and rarely attacked including the Cardiff Semi final year.


I would argue the football was far worse under Freedman. For me the last time we played attractive free flowing attacking football that had an end product was under Steve Bruce! That was over 12 years ago.

Really ? What about last year ? Champ POTY, top goalscorer in the league and highest scorers in the championship ?


Edited by FinchleyEagle (21 Mar 2014 9.12am)

 


You'll be forever in my family's memories and it was an honor and privilege to play and lead in the red and blue
Yours sincerely
Mile Jedinak

Prettything Flag Birmingham 21 Mar 14 11.44pm

Stoke fan in peace, also.

Posted on here before his appointment.

I said at the time he would be the best, and only manager to keep you up. Im pleased Im right so far.

Tough games coming up. Seems he still hasn't got the approach right away from home. Always sets the team up not to concede, very frustrating. His pragmatic approach is reasonable for the first couple of seasons, but when your established, this strategy can be very frustrating.

However, he's the right man for a dogfight. He will prioritise the games he knows he can get points from, and will communicate this, with great effect, to the players. You won't go down .

As a man, he is someone I would follow into war. You may already know, but I will repeat it for those who are not aware. AstonVilla at home, two years ago. We were told by the PA that his mother had died, and would not be attending the game. One nil down at half time. The start of the the second half, Tone jogs onto the pitch. We won 2 1. Thats the measure of the man.

As for us? We seem to have recovered from the transition, and now playing some lovely stuff. We seem to have survived the many blips, and are looking good for next season. Remember, we have four years over you guys, and have the back ground stuff in place. (Training facilities etc.)

We, however, owe it all to Pulis. If he keeps you up this season, I don't doubt he has learnt from his time at Stoke, and will make the necessary changes to take you forward.

 

Gary St.Andrews Flag Kenley 22 Mar 14 7.00am

I admit i was not singing from the roof tops when he was appointed, but he has done a good job there is no denying that.

We are hard to beat, but we have seem to have lost our cutting edge of late and we have seen some of the worst finishing i have ever witnessed.

A professional footballer should be able to hit the target from 12 yards with the ball at his feet unchallenged. TP has picked the players that can't do this. My feeling is he wants big physical players that are combative and know how to defend, but the trade off is they have limited skills and can't create goal scoring opportunities.

If he keeps us up, it's job done. On the other hand if we go down, it will be what might have been.....

 

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 22 Mar 14 10.25am

Quote Gary St.Andrews at 22 Mar 2014 7.00am

I admit i was not singing from the roof tops when he was appointed, but he has done a good job there is no denying that.

We are hard to beat, but we have seem to have lost our cutting edge of late and we have seen some of the worst finishing i have ever witnessed.

A professional footballer should be able to hit the target from 12 yards with the ball at his feet unchallenged. TP has picked the players that can't do this. My feeling is he wants big physical players that are combative and know how to defend, but the trade off is they have limited skills and can't create goal scoring opportunities.

If he keeps us up, it's job done. On the other hand if we go down, it will be what might have been.....


Sans Pulis, our relegation would have been confirmed some time ago. As un-pretty as our style of play is, it's the only thing that's kept us in contention to stay up.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

Plane Flag Bromley 22 Mar 14 10.39am

Quote Dangermouse at 20 Mar 2014 8.41pm

Quote est1905 at 20 Mar 2014 8.09pm

Quote goodersgold at 20 Mar 2014 10.45am

Quote Dangermouse at 19 Mar 2014 11.55pm

For my part the football is horrendous and I know it won't change next season.


The football has been horrendous for years other than that run we had before Xmas in the championship ,
Even under Dougie we were awful to watch and rarely attacked including the Cardiff Semi final year.


I would argue the football was far worse under Freedman. For me the last time we played attractive free flowing attacking football that had an end product was under Steve Bruce! That was over 12 years ago.

I know we've been a long ball team for years and it's nothing I'm proud of. The semi final against Cardiff where we just decided to park the bus was an embarrassment, but apart from the brief spell under Dougie at least we tried to win games. I'm not asking for us to play like Arsenal, but no one else in this division is just giving the opposition the ball and just putting nine behind the ball.
Sometimes you have spells where nothing seems to go in and you say "One day soon a team is gonna get a real spanking, when it all falls into place." Well it works both ways and one day soon if TP's tactic goes wrong we, are gonna get a right spanking from someone.
Just my opinion.


They are, Cardiff last week had around 31% of the ball, no doubt the other relegation contenders are about the same. We're (us relegation contenders) just not good enough, that's why we are where we are.

 

adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 22 Mar 14 10.41am

Blimey Plane. Hard but true. What to do tho'?

 

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 22 Mar 14 10.44am

Quote Plane at 22 Mar 2014 10.39am

Quote Dangermouse at 20 Mar 2014 8.41pm

Quote est1905 at 20 Mar 2014 8.09pm

Quote goodersgold at 20 Mar 2014 10.45am

Quote Dangermouse at 19 Mar 2014 11.55pm

For my part the football is horrendous and I know it won't change next season.


The football has been horrendous for years other than that run we had before Xmas in the championship ,
Even under Dougie we were awful to watch and rarely attacked including the Cardiff Semi final year.


I would argue the football was far worse under Freedman. For me the last time we played attractive free flowing attacking football that had an end product was under Steve Bruce! That was over 12 years ago.

I know we've been a long ball team for years and it's nothing I'm proud of. The semi final against Cardiff where we just decided to park the bus was an embarrassment, but apart from the brief spell under Dougie at least we tried to win games. I'm not asking for us to play like Arsenal, but no one else in this division is just giving the opposition the ball and just putting nine behind the ball.
Sometimes you have spells where nothing seems to go in and you say "One day soon a team is gonna get a real spanking, when it all falls into place." Well it works both ways and one day soon if TP's tactic goes wrong we, are gonna get a right spanking from someone.
Just my opinion.


They are, Cardiff last week had around 31% of the ball, no doubt the other relegation contenders are about the same. We're (us relegation contenders) just not good enough, that's why we are where we are.


This is a concept that some people appear to have difficulty in understanding.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

Plane Flag Bromley 22 Mar 14 10.46am

Quote adrian b at 22 Mar 2014 10.41am

Blimey Plane. Hard but true. What to do tho'?


Hi Ade, are you stalking me?

Anyway, what to do...keep doing what we're doing. I think we're gonna be ok. I'm gonna check tonight on MOTD and make a note of the amount of ball the other relegation candidates have!

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 22 Mar 14 10.46am

Quote adrian b at 22 Mar 2014 10.41am

Blimey Plane. Hard but true. What to do tho'?


What we are doing of course. TP knows his stuff. We have moved onto simple survival mode quicker than the others at the bottom and we will be better schooled in defending for our lives. Then if we can nick a goal or two we will be fine.

DM, I would put a fairly large bet on against us getting spanked from here on in.

My one hope is we are safe early enough where we can have a couple of games with nothing riding on them so we can try out some new approaches.

 

Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Stoke fan in Peace.