You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Cardiff complaint - Could we face problems if true?
November 16 2026 12.25pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Cardiff complaint - Could we face problems if true?


Page 3 of 25 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >
sidman Flag London 15 Apr 14 9.17am

This is what will happen.

Palace will be safe from relegation and oh what is this??? The FA will dock points from Palace, which will coincidently get us relegated.

The FA have had it in for us for a few years.

 

Baldfella Flag Wigan 15 Apr 14 9.22am

Quote sidman at 15 Apr 2014 9.17am

This is what will happen.

Palace will be safe from relegation and oh what is this??? The FA will dock points from Palace, which will coincidently get us relegated.

The FA have had it in for us for a few years.


I fail to see how;

1.You think The FA have had it in for us for years (examples)

2. Points deduction ? This hasn't happened before so why do you think it will be that ?

3. We can be punished for something that nowhere does it say we can't do what we're alleged to have done !

 

slubglurge Flag welling 15 Apr 14 9.23am

This is all about Tan trying to discredit Moody before their court case. Tan and his mad board know nothing about football, they are a bunch of mugs. I almost feel sorry for Cardiff fans because this lunatic is destroying their clubs name as well as their heritage. When the court case is over though i expect Moody to link up with Mackay again.

 

Palace15eagle Flag London 15 Apr 14 9.41am

Quote Baldfella at 15 Apr 2014 9.22am

Quote sidman at 15 Apr 2014 9.17am

This is what will happen.

Palace will be safe from relegation and oh what is this??? The FA will dock points from Palace, which will coincidently get us relegated.

The FA have had it in for us for a few years.


I fail to see how;

1.You think The FA have had it in for us for years (examples)

2. Points deduction ? This hasn't happened before so why do you think it will be that ?

3. We can be punished for something that nowhere does it say we can't do what we're alleged to have done !

Plus it will be the Premier League, not the FA who will dock us points, and I've not seen any evidence that the Premier League 'have it in for us!' If the PL did try to dock us points then you can also almost guarantee that there would be appeals that would subsequently lead to a high court case. This would be after the fixtures for next season come out so it will be more trouble than it's worth. Probably.

 


Your HOL best newcomer of the year 2013.

My twitter account: [Link]

collier row eagle Flag romford essex via another galaxy 15 Apr 14 9.49am

Tan is a Cnut, everybody knows it.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 15 Apr 14 9.59am

At worst any deduction would be the 'three points' - its worth noting that moodys information did not match the team cardiff put out, so its difficult to claim we got an advantage. Anyone whos read a book probably realises that if you have information on your enemy that is wrong, its not an advantage but a disadvantage.

Plus this is fairly common practice in football to try to get information about a team prior to the game. The PML don't like deducting points unless they have to.

A fine is the worst we'll get for bringing the game into disrepute.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Alexi_the_Eagle Flag Newton-le-Willows 15 Apr 14 10.08am

Quote sidman at 15 Apr 2014 9.17am

This is what will happen.

Palace will be safe from relegation and oh what is this??? The FA will dock points from Palace, which will coincidently get us relegated.

The FA have had it in for us for a few years.

You worry too much.

 


"Look at that. Accident blackspot? These aren't accidents! They're throwing themselves into the road gladly! Throwing themselves into the road to escape all this hideousness!"

GladAllOverJames Flag Maidstone 15 Apr 14 10.28am

What difference would it have made if we knew their team, we start the same players every week!

 

Sg Bilko Flag Deurne Holland 15 Apr 14 11.00am

Stop panicking, there's no criteria for any punishment for this, there's no crime been committed.
Spying is a clandestine activity and hard to prove and will take a full scale investigation.
Texting a former work college, unless they brought about a new law forbidding it Moody can text who he wishes does not mean he knows anything, especially as the only changes they made were obvious, Zaha for Gunnarsson(injury) and Jones for Bellemy, apart from that they fielded the same side defensively, and lets face it their defense is a joke.

 

paperhat Flag croydon 15 Apr 14 11.12am

They knew about this 2 days before the match? If its so serious, why didn't they complain BEFORE they got spanked???

 


Clinton is Clinton. I have known him for a long time, I know his mother... Simon Jordan


jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 15 Apr 14 11.30am

Quote Sg Bilko at 15 Apr 2014 11.00am

Stop panicking, there's no criteria for any punishment for this, there's no crime been committed.
Spying is a clandestine activity and hard to prove and will take a full scale investigation.
Texting a former work college, unless they brought about a new law forbidding it Moody can text who he wishes does not mean he knows anything, especially as the only changes they made were obvious, Zaha for Gunnarsson(injury) and Jones for Bellemy, apart from that they fielded the same side defensively, and lets face it their defense is a joke.

Indeed, unless we've actively committed a corrupt act in the process (such as blackmail and or bribery) or instructed a third party to do so, then there is no offence committed, unless of course the material falls under the Offical Secrets Act (which it doesn't).

Corporate espionage offences require the theft of materials that are 'trade secrets' such as intellectual propritory properties, prototypes etc.

if its a disgruntled employee then whatever they do is not a criminal offence, or the responsibility of the recepient (as they were approched by a third party).

In any other business its just an internal disciplinary action, and possible lawsuit to prevent the use of the material prior to market distribution (or share of sales based on violation of intellectual property by illict means).

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 15 Apr 14 11.51am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 15 Apr 2014 11.30am

Quote Sg Bilko at 15 Apr 2014 11.00am

Stop panicking, there's no criteria for any punishment for this, there's no crime been committed.
Spying is a clandestine activity and hard to prove and will take a full scale investigation.
Texting a former work college, unless they brought about a new law forbidding it Moody can text who he wishes does not mean he knows anything, especially as the only changes they made were obvious, Zaha for Gunnarsson(injury) and Jones for Bellemy, apart from that they fielded the same side defensively, and lets face it their defense is a joke.

Indeed, unless we've actively committed a corrupt act in the process (such as blackmail and or bribery) or instructed a third party to do so, then there is no offence committed, unless of course the material falls under the Offical Secrets Act (which it doesn't).

Corporate espionage offences require the theft of materials that are 'trade secrets' such as intellectual propritory properties, prototypes etc.

if its a disgruntled employee then whatever they do is not a criminal offence, or the responsibility of the recepient (as they were approched by a third party).

In any other business its just an internal disciplinary action, and possible lawsuit to prevent the use of the material prior to market distribution (or share of sales based on violation of intellectual property by illict means).

All that is absolutely true and eliminates criminal allegations but does anyone know what specific FA or Premier League rules Cardiff think that we've broken?

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

Ketteridge Flag Brighton 15 Apr 14 12.04pm

Let's face Caulker has already stated that there have been leaks all year, so pretty common practice so the prem are not going to want to open a can of worms.
That's rationale speaking but we all know that rationale and reasonable never applies to Palace so it will be discovered that Moody hired Paddy The Greek and Sunglasses Ron to break into Cardiff and get the team sheet.We will be docked 37 points, forced to play blindfolded next year to prove we are not spying and Kayla will made to live out her days as pigeon to stop her swooping in on info.

 


One supporter of hacking argued that without it "you will do away with the courage and pluck of the game, and I will be bound to bring over a lot of Frenchmen who would beat you with a week's practice -Blackheath secretary at first meeting of the F.A

turbohorsebox Flag Coulsdon 15 Apr 14 12.20pm

Quote EagleEyedAlbert at 15 Apr 2014 8.05am

"A Cardiff source said manager Ole Gunnar Solskjaerwas made aware of what was allegedly going on when a message sent from Moody's phone was received by a third party, listing the starting XI that Solskjaer ultimately fielded against Palace."

Hang on, that to me suggests somebody AT Cardiff received the Cardiff lineup from Iain Moody?

I thought that - maybe OGS thought it was such a good line up that he played the team Pulis was suggesting?

 


All good. Nothing bad.

adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 15 Apr 14 12.24pm


What are the allegations being made by Tan? I have thought of a few that may be the case.

1) Someone blackmailed a Cardiff employee to pass over information. If proved this is criminal.
2) Someone bribed a Cardiff employee to pass over information. Just an internal issue of trust for Cardiff, though not nice to know someone at Palace did this.
3) Someone at Palace bribed Cardiff player(s) to do something during the match to help Palace get a result, like give away a penalty, miss an open goal or something similar. If this is the case the implications are truly horrendous if proved. The way Cardiff played Tan believes this is possible. Some ex-Palace players are at the moment being investigated for something like this, though this of course is nothing to do with what Tan is on about.
Cannot think of anything else on this matter that could possibly be a problem, tho' I'll keep my thinking cap on!

 

SloveniaDave Flag Tirana, Albania 15 Apr 14 12.26pm

Quote adrian b at 15 Apr 2014 12.24pm


What are the allegations being made by Tan? I have thought of a few that may be the case.

1) Someone blackmailed a Cardiff employee to pass over information. If proved this is criminal.
2) Someone bribed a Cardiff employee to pass over information. Just an internal issue of trust for Cardiff, though not nice to know someone at Palace did this.
3) Someone at Palace bribed Cardiff player(s) to do something during the match to help Palace get a result, like give away a penalty, miss an open goal or something similar. If this is the case the implications are truly horrendous if proved. The way Cardiff played Tan believes this is possible. Some ex-Palace players are at the moment being investigated for something like this, though this of course is nothing to do with what Tan is on about.
Cannot think of anything else on this matter that could possibly be a problem, tho' I'll keep my thinking cap on!


Bribery is a criminal offence, not just an internal issue.

 


Just because I don't care doesn't mean I don't understand!

My opinions may have changed, but not the fact that I am right.

(Member of the School of Optimism 1969-2016 inclusive)

Part Time James Flag 15 Apr 14 12.32pm

We also must have a bit of faith that even if this gets to the point where the FA involve Palace (as opposed to them just laughing at Cardiff) that CPFC2010 and co, I imagine, will do a pretty bang up job of defending the club.

If this sticks I'd be very surprised and I'd also be surprised if Palace didn't successfully appeal against any fines or anything inflicting on us.

 




sydtheeagle Flag England 15 Apr 14 12.36pm

Quote EagleLegend97 at 14 Apr 2014 8.29pm

Obviously Moody shouldn't be asking

Why? To the best of my knowledge there's nothing in commercial law that makes it illegal to call a mate who works at another company and try to get information out of him. It's not theft; it's not illegal; it's just doing your job. Of course, your mate should tell you to f-off but if he doesn't, that Cardiff's problem, not Palaces. Asking a question has never been a crime.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

Mapletree Flag Croydon 15 Apr 14 12.38pm

I guess it is likely that Moody had a confidentiality clause in his contract.

If he breached it, he can be sued.

If the club encouraged that breach, or could have prevented it but did not, then it also could be sued.

Presumably it would be sued for damages, so Cardiff would have to prove the damages. If Cardiff goes down but would have stayed up had it had three more points this could - in theory - become a problem.

Mind you, if Moody was unfairly dismissed that may impact upon this. I am guessing there was a Settlement Agreement in place, it would be interesting to know what it had to say on confidentiality but likely it reinforced the requirement.

Edited by Mapletree (15 Apr 2014 12.38pm)

 

SloveniaDave Flag Tirana, Albania 15 Apr 14 12.40pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 15 Apr 2014 12.36pm

Quote EagleLegend97 at 14 Apr 2014 8.29pm

Obviously Moody shouldn't be asking

Why? To the best of my knowledge there's nothing in commercial law that makes it illegal to call a mate who works at another company and try to get information out of him. It's not theft; it's not illegal; it's just doing your job. Of course, your mate should tell you to f-off but if he doesn't, that Cardiff's problem, not Palaces. Asking a question has never been a crime.


Not quite. There are specific offences such as insider dealing where both parties can be liable. And soliciting someone else to commit a crime is also an offence. I don't see this case having any serious basis, but its not quite black and white.

 


Just because I don't care doesn't mean I don't understand!

My opinions may have changed, but not the fact that I am right.

(Member of the School of Optimism 1969-2016 inclusive)

Page 3 of 25 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Cardiff complaint - Could we face problems if true?