Quote sydtheeagle at 09 May 2014 10.16pm
Quote Happiness Stan at 09 May 2014 9.28pm
Again, you lot and your herd mentality. A guy posts a rumour, and you attack him for it. Posted this on the other thread, but just as applicable here...
I understand the reaction, in that when a group hear something they don't want to happen, rather than entertain the notion that it might be credible, they attack the root and discredit the person. This way they don't have to confront the possibility of it being true.
On the contrary, he got excoriated because he wrote a blithely stupid post. Let's examine it:
Guy's I got told the worst thing about pulis, by someone who works at the training ground;
OK, so he doesn't start by presenting his credentials. Tony Pulis' secretary?...I might worry a bit. The bloke who cleans the bog? I doubt he knows anything (other than whether TPs turds smell). In other words, the OPs failure to present a credible source for his "inside information" instantly undermines him. "Someone who works at the training ground" is a claimed connection that does little more than invite ridicule.
pulis has been in and out of the office having talks with west ham.
And his connection knows this how exactly? Even if he (or she) does work at the training ground and even if TP really is looking for a new job, do you actually suppose that he is advertising the fact that he's talking to West Ham to anyone who works at Palace or taking no precautions at all to keep the information secure? I'd say, on the contrary, he'd be attending meetings with West Ham as quietly as possible, in motorway hotels, and preferably going in and out with a stocking over his head. Certainly he'd be trying to be as anonymous as possible, if not going quite that far.
I got told that they are offering him a lot more money then we are I am worried!
Aaah, so your unidentified contact who works in an unidentified job at the training ground not only knows that TP is looking for a new position, he also knows who that job is with and, even better, he knows what it pays. That's a lot of information to be gleaned presumably on hearsay only. And he knows this because, presumably, Tony is the least discreet man in football and has taken no care at all to protect his own privacy. Further more, the man at the training ground knows more than the media (because this rumour hasn't been reported there), more than anyone in the West Ham hierarchy (because no one in the WHU community is talking about it) and more than anyone else at Palace (because no one here is talking about it either.)
Like I said, the OP took a kicking because he wrote a pile of crap.
If you don't mind Syd, I'm going to cut and paste this and use it on every tinpot rumour posted by Brigh2-0n/Chortletown/Knuckledragger numpties who are 'in the know' 