This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| nickgusset |
|
|---|---|
|
|
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Pussay Patrol at 01 Nov 2014 2.36pm
Quote EsussexEagle at 01 Nov 2014 1.33pm
The old Firefighters scheme needs 30 yrs service, not 25 as previously mentioned, and the contributions paid by members was almost double the standard scheme costs paid by other types of final salary jobs to allow for the 'early'retirement. The new scheme for Firefighters that says they will all get £19000 a year pension only works if you start by age 20 and work till 60 on a salary of £28000. Fair enough. But if you can't physically manage as you get older and are made to retire at say age 55 for example, your pension will be reduced to a figure of £9000, less than half the quoted perfect scenario pension for just 5 years less work.It's worth noting the Employer will decide the levels of fitness required, tests to pass and it isn't beyond anyone's thinking I've done it and had to retire early, people can harp on about statistics for less danger, less fires etc etc, try telling that to the families of the 2 good mates I've lost. Yes there are jobs out there that have higher mortality rates, farming being one and I think they should be better rewarded too, but being a Firefighter is still one of the jobs where when you go to work there is slightly more of a chance you may not come home. I believe everyone has a right to withhold their labour to not see their conditions made worse. Why wouldn't you be able to physically manage at 55? Surely the point of working patterns are designed so that firefighters have ample rest inbetween shifts? i'd expect all firemen to be in the gym on their days off, be non-smokers and have a healthy diet. I fully respect the job they do and the element of danger associated with it but I don't agree with using this to garner sympathy in order to keep an unsustainable pension fund. You are living longer and taking more out so it's only fair you put more in. Why should I pay for that? Maybe the physical strain and the stress of being in life threatening scenarios, where other peoples lives are dependent on your instinctive reactions take its toll. Non-Smoking, probably doesn't make a huge amount of difference when you're regularly exposed to burning materials, fumes and hot air. Whilst there are no doubt routine jobs such an inventory, checking hydrants etc there is also the necessity of maintaining people to a sufficient physical standard to deal with emergency situations, and the unpredictability of deterioration through old age is unpredictable. Going to the gym doesn't imbume people with a magical capacity to avoid injury (indeed in terms of maintaining a certain level of physical capability at an advanced age it can increase the risk of injuries). Why should you and I pay for that? Because if I'm trapped in a burning building, they're the people who will come through the door to try to rescue me. If I'm trapped in car crash they'll be the people who cut me free in time etc. I'd say that's on a par with deserving a little bit extra to take care of them when they are no longer capable of doing the job. The fact that they can be forced into early retirement and lose 9k of their pension shames us all. And that's not counting the psychological stress. I'm happy to say I don't mind paying a little bit extra as I don't generally have to deal with mangled corpses in car wrecks, the smell of burnt flesh, the screams of the badly burned etc.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote rob1969 at 01 Nov 2014 5.21pm
Firstly let me say I appreciate that fire-fighters are fully entitled to go on strike even though I think it undermines the support they have and more import is almost certainly futile. Now - regarding firemen working to 60 yeas to get their full pension. It strikes me (no pun untended!) PS: Me trying to get back to the original thread issue regarding fire-fighters ! Edited by rob1969 (01 Nov 2014 5.27pm) I think those jobs are currently done by the existing firemen, are you suggesting we should employ more firemen to cover those aged fireman having to do the administrative stuff, that they already would likely have been doing. Also paying them less seems a bit of a slap in the face after years of service. Especially as you'll have to hire a new fireman for each one.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote npn at 03 Nov 2014 1.42pm
The timing of the strike, which is being made such a meal of: Weird, I was talking to a fireman the other day, and he reckoned that in 10 years they only call out they'd had on Nov 5th was for a car crash. I'd imagine its a busy time for the Paramedics mind. I suppose the actual risks on bonfire night of a fire are probably lower, if you consider the number of people who aren't indoors, and that the main risk of fireworks night is injury from fireworks.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.