Quote Seth at 21 Nov 2014 3.19pm
Quote Pawson Palace at 21 Nov 2014 2.20pm
I'm always amused by people who get offended on others behalf.
I've seen this sentiment a few times on here and want to pick up on it.
If a white person is with a black friend and the black friend gets called a "n****r" by someone and the white person doesn't like it, is he being "offended on someone else's behalf"?
Were white people who campaigned against slavery being "offended on someone else's behalf"?
Was Oskar Schindler "offended on someone else's behalf"?
Was Nicholas Winton "offended on someone else's behalf"?
Were any non-Jews who fought against the Nazis "offended on someone else's behalf"?
If I object to my daughter being cat-called and leered at in the street am I "offended on someone else's behalf"?
My friend has a son who is gay. He was once beaten up in a club for his sexuality. I was angry at that. Am I "offended on someone else's behalf"?
If I campaign against animal cruelty am I "offended on someone else's behalf"?
If you donate to a charity which helps starving children, are you "offended on someone else's behalf"?
It seems that, according to the "offended on someone else's behalf" brigade, it's not right for anyone to empathise with or support someone who is suffering discrimination or violence. By this logic only Jews can protest at anti-semitism, only black people can fight racism and only gay people can campaign against homophobia. This is clearly a ridiculous position.
As for Whelan and Mackay, they are welcome to each other. I feel sorry for the ordinary Wigan fans who must be cringing at the thought of their club being associated with these kind of outdated and racist attitudes.
Whelan saying chink in a generic context- where it's not specifically aimed at anyone person- and I think that is different. Had he said Ken Hom is a chink then that would be offensive.
Again, as above I've been told as a white guy I have no rhythm...are you going to accuse my black team mates and black coach as being racist?