You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Ched Evans saga part ???
November 22 2026 1.18am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Ched Evans saga part ???


Page 3 of 19 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >
The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 07 Jan 15 12.58pm

Quote black eagle. at 07 Jan 2015 12.32pm

Ched Evans served 2 and a half years for rape,he's victim will have to live with the rape for ever.

so for her it's a life sentence,probably still having nightmares,should he sign for Oldham attendances will drop and sponsors will no longer sponsor the latics.

Sad day for football if this piece off sh!t is allowed to continue playing football.

Is he a piece of sh*t if he is actually innocent or has a favourable case review though???

The problem with rape cases such as this is you have one drunk party claiming consensual sex and one drunken party claiming rape - physical evidence is very thin on the ground so its essentially down to a group of 12 member of the general public picking their favourite of two stories.

 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

Mapletree Flag Croydon 07 Jan 15 12.58pm



Again Jamie, you claim certainty for events that you can't be sure of.

You assume that he raped this girl, you can't know it.

I don't personally feel the level of evidence you state is sufficient of this conviction and I think the verdict is going to change.

There are a lot of uncertainties in this case portrayed as facts.


He was sentenced. He raped her in the eyes of the law. Furthermore he has shown no remorse. I'm sure he would find a job if he came out and apologised.


His case is being looked into by the Criminal Case Review Board which unless it was a stone banker wouldn't be happening if the eyes of the law were entirely satisfied.


Or the eyes of the law think there is so much public interest they had no choice. He has already been refused leave to appeal, so you would think this was a pretty tight case.

And by the way, I for one have never considered a BJ as an open invitation for a full-on f*ck. Some girls give them because they don't want to go the whole way.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 07 Jan 15 12.59pm

Quote lil j-eagle at 07 Jan 2015 12.31pm


that's not what I meant. On the scale of rape, it isnt as bad as other rapes (hence the 5 year sentence rather than life), but is still obviously horrific and punishable by jail. And there was enoguh evidence to prove he is guilty and I'm fine with that, but when it is one person's word against the other, there will always be an element of doubt. Even if there is enough evidence to convict them, there will still be a tiny element of doubt.

Dodgy ground to get into, the idea that some types of crime are morally more acceptable than other crimes of the same category. Rape is rape, sentencing is much more along lines of rehabilition and social protection than the crime itself.

Beyond reasonable doubt is the key word of criminal justice.

Importantly, the evidence required to convict Evans came from his own admission of having sex with the girl and his activities prior to the event and after.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Kingvagabond Flag London 07 Jan 15 1.11pm

I struggle with the conviction myself having read everything available to be read (and no not just chedevans.com). Is Ched Evans a scumbag? Without doubt. Is he a rapist? Well he has been convicted of it by a jury of his peers. Will his conviction be quashed? Possibly. Will the petitions then count as criminal harassment? Possibly.

 


Part of Holmesdale Radio: The Next Generation
@KingvagabondHOL

Quote cornwalls palace at 24 Oct 2012 9.37am

He was right!!!...and we killed him!!... poor Orpinton Eagles........

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 07 Jan 15 1.12pm


I think that its reasonable to accept that he engaged in sexual conduct with the victim without her consent, due to her intoxication, and that his actions before and after made it unreasonable to assume that consent was granted.

Unless you think its 'reasonable' to turn up to a hotel room, after your friend has texted you that he's gone back with a drunk girl, obtain the key by deception from the night porter while your friends wait outside in the car, enter the room, engage in sexual activity with said drunk girl, and then attempt to leave the premises via a back door to avoid cameras.

Where as McDonald had sex with a woman he had spent the night drinking with, and had come home with him - its reasonable to assume he believed he had valid consent by the actions involved.

Evans' defence and appeals seem to generally be around issues around the case, rather than those necessary for his conviction (reasonable to accept she was drunk, that she had no prior contact with Evans, and that at the time of sexual activity was incapable of giving consent through intoxication).

What I believe is that McDonald and Evans planned this ahead of time, that McDonald would procure the girl, ply her with drinks and then notify Evans so that he could join in - McDonalds role was to get her too drunk to remember.

It would be a travesty of justice to overturn the conviction unless they could prove that Evans wasn't there or that the girl was not sufficiently intoxicated.

By his own words he stated to the police, under oath that he had sex with her, and the Night Manager specifically stated that Evans told him to take care of the drunk girl in that room (so he clearly was aware of how drunk she was).

Arguably by his own words he's a rapist.

Edited by jamiemartin721 (07 Jan 2015 1.13pm)

Edited by jamiemartin721 (07 Jan 2015 1.20pm)

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 07 Jan 15 1.19pm

Quote Kingvagabond at 07 Jan 2015 1.11pm

I struggle with the conviction myself having read everything available to be read (and no not just chedevans.com). Is Ched Evans a scumbag? Without doubt. Is he a rapist? Well he has been convicted of it by a jury of his peers. Will his conviction be quashed? Possibly. Will the petitions then count as criminal harassment? Possibly.

Ok, for it to be rape a number of factors are required.

1) Sex occurred
2) Consent was not given by the victim or the victim was rendered incapable of giving consent
3) If the victim is rendered incapable of giving consent then the defendant can avoid conviction if they can be said to have reasonable grounds for believing consent was given.

So if you spend the evening with a girl drinking, and go back with her, even if she's to drunk to consent when you have sex, it can be said to be reasonable by her actions, to assume you had consent (providing she didn't refuse - where as if you just took home a girl you met outside a club who was really drunk you might be in trouble).

Evans admits sex, the prosecution showed she was intoxicated, Evans knew she was drunk and her actions prior to sex gave him no reasonable grounds to assume consent.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Sg Bilko Flag Deurne Holland 07 Jan 15 1.20pm

Quote OknotOK at 07 Jan 2015 10.37am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 07 Jan 2015 10.30am

I'm with Ian J and Sash etc.

Evans is no worse than other offenders that have been allowed back in to play..... how many times has Joey Barton offended?

You cannot have arbitrary rules applied on emotive feelings.

Either all offenders are banned or not at all.

I am also not convinced about the safety of the Ched Evans' verdict either.

I don't know of many that have actually called seriously for him to be banned. They have just said they don't want him playing for their club.

And clubs have to weigh up the potential gains (playing side only as far as I can see) against the potential damage (financial, reputational) of employing him.

I wouldn't want him playing for our club. And I suspect a lot of fans and sponsors wouldn't want to be associated with a club that does employ him. There's no ban involved. It is the free market working.

That's all bullsqirt, 160,000 signed a partition with Sheff U, Sheff U don't have 160,000 supporters they are struggling to average 20,000 for home games, so how can 160,000 so called supporters sign a partition.

Personally I know nothing about the case, but if he's done his time, he's paid for his crime, and should therefore be able to return to his work, and how twofaced are those same Sheff U supporters, Ched Evans mustn't play for them but Marlon Harewood did, and he has a record going back to the late 90s including Sexual assault.


Edited by Sg Bilko (07 Jan 2015 1.42pm)

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 07 Jan 15 1.21pm

Quote The Sash at 07 Jan 2015 12.58pm

Quote black eagle. at 07 Jan 2015 12.32pm

Ched Evans served 2 and a half years for rape,he's victim will have to live with the rape for ever.

so for her it's a life sentence,probably still having nightmares,should he sign for Oldham attendances will drop and sponsors will no longer sponsor the latics.

Sad day for football if this piece off sh!t is allowed to continue playing football.

Is he a piece of sh*t if he is actually innocent or has a favourable case review though???

The problem with rape cases such as this is you have one drunk party claiming consensual sex and one drunken party claiming rape - physical evidence is very thin on the ground so its essentially down to a group of 12 member of the general public picking their favourite of two stories.


Still a piece of sh*t given he obtain a key card to get into a room where his friend was having sex with a girl so that he could have sex with her.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

black eagle. Flag south croydon. 07 Jan 15 1.21pm

Quote The Sash at 07 Jan 2015 12.58pm

Quote black eagle. at 07 Jan 2015 12.32pm

Ched Evans served 2 and a half years for rape,he's victim will have to live with the rape for ever.

so for her it's a life sentence,probably still having nightmares,should he sign for Oldham attendances will drop and sponsors will no longer sponsor the latics.

Sad day for football if this piece off sh!t is allowed to continue playing football.

Is he a piece of sh*t if he is actually innocent or has a favourable case review though???

The problem with rape cases such as this is you have one drunk party claiming consensual sex and one drunken party claiming rape - physical evidence is very thin on the ground so its essentially down to a group of 12 member of the general public picking their favourite of two stories.


The evidance against Evans were very strong,if he plays football again i hope someone breaks he's leg in his first game and he never plays football again.

 

chateauferret Flag 07 Jan 15 1.27pm

I should've thought the FA had the power and the locus to determine exceptionally that a particular person was not a fit and proper person to participate in the Football League and to define criteria and processes according to which this may be determined.

I should also have thought that whatever his legal status his conduct and image bring football into disrepute. I think it's for the FA to safeguard the reputation of the sport, since individual clubs have a conflict of interest - on the one hand they want to avoid alienating their fans and sponsors, but on the other they also want to score goals and get up the league. What is more, clubs might (or might not) act in the interests of their own fan base but they won't give a to$$ about other clubs' fans - nobody here is acting in the interests of football supporters in general.

Would you lot be happy seeing him in a Palace shirt? I jolly well wouldn't.

Edited by chateauferret (07 Jan 2015 1.28pm)

 


============
The Ferret
============

Username Flag Horsham 07 Jan 15 1.36pm

Quote black eagle. at 07 Jan 2015 1.21pm

Quote The Sash at 07 Jan 2015 12.58pm

Quote black eagle. at 07 Jan 2015 12.32pm

Ched Evans served 2 and a half years for rape,he's victim will have to live with the rape for ever.

so for her it's a life sentence,probably still having nightmares,should he sign for Oldham attendances will drop and sponsors will no longer sponsor the latics.

Sad day for football if this piece off sh!t is allowed to continue playing football.

Is he a piece of sh*t if he is actually innocent or has a favourable case review though???

The problem with rape cases such as this is you have one drunk party claiming consensual sex and one drunken party claiming rape - physical evidence is very thin on the ground so its essentially down to a group of 12 member of the general public picking their favourite of two stories.


The evidance against Evans were very strong,if he plays football again i hope someone breaks he's leg in his first game and he never plays football again.

It is incredibly difficult to secure a conviction for rape because of these reasons. For him to be convicted, the evidence must have been overwhelmingly against him.

Not sure where this review business has come from, his appeal was rejected?

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

black eagle. Flag south croydon. 07 Jan 15 1.41pm

One off Oldhams main sponsors have just ended their association with the club and two more are to follow.

it's rare that a player like Evans will be jeered by both sets off Fans week in and week out.

 

The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 07 Jan 15 1.51pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 07 Jan 2015 1.21pm

Quote The Sash at 07 Jan 2015 12.58pm

Quote black eagle. at 07 Jan 2015 12.32pm

Ched Evans served 2 and a half years for rape,he's victim will have to live with the rape for ever.

so for her it's a life sentence,probably still having nightmares,should he sign for Oldham attendances will drop and sponsors will no longer sponsor the latics.

Sad day for football if this piece off sh!t is allowed to continue playing football.

Is he a piece of sh*t if he is actually innocent or has a favourable case review though???

The problem with rape cases such as this is you have one drunk party claiming consensual sex and one drunken party claiming rape - physical evidence is very thin on the ground so its essentially down to a group of 12 member of the general public picking their favourite of two stories.


Still a piece of sh*t given he obtain a key card to get into a room where his friend was having sex with a girl so that he could have sex with her.

Doesn't make him a rapist though.

 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 07 Jan 15 1.53pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 07 Jan 2015 1.12pm


Where as McDonald had sex with a woman he had spent the night drinking with, and had come home with him - its reasonable to assume he believed he had valid consent by the actions involved.


He didn't though Jamie. In the words of the case summary posted earlier in the thread;

"The applicant and McDonald had spent the evening with friends visiting various licensed premises. At some time shortly before 4am McDonald became separated from the group of friends. The complainant seems to have wandered into his path."

She claims to remember nothing from when she left the club she was in until the following morning which for me provides the biggest question mark over the entire case. How can she have been able to consent to one and not the other given that they had sex with her consecutively?

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 07 Jan 15 2.07pm

Even assuming his guilt, which I'm not 100% comfortable with, I don't like the way the whole thing has turned into a social media based witch hunt. It's very dangerous when mob rule starts to take precedence over the justice system.

It's a damning indictment of the way our society has become when free speech and debate are no longer permitted by a culture of Twitter users who bully anybody who dares to take a different stance. I thought, in particular, the abuse of Judy Finnigan was a disgrace and the fact that her daughter suffered rape threats as a result showed how moronic and hypocritical these people really are.

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

Part Time James Flag 07 Jan 15 2.12pm

Quote black eagle. at 07 Jan 2015 1.41pm

One off Oldhams main sponsors have just ended their association with the club and two more are to follow.

it's rare that a player like Evans will be jeered by both sets off Fans week in and week out.

It will be interesting to see what happens if he scores a goal. Will the fans sit in silence? What if it's not obvious whether it was him or someone else that touched the ball? Sit in silence and wait confirmation it was the other guy before cheering? Or will they just treat him normally? I can imagine a strange atmosphere at first.

 




npn Flag Crowborough 07 Jan 15 2.16pm

Quote Part Time James at 07 Jan 2015 2.12pm

Quote black eagle. at 07 Jan 2015 1.41pm

One off Oldhams main sponsors have just ended their association with the club and two more are to follow.

it's rare that a player like Evans will be jeered by both sets off Fans week in and week out.

It will be interesting to see what happens if he scores a goal. Will the fans sit in silence? What if it's not obvious whether it was him or someone else that touched the ball? Sit in silence and wait confirmation it was the other guy before cheering? Or will they just treat him normally? I can imagine a strange atmosphere at first.


I'd be surprised if there's anything particularly unusual about it - they keep talking about these petitions being signed by thousands of fans of {insert club here} when clearly they haven't - it's anyone who objects to him playing full stop (many of which would be completely uninterested in football).

I'd imagine his first goal will be celebrated uproariously, as normal, and I'd not be at all surprised if he gets a decent reception when he runs out for his first home game (from the home fans, at least - the away section will give him Hell)

 

Username Flag Horsham 07 Jan 15 2.20pm

Quote The Sash at 07 Jan 2015 1.51pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 07 Jan 2015 1.21pm

Quote The Sash at 07 Jan 2015 12.58pm

Quote black eagle. at 07 Jan 2015 12.32pm

Ched Evans served 2 and a half years for rape,he's victim will have to live with the rape for ever.

so for her it's a life sentence,probably still having nightmares,should he sign for Oldham attendances will drop and sponsors will no longer sponsor the latics.

Sad day for football if this piece off sh!t is allowed to continue playing football.

Is he a piece of sh*t if he is actually innocent or has a favourable case review though???

The problem with rape cases such as this is you have one drunk party claiming consensual sex and one drunken party claiming rape - physical evidence is very thin on the ground so its essentially down to a group of 12 member of the general public picking their favourite of two stories.


Still a piece of sh*t given he obtain a key card to get into a room where his friend was having sex with a girl so that he could have sex with her.

Doesn't make him a rapist though.

The guilty verdict does. There was enough evidence to convict him of rape and he has had an appeal rejected.

He is a convicted rapist. Not really sure what you're struggling with here.

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

npn Flag Crowborough 07 Jan 15 2.23pm

Quote Username at 07 Jan 2015 2.20pm

Quote The Sash at 07 Jan 2015 1.51pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 07 Jan 2015 1.21pm

Quote The Sash at 07 Jan 2015 12.58pm

Quote black eagle. at 07 Jan 2015 12.32pm

Ched Evans served 2 and a half years for rape,he's victim will have to live with the rape for ever.

so for her it's a life sentence,probably still having nightmares,should he sign for Oldham attendances will drop and sponsors will no longer sponsor the latics.

Sad day for football if this piece off sh!t is allowed to continue playing football.

Is he a piece of sh*t if he is actually innocent or has a favourable case review though???

The problem with rape cases such as this is you have one drunk party claiming consensual sex and one drunken party claiming rape - physical evidence is very thin on the ground so its essentially down to a group of 12 member of the general public picking their favourite of two stories.


Still a piece of sh*t given he obtain a key card to get into a room where his friend was having sex with a girl so that he could have sex with her.

Doesn't make him a rapist though.

The guilty verdict does. There was enough evidence to convict him of rape and he has had an appeal rejected.

He is a convicted rapist. Not really sure what you're struggling with here.


I get where you're coming from, but didn't the Guildford 4 and Birmingham 6 also get convicted and lose appeals?

Mistakes happen, sadly.

Personally, I'm fairly sure he's a maggot, but wasn't at the trial, so can't be 100% sure.

 

bright&wright Flag 07 Jan 15 2.23pm

If we played Oldham I would give him absolute dogs abuse from first minute to last. Because he would deserve it.

 


'We are going to make a little bit of history here’ Mr. J. Ertl.

Page 3 of 19 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Ched Evans saga part ???