You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Jordan (the country)
November 22 2026 2.19am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Jordan (the country)


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
gambler Flag Kent 04 Feb 15 6.00am

Well done.

About time the world followed your lead.

Stop pussy footing around and execute the whole lot of them.

 

redandblue4life Flag Auckland city ! 04 Feb 15 7.01am

Agreed !!

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 04 Feb 15 9.23am

Yes, because the best solution is to reduce yourself to the same level as the enemy and validate their hateful position, and dispose of due purpose etc.

ISIS doesn't care about its prisoners, they're effectively determined as casualties, written off and lost (the fact that most of these captive relate to a much earlier incarnation of ISIS is another problem).

Once you get down to a good guys / bad guys black and white kind of view of morality and ethics, then your effectively posturing in the same stance as your enemy - Anything is justified because they did it first (which is exactly the kind of mentality groups like IS utilize in the first place - That we started it, so its all just).

By all means strike at the guilty, arrest and round people up, but when you've effectively resorted to murder as a means of politics you're not really all that much different.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

gbox82 Flag Meols, Wirral 04 Feb 15 9.30am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 04 Feb 2015 9.23am

Yes, because the best solution is to reduce yourself to the same level as the enemy and validate their hateful position, and dispose of due purpose etc.

ISIS doesn't care about its prisoners, they're effectively determined as casualties, written off and lost (the fact that most of these captive relate to a much earlier incarnation of ISIS is another problem).

Once you get down to a good guys / bad guys black and white kind of view of morality and ethics, then your effectively posturing in the same stance as your enemy - Anything is justified because they did it first (which is exactly the kind of mentality groups like IS utilize in the first place - That we started it, so its all just).

By all means strike at the guilty, arrest and round people up, but when you've effectively resorted to murder as a means of politics you're not really all that much different.

Hear hear!

 

aquickgame2 Flag Beni = summer,Caribbean = winter 04 Feb 15 10.38am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 04 Feb 2015 9.23am

Yes, because the best solution is to reduce yourself to the same level as the enemy and validate their hateful position, and dispose of due purpose etc.

ISIS doesn't care about its prisoners, they're effectively determined as casualties, written off and lost (the fact that most of these captive relate to a much earlier incarnation of ISIS is another problem).

Once you get down to a good guys / bad guys black and white kind of view of morality and ethics, then your effectively posturing in the same stance as your enemy - Anything is justified because they did it first (which is exactly the kind of mentality groups like IS utilize in the first place - That we started it, so its all just).

By all means strike at the guilty, arrest and round people up, but when you've effectively resorted to murder as a means of politics you're not really all that much different.

The Jordanian people wanted revenge,they were on the streets in Amman,the King had to decide whether to pacify his people and give them what they want or have a large internal battle on his hands.

Rightly or wrongly he decided on the people wishes.

 

Hoof Hearted 04 Feb 15 10.50am

This is similar to the Churchill was a prick thread.

Jordan have been pragmatic and dealt with the situation much like Winston would have done.

It's all very well playing to the Marquis of Queensberry rules, but ISIS etc are not, so instead of tying one hand behind your back, engage these barstewards without any reservations and blow them away.

We'll never rid ourselves of this scum if we adopt principles like "Don't lower yourselves to their standards!".

Meet them with full force and gloves off, and hit below the belt if necessary.

 

Palace BANANA Flag Ringmer, Lewes, East Sussex 04 Feb 15 10.54am

So JM721 what would be your solution to the IS/terrorist problem?.. how would you deal with this world threat?.. Remember the two terrorists that the Jordanian government hung had tried to kill Jordanians, one was a failed suicide bomber that IS had requested as an exchange for the pilot IS burned alive in a cage... maybe retaliation with force and no quarter is the only solution or IS will be allowed to take control of, and continue to terrorise, the rest of the world... what would you suggest that the governments of the world should do to counter act these acts of a barbaric, inhuman and unforgiveable nature?..

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 04 Feb 15 11.34am

I have said before, since Vietnam war is conducted as much in the media as it is on the battlefield.

The "bad guys" revel in negative coverage and use it to their advantage whilst the good guys have to be extremely careful.

However, people need to realise that the decision to go to war must not be taken lightly. Once it is, whilst being mindful of collateral damage it should be conducted with the utmost violence and not namby pambying

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

dannyh Flag wherever I lay my hat....... 04 Feb 15 11.46am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 04 Feb 2015 9.23am

Yes, because the best solution is to reduce yourself to the same level as the enemy and validate their hateful position, and dispose of due purpose etc.

ISIS doesn't care about its prisoners, they're effectively determined as casualties, written off and lost (the fact that most of these captive relate to a much earlier incarnation of ISIS is another problem).

Once you get down to a good guys / bad guys black and white kind of view of morality and ethics, then your effectively posturing in the same stance as your enemy - Anything is justified because they did it first (which is exactly the kind of mentality groups like IS utilize in the first place - That we started it, so its all just).

By all means strike at the guilty, arrest and round people up, but when you've effectively resorted to murder as a means of politics you're not really all that much different.


Sounds good, might even feel good to take the moral high ground, meanwhile ISIS continue to NOT play by the rules that NATO enforces on it's troops. You can not fight against a guerrilla force that fights with absolutely no rules of engagement by using a force that IS playing by the rules of engagement. You might as well bet on a one legged man to win an arse kicking competition

Pay a thief to catch a thief is the only answer, and until someone has the balls to send a force into ISIS held strongholds with a "no stone unturned" attitude, with zero culpability for their actions, they will continue to stick two fingers up at the "infidels", and behead innocent westerners, as they know only to well there is f*** all we can do about it, with the current law of armed conflict as is.

 


"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"

Harpo Flag Oxfordshire 04 Feb 15 11.51am

IS, ISIS or whatever they may morph into in the future are nothing more than hobby butchers of humanity.

They are a cancer in the global community.

Cut the cancer out and incinerate. It's the only option.

But we also have the problem of their financiers as well, and resolving that isn't going to be very tidy either.

Sadly, I can see the development and use of smart chemical weapons as a desirable option for the US to curtail the threat, whether or not it is considered acceptable within UN conventions.

 

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 04 Feb 15 11.53am

Mexican drugs gangs do the same and lots more. This type of cvntishness is not limited to fanatical 'muslims'

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


Andy_G Flag Wimbledon 04 Feb 15 12.18pm

It certainly made everyone stand up and take notice. No one has really ever met IS with such a swift and dramatic fight fire with fire solution. Bombing runs are all very well but executing people gets right to the heart of it so may be IS will think twice. I doubt it will but fair play to Jordan.

 


The ups and downs of Palace have left me older than my years

Southampton_Eagle Flag At the after party 04 Feb 15 12.27pm

Quote Andy_G at 04 Feb 2015 12.18pm

It certainly made everyone stand up and take notice. No one has really ever met IS with such a swift and dramatic fight fire with fire solution. Bombing runs are all very well but executing people gets right to the heart of it so may be IS will think twice. I doubt it will but fair play to Jordan.


Too soon?

 

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 04 Feb 15 12.38pm

Quote Andy_G at 04 Feb 2015 12.18pm

It certainly made everyone stand up and take notice. No one has really ever met IS with such a swift and dramatic fight fire with fire solution. Bombing runs are all very well but executing people gets right to the heart of it so may be IS will think twice. I doubt it will but fair play to Jordan.


Probably not. They welcome death and I would imagine celebrated the execution of their sister martyr.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


Kermit8 Flag Hevon 04 Feb 15 12.39pm

Quote Southampton_Eagle at 04 Feb 2015 12.27pm

Quote Andy_G at 04 Feb 2015 12.18pm

It certainly made everyone stand up and take notice. No one has really ever met IS with such a swift and dramatic fight fire with fire solution. Bombing runs are all very well but executing people gets right to the heart of it so may be IS will think twice. I doubt it will but fair play to Jordan.


Too soon?


Way too soon. Extinguish those thoughts.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


Andy_G Flag Wimbledon 04 Feb 15 1.21pm

Quote Southampton_Eagle at 04 Feb 2015 12.27pm

Quote Andy_G at 04 Feb 2015 12.18pm

It certainly made everyone stand up and take notice. No one has really ever met IS with such a swift and dramatic fight fire with fire solution. Bombing runs are all very well but executing people gets right to the heart of it so may be IS will think twice. I doubt it will but fair play to Jordan.


Too soon?


I see my error, it wasn't meant as a joke.

 


The ups and downs of Palace have left me older than my years

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 04 Feb 15 1.26pm

Quote Palace BANANA at 04 Feb 2015 10.54am

So JM721 what would be your solution to the IS/terrorist problem?.. how would you deal with this world threat?.. Remember the two terrorists that the Jordanian government hung had tried to kill Jordanians, one was a failed suicide bomber that IS had requested as an exchange for the pilot IS burned alive in a cage... maybe retaliation with force and no quarter is the only solution or IS will be allowed to take control of, and continue to terrorise, the rest of the world... what would you suggest that the governments of the world should do to counter act these acts of a barbaric, inhuman and unforgiveable nature?..

If I was leader, it wouldn't be a problem, because I wouldn't have invaded Iraq in the first place. ISIS stems from the Al-Queda in Iraq movement, that sprung up and flourished in 2004, following the occupation of Iraq. ISIS itself was founded on the back of the sunni insurgent groups that were engaged against the US in Iraq, who during the rise of the Syrian Civil war trained and equipped ISIS which split for Al-Queda becoming IS before the recent incursion.

See, the problem is we see the consequences of our own nations actions are intrinsically inherent in the creation of a much larger problem - ISIL / ISIS / IS would never have become anything of note, had it not been for the policy of war and occupation of Iraq - The elimination of the Sunni political bias under Saddam Hussain to an affect exclusion under the post war political system is at the core of IS.

So, yes, I had, rather than have, a solution, back in 2003 - Not invading Iraq in the first f**king place.

There would be no ISIS without the UK and US invasion. AL-Qaeda had no presence in Iraq prior to 2003 (indeed the regime regarded Hussain and Baathists as apostacy - and the Iraqi regime wasn't particually keen on them either).


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 04 Feb 15 1.39pm

Quote dannyh at 04 Feb 2015 11.46am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 04 Feb 2015 9.23am

Yes, because the best solution is to reduce yourself to the same level as the enemy and validate their hateful position, and dispose of due purpose etc.

ISIS doesn't care about its prisoners, they're effectively determined as casualties, written off and lost (the fact that most of these captive relate to a much earlier incarnation of ISIS is another problem).

Once you get down to a good guys / bad guys black and white kind of view of morality and ethics, then your effectively posturing in the same stance as your enemy - Anything is justified because they did it first (which is exactly the kind of mentality groups like IS utilize in the first place - That we started it, so its all just).

By all means strike at the guilty, arrest and round people up, but when you've effectively resorted to murder as a means of politics you're not really all that much different.


Sounds good, might even feel good to take the moral high ground, meanwhile ISIS continue to NOT play by the rules that NATO enforces on it's troops. You can not fight against a guerrilla force that fights with absolutely no rules of engagement by using a force that IS playing by the rules of engagement. You might as well bet on a one legged man to win an arse kicking competition

Pay a thief to catch a thief is the only answer, and until someone has the balls to send a force into ISIS held strongholds with a "no stone unturned" attitude, with zero culpability for their actions, they will continue to stick two fingers up at the "infidels", and behead innocent westerners, as they know only to well there is f*** all we can do about it, with the current law of armed conflict as is.

Indeed, but there is a difference between engaging enemy on a military basis. By all means target their leaders, their troops, their financiers and take them out if necessary (or detain). But simply responding to the shouts of an angry crowd by hanging some people because some other, vaguely related people, killed one of your people, that you sent to kill their people, because the US wanted you too isn't really productive policy.

I quite agree, that realistically, you need to destroy such an enemy, utterly. I think your right, hitting strong holds, no stone unturned, makes sense. Its a war they wanted. But that doesn't really translate into 'lets just hang some people to keep the public happy'.

Indeed, I'd suggest that the whole 'no stone unturned' should just happen. No one claiming responsibility, no political posturing, that stronghold just be left as a fortress of corpses. Their leaders and agents, should just be found dead and so on. No claims of responsibility, just denials and silence.

But we shouldn't forget that we have a responsibility in all of this, as the UK, IS exists because of our decision to invade Iraq in 2003.

Plus the language used by the Jordanian state talks of vengeance, martyrdom, blood for blood, swift reprisals and god. Sounds a bit like the enemy already.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 04 Feb 15 1.40pm

Quote Kermit8 at 04 Feb 2015 12.38pm

Quote Andy_G at 04 Feb 2015 12.18pm

It certainly made everyone stand up and take notice. No one has really ever met IS with such a swift and dramatic fight fire with fire solution. Bombing runs are all very well but executing people gets right to the heart of it so may be IS will think twice. I doubt it will but fair play to Jordan.


Probably not. They welcome death and I would imagine celebrated the execution of their sister martyr.

Almost certainly, and they'll be using that to recruit in Jordan and the Islamic world.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

serial thriller Flag The Promised Land 04 Feb 15 1.43pm

Other thing to say is that ISIS are an incredibly disparate organisation, so bombing them out of existence just isn't an option. They have managed to mobilise supporters in parts of the Western world, as well as in Northern and Western Iraq and Eastern Syria. Despite calling themselves a 'state' they are nothing of the kind; they are an ideological collective desiring global adherence to their interpretation of Islam. To be an ideological rather than a national group means that they will always be transnational, gaining support wherever other radical elements of Islam reside.

If you view them in purely religious terms though, it's easy to justify belligerent measures, because you can 'other' them as some sort of brainwashed sub-human nutters. Actually, like any group, they are influenced by the wider political and economic landscape they find themselves in, one where we, as Jamie said, have bombed them to sh*t, then armed them to fight Assad, then bombed them some more. The areas they are thriving in are in such extreme poverty and destitution that a group of intellectual radicals can seem very appealing, especially if their rhetoric is absolutely anti-Western.

What we really should be doing is building bridges in the surrounding areas to prevent the spread, arming local groups combatting IS (like the Rojava area of Syria I linked in the other thread) and combatting the anti-Islamic rhetoric in the West which is turning many disillusioned young Muslim blokes to sympathise with them. But of course we're not doing that, we're instead looking short term and assume bombing the sh*t out of an area we've bombed the sh*t out of several times in the last few decades will solve the problem.

[Link]

Edited by serial thriller (04 Feb 2015 1.44pm)

 


If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Jordan (the country)