You are here: Home > Message Board > Transfer Talk > Virgil Van Dijk (papertalk)
November 22 2026 8.28pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Virgil Van Dijk (papertalk)


Page 3 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
palace99 Flag New Mills 19 Aug 15 1.17pm

Quote elky94 at 19 Aug 2015 12.42pm

would love for palace to sign him.


Who? One of the Thunderbirds??

 

black eagle. Flag south croydon. 19 Aug 15 1.18pm

Quote elky94 at 19 Aug 2015 12.42pm

would love for palace to sign him.


Yeah me to but i think his of to Southampton.

 

black eagle. Flag south croydon. 19 Aug 15 1.20pm

Quote palace99 at 19 Aug 2015 1.17pm

Quote elky94 at 19 Aug 2015 12.42pm

would love for palace to sign him.


Who? One of the Thunderbirds??


Yes Virgil who flies thunderbird two,keep up

 

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 19 Aug 15 2.44pm

Quote black eagle. at 19 Aug 2015 1.18pm

Quote elky94 at 19 Aug 2015 12.42pm

would love for palace to sign him.


Yeah me to but i think his of to Southampton.


With a certain Mr Fonte coming to us then?

 


Bring back Brolin

Chirrup Flag Berkshire 26 Aug 15 7.08am

Dare say this guy will be sold now.

Getting pelters for his performance last night mind.

 

kennybrowns leftfoot Flag Reigate 26 Aug 15 12.53pm

He has already said on SSN today that as Celtic have failed to qualify he will have to seriously consider his options.... Putting himself out there for the last 4-5 days of the window by the looks of it!!

 


Don't waste your time with jealousy. Sometimes your ahead, sometimes your behind, the race is long. But in the end it's only with yourself!!

sydtheeagle Flag England 26 Aug 15 1.47pm

I think with Van Dijk the only question now is where he goes, and what's the knock-on effect for the club that buys him (i.e. if he joins Southampton, does Fonte leave?)

There are plenty of serviceable, Premier League experienced full backs who could be had. Lescott and Evans to name but two.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

alffy Flag 26 Aug 15 6.58pm

Don't want to be picky but I think you mean 'Centre Halfs' as 'Full Backs' are Left and right backs.

 

minted 26 Aug 15 7.22pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 26 Aug 2015 1.47pm

I think with Van Dijk the only question now is where he goes, and what's the knock-on effect for the club that buys him (i.e. if he joins Southampton, does Fonte leave?)

There are plenty of serviceable, Premier League experienced full backs who could be had. Lescott and Evans to name but two.

I've seen this guy a lot. Take it from me, he aint that good. Avoid.


 

samprior Flag Hamburg 26 Aug 15 8.05pm

Quote minted at 26 Aug 2015 7.22pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 26 Aug 2015 1.47pm

I think with Van Dijk the only question now is where he goes, and what's the knock-on effect for the club that buys him (i.e. if he joins Southampton, does Fonte leave?)

There are plenty of serviceable, Premier League experienced full backs who could be had. Lescott and Evans to name but two.

I've seen this guy a lot. Take it from me, he aint that good. Avoid.


Interesting.

All i've seen is his highlights reel, where obviously he looks like a world beater (albeit more attacking highlights than defensive) but I did wonder why no one else has shown any concrete interest other than Southampton. I saw a quote today stating he was one of Europes top defenders, which seems odd when there's been top teams looking for a CB all offseason but haven't even sniffed round him.

 

Sg Bilko Flag Deurne Holland 26 Aug 15 8.17pm

Quote minted at 26 Aug 2015 7.22pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 26 Aug 2015 1.47pm

I think with Van Dijk the only question now is where he goes, and what's the knock-on effect for the club that buys him (i.e. if he joins Southampton, does Fonte leave?)

There are plenty of serviceable, Premier League experienced full backs who could be had. Lescott and Evans to name but two.

I've seen this guy a lot. Take it from me, he aint that good. Avoid.


I second that, he is well down the pecking order for the Dutch national side with the likes of Martins Indi, Stefan de Vrij, Jeffrey Bruma, Joël Veltman, Paul Verhaegh, and Terence Kongolo, well ahead of Virgil Van Dijk, whose played 4 times for Jong Oranij and has not been able to make that step up to the next level.

 

NickinOX Flag Sailing country. 26 Aug 15 8.46pm

We only seem to be linked to him because of some previous pretty vague rumours. People only seem to want him because we've previously been linked. It's strange.

 


If you come to a fork in the road, take it.

dougster Flag 27 Aug 15 1.40pm

Quote Sg Bilko at 26 Aug 2015 8.17pm

Quote minted at 26 Aug 2015 7.22pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 26 Aug 2015 1.47pm

I think with Van Dijk the only question now is where he goes, and what's the knock-on effect for the club that buys him (i.e. if he joins Southampton, does Fonte leave?)

There are plenty of serviceable, Premier League experienced full backs who could be had. Lescott and Evans to name but two.

I've seen this guy a lot. Take it from me, he aint that good. Avoid.


I second that, he is well down the pecking order for the Dutch national side with the likes of Martins Indi, Stefan de Vrij, Jeffrey Bruma, Joël Veltman, Paul Verhaegh, and Terence Kongolo, well ahead of Virgil Van Dijk, whose played 4 times for Jong Oranij and has not been able to make that step up to the next level.

I have watched a good number of Celtic games over past couple of years and I'd have to disagree.

If Stones is worth £35M+ - he is a bargain for £11M.

A Dann & Van Dijk partnership would be immense.

 

cooleagle89 Flag Montrose 27 Aug 15 1.57pm

I am with you on that

Quote dougster at 27 Aug 2015 1.40pm

Quote Sg Bilko at 26 Aug 2015 8.17pm

Quote minted at 26 Aug 2015 7.22pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 26 Aug 2015 1.47pm

I think with Van Dijk the only question now is where he goes, and what's the knock-on effect for the club that buys him (i.e. if he joins Southampton, does Fonte leave?)

There are plenty of serviceable, Premier League experienced full backs who could be had. Lescott and Evans to name but two.

I've seen this guy a lot. Take it from me, he aint that good. Avoid.


I second that, he is well down the pecking order for the Dutch national side with the likes of Martins Indi, Stefan de Vrij, Jeffrey Bruma, Joël Veltman, Paul Verhaegh, and Terence Kongolo, well ahead of Virgil Van Dijk, whose played 4 times for Jong Oranij and has not been able to make that step up to the next level.

I have watched a good number of Celtic games over past couple of years and I'd have to disagree.

If Stones is worth £35M+ - he is a bargain for £11M.

A Dann & Van Dijk partnership would be immense.


 

sickboy Flag Deal or Croydon 27 Aug 15 2.31pm

you have to factor in the standard of league he is playing in as well. ie scot prem = not very good so average players look tip top.

 

europalace Flag Europe 27 Aug 15 8.18pm

Quote sickboy at 27 Aug 2015 2.31pm

you have to factor in the standard of league he is playing in as well. ie scot prem = not very good so average players look tip top.

Isn't that where Speroni came from? By your conclusion he's "not very good"


 

sickboy Flag Deal or Croydon 27 Aug 15 8.57pm

Quote europalace at 27 Aug 2015 8.18pm

Quote sickboy at 27 Aug 2015 2.31pm

you have to factor in the standard of league he is playing in as well. ie scot prem = not very good so average players look tip top.

Isn't that where Speroni came from? By your conclusion he's "not very good"


Over 10 years ago, and he wasnt great when he first came down. Are you seriously saying that the sot prem is a good standard? Imho most of their prem teams would struggle against top half champ teams down here.

 

deflemonkid Flag 27 Aug 15 9.41pm

Quote sickboy at 27 Aug 2015 8.57pm

Quote europalace at 27 Aug 2015 8.18pm

Quote sickboy at 27 Aug 2015 2.31pm

you have to factor in the standard of league he is playing in as well. ie scot prem = not very good so average players look tip top.

Isn't that where Speroni came from? By your conclusion he's "not very good"


Over 10 years ago, and he wasnt great when he first came down. Are you seriously saying that the sot prem is a good standard? Imho most of their prem teams would struggle against top half champ teams down here.


Average players may look great against poor opposition but you're neglecting the fact that great players can also make the step up from a lower standard of competition. Just look at where the players in our own squad that were part of the promotion side came from and still dont look out of place in the PL, and lest we forget Punch came all the way up form league one with Southampton.

Edited by deflemonkid (27 Aug 2015 9.41pm)

 

sickboy Flag Deal or Croydon 27 Aug 15 9.54pm

Quote deflemonkid at 27 Aug 2015 9.41pm

Quote sickboy at 27 Aug 2015 8.57pm

Quote europalace at 27 Aug 2015 8.18pm

Quote sickboy at 27 Aug 2015 2.31pm

you have to factor in the standard of league he is playing in as well. ie scot prem = not very good so average players look tip top.

Isn't that where Speroni came from? By your conclusion he's "not very good"


Over 10 years ago, and he wasnt great when he first came down. Are you seriously saying that the sot prem is a good standard? Imho most of their prem teams would struggle against top half champ teams down here.


Average players may look great against poor opposition but you're neglecting the fact that great players can also make the step up from a lower standard of competition. Just look at where the players in our own squad that were part of the promotion side came from and still dont look out of place in the PL, and lest we forget Punch came all the way up form league one with Southampton.

Edited by deflemonkid (27 Aug 2015 9.41pm)


Over a period of time they can improve but it is a big step up to the prem to be consistantly good. Look at other threads on here to see the difference of opinion over Gayle. It takes time and personally i dont think virgil is that great. I also pointed out that our championship is probably a higher standard than the scot prem so therefore the step up to our premier league is not so great. How many players have come down from the spl in recent years and had an effect? Its a bigger step up in class than from the champ .

 

deflemonkid Flag 27 Aug 15 10.11pm

Quote sickboy at 27 Aug 2015 9.54pm

Quote deflemonkid at 27 Aug 2015 9.41pm

Quote sickboy at 27 Aug 2015 8.57pm

Quote europalace at 27 Aug 2015 8.18pm

Quote sickboy at 27 Aug 2015 2.31pm

you have to factor in the standard of league he is playing in as well. ie scot prem = not very good so average players look tip top.

Isn't that where Speroni came from? By your conclusion he's "not very good"


Over 10 years ago, and he wasnt great when he first came down. Are you seriously saying that the sot prem is a good standard? Imho most of their prem teams would struggle against top half champ teams down here.


Average players may look great against poor opposition but you're neglecting the fact that great players can also make the step up from a lower standard of competition. Just look at where the players in our own squad that were part of the promotion side came from and still dont look out of place in the PL, and lest we forget Punch came all the way up form league one with Southampton.

Edited by deflemonkid (27 Aug 2015 9.41pm)


Over a period of time they can improve but it is a big step up to the prem to be consistantly good. Look at other threads on here to see the difference of opinion over Gayle. It takes time and personally i dont think virgil is that great. I also pointed out that our championship is probably a higher standard than the scot prem so therefore the step up to our premier league is not so great. How many players have come down from the spl in recent years and had an effect? Its a bigger step up in class than from the champ .


joe ledley didnt seem to have a problem. James Macarthur went from Hamilton to wigan when he first moved to England and didnt do to bad. Steven fletcher and charlie adam are another couple that made the step up. I dont think the level of competition you play against is going to be the defining factor to whether or not Pardew or any of the scouts/coaches think a play can cut it in the PL.

 

Page 3 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Transfer Talk > Virgil Van Dijk (papertalk)