Quote Stirlingsays at 14 Mar 2015 12.31pm
Quote Johnny Eagles at 14 Mar 2015 11.36am
Quote Stirlingsays at 13 Mar 2015 8.47pm
Quote Johnny Eagles at 13 Mar 2015 7.59pm
F*ck off red nose day. F*ck off tedious celebrity c*nts demanding public praise for grabbing the limelight and cynically exploiting people less well off than them. F*ck off broadcasters bullying people into giving to charities of their choosing. F*ck off zany "charideee mate" cheerleaders dragooning people into having "fun" and making them feel bad if they don't. Red Nose Day is the OPPOSITE of what charity is supposed to be about you C*NTS!!!
Edited by Johnny Eagles (13 Mar 2015 8.05pm)
Mmmm....I think the veil slipped a little here Herr Eagles.
Please elaborate what you mean by this.
For the record, I would like to categorically state I have no issue with where Comic Relief sends the money and do not agree with the "we need to sort our own out first" argument made by others on this thread.
I dislike Comic Relief because:
1. I think charity should be a private matter, not a big public jamboree with celebrities (whose charitable motivations happily coincide with appearances on the broadcast media)
2. I think it's a Christian or civic duty and a matter of conscience, not something you dragoon people into doing by bullying them into having "fun"
I can't agree with your position upon charity shows because essentially the practical outcome of this would be less take for charities. Human nature is to ignore negative messages. Taking these shows off air would essentially be removing 'positive' spins on hard subjects...The jollying people along to give factor.....It would result in less take.
Sure it's the duty of any reasonable person who has the means to give to charities they feel an affinity with. These people would do this anyway. But does everyone? Nope, there are a lot of very selfish people out there with very little conscience.
I say good on these collective appeals that use celebrity to secure funding for situations of need.
Your personal discomfort means nothing really in the scheme of things. This is just one of many minor irritations an adult puts up with. We have been gifted opportunities in life by the dice of chance and I personally think that being reminded of this once in a while is fine....None of us is any more worthy of life than a child starving in a hellhole.....Yours are the moanings of the relatively secure.
Who cares if some celebrates ride on the back of the events......All that matters is the practical result.
As for the veil comment. It's suggests that you are revealing that you feel socially resentful in socially 'positive' events......In other words, you're basically saying you're a curmudgeon.
Some people try to put a little bit of light into the world for a good cause...Celebrities or not, motive or not......So what?...Good on em. Maybe a child somewhere will live longer for it.
Edited by Stirlingsays (14 Mar 2015 12.45pm)
"All that matters is the practical result."
Are you sure you mean that? So, by your logic, if we sent round gangs of celebrities with baseball bats to demand money from people less well off than them, that would be ok? I'm sure you'd generate big sums for "charity" so it must be.
I'm exaggerating to make a point: where does your "jollying people along" cross the line into "bullying people"?
You can stick a red nose on a comedian and call it "jollying", but it comes down to the same thing, in my book. It's a form of coercion.
I also question the idea that watching some celebrity make a fool of himself and then being guilt-tripped into making a credit card donation from my sofa is true "charity".
I agree with William Blake:
"He who would do good to another, must do it in Minute Particulars. General Good is the plea of the scoundrel, hypocrite, and flatterer."
and with St. Paul in his letter to the Corinthians:
"charity vaunteth not itself, is not puffed up"
That is, I think people should DO things for one another, especially those less fortunate for them, in the form of everyday kindness. They should not make a fuss about it. Rather than making a credit card donation once a year because someone from Strictly has guilt tripped them into it.
I suspect if everyone was persuaded of the former, rather than the latter then the "practical result" which you find so important, would also be better in the long run.
As for your ad hominem point about me being a "curmudgeon" (I expect you to do better than that, Stirling) it struck me rather as the kind of thing all the people going to a nazi rally might have said about those that didn't want to join in. It's a nasty form of groupthink coercion. "Join in or we'll call you names!"
...we must expand...get more pupils...so that the knowledge will spread...
|