You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > 2015 budget
November 22 2026 2.07am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

2015 budget


Page 3 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
OknotOK Flag Cockfosters, London 19 Mar 15 2.16pm

Quote Charlie Croker at 19 Mar 2015 1.53pm

Quote Turd Alert at 19 Mar 2015 1.29pm

i think a question i wish to ask tonight will surround the budget, and if it has overlooked my generation (i am 21)

i.e - housing still unnafordable / too much demand - not enough supply

'Saving ISA' - cap at £3k only get if you put in 200pounds a month.. to get full ammount would have to save until april 2020 - not actually beneficial.

anyone have any thoughts/suggestions on this?

Maybe it's a generational thing, but it sounds (on the face of it, I haven't done too much research) like not a bad deal.

I would have thought it was actually very beneficial. Save £12K and we'll give you another £3K?

Okay, in house price terms that's a drop in the ocean, but also a 25% return over 4.5 years, better than you'd get if you were just saving with the bank/building society.

And it's doubled if you're a couple and both do this. F*ck - I wish that had been available when I was buying.

I will be encouraging my son (just starting work) to think seriously about this, in 5 years he and his girlfriend could have £30K, with £6K from David & George (sounds like a bad 60's pop duo).

The real issue in this though is affordability. With house price differences around the country - the same ISA will be of more benefit depending on where you want to live. A better q would be linked to the ISA, but with a "thanks for that, but what are you going to do to make cheaper housing stock available?"

I don't think it is a generational thing - it *is* a very good deal. It just won't actually have a positive outcome for helping people onto the housing ladder. £3k (or £6k if a couple) won't be enough to make the difference in terms of deposit, and it doesn't address the fundamental issue which is (as you've indicated) the lack of supply.

For years and years we have been crying out for a radical solution. It doesn't have to be public sector building; private sector building is perfectly acceptable but to do so then you need to have a step change in the regulatory regime and some inducements to home builders.

Instead we get the government chucking £3k at FTB. It is a joke, as has been housing policy in successive governments since the 70s.

 


"It's almost like a moral decision. Except not really cos noone is going to find out," Jez, Peep Show

We are goin up! Flag Coulsdon 19 Mar 15 2.18pm

Quote OknotOK at 19 Mar 2015 12.10pm

Had his deficit reduction plan from 2010 been in any way successful then he would have been able to make big giveaways now. The fact it has failed spectacularly means he can't and campaigns like the UKIP one attached are credible mockery of Tory claims in 2010.

Given Labour haven't announced their manifesto then I think it's unreasonable to expect their economic plan to be clear at this point. But there is a credibility gap for all the parties now. The cuts that are going to be required per the OBR in the next 2 years mean people have to be much more transparent - especially the Tories - over what is going to be cut and what is not.

And people shouldn't fail to acknowledge how lucky George Osborne has been - especially in the last year. Inflation falling away, driven by an absolute collapse now in the price of oil; and virtually zero inflation meaning that real wages are increasing for example.

Edited by OknotOK (19 Mar 2015 12.26pm)


In what way has it failed spectacularly? Are you suggesting that he should have cut the deficit slower, and therefore more than doubled the debt? Or did you want him to cut it faster? This line that UKIP and Labour are trotting out about the debt having doubled abandons even a basic understanding on spending and economics. Of course the debt has ballooned, borrowing is at record levels because we have a massive deficit. It's pretty simple.

Osborne has hardly been lucky either. His biggest trading partner (the EU) has a massive issue with demand, we need exports to prosper and he's got a world economy struggling with purchasing as a backdrop. It's hardly been all rosy. We're performing better than everyone else for having adopted his policies, if you judge purely on results you have to say he is delivering as Chancellor. Whether you like his ideologies and how he got there is another matter.

 


The problem with socialism is that you eventually run out of other people's money.

Turd Alert Flag Woldingham 19 Mar 15 2.25pm

Quote Charlie Croker at 19 Mar 2015 1.53pm

Quote Turd Alert at 19 Mar 2015 1.29pm

i think a question i wish to ask tonight will surround the budget, and if it has overlooked my generation (i am 21)

i.e - housing still unnafordable / too much demand - not enough supply

'Saving ISA' - cap at £3k only get if you put in 200pounds a month.. to get full ammount would have to save until april 2020 - not actually beneficial.

anyone have any thoughts/suggestions on this?

Maybe it's a generational thing, but it sounds (on the face of it, I haven't done too much research) like not a bad deal.

I would have thought it was actually very beneficial. Save £12K and we'll give you another £3K?

Okay, in house price terms that's a drop in the ocean, but also a 25% return over 4.5 years, better than you'd get if you were just saving with the bank/building society.

And it's doubled if you're a couple and both do this. F*ck - I wish that had been available when I was buying.

I will be encouraging my son (just starting work) to think seriously about this, in 5 years he and his girlfriend could have £30K, with £6K from David & George (sounds like a bad 60's pop duo).

The real issue in this though is affordability. With house price differences around the country - the same ISA will be of more benefit depending on where you want to live. A better q would be linked to the ISA, but with a "thanks for that, but what are you going to do to make cheaper housing stock available?"

The only issue for me is the length. You will only gain that after 4 years of saving. If i saved with an idea to move out in 2 years then it is not quite as handy! Plus you are commiting to an isa for 4 years and rates may shoot up, you never know!

more over, i am on an apprenticeship and believe you me the salary is absolutely atrocious, how i am expected to save that much on top of paying rent and traveling to work (in london) with no disoc*** paying full price is absurd. Minimum wage is £2.73 yet i am expected to live like every other perosn on a salary almost treble mine!

Just infuriates me!

The idea is a good one, but i do not think it its quite as good as it sounds

 


RIP staffie

OknotOK Flag Cockfosters, London 19 Mar 15 2.48pm

Quote We are goin up! at 19 Mar 2015 2.18pm

Quote OknotOK at 19 Mar 2015 12.10pm

Had his deficit reduction plan from 2010 been in any way successful then he would have been able to make big giveaways now. The fact it has failed spectacularly means he can't and campaigns like the UKIP one attached are credible mockery of Tory claims in 2010.

Given Labour haven't announced their manifesto then I think it's unreasonable to expect their economic plan to be clear at this point. But there is a credibility gap for all the parties now. The cuts that are going to be required per the OBR in the next 2 years mean people have to be much more transparent - especially the Tories - over what is going to be cut and what is not.

And people shouldn't fail to acknowledge how lucky George Osborne has been - especially in the last year. Inflation falling away, driven by an absolute collapse now in the price of oil; and virtually zero inflation meaning that real wages are increasing for example.

Edited by OknotOK (19 Mar 2015 12.26pm)


In what way has it failed spectacularly? Are you suggesting that he should have cut the deficit slower, and therefore more than doubled the debt? Or did you want him to cut it faster? This line that UKIP and Labour are trotting out about the debt having doubled abandons even a basic understanding on spending and economics. Of course the debt has ballooned, borrowing is at record levels because we have a massive deficit. It's pretty simple.

Osborne has hardly been lucky either. His biggest trading partner (the EU) has a massive issue with demand, we need exports to prosper and he's got a world economy struggling with purchasing as a backdrop. It's hardly been all rosy. We're performing better than everyone else for having adopted his policies, if you judge purely on results you have to say he is delivering as Chancellor. Whether you like his ideologies and how he got there is another matter.

He failed spectacularly because he failed spectacularly to meet his own targets. Indeed in 2010 he was slating the Darling/Brown plans for putting us at risk financially due to massive over borrowing. He has ended up borrowing significantly more in the same period. So by his own targets he has failed spectacularly.

And saying that debt has doubled abandons no such thing. In 5 years he borrowed more that Labour did in 13. That is factual. So again by his own standards and targets he failed spectacularly.

And the deficit - which he had said would now be £37bn is actually about 2.5 times that (£91bn). So again he has failed spectacularly on his own targets.

As I said, whether you think that is due to external factors, his policies, or previous administration policies will help decide how you vote.

In terms of delivering as a chancellor, the only measure he can be seen to have been a success is on jobs. He has overseen the slowest recovery in UK history (with the exception I think of the one after the Black Death) and has failed to rebalance the economy, significantly reduce the trade deficit (other than through external factors), or improve productivity.

In terms of who is performing best, the UK currently has the best performing economy in the G7, but over the period lags miles behind the US, Canada, and Germany. I think we're still behind France but would have to check.

I accept that he has had challenges in the entire period, but the last year he has been very fortunate. And probably at just the right time for election purposes.

 


"It's almost like a moral decision. Except not really cos noone is going to find out," Jez, Peep Show

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 19 Mar 15 5.41pm

[Link]

 

Pawson Palace Flag Croydon 20 Mar 15 9.37am

Quote nickgusset at 19 Mar 2015 5.41pm

[Link]


Considering the leader of the green's doesn't even know her own manifesto or the numbers behind it, I find this somewhat amusing they would thrown stones whilst sat in their shiney glass house.

 


Pride of South London
Upper Holmesdale Block P

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 20 Mar 15 9.55am

Quote OknotOK at 19 Mar 2015 2.48pm

In terms of delivering as a chancellor, the only measure he can be seen to have been a success is on jobs.

Total and utter bilge, the likes of which we heard from Miliband after the Budget.

I could trot out a load of statistics which would bore all and sundry on here so I shall refrain from doing so.

All I will say is that it has been a terrific success story but of course there is more to be done.
Over to you chaps ! I will only raise all your hackles if I get on my political "Soapbox" so I shall stick to the football and not get embroiled in the political debate!!!!


 

OknotOK Flag Cockfosters, London 20 Mar 15 10.37am

Quote Willo at 20 Mar 2015 9.55am

Quote OknotOK at 19 Mar 2015 2.48pm

In terms of delivering as a chancellor, the only measure he can be seen to have been a success is on jobs.

Total and utter bilge, the likes of which we heard from Miliband after the Budget.

I could trot out a load of statistics which would bore all and sundry on here so I shall refrain from doing so.

All I will say is that it has been a terrific success story but of course there is more to be done.
Over to you chaps ! I will only raise all your hackles if I get on my political "Soapbox" so I shall stick to the football and not get embroiled in the political debate!!!!


Ummmm except you just did "get embroiled in a political debate".

And you're still wrong. I'm not judging George Osborne on anything other than his own targets and his own guidance. And the only measure he can point to as a success on that basis is job creation. Everything else he has massively missed his own targets/expectations.

Like I said, you don't have to think he is culpable for that. Feel free to think he has done a splendid job based upon horrific conditions and the Eurozone collapsing around him. But by his own criteria - set out when he had been in office for several months - he has failed to live up to expectations.

And for the record I won't be voting (and haven't ever voted) for Labour at a general election.

 


"It's almost like a moral decision. Except not really cos noone is going to find out," Jez, Peep Show

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 20 Mar 15 10.46am

Quote OknotOK at 20 Mar 2015 10.37am

Quote Willo at 20 Mar 2015 9.55am

Quote OknotOK at 19 Mar 2015 2.48pm

In terms of delivering as a chancellor, the only measure he can be seen to have been a success is on jobs.

Total and utter bilge, the likes of which we heard from Miliband after the Budget.

I could trot out a load of statistics which would bore all and sundry on here so I shall refrain from doing so.

All I will say is that it has been a terrific success story but of course there is more to be done.
Over to you chaps ! I will only raise all your hackles if I get on my political "Soapbox" so I shall stick to the football and not get embroiled in the political debate!!!!


Ummmm except you just did "get embroiled in a political debate".

And you're still wrong. I'm not judging George Osborne on anything other than his own targets and his own guidance. And the only measure he can point to as a success on that basis is job creation. Everything else he has massively missed his own targets/expectations.

Like I said, you don't have to think he is culpable for that. Feel free to think he has done a splendid job based upon horrific conditions and the Eurozone collapsing around him. But by his own criteria - set out when he had been in office for several months - he has failed to live up to expectations.

And for the record I won't be voting (and haven't ever voted) for Labour at a general election.

Completely agree that he hasn’t met the targets that he set…but the economy is moving in the right direction as a result of the policies he put in place.

If anyone of us said we wanted to reduce our credit card bill by x thousand and only managed y thousand its not a failure…it’s a smaller than anticipated success. The issue is still smaller than when you started.

For people to cite falling short of original targets whilst in the process conveniently ignoring that progress has still been made really says much much more about the weakness of their arguments than anything else.

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

Hoof Hearted 20 Mar 15 10.51am

Quote OknotOK at 20 Mar 2015 10.37am

Quote Willo at 20 Mar 2015 9.55am

Quote OknotOK at 19 Mar 2015 2.48pm

In terms of delivering as a chancellor, the only measure he can be seen to have been a success is on jobs.

Total and utter bilge, the likes of which we heard from Miliband after the Budget.

I could trot out a load of statistics which would bore all and sundry on here so I shall refrain from doing so.

All I will say is that it has been a terrific success story but of course there is more to be done.
Over to you chaps ! I will only raise all your hackles if I get on my political "Soapbox" so I shall stick to the football and not get embroiled in the political debate!!!!


Ummmm except you just did "get embroiled in a political debate".

And you're still wrong. I'm not judging George Osborne on anything other than his own targets and his own guidance. And the only measure he can point to as a success on that basis is job creation. Everything else he has massively missed his own targets/expectations.

Like I said, you don't have to think he is culpable for that. Feel free to think he has done a splendid job based upon horrific conditions and the Eurozone collapsing around him. But by his own criteria - set out when he had been in office for several months - he has failed to live up to expectations.

And for the record I won't be voting (and haven't ever voted) for Labour at a general election.

You could judge Osborne by how he has performed versus the previous Labour chancellors and conclude that he has managed to clear up a lot of their mess.

I note you distance yourself from Labour, and by deduction you won't be voting Tory I guess?

Who are you voting for?

 

OknotOK Flag Cockfosters, London 20 Mar 15 11.20am

Quote Lyons550 at 20 Mar 2015 10.46am

For people to cite falling short of original targets whilst in the process conveniently ignoring that progress has still been made really says much much more about the weakness of their arguments than anything else.

As I said, I don't pass judgement on the progress. I am simply stating that by his own targets he has failed. And miserably.

In fact even by the definition you have given he has failed, given his deficit and debt reduction achievements are both below that specified by Labour in 2010 (which he said was dangerous and fiscally irresponsible).

I don't know whether George Osborne deserves credit or criticism. Overall it is probably a big dollop of both.

As to who I would be voting for at the next GE; to be honest I haven't fully decided. But I sit in Northern Ireland Minister Theresa Villiers consituency. She has a majority of 12,000 and there is about as much chance of my vote influencing my next MP either way as there is of Nick Clegg being the next PM.

Edited by OknotOK (20 Mar 2015 11.37am)

 


"It's almost like a moral decision. Except not really cos noone is going to find out," Jez, Peep Show

Johnny Eagles Flag berlin 20 Mar 15 11.24am

I think it's a bit rich for Labour to have a go at Osborne for "missing his targets", ie not eliminating the deficit.

They spent the first couple of years shouting "too far, too fast" at loud volume and insisting he move to "Plan B". Which he then effectively did. Just, for obvious political reasons, pretending it was still "plan A".

They should make more of the fact that he's basically done what Darling / Balls said should be done. It's right-wing hawks who should be moaning about him missing his targets.

But I guess that doesn't win as many votes.

 


...we must expand...get more pupils...so that the knowledge will spread...

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 20 Mar 15 11.44am

Quote OknotOK at 20 Mar 2015 11.20am

Quote Lyons550 at 20 Mar 2015 10.46am

For people to cite falling short of original targets whilst in the process conveniently ignoring that progress has still been made really says much much more about the weakness of their arguments than anything else.

As I said, I don't pass judgement on the progress. I am simply stating that by his own targets he has failed. And miserably.

In fact even by the definition you have given he has failed, given his deficit and debt reduction achievements are both below that specified by Labour in 2010 (which he said was dangerous and fiscally irresponsible).

I don't know whether George Osborne deserves credit or criticism. Overall it is probably a big dollop of both.

As to who I would be voting for at the next GE; to be honest I haven't fully decided. But I sit in Northern Ireland Minister Theresa Villiers consituency. She has a majority of 12,000 and there is about as much chance of my vote influencing my next MP either way as there is of Nick Clegg being the next PM.

Edited by OknotOK (20 Mar 2015 11.37am)


Yeah I wasn't actually point the finger at you OK but to anyone trying to put an unreasonably negative spin on the matter.

As I said earlier I totally agree that he failed to meet his targets...but the term 'miserably' is just to exaggerate the matter unnecessarily.

As you suggest a term more along the lines of 'could do better' is probably most apt and something that we could all identify with.

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

serial thriller Flag The Promised Land 20 Mar 15 1.27pm

Over half of the people in poverty are in work - that is an astonishing statistic. It's all well and good creating more jobs than the rest of the EU, but what's the point if people are still unable to pay for living essentials?

 


If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4

Johnny Eagles Flag berlin 20 Mar 15 2.12pm

Quote serial thriller at 20 Mar 2015 1.27pm

Over half of the people in poverty are in work - that is an astonishing statistic. It's all well and good creating more jobs than the rest of the EU, but what's the point if people are still unable to pay for living essentials?


It's only astonishing until you realise that "poverty" is a relative definition, deliberately skewed so that lefties will permanently have a drum to beat.

It's like when they defined "homeless" children as those not having their own bedroom!

Edited by Johnny Eagles (20 Mar 2015 2.13pm)

 


...we must expand...get more pupils...so that the knowledge will spread...

ghosteagle Flag 20 Mar 15 2.26pm

Quote serial thriller at 20 Mar 2015 1.27pm

Over half of the people in poverty are in work - that is an astonishing statistic. It's all well and good creating more jobs than the rest of the EU, but what's the point if people are still unable to pay for living essentials?


Absolutely shocking indeed, just shows how empty claims of an economic revival are. Disgusting.

 

Pawson Palace Flag Croydon 20 Mar 15 2.43pm

Isn't the bottom X percentile deemed to be in poverty??

Kind of a pointless statistic really.

I bet more than half still have Sky, Xbox and a HD TV mind...

 


Pride of South London
Upper Holmesdale Block P

Johnny Eagles Flag berlin 20 Mar 15 2.48pm

Quote Pawson Palace at 20 Mar 2015 2.43pm

Isn't the bottom X percentile deemed to be in poverty??

Kind of a pointless statistic really.

I bet more than half still have Sky, Xbox and a HD TV mind...


It's less than 60% of median income.

Median income = 26,500
60% of that = 15,900

That's about 1,325 quid a month.

Not exactly the life of riley but not the world of flea-infested children with rickets that the word "poverty" conjures up either.

 


...we must expand...get more pupils...so that the knowledge will spread...

ghosteagle Flag 20 Mar 15 2.49pm

Quote Pawson Palace at 20 Mar 2015 2.43pm

Isn't the bottom X percentile deemed to be in poverty??

Kind of a pointless statistic really.

I bet more than half still have Sky, Xbox and a HD TV mind...

Definitions of poverty seem to be arbitrary and depend on who is giving them.

 

serial thriller Flag The Promised Land 20 Mar 15 2.50pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 20 Mar 2015 2.12pm

Quote serial thriller at 20 Mar 2015 1.27pm

Over half of the people in poverty are in work - that is an astonishing statistic. It's all well and good creating more jobs than the rest of the EU, but what's the point if people are still unable to pay for living essentials?


It's only astonishing until you realise that "poverty" is a relative definition, deliberately skewed so that lefties will permanently have a drum to beat.

It's like when they defined "homeless" children as those not having their own bedroom!

Edited by Johnny Eagles (20 Mar 2015 2.13pm)


Johnny come on, you are usually better than that. Relative poverty is a very serious issue, and not just some stick dreamt up by lefties to beat Tories with. It is really a measure of wealth inequality, based on whether your income is less than 60% of the average, thus meaning your share of wealth in relation to the national pie leaves you living without access to what would be considered an acceptable standard of living by most of us.

One of the interesting things about the economic statistics is to look at where jobs are being created. 80% have been in London since 2010, where rents are highest, cost of living highest, etc. This is, unsurprisingly, where income levels have fallen most dramatically too since 2010, and how exactly are you meant to pay your rent, travel and bills in one of the most expensive cities on the planet when you're most probably in a job which pays £6.50 an hour? Answer:you ain't going to, thus you are either forced to move you and your family away from an area despite the fact that you have a full time job, or you become reliant on a food bank to pay for food and the welfare state to top you up. That is detrimental to the wider economy, and while you can call it what you want, I think poverty is probably the most appropriate word for it.

Edited by serial thriller (20 Mar 2015 2.55pm)

 


If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4

Page 3 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > 2015 budget