Quote We are goin up! at 19 Mar 2015 2.18pm
Quote OknotOK at 19 Mar 2015 12.10pm
Had his deficit reduction plan from 2010 been in any way successful then he would have been able to make big giveaways now. The fact it has failed spectacularly means he can't and campaigns like the UKIP one attached are credible mockery of Tory claims in 2010.
Given Labour haven't announced their manifesto then I think it's unreasonable to expect their economic plan to be clear at this point. But there is a credibility gap for all the parties now. The cuts that are going to be required per the OBR in the next 2 years mean people have to be much more transparent - especially the Tories - over what is going to be cut and what is not.
And people shouldn't fail to acknowledge how lucky George Osborne has been - especially in the last year. Inflation falling away, driven by an absolute collapse now in the price of oil; and virtually zero inflation meaning that real wages are increasing for example.
Edited by OknotOK (19 Mar 2015 12.26pm)
In what way has it failed spectacularly? Are you suggesting that he should have cut the deficit slower, and therefore more than doubled the debt? Or did you want him to cut it faster? This line that UKIP and Labour are trotting out about the debt having doubled abandons even a basic understanding on spending and economics. Of course the debt has ballooned, borrowing is at record levels because we have a massive deficit. It's pretty simple.
Osborne has hardly been lucky either. His biggest trading partner (the EU) has a massive issue with demand, we need exports to prosper and he's got a world economy struggling with purchasing as a backdrop. It's hardly been all rosy. We're performing better than everyone else for having adopted his policies, if you judge purely on results you have to say he is delivering as Chancellor. Whether you like his ideologies and how he got there is another matter.
He failed spectacularly because he failed spectacularly to meet his own targets. Indeed in 2010 he was slating the Darling/Brown plans for putting us at risk financially due to massive over borrowing. He has ended up borrowing significantly more in the same period. So by his own targets he has failed spectacularly.
And saying that debt has doubled abandons no such thing. In 5 years he borrowed more that Labour did in 13. That is factual. So again by his own standards and targets he failed spectacularly.
And the deficit - which he had said would now be £37bn is actually about 2.5 times that (£91bn). So again he has failed spectacularly on his own targets.
As I said, whether you think that is due to external factors, his policies, or previous administration policies will help decide how you vote.
In terms of delivering as a chancellor, the only measure he can be seen to have been a success is on jobs. He has overseen the slowest recovery in UK history (with the exception I think of the one after the Black Death) and has failed to rebalance the economy, significantly reduce the trade deficit (other than through external factors), or improve productivity.
In terms of who is performing best, the UK currently has the best performing economy in the G7, but over the period lags miles behind the US, Canada, and Germany. I think we're still behind France but would have to check.
I accept that he has had challenges in the entire period, but the last year he has been very fortunate. And probably at just the right time for election purposes.
"It's almost like a moral decision. Except not really cos noone is going to find out," Jez, Peep Show
|