You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Bali Nine
November 22 2026 2.07am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Bali Nine


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
Jimenez Flag SELHURSTPARKCHESTER,DA BRONX 29 Apr 15 9.59pm

Couldn't see a thread on this subject. I'm kind of surprised that this hasn't raised too many eye brows. I'm convinced if this had been done in The USA all the liberals & Lefties would have been out in force condemning it in the strongest possible way.


[Link]

 


Pro USA & Israel

gerry theagle Flag newbury 29 Apr 15 10.22pm

No Brits involved so I guess not a lot of interest, but we do have a woman on a death row in Indonesia so things may change.Sad but these people do know the stakes.

 

legaleagle Flag 29 Apr 15 10.36pm

Quote Jimenez at 29 Apr 2015 9.59pm

Couldn't see a thread on this subject. I'm kind of surprised that this hasn't raised too many eye brows. I'm convinced if this had been done in The USA all the liberals & Lefties would have been out in force condemning it in the strongest possible way.


[Link]


Do you personally think the death sentence is appropriate for drug offences,Jimenez? Bear in mind,if a miscarriage of justice (and they do happen) comes out later,its too late for the accused.In the case of one of those scheduled to be killed,a new witness came forward at the 11th hour and their execution has been suspended.Day or two later and it would have been irrelevant...

Or is someone automatically to be dismissed as a "liberal" or a "leftie" for simply raising the point?

Edited by legaleagle (29 Apr 2015 10.38pm)

 

Jimenez Flag SELHURSTPARKCHESTER,DA BRONX 29 Apr 15 10.45pm

Quote legaleagle at 29 Apr 2015 10.36pm

Quote Jimenez at 29 Apr 2015 9.59pm

Couldn't see a thread on this subject. I'm kind of surprised that this hasn't raised too many eye brows. I'm convinced if this had been done in The USA all the liberals & Lefties would have been out in force condemning it in the strongest possible way.


[Link]


Do you personally think the death sentence is appropriate for drug offences,Jimenez? Bear in mind,if a miscarriage of justice (and they do happen) comes out later,its too late for the accused.In the case of one of those scheduled to be killed,a new witness came forward at the 11th hour and their execution has been suspended.Day or two later and it would have been irrelevant...

Or is someone automatically to be dismissed as a "liberal" or a "leftie" for simply raising the point?

Edited by legaleagle (29 Apr 2015 10.38pm)


As it happens yes. Anyone caught trafficking drugs in countries where they know there is a chance they are going to get sentenced to death have little sympathy from me, but I digress Legal. My main point was that there has been little news or condemnation from the usual suspects (scuse pun)because this has been carried out in the Far East. The same can be said for executions in North Korea, Saudi Arabia Et al

 


Pro USA & Israel

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 29 Apr 15 10.53pm

Quote Jimenez at 29 Apr 2015 10.45pm

Quote legaleagle at 29 Apr 2015 10.36pm

Quote Jimenez at 29 Apr 2015 9.59pm

Couldn't see a thread on this subject. I'm kind of surprised that this hasn't raised too many eye brows. I'm convinced if this had been done in The USA all the liberals & Lefties would have been out in force condemning it in the strongest possible way.


[Link]


Do you personally think the death sentence is appropriate for drug offences,Jimenez? Bear in mind,if a miscarriage of justice (and they do happen) comes out later,its too late for the accused.In the case of one of those scheduled to be killed,a new witness came forward at the 11th hour and their execution has been suspended.Day or two later and it would have been irrelevant...

Or is someone automatically to be dismissed as a "liberal" or a "leftie" for simply raising the point?

Edited by legaleagle (29 Apr 2015 10.38pm)


As it happens yes. Anyone caught trafficking drugs in countries where they know there is a chance they are going to get sentenced to death have little sympathy from me, but I digress Legal. My main point was that there has been little news or condemnation from the usual suspects (scuse pun)because this has been carried out in the Far East. The same can be said for executions in North Korea, Saudi Arabia Et al

The subject of Saudi Arabia has been broached on many occasions.

 

Eagle_SA Flag Just outside Cape Town 29 Apr 15 11.26pm

Whilst I'm oppossed to the death penalty I think we should be far more concerned about the hundreds of thousands of people addicted to heroin & cocaine rather than worrying about how their dealers are being dealt with.

 


And I see signs of half remembered days, I hear bells that chime in strange familiar ways

Pawson Palace Flag Croydon 30 Apr 15 8.30am

f*** them. They knew the risks and they accepted them when tried it. You can't play the game knowing the rules and then cry because you lost.

The dear old "grandma" tried taking 1.6kg of heroin that's not exactly personal use is it?

Just because she has a British passport does not exonerate her from what she did. They should handle her as they see fit on the grounds she had a fair trial.

 


Pride of South London
Upper Holmesdale Block P

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 30 Apr 15 10.08am

Quote Pawson Palace at 30 Apr 2015 8.30am

f*** them. They knew the risks and they accepted them when tried it. You can't play the game knowing the rules and then cry because you lost.

The dear old "grandma" tried taking 1.6kg of heroin that's not exactly personal use is it?

Just because she has a British passport does not exonerate her from what she did. They should handle her as they see fit on the grounds she had a fair trial.

Where in lies the problem, they don't. At least one of the people sentenced to die has had a last minute reprieve on the basis of evidence corroborating the fact she wasn't aware she was carrying the heroin. Another of the individuals executed suffers from schizophrenia and bipolar disorder.

Generally, when you see countries that have 'very strict' drug laws, those laws generally serve to 'protect' the business from outside competition (In Thailand, the military is effectively at war in the northern region to protect its 'dominance' over the drug trade). Typically those 'punished' are really offered up to show the governments take it seriously.

However for all the crackdowns in the world, the tide of heroin from these countries has never diminished nor the profits which effectively continue to flow into the hands of those in positions of power and authority.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 30 Apr 15 10.10am

Quote Eagle_SA at 29 Apr 2015 11.26pm

Whilst I'm oppossed to the death penalty I think we should be far more concerned about the hundreds of thousands of people addicted to heroin & cocaine rather than worrying about how their dealers are being dealt with.

If we really worried about that, we'd sell them heroin and cocaine via the NHS, which pays about 1/35th of the street price addicts do.

No matter how many dealers you target or take out, addicts find drugs, and drug dealers find sources of drugs.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Hoof Hearted 30 Apr 15 10.34am

Quote Pawson Palace at 30 Apr 2015 8.30am

f*** them. They knew the risks and they accepted them when tried it. You can't play the game knowing the rules and then cry because you lost.

The dear old "grandma" tried taking 1.6kg of heroin that's not exactly personal use is it?

Just because she has a British passport does not exonerate her from what she did. They should handle her as they see fit on the grounds she had a fair trial.


Exactly.

People that deal in drugs have no welfare concerns for those addicted to their poison.... why should we be concerned that they have died?

Hopefully it will be a deterrent to others although I somehow doubt it.

More scum off our streets.

 

npn Flag Crowborough 30 Apr 15 10.41am

1. I oppose the death penalty, but it exists for drug offences in some countries

2. I believe justice in some of those countries is not fairly administered

3. They knew both 1&2 and decided to give it a go anyway - therefore the net result is "unlucky"

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 30 Apr 15 10.57am

Quote npn at 30 Apr 2015 10.41am

1. I oppose the death penalty, but it exists for drug offences in some countries

2. I believe justice in some of those countries is not fairly administered

3. They knew both 1&2 and decided to give it a go anyway - therefore the net result is "unlucky"

Problem with these countries, guilt is often determined by the same people being paid off by the primary drug traffickers. Their 'hardline' really is about protecting the monopoly of the trade, rather than any kind of justice, and frequently their trials involve questionable evidence, forced confessions and limited 'view of what constitutes' guilt. Trials can often be a farce of justice as well, along with the appeals process, and then the whole thing is generally utilized to serve political ambitions.

Reasonable doubt, for example, is rarely a consideration.

And of course usually they're the middle men, between the exporters and the importers. Often 'given up' to make it look like the country is 'doing its bit' - ie expendable costs of doing business. A variation on the Colombian 'Sacrifical Mule' (where in you send two mules on the same flight, and sacrifice one so as to reduce the risk to the primary mule).


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 30 Apr 15 10.58am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 30 Apr 2015 10.34am

Quote Pawson Palace at 30 Apr 2015 8.30am

f*** them. They knew the risks and they accepted them when tried it. You can't play the game knowing the rules and then cry because you lost.

The dear old "grandma" tried taking 1.6kg of heroin that's not exactly personal use is it?

Just because she has a British passport does not exonerate her from what she did. They should handle her as they see fit on the grounds she had a fair trial.


Exactly.

People that deal in drugs have no welfare concerns for those addicted to their poison.... why should we be concerned that they have died?

Hopefully it will be a deterrent to others although I somehow doubt it.

More scum off our streets.

Well none of them are actually on our street, and most of the UK's heroin doesn't come via the far east anyhow (it comes from Afghanistan, via pakistan, Turkey and Italy).


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

rob1969 Flag Banstead Surrey 30 Apr 15 11.21am

Quote Jimenez at 29 Apr 2015 10.45pm

Quote legaleagle at 29 Apr 2015 10.36pm

Quote Jimenez at 29 Apr 2015 9.59pm

Couldn't see a thread on this subject. I'm kind of surprised that this hasn't raised too many eye brows. I'm convinced if this had been done in The USA all the liberals & Lefties would have been out in force condemning it in the strongest possible way.

Their are countries that we would like to think have similar principles and values to us. We normally include the USA amongst these. However occasionally things occur in some of these countries that would more normally be associated with countries sharing different values. When that happens criticism is made.

Personally I find keeping people on death row for years - sometimes decades - with the constant threat of eventual execution to be cruel in the extreme. If execution is really considered necessary then better to carry it out - as in Indonesia - and at lease limit the mental suffering.


[Link]


Do you personally think the death sentence is appropriate for drug offences,Jimenez? Bear in mind,if a miscarriage of justice (and they do happen) comes out later,its too late for the accused.In the case of one of those scheduled to be killed,a new witness came forward at the 11th hour and their execution has been suspended.Day or two later and it would have been irrelevant...

Or is someone automatically to be dismissed as a "liberal" or a "leftie" for simply raising the point?

Edited by legaleagle (29 Apr 2015 10.38pm)


As it happens yes. Anyone caught trafficking drugs in countries where they know there is a chance they are going to get sentenced to death have little sympathy from me, but I digress Legal. My main point was that there has been little news or condemnation from the usual suspects (scuse pun)because this has been carried out in the Far East. The same can be said for executions in North Korea, Saudi Arabia Et al

Not sure what happened her - this not my thread !


Edited by rob1969 (30 Apr 2015 11.24am)

 

DanH Flag SW2 30 Apr 15 11.37am

Nice to see the usual compassion on show here.

 

Johnny Eagles Flag berlin 30 Apr 15 11.41am

I think it's a bit f*cking rich, frankly, for Western so-called liberal nations to go round condemning other countries.

If it wasn't for the demand for drugs that so-called liberal countries tolerate then poorer countries who supply them wouldn't be riddled with crime and corruption.

If a country wants to send a strong deterrent message then it's up to them. I'm a bit ambivalent on the death penalty in principle, but I think this example acts as a pretty big warning. I bet spoilt Western kids will think twice before trafficking drugs through Indonesia again.

 


...we must expand...get more pupils...so that the knowledge will spread...

johnfirewall Flag 30 Apr 15 12.48pm

Quote legaleagle at 29 Apr 2015 10.36pm

Quote Jimenez at 29 Apr 2015 9.59pm

Couldn't see a thread on this subject. I'm kind of surprised that this hasn't raised too many eye brows. I'm convinced if this had been done in The USA all the liberals & Lefties would have been out in force condemning it in the strongest possible way.


[Link]


Do you personally think the death sentence is appropriate for drug offences,Jimenez? Bear in mind,if a miscarriage of justice (and they do happen) comes out later,its too late for the accused.In the case of one of those scheduled to be killed,a new witness came forward at the 11th hour and their execution has been suspended.Day or two later and it would have been irrelevant...

Or is someone automatically to be dismissed as a "liberal" or a "leftie" for simply raising the point?

Edited by legaleagle (29 Apr 2015 10.38pm)

Any decent lefty should boybott these places with awful human rights. Dunno if that's his point but it's mine.

Perhaps specious but it's like the fairtrade coffee / coke habit anology someone used on here recently.

 

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 30 Apr 15 12.57pm

Quote Pawson Palace at 30 Apr 2015 8.30am

f*** them. They knew the risks and they accepted them when tried it. You can't play the game knowing the rules and then cry because you lost.

The dear old "grandma" tried taking 1.6kg of heroin that's not exactly personal use is it?

Just because she has a British passport does not exonerate her from what she did. They should handle her as they see fit on the grounds she had a fair trial.


^^spot bollok ^^

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 30 Apr 15 1.18pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 30 Apr 2015 11.41am

I think it's a bit f*cking rich, frankly, for Western so-called liberal nations to go round condemning other countries.

If it wasn't for the demand for drugs that so-called liberal countries tolerate then poorer countries who supply them wouldn't be riddled with crime and corruption.

If a country wants to send a strong deterrent message then it's up to them. I'm a bit ambivalent on the death penalty in principle, but I think this example acts as a pretty big warning. I bet spoilt Western kids will think twice before trafficking drugs through Indonesia again.


Is the right answer.

Although personally not one for the death penalty for two reasons. Each one side of the pro / anti coin.

1 The risk of executing the innocent then saying oops sorry afterwards doesn't quite cut it for me

2. The punishment of physically decaying in some skanking Victorian prison for a lifetime, never seeing the sun as a free man again, one eye always looking behind you for fear of physical harm for the likes of an Ian Huntley fits the public punishment / retribution angle far better than a quick and easy death.

As for countries who exercise the death penalty for drugs. If you are willing to smuggle a kilo and a half knowing if you are caught you have every chance of being executed if you still choose to do it then tough s*** frankly...risk and reward innit - Get away with it and you make easy money, get caught you is f***ed - as Norman Stanley put it - Occupational Hazard

 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

dannyh Flag wherever I lay my hat....... 30 Apr 15 1.26pm

If you cant do the time, dont do the crime.

 


"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Bali Nine