You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Union bashing
November 22 2026 1.57am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Union bashing


Page 3 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
ChuFukka Flag 15 May 15 4.47pm

Quote TUX at 14 May 2015 8.51pm

Quote ChuFukka at 14 May 2015 7.22pm

Quote derben at 14 May 2015 5.47pm

Quote nickgusset at 14 May 2015 5.31pm

Make it impossible to strike, then hit people with cuts to work rights.

Cunds

Impossible? Why impossible?

50% of those eligible to vote must vote, and 40% of those eligible to vote must vote for the strike.
So if the workforce numbered a 100, 50 of them must vote and 40 of those must vote to strike. So you could still have your strike although 60% do not want it or have no opinion.

Hardly communist-block suppression of union rights is it.


Exactly. Some of the opposition is laughable.


Also, the reason the Tories are entitled to govern with so little of the public voting for them (just like Labour - not that anyone was complaining then) is because we NEED a government, so we have to accept that whoever gets the most votes should fulfil that role. We don't need strikes, so abstention from voting should be taken as a lack of support for the contention - if people cared enough, they would vote.

A lesson in contradicting yourself.



That's a very poor, simplistic interpretation of what is not a particularly complex argument.

Elections are about choosing representatives; there is no simple way to interpret abstentions as it isn't a case of support/oppose. As we need a government, it makes sense that the one chosen should be that with the most votes (or seats, in FPTP), ignoring the people who choose not to vote.

The difference is that motions to strike are about yes or no, and, because having a strike is not a matter of national importance, assuming an abstention is an indication of 'don't really care' is not only viable, but the most reasonable option.

Edited by ChuFukka (15 May 2015 4.48pm)

 

ChuFukka Flag 15 May 15 4.52pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 15 May 2015 4.41pm

Quote Stuk at 15 May 2015 4.31pm

Quote legaleagle at 15 May 2015 4.20pm

Quote ambrose7 at 15 May 2015 3.58pm

There seems to be a lot of opposition on this thread stating why we should have trade unions and why they should be able to strike, and very few addressing why a 40% pass rate is so unreasonable

Perhaps we should link the % votes ability to strike to the % votes ability of a government to proclaim its legitimacy given the percentage of votes it got? At the moment,that would lower the % rate to 36.9%.

A general election is nothing like a strike ballot which is almost always a basic yes or no.

Stop comparing them, they're nothing like each other.

I think its the inconsistency of a government that has a 37% return, demanding that other systems of approval must represent a much higher figure.

The reality of the unions is that a strike ballot can only be conducted lawfully, by post. Which is about the most inconsistent and unreliable means by which to do so.

The idea that the number of votes necessary should be based on the number of members rather than the returns is absurd, because the returns include no votes as well and may well be related to a local rather than national matter.

But the whole thing is a strawman argument, because the actual reality of the Conservative position isn't about the percentages at all, its about reducing the power and influence of Unions and the capacity of unions to act against the interests of the Government and of Employers.

People who bang on about the percentages are missing the point, the people supporting the anti-union laws aren't interested in whether its 8% of the total membership, or 90% - they want to see the power of unions restricted, they'd support anti-union laws even if the strike actions were returning 100% of the members wishes for strike action.


There's no inconsistency. We need somebody to run the country - what do you suggest we do if there's low turnout; have no government?

Also, the two scenarios aren't remotely comparable, as I explained in my post above.


Edited by ChuFukka (15 May 2015 5.03pm)

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 15 May 15 5.00pm

Quote derben at 15 May 2015 4.41pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 15 May 2015 3.01pm

Quote derben at 15 May 2015 12.10pm

Quote imbored at 14 May 2015 7.06pm

Quote derben at 14 May 2015 6.11pm

Quote nickgusset at 14 May 2015 6.01pm

Quote derben at 14 May 2015 5.47pm

Quote nickgusset at 14 May 2015 5.31pm

Make it impossible to strike, then hit people with cuts to work rights.

Cunds

Impossible? Why impossible?

50% of those eligible to vote must vote, and 40% of those eligible to vote must vote for the strike.
So if the workforce numbered a 100, 50 of them must vote and 40 of those must vote to strike. So you could still have your strike although 60% do not want it or have no opinion.

Hardly communist-block suppression of union rights is it.

Not Communist block suppression. No. But still suppression. We already have among the harshest anti union laws in the western world as it is.


Edited by nickgusset (14 May 2015 6.03pm)

Lucky you are not in South Africa, they shoot striking workers there.

This is basically the equivalent of slapping your wife then telling her to be thankful she's not in the middle east being stoned to death?


Edited by imbored (14 May 2015 7.08pm)

No it is not. It is merely pointing out that Britain supposedly having 'the harshest anti union laws' is nonsense when regimes like South Africa (that gussett no doubt generally supports) shoots striking workers dead. Where were the protest marches and denunciations of it from the left by the way?

South African Anti-Union laws don't actually permit shooting protesters to death, similarly Apathied law didn't legally allow extra judicial police murders of dissdents such as Steve Bilko.

I think we might agree - both government are/were appalling. What also appalls me is that most of the left only sees the evil of the aparthied government and turns a blind eye to the racism and corruption of the new government. (Similar to Kermit's post on here about appalling Israeli acts while totally ignoring appalling acts of the Palestinians.)

One was ruthlessly efficient, the other is dangerously incompetent. Both were horribly corrupt, but in different ways (efficient corruption vs nepotistic corruption). Its very easy when your the opposition, especially in an 'armed struggle' you may never actually survive, because ultimately you have 'right' on your side (more or less).

Of course the writing was on the wall with the ANC, because they were busier fighting the IFP than the state.

Its quite rare that 'liberation' movements actually make good governments - the kind of people involved rarely make good peace time leaders. The ANC by the start of the 80s had become more of a problem to the future of SA, than a solution to the problems. Effectively its political classes had been wiped out, either by decades in prison or more literally, and the generations that survied the armed struggle tended to be more gangster than idealist - The likes of Mandela were iconic, and would hold influence, but essentially 25 years in prison doesn't give you a grip on how the world works.

The rapidity of 'change' post Apathied generally resulted in a massive loss of the skilled and educated workforce leaving, and that desporia increasing over time as key jobs went to 'ANC faithful' over people who knew what they were doing.

In the reversal or Aptheid, the government of South Africa implemented its own racial policies which would effectively force more and more people to leave, taking more skills.

Exactly the problem of Zimbabwe, it wasn't about blacks and whites, it was about equality. Just taking power from the whites and giving it to the blacks, simply changes the problems you have (because now you have a racist government without the skills it needs to function).


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 15 May 15 5.10pm

Quote ChuFukka at 15 May 2015 4.52pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 15 May 2015 4.41pm

Quote Stuk at 15 May 2015 4.31pm

Quote legaleagle at 15 May 2015 4.20pm

Quote ambrose7 at 15 May 2015 3.58pm

There seems to be a lot of opposition on this thread stating why we should have trade unions and why they should be able to strike, and very few addressing why a 40% pass rate is so unreasonable

Perhaps we should link the % votes ability to strike to the % votes ability of a government to proclaim its legitimacy given the percentage of votes it got? At the moment,that would lower the % rate to 36.9%.

A general election is nothing like a strike ballot which is almost always a basic yes or no.

Stop comparing them, they're nothing like each other.

I think its the inconsistency of a government that has a 37% return, demanding that other systems of approval must represent a much higher figure.

The reality of the unions is that a strike ballot can only be conducted lawfully, by post. Which is about the most inconsistent and unreliable means by which to do so.

The idea that the number of votes necessary should be based on the number of members rather than the returns is absurd, because the returns include no votes as well and may well be related to a local rather than national matter.

But the whole thing is a strawman argument, because the actual reality of the Conservative position isn't about the percentages at all, its about reducing the power and influence of Unions and the capacity of unions to act against the interests of the Government and of Employers.

People who bang on about the percentages are missing the point, the people supporting the anti-union laws aren't interested in whether its 8% of the total membership, or 90% - they want to see the power of unions restricted, they'd support anti-union laws even if the strike actions were returning 100% of the members wishes for strike action.


There's no inconsistency. We need somebody to run the country - what do you suggest we do if there's low turnout; have no government?

Also, the two scenarios aren't remotely comparable, as I explained in my post above.

EDIT: and just to be clear, I don't accept for a second that you truly believe that last sentence, which, in itself, is a neat little straw man (ironically).

Edited by ChuFukka (15 May 2015 4.59pm)

No, what I'm saying is that you can contrast the situation. 35% of the Electorate didn't vote, and the Conservatives got 36% of the votes of those who did.

The interest of the conservatives isn't in fairness, democracy in unions, its about reducing their capacity to act and most notably to take strike action.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

ChuFukka Flag 15 May 15 5.11pm

Quote legaleagle at 15 May 2015 4.20pm

Quote ambrose7 at 15 May 2015 3.58pm

There seems to be a lot of opposition on this thread stating why we should have trade unions and why they should be able to strike, and very few addressing why a 40% pass rate is so unreasonable

Perhaps we should link the % votes ability to strike to the % votes ability of a government to proclaim its legitimacy given the percentage of votes it got? At the moment,that would lower the % rate to 36.9%.


That's not an answer to his question - it's intentionally diversionary and shows the lack of a solid argument. It also assumes you can compare a general election to a yes/no vote, which, of course, you can't.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 15 May 15 5.13pm

Quote ChuFukka at 15 May 2015 4.52pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 15 May 2015 4.41pm

Quote Stuk at 15 May 2015 4.31pm

Quote legaleagle at 15 May 2015 4.20pm

Quote ambrose7 at 15 May 2015 3.58pm

There seems to be a lot of opposition on this thread stating why we should have trade unions and why they should be able to strike, and very few addressing why a 40% pass rate is so unreasonable

Perhaps we should link the % votes ability to strike to the % votes ability of a government to proclaim its legitimacy given the percentage of votes it got? At the moment,that would lower the % rate to 36.9%.

A general election is nothing like a strike ballot which is almost always a basic yes or no.

Stop comparing them, they're nothing like each other.

I think its the inconsistency of a government that has a 37% return, demanding that other systems of approval must represent a much higher figure.

The reality of the unions is that a strike ballot can only be conducted lawfully, by post. Which is about the most inconsistent and unreliable means by which to do so.

The idea that the number of votes necessary should be based on the number of members rather than the returns is absurd, because the returns include no votes as well and may well be related to a local rather than national matter.

But the whole thing is a strawman argument, because the actual reality of the Conservative position isn't about the percentages at all, its about reducing the power and influence of Unions and the capacity of unions to act against the interests of the Government and of Employers.

People who bang on about the percentages are missing the point, the people supporting the anti-union laws aren't interested in whether its 8% of the total membership, or 90% - they want to see the power of unions restricted, they'd support anti-union laws even if the strike actions were returning 100% of the members wishes for strike action.


There's no inconsistency. We need somebody to run the country - what do you suggest we do if there's low turnout; have no government?

Also, the two scenarios aren't remotely comparable, as I explained in my post above.


Edited by ChuFukka (15 May 2015 5.03pm)

No you don't, the government doesn't run the country, it represents the people. The civil service runs the country.

Mid-Long term it could be problematic, but you could easily default to the Lords until such times as a government could be formed. Parliament has long breaks etc and the country doesn't just stop.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Stuk Flag Top half 15 May 15 5.13pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 15 May 2015 4.41pm

Quote Stuk at 15 May 2015 4.31pm

Quote legaleagle at 15 May 2015 4.20pm

Quote ambrose7 at 15 May 2015 3.58pm

There seems to be a lot of opposition on this thread stating why we should have trade unions and why they should be able to strike, and very few addressing why a 40% pass rate is so unreasonable

Perhaps we should link the % votes ability to strike to the % votes ability of a government to proclaim its legitimacy given the percentage of votes it got? At the moment,that would lower the % rate to 36.9%.

A general election is nothing like a strike ballot which is almost always a basic yes or no.

Stop comparing them, they're nothing like each other.

I think its the inconsistency of a government that has a 37% return, demanding that other systems of approval must represent a much higher figure.

The reality of the unions is that a strike ballot can only be conducted lawfully, by post. Which is about the most inconsistent and unreliable means by which to do so.

The idea that the number of votes necessary should be based on the number of members rather than the returns is absurd, because the returns include no votes as well and may well be related to a local rather than national matter.

But the whole thing is a strawman argument, because the actual reality of the Conservative position isn't about the percentages at all, its about reducing the power and influence of Unions and the capacity of unions to act against the interests of the Government and of Employers.

People who bang on about the percentages are missing the point, the people supporting the anti-union laws aren't interested in whether its 8% of the total membership, or 90% - they want to see the power of unions restricted, they'd support anti-union laws even if the strike actions were returning 100% of the members wishes for strike action.


37% return of 30+ options.

I don't give a f*** how unjust they think a GE is, just don't compare it to a poxy strike ballot.

The idea that you can be a member when you don't do that job is equally absurd. Voting by post is presumably the only way to verify the votes have come from that particular union member.

The unions aren't interested in whether 10% or 100% of the public don't support them. And this strike is basically them asking for more money (than offered already), from us, the taxpayers.

 


Optimistic as ever

ChuFukka Flag 15 May 15 5.14pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 15 May 2015 5.10pm

Quote ChuFukka at 15 May 2015 4.52pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 15 May 2015 4.41pm

Quote Stuk at 15 May 2015 4.31pm

Quote legaleagle at 15 May 2015 4.20pm

Quote ambrose7 at 15 May 2015 3.58pm

There seems to be a lot of opposition on this thread stating why we should have trade unions and why they should be able to strike, and very few addressing why a 40% pass rate is so unreasonable

Perhaps we should link the % votes ability to strike to the % votes ability of a government to proclaim its legitimacy given the percentage of votes it got? At the moment,that would lower the % rate to 36.9%.

A general election is nothing like a strike ballot which is almost always a basic yes or no.

Stop comparing them, they're nothing like each other.

I think its the inconsistency of a government that has a 37% return, demanding that other systems of approval must represent a much higher figure.

The reality of the unions is that a strike ballot can only be conducted lawfully, by post. Which is about the most inconsistent and unreliable means by which to do so.

The idea that the number of votes necessary should be based on the number of members rather than the returns is absurd, because the returns include no votes as well and may well be related to a local rather than national matter.

But the whole thing is a strawman argument, because the actual reality of the Conservative position isn't about the percentages at all, its about reducing the power and influence of Unions and the capacity of unions to act against the interests of the Government and of Employers.

People who bang on about the percentages are missing the point, the people supporting the anti-union laws aren't interested in whether its 8% of the total membership, or 90% - they want to see the power of unions restricted, they'd support anti-union laws even if the strike actions were returning 100% of the members wishes for strike action.


There's no inconsistency. We need somebody to run the country - what do you suggest we do if there's low turnout; have no government?

Also, the two scenarios aren't remotely comparable, as I explained in my post above.

EDIT: and just to be clear, I don't accept for a second that you truly believe that last sentence, which, in itself, is a neat little straw man (ironically).

Edited by ChuFukka (15 May 2015 4.59pm)

No, what I'm saying is that you can contrast the situation. 35% of the Electorate didn't vote, and the Conservatives got 36% of the votes of those who did.

The interest of the conservatives isn't in fairness, democracy in unions, its about reducing their capacity to act and most notably to take strike action.

I don't doubt that the Conservatives want to quell the (admittedly diminishing) powers of unions - and I'm absolutely behind them on that one.

However, there is simply no comparison between a general election and a yes/no strike vote.

 

ChuFukka Flag 15 May 15 5.18pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 15 May 2015 5.13pm

Quote ChuFukka at 15 May 2015 4.52pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 15 May 2015 4.41pm

Quote Stuk at 15 May 2015 4.31pm

Quote legaleagle at 15 May 2015 4.20pm

Quote ambrose7 at 15 May 2015 3.58pm

There seems to be a lot of opposition on this thread stating why we should have trade unions and why they should be able to strike, and very few addressing why a 40% pass rate is so unreasonable

Perhaps we should link the % votes ability to strike to the % votes ability of a government to proclaim its legitimacy given the percentage of votes it got? At the moment,that would lower the % rate to 36.9%.

A general election is nothing like a strike ballot which is almost always a basic yes or no.

Stop comparing them, they're nothing like each other.

I think its the inconsistency of a government that has a 37% return, demanding that other systems of approval must represent a much higher figure.

The reality of the unions is that a strike ballot can only be conducted lawfully, by post. Which is about the most inconsistent and unreliable means by which to do so.

The idea that the number of votes necessary should be based on the number of members rather than the returns is absurd, because the returns include no votes as well and may well be related to a local rather than national matter.

But the whole thing is a strawman argument, because the actual reality of the Conservative position isn't about the percentages at all, its about reducing the power and influence of Unions and the capacity of unions to act against the interests of the Government and of Employers.

People who bang on about the percentages are missing the point, the people supporting the anti-union laws aren't interested in whether its 8% of the total membership, or 90% - they want to see the power of unions restricted, they'd support anti-union laws even if the strike actions were returning 100% of the members wishes for strike action.


There's no inconsistency. We need somebody to run the country - what do you suggest we do if there's low turnout; have no government?

Also, the two scenarios aren't remotely comparable, as I explained in my post above.


Edited by ChuFukka (15 May 2015 5.03pm)

No you don't, the government doesn't run the country, it represents the people. The civil service runs the country.

Mid-Long term it could be problematic, but you could easily default to the Lords until such times as a government could be formed. Parliament has long breaks etc and the country doesn't just stop.


Without a government, the country would be left utterly stagnant. 'Running' a country isn't just about administration, it's about progress, representation and direction.

Edited by ChuFukka (15 May 2015 5.19pm)

 

Stuk Flag Top half 15 May 15 5.18pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 15 May 2015 5.13pm

Quote ChuFukka at 15 May 2015 4.52pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 15 May 2015 4.41pm

Quote Stuk at 15 May 2015 4.31pm

Quote legaleagle at 15 May 2015 4.20pm

Quote ambrose7 at 15 May 2015 3.58pm

There seems to be a lot of opposition on this thread stating why we should have trade unions and why they should be able to strike, and very few addressing why a 40% pass rate is so unreasonable

Perhaps we should link the % votes ability to strike to the % votes ability of a government to proclaim its legitimacy given the percentage of votes it got? At the moment,that would lower the % rate to 36.9%.

A general election is nothing like a strike ballot which is almost always a basic yes or no.

Stop comparing them, they're nothing like each other.

I think its the inconsistency of a government that has a 37% return, demanding that other systems of approval must represent a much higher figure.

The reality of the unions is that a strike ballot can only be conducted lawfully, by post. Which is about the most inconsistent and unreliable means by which to do so.

The idea that the number of votes necessary should be based on the number of members rather than the returns is absurd, because the returns include no votes as well and may well be related to a local rather than national matter.

But the whole thing is a strawman argument, because the actual reality of the Conservative position isn't about the percentages at all, its about reducing the power and influence of Unions and the capacity of unions to act against the interests of the Government and of Employers.

People who bang on about the percentages are missing the point, the people supporting the anti-union laws aren't interested in whether its 8% of the total membership, or 90% - they want to see the power of unions restricted, they'd support anti-union laws even if the strike actions were returning 100% of the members wishes for strike action.


There's no inconsistency. We need somebody to run the country - what do you suggest we do if there's low turnout; have no government?

Also, the two scenarios aren't remotely comparable, as I explained in my post above.


Edited by ChuFukka (15 May 2015 5.03pm)

No you don't, the government doesn't run the country, it represents the people. The civil service runs the country.

Mid-Long term it could be problematic, but you could easily default to the Lords until such times as a government could be formed. Parliament has long breaks etc and the country doesn't just stop.



This isn't Belgium!

We do need a government or the EU would arse rape us to death.

 


Optimistic as ever

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 15 May 15 5.20pm

Quote ChuFukka at 15 May 2015 5.18pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 15 May 2015 5.13pm

Quote ChuFukka at 15 May 2015 4.52pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 15 May 2015 4.41pm

Quote Stuk at 15 May 2015 4.31pm

Quote legaleagle at 15 May 2015 4.20pm

Quote ambrose7 at 15 May 2015 3.58pm

There seems to be a lot of opposition on this thread stating why we should have trade unions and why they should be able to strike, and very few addressing why a 40% pass rate is so unreasonable

Perhaps we should link the % votes ability to strike to the % votes ability of a government to proclaim its legitimacy given the percentage of votes it got? At the moment,that would lower the % rate to 36.9%.

A general election is nothing like a strike ballot which is almost always a basic yes or no.

Stop comparing them, they're nothing like each other.

I think its the inconsistency of a government that has a 37% return, demanding that other systems of approval must represent a much higher figure.

The reality of the unions is that a strike ballot can only be conducted lawfully, by post. Which is about the most inconsistent and unreliable means by which to do so.

The idea that the number of votes necessary should be based on the number of members rather than the returns is absurd, because the returns include no votes as well and may well be related to a local rather than national matter.

But the whole thing is a strawman argument, because the actual reality of the Conservative position isn't about the percentages at all, its about reducing the power and influence of Unions and the capacity of unions to act against the interests of the Government and of Employers.

People who bang on about the percentages are missing the point, the people supporting the anti-union laws aren't interested in whether its 8% of the total membership, or 90% - they want to see the power of unions restricted, they'd support anti-union laws even if the strike actions were returning 100% of the members wishes for strike action.


There's no inconsistency. We need somebody to run the country - what do you suggest we do if there's low turnout; have no government?

Also, the two scenarios aren't remotely comparable, as I explained in my post above.


Edited by ChuFukka (15 May 2015 5.03pm)

No you don't, the government doesn't run the country, it represents the people. The civil service runs the country.

Mid-Long term it could be problematic, but you could easily default to the Lords until such times as a government could be formed. Parliament has long breaks etc and the country doesn't just stop.


Without a government, the country would be left utterly stagnant. 'Running' a country isn't just about administration, it's about progress, representation and direction.

Edited by ChuFukka (15 May 2015 5.19pm)


Progress? Taking us back to pre war civil liberties and rights...

 

derben Flag 15 May 15 5.23pm

Quote nickgusset at 15 May 2015 5.20pm

Quote ChuFukka at 15 May 2015 5.18pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 15 May 2015 5.13pm

Quote ChuFukka at 15 May 2015 4.52pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 15 May 2015 4.41pm

Quote Stuk at 15 May 2015 4.31pm

Quote legaleagle at 15 May 2015 4.20pm

Quote ambrose7 at 15 May 2015 3.58pm

There seems to be a lot of opposition on this thread stating why we should have trade unions and why they should be able to strike, and very few addressing why a 40% pass rate is so unreasonable

Perhaps we should link the % votes ability to strike to the % votes ability of a government to proclaim its legitimacy given the percentage of votes it got? At the moment,that would lower the % rate to 36.9%.

A general election is nothing like a strike ballot which is almost always a basic yes or no.

Stop comparing them, they're nothing like each other.

I think its the inconsistency of a government that has a 37% return, demanding that other systems of approval must represent a much higher figure.

The reality of the unions is that a strike ballot can only be conducted lawfully, by post. Which is about the most inconsistent and unreliable means by which to do so.

The idea that the number of votes necessary should be based on the number of members rather than the returns is absurd, because the returns include no votes as well and may well be related to a local rather than national matter.

But the whole thing is a strawman argument, because the actual reality of the Conservative position isn't about the percentages at all, its about reducing the power and influence of Unions and the capacity of unions to act against the interests of the Government and of Employers.

People who bang on about the percentages are missing the point, the people supporting the anti-union laws aren't interested in whether its 8% of the total membership, or 90% - they want to see the power of unions restricted, they'd support anti-union laws even if the strike actions were returning 100% of the members wishes for strike action.


There's no inconsistency. We need somebody to run the country - what do you suggest we do if there's low turnout; have no government?

Also, the two scenarios aren't remotely comparable, as I explained in my post above.


Edited by ChuFukka (15 May 2015 5.03pm)

No you don't, the government doesn't run the country, it represents the people. The civil service runs the country.

Mid-Long term it could be problematic, but you could easily default to the Lords until such times as a government could be formed. Parliament has long breaks etc and the country doesn't just stop.


Without a government, the country would be left utterly stagnant. 'Running' a country isn't just about administration, it's about progress, representation and direction.

Edited by ChuFukka (15 May 2015 5.19pm)


Progress? Taking us back to pre war civil liberties and rights...

Which war?

 

ChuFukka Flag 15 May 15 5.25pm

Quote nickgusset at 15 May 2015 5.20pm

Quote ChuFukka at 15 May 2015 5.18pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 15 May 2015 5.13pm

Quote ChuFukka at 15 May 2015 4.52pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 15 May 2015 4.41pm

Quote Stuk at 15 May 2015 4.31pm

Quote legaleagle at 15 May 2015 4.20pm

Quote ambrose7 at 15 May 2015 3.58pm

There seems to be a lot of opposition on this thread stating why we should have trade unions and why they should be able to strike, and very few addressing why a 40% pass rate is so unreasonable

Perhaps we should link the % votes ability to strike to the % votes ability of a government to proclaim its legitimacy given the percentage of votes it got? At the moment,that would lower the % rate to 36.9%.

A general election is nothing like a strike ballot which is almost always a basic yes or no.

Stop comparing them, they're nothing like each other.

I think its the inconsistency of a government that has a 37% return, demanding that other systems of approval must represent a much higher figure.

The reality of the unions is that a strike ballot can only be conducted lawfully, by post. Which is about the most inconsistent and unreliable means by which to do so.

The idea that the number of votes necessary should be based on the number of members rather than the returns is absurd, because the returns include no votes as well and may well be related to a local rather than national matter.

But the whole thing is a strawman argument, because the actual reality of the Conservative position isn't about the percentages at all, its about reducing the power and influence of Unions and the capacity of unions to act against the interests of the Government and of Employers.

People who bang on about the percentages are missing the point, the people supporting the anti-union laws aren't interested in whether its 8% of the total membership, or 90% - they want to see the power of unions restricted, they'd support anti-union laws even if the strike actions were returning 100% of the members wishes for strike action.


There's no inconsistency. We need somebody to run the country - what do you suggest we do if there's low turnout; have no government?

Also, the two scenarios aren't remotely comparable, as I explained in my post above.


Edited by ChuFukka (15 May 2015 5.03pm)

No you don't, the government doesn't run the country, it represents the people. The civil service runs the country.

Mid-Long term it could be problematic, but you could easily default to the Lords until such times as a government could be formed. Parliament has long breaks etc and the country doesn't just stop.


Without a government, the country would be left utterly stagnant. 'Running' a country isn't just about administration, it's about progress, representation and direction.

Edited by ChuFukka (15 May 2015 5.19pm)


Progress? Taking us back to pre war civil liberties and rights...

There are no words to describe how cataclysmically incorrect that is. Shocking, I know...

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 15 May 15 5.29pm

Quote ChuFukka at 15 May 2015 5.18pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 15 May 2015 5.13pm

Quote ChuFukka at 15 May 2015 4.52pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 15 May 2015 4.41pm

Quote Stuk at 15 May 2015 4.31pm

Quote legaleagle at 15 May 2015 4.20pm

Quote ambrose7 at 15 May 2015 3.58pm

There seems to be a lot of opposition on this thread stating why we should have trade unions and why they should be able to strike, and very few addressing why a 40% pass rate is so unreasonable

Perhaps we should link the % votes ability to strike to the % votes ability of a government to proclaim its legitimacy given the percentage of votes it got? At the moment,that would lower the % rate to 36.9%.

A general election is nothing like a strike ballot which is almost always a basic yes or no.

Stop comparing them, they're nothing like each other.

I think its the inconsistency of a government that has a 37% return, demanding that other systems of approval must represent a much higher figure.

The reality of the unions is that a strike ballot can only be conducted lawfully, by post. Which is about the most inconsistent and unreliable means by which to do so.

The idea that the number of votes necessary should be based on the number of members rather than the returns is absurd, because the returns include no votes as well and may well be related to a local rather than national matter.

But the whole thing is a strawman argument, because the actual reality of the Conservative position isn't about the percentages at all, its about reducing the power and influence of Unions and the capacity of unions to act against the interests of the Government and of Employers.

People who bang on about the percentages are missing the point, the people supporting the anti-union laws aren't interested in whether its 8% of the total membership, or 90% - they want to see the power of unions restricted, they'd support anti-union laws even if the strike actions were returning 100% of the members wishes for strike action.


There's no inconsistency. We need somebody to run the country - what do you suggest we do if there's low turnout; have no government?

Also, the two scenarios aren't remotely comparable, as I explained in my post above.


Edited by ChuFukka (15 May 2015 5.03pm)

No you don't, the government doesn't run the country, it represents the people. The civil service runs the country.

Mid-Long term it could be problematic, but you could easily default to the Lords until such times as a government could be formed. Parliament has long breaks etc and the country doesn't just stop.


Without a government, the country would be left utterly stagnant. 'Running' a country isn't just about administration, it's about progress, representation and direction.

Edited by ChuFukka (15 May 2015 5.19pm)

Hence the short term bit.

As for Progress, Representation and Direction - I think you've mistaken the ideology with the reality - esp in regards to Conservatism, which really has always been more traditionally minded, rather than progressive (one of its greatest traits has been careful change along with economic pragmatism)

I wouldn't say any government has ever been about progress, representation and direction, and that being popular, winning elections and the status quo has been the priority of every government since Thatcher (who definitely had a progressive agenda, one that was sometimes very flawed and ideologically driven with direction - I'm biased, but she definitely had an agenda, a direction, an ideology and was into progress).

The exception is probably Blair thinking about it, who was all about 'Progress and Direction'. His progress and his direction.


Also, progress is the great myth, but that's a different argument.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 15 May 15 5.47pm

Quote derben at 15 May 2015 5.23pm

Quote nickgusset at 15 May 2015 5.20pm

Quote ChuFukka at 15 May 2015 5.18pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 15 May 2015 5.13pm

Quote ChuFukka at 15 May 2015 4.52pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 15 May 2015 4.41pm

Quote Stuk at 15 May 2015 4.31pm

Quote legaleagle at 15 May 2015 4.20pm

Quote ambrose7 at 15 May 2015 3.58pm

There seems to be a lot of opposition on this thread stating why we should have trade unions and why they should be able to strike, and very few addressing why a 40% pass rate is so unreasonable

Perhaps we should link the % votes ability to strike to the % votes ability of a government to proclaim its legitimacy given the percentage of votes it got? At the moment,that would lower the % rate to 36.9%.

A general election is nothing like a strike ballot which is almost always a basic yes or no.

Stop comparing them, they're nothing like each other.

I think its the inconsistency of a government that has a 37% return, demanding that other systems of approval must represent a much higher figure.

The reality of the unions is that a strike ballot can only be conducted lawfully, by post. Which is about the most inconsistent and unreliable means by which to do so.

The idea that the number of votes necessary should be based on the number of members rather than the returns is absurd, because the returns include no votes as well and may well be related to a local rather than national matter.

But the whole thing is a strawman argument, because the actual reality of the Conservative position isn't about the percentages at all, its about reducing the power and influence of Unions and the capacity of unions to act against the interests of the Government and of Employers.

People who bang on about the percentages are missing the point, the people supporting the anti-union laws aren't interested in whether its 8% of the total membership, or 90% - they want to see the power of unions restricted, they'd support anti-union laws even if the strike actions were returning 100% of the members wishes for strike action.


There's no inconsistency. We need somebody to run the country - what do you suggest we do if there's low turnout; have no government?

Also, the two scenarios aren't remotely comparable, as I explained in my post above.


Edited by ChuFukka (15 May 2015 5.03pm)

No you don't, the government doesn't run the country, it represents the people. The civil service runs the country.

Mid-Long term it could be problematic, but you could easily default to the Lords until such times as a government could be formed. Parliament has long breaks etc and the country doesn't just stop.


Without a government, the country would be left utterly stagnant. 'Running' a country isn't just about administration, it's about progress, representation and direction.

Edited by ChuFukka (15 May 2015 5.19pm)


Progress? Taking us back to pre war civil liberties and rights...

Which war?


The Napoleonic

 

derben Flag 15 May 15 5.57pm

Quote nickgusset at 15 May 2015 5.47pm

Quote derben at 15 May 2015 5.23pm

Quote nickgusset at 15 May 2015 5.20pm

Quote ChuFukka at 15 May 2015 5.18pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 15 May 2015 5.13pm

Quote ChuFukka at 15 May 2015 4.52pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 15 May 2015 4.41pm

Quote Stuk at 15 May 2015 4.31pm

Quote legaleagle at 15 May 2015 4.20pm

Quote ambrose7 at 15 May 2015 3.58pm

There seems to be a lot of opposition on this thread stating why we should have trade unions and why they should be able to strike, and very few addressing why a 40% pass rate is so unreasonable

Perhaps we should link the % votes ability to strike to the % votes ability of a government to proclaim its legitimacy given the percentage of votes it got? At the moment,that would lower the % rate to 36.9%.

A general election is nothing like a strike ballot which is almost always a basic yes or no.

Stop comparing them, they're nothing like each other.

I think its the inconsistency of a government that has a 37% return, demanding that other systems of approval must represent a much higher figure.

The reality of the unions is that a strike ballot can only be conducted lawfully, by post. Which is about the most inconsistent and unreliable means by which to do so.

The idea that the number of votes necessary should be based on the number of members rather than the returns is absurd, because the returns include no votes as well and may well be related to a local rather than national matter.

But the whole thing is a strawman argument, because the actual reality of the Conservative position isn't about the percentages at all, its about reducing the power and influence of Unions and the capacity of unions to act against the interests of the Government and of Employers.

People who bang on about the percentages are missing the point, the people supporting the anti-union laws aren't interested in whether its 8% of the total membership, or 90% - they want to see the power of unions restricted, they'd support anti-union laws even if the strike actions were returning 100% of the members wishes for strike action.


There's no inconsistency. We need somebody to run the country - what do you suggest we do if there's low turnout; have no government?

Also, the two scenarios aren't remotely comparable, as I explained in my post above.


Edited by ChuFukka (15 May 2015 5.03pm)

No you don't, the government doesn't run the country, it represents the people. The civil service runs the country.

Mid-Long term it could be problematic, but you could easily default to the Lords until such times as a government could be formed. Parliament has long breaks etc and the country doesn't just stop.


Without a government, the country would be left utterly stagnant. 'Running' a country isn't just about administration, it's about progress, representation and direction.

Edited by ChuFukka (15 May 2015 5.19pm)


Progress? Taking us back to pre war civil liberties and rights...

Which war?


The Napoleonic

Interesting period that. Napoleon comes to power after the French Revolution overthrew a tyranny, killed loads of people, then turned on each other. He then becomes a more absolute monarch than those they had overthrown and proceeds to 'free' Europe by putting his relations in charge of the countries he invades. Of course 'the left' in Britain at the time thought he was great. Bit like the left's hero worship of Stalin in the 1930s.

 

ChuFukka Flag 15 May 15 6.31pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 15 May 2015 5.29pm

Quote ChuFukka at 15 May 2015 5.18pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 15 May 2015 5.13pm

Quote ChuFukka at 15 May 2015 4.52pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 15 May 2015 4.41pm

Quote Stuk at 15 May 2015 4.31pm

Quote legaleagle at 15 May 2015 4.20pm

Quote ambrose7 at 15 May 2015 3.58pm

There seems to be a lot of opposition on this thread stating why we should have trade unions and why they should be able to strike, and very few addressing why a 40% pass rate is so unreasonable

Perhaps we should link the % votes ability to strike to the % votes ability of a government to proclaim its legitimacy given the percentage of votes it got? At the moment,that would lower the % rate to 36.9%.

A general election is nothing like a strike ballot which is almost always a basic yes or no.

Stop comparing them, they're nothing like each other.

I think its the inconsistency of a government that has a 37% return, demanding that other systems of approval must represent a much higher figure.

The reality of the unions is that a strike ballot can only be conducted lawfully, by post. Which is about the most inconsistent and unreliable means by which to do so.

The idea that the number of votes necessary should be based on the number of members rather than the returns is absurd, because the returns include no votes as well and may well be related to a local rather than national matter.

But the whole thing is a strawman argument, because the actual reality of the Conservative position isn't about the percentages at all, its about reducing the power and influence of Unions and the capacity of unions to act against the interests of the Government and of Employers.

People who bang on about the percentages are missing the point, the people supporting the anti-union laws aren't interested in whether its 8% of the total membership, or 90% - they want to see the power of unions restricted, they'd support anti-union laws even if the strike actions were returning 100% of the members wishes for strike action.


There's no inconsistency. We need somebody to run the country - what do you suggest we do if there's low turnout; have no government?

Also, the two scenarios aren't remotely comparable, as I explained in my post above.


Edited by ChuFukka (15 May 2015 5.03pm)

No you don't, the government doesn't run the country, it represents the people. The civil service runs the country.

Mid-Long term it could be problematic, but you could easily default to the Lords until such times as a government could be formed. Parliament has long breaks etc and the country doesn't just stop.


Without a government, the country would be left utterly stagnant. 'Running' a country isn't just about administration, it's about progress, representation and direction.

Edited by ChuFukka (15 May 2015 5.19pm)

Hence the short term bit.

As for Progress, Representation and Direction - I think you've mistaken the ideology with the reality - esp in regards to Conservatism, which really has always been more traditionally minded, rather than progressive (one of its greatest traits has been careful change along with economic pragmatism)

I wouldn't say any government has ever been about progress, representation and direction, and that being popular, winning elections and the status quo has been the priority of every government since Thatcher (who definitely had a progressive agenda, one that was sometimes very flawed and ideologically driven with direction - I'm biased, but she definitely had an agenda, a direction, an ideology and was into progress).

The exception is probably Blair thinking about it, who was all about 'Progress and Direction'. His progress and his direction.


Also, progress is the great myth, but that's a different argument.



I would disagree with you on 'progress'. Your view is rather nihilist, and it assumes that progress has to be grand and overarching, when it can happen in little increments. Would you not say gay marriage legislation was progress? The introduction of the NMW?

 

legaleagle Flag 15 May 15 6.43pm

Quote ChuFukka at 15 May 2015 5.14pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 15 May 2015 5.10pm

Quote ChuFukka at 15 May 2015 4.52pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 15 May 2015 4.41pm

Quote Stuk at 15 May 2015 4.31pm

Quote legaleagle at 15 May 2015 4.20pm

Quote ambrose7 at 15 May 2015 3.58pm

There seems to be a lot of opposition on this thread stating why we should have trade unions and why they should be able to strike, and very few addressing why a 40% pass rate is so unreasonable

Perhaps we should link the % votes ability to strike to the % votes ability of a government to proclaim its legitimacy given the percentage of votes it got? At the moment,that would lower the % rate to 36.9%.

A general election is nothing like a strike ballot which is almost always a basic yes or no.

Stop comparing them, they're nothing like each other.

I think its the inconsistency of a government that has a 37% return, demanding that other systems of approval must represent a much higher figure.

The reality of the unions is that a strike ballot can only be conducted lawfully, by post. Which is about the most inconsistent and unreliable means by which to do so.

The idea that the number of votes necessary should be based on the number of members rather than the returns is absurd, because the returns include no votes as well and may well be related to a local rather than national matter.

But the whole thing is a strawman argument, because the actual reality of the Conservative position isn't about the percentages at all, its about reducing the power and influence of Unions and the capacity of unions to act against the interests of the Government and of Employers.

People who bang on about the percentages are missing the point, the people supporting the anti-union laws aren't interested in whether its 8% of the total membership, or 90% - they want to see the power of unions restricted, they'd support anti-union laws even if the strike actions were returning 100% of the members wishes for strike action.


There's no inconsistency. We need somebody to run the country - what do you suggest we do if there's low turnout; have no government?

Also, the two scenarios aren't remotely comparable, as I explained in my post above.

EDIT: and just to be clear, I don't accept for a second that you truly believe that last sentence, which, in itself, is a neat little straw man (ironically).

Edited by ChuFukka (15 May 2015 4.59pm)

No, what I'm saying is that you can contrast the situation. 35% of the Electorate didn't vote, and the Conservatives got 36% of the votes of those who did.

The interest of the conservatives isn't in fairness, democracy in unions, its about reducing their capacity to act and most notably to take strike action.

I don't doubt that the Conservatives want to quell the (admittedly diminishing) powers of unions - and I'm absolutely behind them on that one.

However, there is simply no comparison between a general election and a yes/no strike vote.


Not a surprise that your personal preference is to curb the powers of unions.

The issue of what constitutes legitimacy generally in terms of a voting outcome is,viewed more objectively as opposed to someone with an axe to grind, perfectly legitimate to raise .You may not agree but that doesn't mean its not a reasonable point of view to contrast a government whose legitimacy rests on less than 40% of those who voted (and where there is no minimum turnout requirement of those eligible to vote) with the requirements for the outcome of a vote by union members to exercise the right of members to strike if approved in accordance with the union's rules.

As for suggesting that it is "intentionally diversionary" to simply raise as a question a reasonable point of view that you don't agree with and which doesn't fit your agenda of what are pertinent points to raise,, that reflects you seeking to ,that's simply silly IMO.

Edited by legaleagle (15 May 2015 6.49pm)

 

derben Flag 15 May 15 6.49pm

Quote legaleagle at 15 May 2015 6.43pm


Quote ChuFukka at 15 May 2015 5.14pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 15 May 2015 5.10pm

Quote ChuFukka at 15 May 2015 4.52pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 15 May 2015 4.41pm

Quote Stuk at 15 May 2015 4.31pm

Quote legaleagle at 15 May 2015 4.20pm

Quote ambrose7 at 15 May 2015 3.58pm

There seems to be a lot of opposition on this thread stating why we should have trade unions and why they should be able to strike, and very few addressing why a 40% pass rate is so unreasonable

Perhaps we should link the % votes ability to strike to the % votes ability of a government to proclaim its legitimacy given the percentage of votes it got? At the moment,that would lower the % rate to 36.9%.

A general election is nothing like a strike ballot which is almost always a basic yes or no.

Stop comparing them, they're nothing like each other.

I think its the inconsistency of a government that has a 37% return, demanding that other systems of approval must represent a much higher figure.

The reality of the unions is that a strike ballot can only be conducted lawfully, by post. Which is about the most inconsistent and unreliable means by which to do so.

The idea that the number of votes necessary should be based on the number of members rather than the returns is absurd, because the returns include no votes as well and may well be related to a local rather than national matter.

But the whole thing is a strawman argument, because the actual reality of the Conservative position isn't about the percentages at all, its about reducing the power and influence of Unions and the capacity of unions to act against the interests of the Government and of Employers.

People who bang on about the percentages are missing the point, the people supporting the anti-union laws aren't interested in whether its 8% of the total membership, or 90% - they want to see the power of unions restricted, they'd support anti-union laws even if the strike actions were returning 100% of the members wishes for strike action.


There's no inconsistency. We need somebody to run the country - what do you suggest we do if there's low turnout; have no government?

Also, the two scenarios aren't remotely comparable, as I explained in my post above.

EDIT: and just to be clear, I don't accept for a second that you truly believe that last sentence, which, in itself, is a neat little straw man (ironically).

Edited by ChuFukka (15 May 2015 4.59pm)

No, what I'm saying is that you can contrast the situation. 35% of the Electorate didn't vote, and the Conservatives got 36% of the votes of those who did.

The interest of the conservatives isn't in fairness, democracy in unions, its about reducing their capacity to act and most notably to take strike action.

I don't doubt that the Conservatives want to quell the (admittedly diminishing) powers of unions - and I'm absolutely behind them on that one.

However, there is simply no comparison between a general election and a yes/no strike vote.


Not a surprise that your personal preference is to curb the powers of unions.

The issue of what constitutes legitimacy generally in terms of a voting outcome is,viewed more objectively as opposed to someone with an axe to grind, perfectly legitimate to raise .You may not agree but that doesn't mean its not a reasonable point of view to contrast a government whose legitimacy rests on less than 40% of those who voted (and where there is no minimum turnout requirement of those eligible to vote) with the requirements for the outcome of a vote by union members to exercise the right of members to strike if approved in accordance with the union's rules.

As for suggesting that it is "intentionally diversionary" to simply raise a reasonable point of view that you don't agree with as a question,that's simply silly,intentionally or otherwise.

Edited by legaleagle (15 May 2015 6.46pm)

You should change your name to pompouseagle

 

ChuFukka Flag 15 May 15 6.55pm

Quote legaleagle at 15 May 2015 6.43pm

Quote ChuFukka at 15 May 2015 5.14pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 15 May 2015 5.10pm

Quote ChuFukka at 15 May 2015 4.52pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 15 May 2015 4.41pm

Quote Stuk at 15 May 2015 4.31pm

Quote legaleagle at 15 May 2015 4.20pm

Quote ambrose7 at 15 May 2015 3.58pm

There seems to be a lot of opposition on this thread stating why we should have trade unions and why they should be able to strike, and very few addressing why a 40% pass rate is so unreasonable

Perhaps we should link the % votes ability to strike to the % votes ability of a government to proclaim its legitimacy given the percentage of votes it got? At the moment,that would lower the % rate to 36.9%.

A general election is nothing like a strike ballot which is almost always a basic yes or no.

Stop comparing them, they're nothing like each other.

I think its the inconsistency of a government that has a 37% return, demanding that other systems of approval must represent a much higher figure.

The reality of the unions is that a strike ballot can only be conducted lawfully, by post. Which is about the most inconsistent and unreliable means by which to do so.

The idea that the number of votes necessary should be based on the number of members rather than the returns is absurd, because the returns include no votes as well and may well be related to a local rather than national matter.

But the whole thing is a strawman argument, because the actual reality of the Conservative position isn't about the percentages at all, its about reducing the power and influence of Unions and the capacity of unions to act against the interests of the Government and of Employers.

People who bang on about the percentages are missing the point, the people supporting the anti-union laws aren't interested in whether its 8% of the total membership, or 90% - they want to see the power of unions restricted, they'd support anti-union laws even if the strike actions were returning 100% of the members wishes for strike action.


There's no inconsistency. We need somebody to run the country - what do you suggest we do if there's low turnout; have no government?

Also, the two scenarios aren't remotely comparable, as I explained in my post above.

EDIT: and just to be clear, I don't accept for a second that you truly believe that last sentence, which, in itself, is a neat little straw man (ironically).

Edited by ChuFukka (15 May 2015 4.59pm)

No, what I'm saying is that you can contrast the situation. 35% of the Electorate didn't vote, and the Conservatives got 36% of the votes of those who did.

The interest of the conservatives isn't in fairness, democracy in unions, its about reducing their capacity to act and most notably to take strike action.

I don't doubt that the Conservatives want to quell the (admittedly diminishing) powers of unions - and I'm absolutely behind them on that one.

However, there is simply no comparison between a general election and a yes/no strike vote.


Not a surprise that your personal preference is to curb the powers of unions.

The issue of what constitutes legitimacy generally in terms of a voting outcome is,viewed more objectively as opposed to someone with an axe to grind, perfectly legitimate to raise .You may not agree but that doesn't mean its not a reasonable point of view to contrast a government whose legitimacy rests on less than 40% of those who voted (and where there is no minimum turnout requirement of those eligible to vote) with the requirements for the outcome of a vote by union members to exercise the right of members to strike if approved in accordance with the union's rules.

As for suggesting that it is "intentionally diversionary" to simply raise as a question a reasonable point of view that you don't agree with and which doesn't fit your agenda of what are pertinent points to raise,, that reflects you seeking to ,that's simply silly IMO.

Edited by legaleagle (15 May 2015 6.49pm)


The key is that they got 40% when there were many, many options in each constituency. Had it been more akin to a strike vote (ie Tory vs Labour) I dare say they might have got a rather higher proportion. As has been said countless times by countless people, it's just not a good comparison.

 

Page 3 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Union bashing