This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Books to Films
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
jamiemartin721 Reading 02 Jun 15 2.54pm |
|
Quote ghosteagle at 02 Jun 2015 2.41pm
Quote Part Time James at 02 Jun 2015 2.30pm
For me books better than films: Virtually every Stephen King book (especially Needful Things, Dark Half and Pet Semetary). I quite liked the Shining but the Kubrick film did miss a lot of important detail and Stephen King hated it. A Clockwork Orange (the film totally missed the main point of the book). The Hunger Games. The books are amazing (IMO). The films are almost as good but you're left there wondering what happened to some of the story.
Films better than books: Trainspotting. I love Irvine Welsh but I thought the film flowed better and made more sense than the book. It was turned more into a storyline by the film. Still a good book though.
I think the missing out of the final chapter was a deliberate attempt to change the tone of the film by Kubrick rather than him missing the point.
Kubrick adapted it from the US novel which didn't have the final chapter for some reason.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" [Link]
|
Part Time James 02 Jun 15 2.57pm |
|
Quote jamiemartin721 at 02 Jun 2015 2.54pm
Quote ghosteagle at 02 Jun 2015 2.41pm
Quote Part Time James at 02 Jun 2015 2.30pm
For me books better than films: Virtually every Stephen King book (especially Needful Things, Dark Half and Pet Semetary). I quite liked the Shining but the Kubrick film did miss a lot of important detail and Stephen King hated it. A Clockwork Orange (the film totally missed the main point of the book). The Hunger Games. The books are amazing (IMO). The films are almost as good but you're left there wondering what happened to some of the story.
Films better than books: Trainspotting. I love Irvine Welsh but I thought the film flowed better and made more sense than the book. It was turned more into a storyline by the film. Still a good book though.
I think the missing out of the final chapter was a deliberate attempt to change the tone of the film by Kubrick rather than him missing the point.
Kubrick adapted it from the US novel which didn't have the final chapter for some reason.
Well I'm learning new things today. It's not like the final chapter really contained any controversy in comparison to earlier chapters so it's odd that it was omitted from the US version of the book. Maybe it was a mis-print? 
|
ghosteagle 02 Jun 15 3.00pm |
|
Quote jamiemartin721 at 02 Jun 2015 2.54pm
Quote ghosteagle at 02 Jun 2015 2.41pm
Quote Part Time James at 02 Jun 2015 2.30pm
For me books better than films: Virtually every Stephen King book (especially Needful Things, Dark Half and Pet Semetary). I quite liked the Shining but the Kubrick film did miss a lot of important detail and Stephen King hated it. A Clockwork Orange (the film totally missed the main point of the book). The Hunger Games. The books are amazing (IMO). The films are almost as good but you're left there wondering what happened to some of the story.
Films better than books: Trainspotting. I love Irvine Welsh but I thought the film flowed better and made more sense than the book. It was turned more into a storyline by the film. Still a good book though.
I think the missing out of the final chapter was a deliberate attempt to change the tone of the film by Kubrick rather than him missing the point.
Kubrick adapted it from the US novel which didn't have the final chapter for some reason.
Ahh, weird. Still, someone must have pointed out that it was missing at some point prior/during filming, so its omission must have been his choice? As PT James says the final chapter is somewhat the moral of the book, and not having it changes the view of 'Alex' that the viewer walks away with.
|
EddtheEagle Falmouth, Cornwall 02 Jun 15 3.02pm |
|
|
Shawshank Redemption - average book made into a great film
|
jamiemartin721 Reading 02 Jun 15 3.11pm |
|
|
As a general rule of thumb it seems Stephen King translates better as film than book. Probably because most of his books are s**t.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" [Link]
|
ghosteagle 02 Jun 15 3.13pm |
|
Quote jamiemartin721 at 02 Jun 2015 3.11pm
As a general rule of thumb it seems Stephen King translates better as film than book. Probably because most of his books are s**t.
I'd say it was more 50/50 then that, there are some truly awful King films. The Langoliers is the worst i've ever seen, not even Dean Stockwell could save it.
|
Canterbury Palace Whitstable 02 Jun 15 3.19pm |
|
|
I thought Hannibal was a fantastic read and a woeful film. I suspect Shantaram might meet the same eventual fate as Johnny Depp has his hands on it.
We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...
|
ghosteagle 02 Jun 15 3.22pm |
|
Quote Canterbury Palace at 02 Jun 2015 3.19pm
I thought Hannibal was a fantastic read and a woeful film. I suspect Shantaram might meet the same eventual fate as Johnny Depp has his hands on it.
If i remember rightly the film bottled the ending which in the book has Starling running off with Hannibal in a kind of gothic romance. It also suffered from the loss of Jody Foster and her replacement by somebody crap.
|
jamiemartin721 Reading 02 Jun 15 3.26pm |
|
Quote Canterbury Palace at 02 Jun 2015 3.19pm
I thought Hannibal was a fantastic read and a woeful film. I suspect Shantaram might meet the same eventual fate as Johnny Depp has his hands on it.
Mordici is a work of genius.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" [Link]
|
Alexi_the_Eagle Newton-le-Willows 02 Jun 15 3.33pm |
|
|
American Psycho is better as a book than a film. Even though Christian Bale was superb as Patrick Bateman, there are chapters in the book that would never have made it into the final cut. The torture with a rat for example, the murder of his ex-girlfriend or the random murder of a child in Central Park Zoo.
Chapters such as Bateman rejecting the advances of a homosexual colleague, or tripping off his face as he walks down a New York street should of made the cut.
Besides, a certain Mr DiCaprio nearly got the part as Bateman.....
"Look at that. Accident blackspot? These aren't accidents! They're throwing themselves into the road gladly! Throwing themselves into the road to escape all this hideousness!"
|
Part Time James 02 Jun 15 3.34pm |
|
Quote jamiemartin721 at 02 Jun 2015 3.11pm
As a general rule of thumb it seems Stephen King translates better as film than book. Probably because most of his books are s**t.
I know these are more like tele-films than 'movies' but have you seen Salem's Lot, Dark Half or Tommyknockers? Amongst the worst films I have ever seen! Although I start from a point of loving his books which is different to your basis for comparison so you could just argue "sh*t films, sh*t books"!
|
Canterbury Palace Whitstable 02 Jun 15 3.37pm |
|
Quote ghosteagle at 02 Jun 2015 3.22pm
Quote Canterbury Palace at 02 Jun 2015 3.19pm
I thought Hannibal was a fantastic read and a woeful film. I suspect Shantaram might meet the same eventual fate as Johnny Depp has his hands on it.
If i remember rightly the film bottled the ending which in the book has Starling running off with Hannibal in a kind of gothic romance. It also suffered from the loss of Jody Foster and her replacement by somebody crap.
Yeah absolutely, it was Julianne Moore who took over and whilst I don't mind her too much, the change of the ending was unforgivable. If my memory serves me, the book also featured the most wonderfully gruesome description of feeding humans to pigs, stuff that would make Brick Top shudder.
We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...
|
Canterbury Palace Whitstable 02 Jun 15 3.40pm |
|
Quote jamiemartin721 at 02 Jun 2015 3.26pm
Quote Canterbury Palace at 02 Jun 2015 3.19pm
I thought Hannibal was a fantastic read and a woeful film. I suspect Shantaram might meet the same eventual fate as Johnny Depp has his hands on it.
Mordici is a work of genius.
I haven't seen it actually but based on IMDB it looks like essential viewing. Any film featuring Paul Whitehouse is bound to have real gravitas.
We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...
|
Part Time James 02 Jun 15 3.41pm |
|
Quote Canterbury Palace at 02 Jun 2015 3.37pm
Quote ghosteagle at 02 Jun 2015 3.22pm
Quote Canterbury Palace at 02 Jun 2015 3.19pm
I thought Hannibal was a fantastic read and a woeful film. I suspect Shantaram might meet the same eventual fate as Johnny Depp has his hands on it.
If i remember rightly the film bottled the ending which in the book has Starling running off with Hannibal in a kind of gothic romance. It also suffered from the loss of Jody Foster and her replacement by somebody crap.
Yeah absolutely, it was Julianne Moore who took over and whilst I don't mind her too much, the change of the ending was unforgivable. If my memory serves me, the book also featured the most wonderfully gruesome description of feeding humans to pigs, stuff that would make Brick Top shudder.
Would.
|
Canterbury Palace Whitstable 02 Jun 15 3.45pm |
|
Quote Part Time James at 02 Jun 2015 3.41pm
Quote Canterbury Palace at 02 Jun 2015 3.37pm
Quote ghosteagle at 02 Jun 2015 3.22pm
Quote Canterbury Palace at 02 Jun 2015 3.19pm
I thought Hannibal was a fantastic read and a woeful film. I suspect Shantaram might meet the same eventual fate as Johnny Depp has his hands on it.
If i remember rightly the film bottled the ending which in the book has Starling running off with Hannibal in a kind of gothic romance. It also suffered from the loss of Jody Foster and her replacement by somebody crap.
Yeah absolutely, it was Julianne Moore who took over and whilst I don't mind her too much, the change of the ending was unforgivable. If my memory serves me, the book also featured the most wonderfully gruesome description of feeding humans to pigs, stuff that would make Brick Top shudder.
Would.
Seconded. Motion carried.
We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...
|
silvertop Portishead 02 Jun 15 4.30pm |
|
|
The Godfather The Exorcist Goodfellas
Trashy airport pulp; masterpiece cinema. You wonder what inspired them? It certainly wasn't the quality of the writing.
|
fledgling Beckenham 02 Jun 15 4.35pm |
|
Quote Canterbury Palace at 02 Jun 2015 3.19pm
I thought Hannibal was a fantastic read and a woeful film. I suspect Shantaram might meet the same eventual fate as Johnny Depp has his hands on it.
As an aside, what did you think of the book?
I saw it through to the bitter end but got so bored with him about a third of the way through.
|
Kermit8 Hevon 02 Jun 15 4.45pm |
|
Quote EddtheEagle at 02 Jun 2015 3.02pm
Shawshank Redemption - average book made into a great film
I believe I am the only person who thought the film was absolute pants especially in comparison to earlier Hollywood prison dramas.
Big chest and massive boobs
[Link]
|
Kermit8 Hevon 02 Jun 15 4.46pm |
|
Quote Canterbury Palace at 02 Jun 2015 3.45pm
Quote Part Time James at 02 Jun 2015 3.41pm
Quote Canterbury Palace at 02 Jun 2015 3.37pm
Quote ghosteagle at 02 Jun 2015 3.22pm
Quote Canterbury Palace at 02 Jun 2015 3.19pm
I thought Hannibal was a fantastic read and a woeful film. I suspect Shantaram might meet the same eventual fate as Johnny Depp has his hands on it.
If i remember rightly the film bottled the ending which in the book has Starling running off with Hannibal in a kind of gothic romance. It also suffered from the loss of Jody Foster and her replacement by somebody crap.
Yeah absolutely, it was Julianne Moore who took over and whilst I don't mind her too much, the change of the ending was unforgivable. If my memory serves me, the book also featured the most wonderfully gruesome description of feeding humans to pigs, stuff that would make Brick Top shudder.
Would.
Seconded. Motion carried.
Saw her do a lezzer scene with Amanda Seyfried last week in some movie. Still a quiver.
Big chest and massive boobs
[Link]
|
sa_eagle Just outside Cape Town 02 Jun 15 4.47pm |
|
Quote The Sash at 02 Jun 2015 12.01pm
Quote sa_eagle at 02 Jun 2015 11.40am
I've not read Jaws but it sounds like you got hold of that rare book that isn't better than the film.
The worst I've ever seen was Polanski's version of Tess of the d'Urbervilles (Tess). He cocked up the order of events so after Tess is raped she's seen with her attacker enjoying a row on the pond. For me that ruined the film.
Another example of a film not being anywhere near as good as the book is 12 Years A Slave. A really good film I'll admit but not a patch on the book, mainly because it misses the main point which was Solomon Northup's unending quest to regain his freedom. The film seemed to prefer to revel in the baseness of the condition of the slaves which isn't the point of the book, though Northup does address it.
I think the worst I know is To Kill a Mockingbird...as a book its a sublime journey through a young kids rite of passage - the film is just turned into s simplistic courtroom drama with the rest tacked on...
Totally agree!
Cynic or realist? It's a fine line!
|