You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > The Met - TV documentary
November 22 2026 1.58am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Met - TV documentary


Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
dannyh Flag wherever I lay my hat....... 10 Jun 15 9.45am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 10 Jun 2015 9.41am

Quote JL85 at 09 Jun 2015 8.58pm

Quote kennybrowns leftfoot at 09 Jun 2015 8.48pm

Quote JL85 at 09 Jun 2015 8.01pm

I'm with ghosteagle and unfortunately the law doesn't act on balance of probability. As a juror you have to be absolutely 100% sure a defendant is guilty to pass a guilty judgement. The same should go for armed police, imo.

Balance of probability killed Mark Duggan, who, yes, was scum. But balance of probability also killed alot of innocent people down the years too.

It's not acceptable and we should demand more from our police, especially those carrying live fire arms.

You're right the law doesn't act on the balance of probability, but this wasn't a criminal trial, it was an inquest.

It doesn't matter what it was or wasn't. A humans life should never be taken on a balance of probability. The officer failed his duty, in my eyes, and wrongly killed a man.

That's not to say he should be demonised, I won't claim to have done differently, but then, I'm not a trained Police marksman.


Edited by JL85 (09 Jun 2015 8.59pm)

You can only really work on the information that you have available to you. Duggan had just purchased a firearm from friend, who was also a police informant I believe, when the police intercepted the taxi he was travelling in, Duggan disposed of the gun it seems, but its reasonable to assume the police, from the evidence, we not aware of that fact, and were still to the best of their knowledge dealing with an armed suspect.

Its a regrettable outcome, that an unarmed man was shot and killed. Pending further evidence, its hard not to accepted that whilst regrettable, the evidence points towards a lawful shooting.


How dare you let fect and common sense take away the god given right of scum bags to demand money from the Government ( because for sure that will be next ).

 


"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 10 Jun 15 9.50am

Quote npn at 10 Jun 2015 8.27am

I'm with the boys in blue all the way on this one.

If Duggan had got away, complete with gun, and had subsequently shot someone, the police would have been deemed to be in the wrong for not stopping him (presumably by asking him politely if he still had the gun, and if he said no, asking him to be a good chap and stop for a bit of a chat).

People still also get up in arms (pardon the pun) about people shot who are holding imitation firearms - honestly, it's like you've actually got to be shot before you can fire back if you're a policeman to keep everyone happy.

I think we should always investigate police shootings to see if they could be avoided, and what went wrong, because procedurally the methods used in say the Charles De Menezies shooting really were flawed to the point of incompetence (and was essentially a tragedy waiting to happen).

We also need to reform the IPCC so that it trains its own investigators rather than its current approach where its 80% ex-Police (Cheaper as they have the skills). Its independence is questionable at best.

Also the laws need to be changed so that the investigation isn't based around the shooter, but the operation itself. Too often its the firing officer who is on trial, not the operation planner. The interception of Mark Duggan put the life of the Taxi Driver at serious risk, in order to obtain a 'conviction in possession', it has the hallmarks of some of the recklessness used by the Flying Squad in the 70s.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

kennybrowns leftfoot Flag Reigate 10 Jun 15 9.50am

What did annoy me about the documentary on Monday was the senior officers reactions when the verdict came through.

They were virtually apologetic for the outcome of the verdict when they should of been re-inforcing that jury had made the correct correct decision and also thanked and supported those firearms officers involved for what they had been through.

 


Don't waste your time with jealousy. Sometimes your ahead, sometimes your behind, the race is long. But in the end it's only with yourself!!

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 10 Jun 15 9.51am

You have to remember that these 'situations' are very fraught and tense, lots of adrenaline, guns and the very real possibility of people, on all sides being killed.

Weirdly the police officer shot, and saved from injury by his radio, was shot by police round.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

kennybrowns leftfoot Flag Reigate 10 Jun 15 9.53am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 10 Jun 2015 9.50am

Quote npn at 10 Jun 2015 8.27am

I'm with the boys in blue all the way on this one.

If Duggan had got away, complete with gun, and had subsequently shot someone, the police would have been deemed to be in the wrong for not stopping him (presumably by asking him politely if he still had the gun, and if he said no, asking him to be a good chap and stop for a bit of a chat).

People still also get up in arms (pardon the pun) about people shot who are holding imitation firearms - honestly, it's like you've actually got to be shot before you can fire back if you're a policeman to keep everyone happy.

I think we should always investigate police shootings to see if they could be avoided, and what went wrong, because procedurally the methods used in say the Charles De Menezies shooting really were flawed to the point of incompetence (and was essentially a tragedy waiting to happen).

We also need to reform the IPCC so that it trains its own investigators rather than its current approach where its 80% ex-Police (Cheaper as they have the skills). Its independence is questionable at best.

Also the laws need to be changed so that the investigation isn't based around the shooter, but the operation itself. Too often its the firing officer who is on trial, not the operation planner. The interception of Mark Duggan put the life of the Taxi Driver at serious risk, in order to obtain a 'conviction in possession', it has the hallmarks of some of the recklessness used by the Flying Squad in the 70s.


I'm all for firearms operations being filmed and every officer has a body camera. I wear one as Croydon is one of the four pilot boroughs that are trailing them... They really are a great bit of kit.


 


Don't waste your time with jealousy. Sometimes your ahead, sometimes your behind, the race is long. But in the end it's only with yourself!!

Plane Flag Bromley 10 Jun 15 10.06am

Quote kennybrowns leftfoot at 10 Jun 2015 9.50am

What did annoy me about the documentary on Monday was the senior officers reactions when the verdict came through.

They were virtually apologetic for the outcome of the verdict when they should of been re-inforcing that jury had made the correct correct decision and also thanked and supported those firearms officers involved for what they had been through.

Trouble is, the top brass are virtually politicians though.

 

Plane Flag Bromley 10 Jun 15 10.07am

Quote kennybrowns leftfoot at 10 Jun 2015 9.53am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 10 Jun 2015 9.50am

Quote npn at 10 Jun 2015 8.27am

I'm with the boys in blue all the way on this one.

If Duggan had got away, complete with gun, and had subsequently shot someone, the police would have been deemed to be in the wrong for not stopping him (presumably by asking him politely if he still had the gun, and if he said no, asking him to be a good chap and stop for a bit of a chat).

People still also get up in arms (pardon the pun) about people shot who are holding imitation firearms - honestly, it's like you've actually got to be shot before you can fire back if you're a policeman to keep everyone happy.

I think we should always investigate police shootings to see if they could be avoided, and what went wrong, because procedurally the methods used in say the Charles De Menezies shooting really were flawed to the point of incompetence (and was essentially a tragedy waiting to happen).

We also need to reform the IPCC so that it trains its own investigators rather than its current approach where its 80% ex-Police (Cheaper as they have the skills). Its independence is questionable at best.

Also the laws need to be changed so that the investigation isn't based around the shooter, but the operation itself. Too often its the firing officer who is on trial, not the operation planner. The interception of Mark Duggan put the life of the Taxi Driver at serious risk, in order to obtain a 'conviction in possession', it has the hallmarks of some of the recklessness used by the Flying Squad in the 70s.


I'm all for firearms operations being filmed and every officer has a body camera. I wear one as Croydon is one of the four pilot boroughs that are trailing them... They really are a great bit of kit.



But how do you get to kick the living sh!t out of some of the scum bags you encounter

 

dannyh Flag wherever I lay my hat....... 10 Jun 15 10.23am

Quote Plane at 10 Jun 2015 10.07am

Quote kennybrowns leftfoot at 10 Jun 2015 9.53am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 10 Jun 2015 9.50am

Quote npn at 10 Jun 2015 8.27am

I'm with the boys in blue all the way on this one.

If Duggan had got away, complete with gun, and had subsequently shot someone, the police would have been deemed to be in the wrong for not stopping him (presumably by asking him politely if he still had the gun, and if he said no, asking him to be a good chap and stop for a bit of a chat).

People still also get up in arms (pardon the pun) about people shot who are holding imitation firearms - honestly, it's like you've actually got to be shot before you can fire back if you're a policeman to keep everyone happy.

I think we should always investigate police shootings to see if they could be avoided, and what went wrong, because procedurally the methods used in say the Charles De Menezies shooting really were flawed to the point of incompetence (and was essentially a tragedy waiting to happen).

We also need to reform the IPCC so that it trains its own investigators rather than its current approach where its 80% ex-Police (Cheaper as they have the skills). Its independence is questionable at best.

Also the laws need to be changed so that the investigation isn't based around the shooter, but the operation itself. Too often its the firing officer who is on trial, not the operation planner. The interception of Mark Duggan put the life of the Taxi Driver at serious risk, in order to obtain a 'conviction in possession', it has the hallmarks of some of the recklessness used by the Flying Squad in the 70s.


I'm all for firearms operations being filmed and every officer has a body camera. I wear one as Croydon is one of the four pilot boroughs that are trailing them... They really are a great bit of kit.



But how do you get to kick the living sh!t out of some of the scum bags you encounter

I will wager the amount of "faulty" camera's in the first few months will be astounding.

 


"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"

kennybrowns leftfoot Flag Reigate 10 Jun 15 10.31am

Hahaha!!.. Honestly though they are great. Complaints have dropped by around 40% since we started wearing them.. I had a black guy ring up and make a complaint that I called him a 'f***in spade' during a traffic stop.. The Inspector said 'ok Sir I'll look at the footage from the officers body camera and get back to you'... The guy said 'don't bother... Your all c***s' and hung up as he knew he'd been found out making things up!!

 


Don't waste your time with jealousy. Sometimes your ahead, sometimes your behind, the race is long. But in the end it's only with yourself!!

JL85 Flag London,SE9 10 Jun 15 10.49am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 10 Jun 2015 9.41am

Quote JL85 at 09 Jun 2015 8.58pm

Quote kennybrowns leftfoot at 09 Jun 2015 8.48pm

Quote JL85 at 09 Jun 2015 8.01pm

I'm with ghosteagle and unfortunately the law doesn't act on balance of probability. As a juror you have to be absolutely 100% sure a defendant is guilty to pass a guilty judgement. The same should go for armed police, imo.

Balance of probability killed Mark Duggan, who, yes, was scum. But balance of probability also killed alot of innocent people down the years too.

It's not acceptable and we should demand more from our police, especially those carrying live fire arms.

You're right the law doesn't act on the balance of probability, but this wasn't a criminal trial, it was an inquest.

It doesn't matter what it was or wasn't. A humans life should never be taken on a balance of probability. The officer failed his duty, in my eyes, and wrongly killed a man.

That's not to say he should be demonised, I won't claim to have done differently, but then, I'm not a trained Police marksman.


Edited by JL85 (09 Jun 2015 8.59pm)

You can only really work on the information that you have available to you. Duggan had just purchased a firearm from friend, who was also a police informant I believe, when the police intercepted the taxi he was travelling in, Duggan disposed of the gun it seems, but its reasonable to assume the police, from the evidence, we not aware of that fact, and were still to the best of their knowledge dealing with an armed suspect.

Its a regrettable outcome, that an unarmed man was shot and killed. Pending further evidence, its hard not to accepted that whilst regrettable, the evidence points towards a lawful shooting.


It's still all assumption based though Jamie, and whilst i appreciate that you never have 100% knolwdge that man is armed/unarmed, the way he is followed, contained etc makes a big difference.

He was shot whilst running away. And he was unarmed. It's not acceptable imo.

 

Hoof Hearted 10 Jun 15 10.49am

Well done Kenny for clearing things up.

There will always be plonkers like "ghosteagle" that will never accept what happened.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 10 Jun 15 11.33am

Quote JL85 at 10 Jun 2015 10.49am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 10 Jun 2015 9.41am

Quote JL85 at 09 Jun 2015 8.58pm

Quote kennybrowns leftfoot at 09 Jun 2015 8.48pm

Quote JL85 at 09 Jun 2015 8.01pm

I'm with ghosteagle and unfortunately the law doesn't act on balance of probability. As a juror you have to be absolutely 100% sure a defendant is guilty to pass a guilty judgement. The same should go for armed police, imo.

Balance of probability killed Mark Duggan, who, yes, was scum. But balance of probability also killed alot of innocent people down the years too.

It's not acceptable and we should demand more from our police, especially those carrying live fire arms.

You're right the law doesn't act on the balance of probability, but this wasn't a criminal trial, it was an inquest.

It doesn't matter what it was or wasn't. A humans life should never be taken on a balance of probability. The officer failed his duty, in my eyes, and wrongly killed a man.

That's not to say he should be demonised, I won't claim to have done differently, but then, I'm not a trained Police marksman.


Edited by JL85 (09 Jun 2015 8.59pm)

You can only really work on the information that you have available to you. Duggan had just purchased a firearm from friend, who was also a police informant I believe, when the police intercepted the taxi he was travelling in, Duggan disposed of the gun it seems, but its reasonable to assume the police, from the evidence, we not aware of that fact, and were still to the best of their knowledge dealing with an armed suspect.

Its a regrettable outcome, that an unarmed man was shot and killed. Pending further evidence, its hard not to accepted that whilst regrettable, the evidence points towards a lawful shooting.


It's still all assumption based though Jamie, and whilst i appreciate that you never have 100% knolwdge that man is armed/unarmed, the way he is followed, contained etc makes a big difference.

He was shot whilst running away. And he was unarmed. It's not acceptable imo.

Except he wasn't shot whilst running away, he was shot whilst stationary, and holding a mobile phone. History of shootings have shown that its quite common for an officer to shoot someone they believe to be holding a firearm, which turns out of be something else and this is a common psychological phenomena in high pressure situations.

Even the eye witness claims Duggan wasn't running when he was shot, but does state that his arms were raised as if surrendering, which does contradict the intercepting officers statements. But without further evidence its impossible to corroborate (one eye witness, from a 9th floor window is not reliable).


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

dannyh Flag wherever I lay my hat....... 10 Jun 15 11.54am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 10 Jun 2015 11.33am

Quote JL85 at 10 Jun 2015 10.49am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 10 Jun 2015 9.41am

Quote JL85 at 09 Jun 2015 8.58pm

Quote kennybrowns leftfoot at 09 Jun 2015 8.48pm

Quote JL85 at 09 Jun 2015 8.01pm

I'm with ghosteagle and unfortunately the law doesn't act on balance of probability. As a juror you have to be absolutely 100% sure a defendant is guilty to pass a guilty judgement. The same should go for armed police, imo.

Balance of probability killed Mark Duggan, who, yes, was scum. But balance of probability also killed alot of innocent people down the years too.

It's not acceptable and we should demand more from our police, especially those carrying live fire arms.

You're right the law doesn't act on the balance of probability, but this wasn't a criminal trial, it was an inquest.

It doesn't matter what it was or wasn't. A humans life should never be taken on a balance of probability. The officer failed his duty, in my eyes, and wrongly killed a man.

That's not to say he should be demonised, I won't claim to have done differently, but then, I'm not a trained Police marksman.


Edited by JL85 (09 Jun 2015 8.59pm)

You can only really work on the information that you have available to you. Duggan had just purchased a firearm from friend, who was also a police informant I believe, when the police intercepted the taxi he was travelling in, Duggan disposed of the gun it seems, but its reasonable to assume the police, from the evidence, we not aware of that fact, and were still to the best of their knowledge dealing with an armed suspect.

Its a regrettable outcome, that an unarmed man was shot and killed. Pending further evidence, its hard not to accepted that whilst regrettable, the evidence points towards a lawful shooting.


It's still all assumption based though Jamie, and whilst i appreciate that you never have 100% knolwdge that man is armed/unarmed, the way he is followed, contained etc makes a big difference.

He was shot whilst running away. And he was unarmed. It's not acceptable imo.

Except he wasn't shot whilst running away, he was shot whilst stationary, and holding a mobile phone. History of shootings have shown that its quite common for an officer to shoot someone they believe to be holding a firearm, which turns out of be something else and this is a common psychological phenomena in high pressure situations.

Even the eye witness claims Duggan wasn't running when he was shot, but does state that his arms were raised as if surrendering, which does contradict the intercepting officers statements. But without further evidence its impossible to corroborate (one eye witness, from a 9th floor window is not reliable).


There you go again, using that common sense malarky, it will get you no where you know.

 


"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 10 Jun 15 5.10pm

The media show on R4 this afternoon discussed the documentary. Quite interesting I thought. Think it's on the R4 website if you want to listen.

 

JL85 Flag London,SE9 10 Jun 15 5.49pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 10 Jun 2015 11.33am

Quote JL85 at 10 Jun 2015 10.49am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 10 Jun 2015 9.41am

Quote JL85 at 09 Jun 2015 8.58pm

Quote kennybrowns leftfoot at 09 Jun 2015 8.48pm

Quote JL85 at 09 Jun 2015 8.01pm

I'm with ghosteagle and unfortunately the law doesn't act on balance of probability. As a juror you have to be absolutely 100% sure a defendant is guilty to pass a guilty judgement. The same should go for armed police, imo.

Balance of probability killed Mark Duggan, who, yes, was scum. But balance of probability also killed alot of innocent people down the years too.

It's not acceptable and we should demand more from our police, especially those carrying live fire arms.

You're right the law doesn't act on the balance of probability, but this wasn't a criminal trial, it was an inquest.

It doesn't matter what it was or wasn't. A humans life should never be taken on a balance of probability. The officer failed his duty, in my eyes, and wrongly killed a man.

That's not to say he should be demonised, I won't claim to have done differently, but then, I'm not a trained Police marksman.


Edited by JL85 (09 Jun 2015 8.59pm)

You can only really work on the information that you have available to you. Duggan had just purchased a firearm from friend, who was also a police informant I believe, when the police intercepted the taxi he was travelling in, Duggan disposed of the gun it seems, but its reasonable to assume the police, from the evidence, we not aware of that fact, and were still to the best of their knowledge dealing with an armed suspect.

Its a regrettable outcome, that an unarmed man was shot and killed. Pending further evidence, its hard not to accepted that whilst regrettable, the evidence points towards a lawful shooting.


It's still all assumption based though Jamie, and whilst i appreciate that you never have 100% knolwdge that man is armed/unarmed, the way he is followed, contained etc makes a big difference.

He was shot whilst running away. And he was unarmed. It's not acceptable imo.

Except he wasn't shot whilst running away, he was shot whilst stationary, and holding a mobile phone. History of shootings have shown that its quite common for an officer to shoot someone they believe to be holding a firearm, which turns out of be something else and this is a common psychological phenomena in high pressure situations.

Even the eye witness claims Duggan wasn't running when he was shot, but does state that his arms were raised as if surrendering, which does contradict the intercepting officers statements. But without further evidence its impossible to corroborate (one eye witness, from a 9th floor window is not reliable).



From the man driving the cab:

The car that had stopped – men got out of it very quickly who were carrying guns in their hands. Then I heard the sound of my rear door opening. I saw that Mark Duggan got out and ran. At the same time, I heard firing from the front. I saw shots strike Mark Duggan. He fell to the ground.

Another witness:


According to another eyewitness cited in The Telegraph, a police officer had "shouted to the man to stop 'a couple of times', but he had not heeded the warning".

Edited by JL85 (10 Jun 2015 5.50pm)

 

JL85 Flag London,SE9 10 Jun 15 5.52pm

Quote dannyh at 09 Jun 2015 7.33pm

Ghost eagle you have no point, no argument, no IQ, no anything really, you are to debate what Pol Pot was to peace and free speech.

If you have nothing constructive to say then please save us all the effort of having to glance at your aimless meandering unfunny and shallow comments.

There's a good boy.


Sometimes i think you need to take your own advice, danny.

 

JL85 Flag London,SE9 10 Jun 15 6.01pm

I think ultimately, the below highlights how lacklustre and amature the whole operation was:

One of the officers who had surrounded Duggan was hit by a bullet, which had lodged in his radio. However, it had not been fired by Duggan but by the policeman identified only as V53, before it passed through Duggan's arm and hit the officer. The shot policeman was taken to a hospital and released the same evening.

Forgive the cut and paste from Wikipedia. Duggan could have been apprehended better, contained better and probably left serving a long sentance if not for the poor judgement of a Police officer.

That's not a lawful killing for me. However, the fact that the shooting officer has been removed from firearms duty is definetly the right course of action to take. Clearly not up to the job.

I also find it incredible that officers can and did refuse to be interviewed by the IPCC.

Edited by JL85 (10 Jun 2015 6.04pm)

 

dannyh Flag wherever I lay my hat....... 10 Jun 15 6.44pm

Quote JL85 at 10 Jun 2015 5.52pm

Quote dannyh at 09 Jun 2015 7.33pm

Ghost eagle you have no point, no argument, no IQ, no anything really, you are to debate what Pol Pot was to peace and free speech.

If you have nothing constructive to say then please save us all the effort of having to glance at your aimless meandering unfunny and shallow comments.

There's a good boy.


Sometimes i think you need to take your own advice, danny.

Oh look another conspiracy theorist.

 


"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"

dannyh Flag wherever I lay my hat....... 10 Jun 15 6.46pm

Quote JL85 at 10 Jun 2015 6.01pm

I think ultimately, the below highlights how lacklustre and amature the whole operation was:

One of the officers who had surrounded Duggan was hit by a bullet, which had lodged in his radio. However, it had not been fired by Duggan but by the policeman identified only as V53, before it passed through Duggan's arm and hit the officer. The shot policeman was taken to a hospital and released the same evening.

Forgive the cut and paste from Wikipedia. Duggan could have been apprehended better, contained better and probably left serving a long sentance if not for the poor judgement of a Police officer.

That's not a lawful killing for me. However, the fact that the shooting officer has been removed from firearms duty is definetly the right course of action to take. Clearly not up to the job.

I also find it incredible that officers can and did refuse to be interviewed by the IPCC.

Edited by JL85 (10 Jun 2015 6.04pm)

Oh right its on Wikipedia it must be true, I'd be more convinced if it appeared in the Sport on Sunday.


 


"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"

JL85 Flag London,SE9 10 Jun 15 6.54pm

Quote dannyh at 10 Jun 2015 6.44pm

Quote JL85 at 10 Jun 2015 5.52pm

Quote dannyh at 09 Jun 2015 7.33pm

Ghost eagle you have no point, no argument, no IQ, no anything really, you are to debate what Pol Pot was to peace and free speech.

If you have nothing constructive to say then please save us all the effort of having to glance at your aimless meandering unfunny and shallow comments.

There's a good boy.


Sometimes i think you need to take your own advice, danny.

Oh look another conspiracy theorist.

How predictable. Thanks for justifying my post.

 

Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > The Met - TV documentary