You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Hate preacher
November 22 2026 1.58am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Hate preacher


Page 3 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
sydtheeagle Flag England 24 Jun 15 7.05am

Quote legaleagle at 23 Jun 2015 11.28pm

But,I am curious.He was born here.Where precisely would you "ship him out" to and on what legal basis?

Also, where would we draw the line between which highly objectionable British citizens born here should be "shipped out" and which should not?As a hypothetical example, what about a born here British citizen with a similar public profile who was a just as objectionable advocate of extreme right ring racism and race war etc and acted as if approvingly of the race-related murders,but was personally not able to be proven to have contravened the law? Ship them out? Where to?

Edited by legaleagle (23 Jun 2015 11.31pm)

If he was not born here then I assume his British citizenship results from his being naturalised at some point (that's an interesting word, isn't it?) So I would ship him back to his country of origin, stripping him of his citizenship in the purpose. I'm sure they wouldn't want him any more than us, but what the Lord giveth, the Lord taketh away. We can argue he's not our problem.

The hypothetical example you give is just as simple if you eschew the layers of moral complexity most of us build around these situations. If he's a born an bred Englishman then he's our problem, unfortunate as that may be, and you can't ship him out because he's already reached his destination. But this reality, in a way, underlines why I would send Choudhary packing. We have a moral responsibility to deal with our own nut jobs. We don't have the bandwidth to deal with those of other countries.

What you would you do with the recondite English-born racist allowed to stay here is another, and perhaps more challenging question. Unfortunately, in a free society the answer is to probably to let him get on with spreading his filth safe in the knowledge that he will be counterbalanced by the opinions of the vast majority of intelligent people. In reality, it is only through the presence of extremists who challenge the status quo that the status quo finds a sensible balance so his presence, in fact, has an unintended beneficial effect on society.

How many right-wing extremists and racists in America, I wonder, will have woken up this week to find Dylan Roof staring back at them in the mirror and been sobered by the experience? I suspect at least some have disavowed their previous beliefs as a result of seeing innocent people dead and Roof in handcuffs. Of course, some will still be lionising him, but not all. The bad serves a purpose as well as the good.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 24 Jun 15 9.48am

You cannot deport someone from the UK without sufficient legal grounds. Its a moot point as he was born in Welling, in England, to parents of pakistani decent. In fact he was deported from Lebanon to the UK (and banned from entry into France).

Very much 'our problem'. Its also very likely that several of the groups he's been a spokesperson of, were banned under anti-terrorist legislation, in a manner that would otherwise infringe the rights of free speech and expression (National Security laws suspend certain human rights).

Often people like this are a godsend to intelligence agencies, as typically people who end up extremists, usually belong in earlier stages to these kinds of people or groups.


Edited by jamiemartin721 (24 Jun 2015 9.50am)

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

legaleagle Flag 24 Jun 15 10.56pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 24 Jun 2015 7.05am

Quote legaleagle at 23 Jun 2015 11.28pm

But,I am curious.He was born here.Where precisely would you "ship him out" to and on what legal basis?

Also, where would we draw the line between which highly objectionable British citizens born here should be "shipped out" and which should not?As a hypothetical example, what about a born here British citizen with a similar public profile who was a just as objectionable advocate of extreme right ring racism and race war etc and acted as if approvingly of the race-related murders,but was personally not able to be proven to have contravened the law? Ship them out? Where to?

Edited by legaleagle (23 Jun 2015 11.31pm)

If he was not born here then I assume his British citizenship results from his being naturalised at some point (that's an interesting word, isn't it?) So I would ship him back to his country of origin, stripping him of his citizenship in the purpose. I'm sure they wouldn't want him any more than us, but what the Lord giveth, the Lord taketh away. We can argue he's not our problem.

The hypothetical example you give is just as simple if you eschew the layers of moral complexity most of us build around these situations. If he's a born an bred Englishman then he's our problem, unfortunate as that may be, and you can't ship him out because he's already reached his destination. But this reality, in a way, underlines why I would send Choudhary packing. We have a moral responsibility to deal with our own nut jobs. We don't have the bandwidth to deal with those of other countries.

What you would you do with the recondite English-born racist allowed to stay here is another, and perhaps more challenging question. Unfortunately, in a free society the answer is to probably to let him get on with spreading his filth safe in the knowledge that he will be counterbalanced by the opinions of the vast majority of intelligent people. In reality, it is only through the presence of extremists who challenge the status quo that the status quo finds a sensible balance so his presence, in fact, has an unintended beneficial effect on society.

How many right-wing extremists and racists in America, I wonder, will have woken up this week to find Dylan Roof staring back at them in the mirror and been sobered by the experience? I suspect at least some have disavowed their previous beliefs as a result of seeing innocent people dead and Roof in handcuffs. Of course, some will still be lionising him, but not all. The bad serves a purpose as well as the good.


I think we're in general agreement on the point I was raising.

I had assumed you already knew he was born here (as I stated in my post) when you wrote the post I was responding to, and that he was was not a naturalised citizen,so I was querying you on the basis I thought you were suggesting he be kicked out notwithstanding him being a British-born British citizen.Hence,I also raised the hypothetical example of another kind of "undesirable" born-here citizen.

As I understand it,you can't strip someone of citizenship unless there are reasonable grounds for believing that the person is able to acquire another nationality. You can't leave someone with no right to any citizenship.UK law (Immigration Act 2014,though I'm not sure if fully implemented yet) now allows for people with only British citizenship to be deprived of citizenship on certain grounds (acting in a manner seriously prejudicial to the UK's vital interests) but not if there are no reasonable grounds for believing they are entitled to other citizenship.

The Australian government have been grappling recently with proposed legislation about stripping citizenship (leading to no right to stay)for people engaging in "terrorist/terrorist support" acts domestically. But it will only apply to dual nationals,no suggestion so far as I'm aware it would strip a person who only has Australian nationality of citizenship and kick them out.

Edited by legaleagle (24 Jun 2015 11.39pm)

 

PassDribbleShoot Flag London 24 Jun 15 11.48pm

This man is a vile individual disliked by Muslims for his views. Unfortunately he is clever and knows the right things to say yet the Media continue to give him importance. He will trip up one day.

Edited by PassDribbleShoot (25 Jun 2015 1.01pm)

 

dannyh Flag wherever I lay my hat....... 25 Jun 15 8.02am

I have no doubt he knows exactly what flames he is fanning with his obviously divisive agenda, and if the media are dumb enough (we all know they are) to give him air time then he will continue to irritate where ever he can. However all this bollicks about him recruiting for ISIS etc etc, is just plain old posturing and tub thumping.

He could fart and the security services would know about it before he did.

Blokes a nuissance nothing more.

 


"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"

elgrande Flag bedford 25 Jun 15 12.09pm

Quote legaleagle at 23 Jun 2015 11.28pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 23 Jun 2015 2.19pm

What Choudhary did is neither terrorism nor even incitement to terrorism. There's no case to answer here though righteous indignation, moral outrage and disgust are the appropriate responses of any sane person. That the policeman appears to have kept his cool is to his credit. I think in another thread I generally defended the rights of those unhappy in this country to remain here as it seems to me the fundamental right, even duty, of a citizen is to seek to change his country for the better where he finds a genuine wrong. So those unhappy here due, say, to racist abuse have every right to complain and remain simultaneously. Choudhary, however, does not fit that bill as he is simply creating outrage for destructive, rather than constructive purposes and I would ship him out without missing a heartbeat. Unreconstructed scum. This is not a question of where you stand on the political spectrum; filth doesn't vote. It's just filth.


syd,

I'm in general full agreement with your analysis and views about him, including the "unreconstructed scum" bit.He's very clever,he's a trained lawyer and is very astute it seems at staying just within the margins of the law generally.It has been speculated (I have no idea with what correctness) that it suits the authorities for him to be "out and about" since the security services have found his presence not unhelpful.

But,I am curious.He was born here.Where precisely would you "ship him out" to and on what legal basis?

Also, where would we draw the line between which highly objectionable British citizens born here should be "shipped out" and which should not?As a hypothetical example, what about a born here British citizen with a similar public profile who was a just as objectionable advocate of extreme right ring racism and race war etc and acted as if approvingly of the race-related murders,but was personally not able to be proven to have contravened the law? Ship them out? Where to?

Edited by legaleagle (23 Jun 2015 11.31pm)

If he is a trained lawyer.....why is he on benefits.

 


always a Norwood boy, where ever I live.

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 25 Jun 15 12.30pm

Quote elgrande at 25 Jun 2015 12.09pm

Quote legaleagle at 23 Jun 2015 11.28pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 23 Jun 2015 2.19pm

What Choudhary did is neither terrorism nor even incitement to terrorism. There's no case to answer here though righteous indignation, moral outrage and disgust are the appropriate responses of any sane person. That the policeman appears to have kept his cool is to his credit. I think in another thread I generally defended the rights of those unhappy in this country to remain here as it seems to me the fundamental right, even duty, of a citizen is to seek to change his country for the better where he finds a genuine wrong. So those unhappy here due, say, to racist abuse have every right to complain and remain simultaneously. Choudhary, however, does not fit that bill as he is simply creating outrage for destructive, rather than constructive purposes and I would ship him out without missing a heartbeat. Unreconstructed scum. This is not a question of where you stand on the political spectrum; filth doesn't vote. It's just filth.


syd,

I'm in general full agreement with your analysis and views about him, including the "unreconstructed scum" bit.He's very clever,he's a trained lawyer and is very astute it seems at staying just within the margins of the law generally.It has been speculated (I have no idea with what correctness) that it suits the authorities for him to be "out and about" since the security services have found his presence not unhelpful.

But,I am curious.He was born here.Where precisely would you "ship him out" to and on what legal basis?

Also, where would we draw the line between which highly objectionable British citizens born here should be "shipped out" and which should not?As a hypothetical example, what about a born here British citizen with a similar public profile who was a just as objectionable advocate of extreme right ring racism and race war etc and acted as if approvingly of the race-related murders,but was personally not able to be proven to have contravened the law? Ship them out? Where to?

Edited by legaleagle (23 Jun 2015 11.31pm)

If he is a trained lawyer.....why is he on benefits.

Out of work probably, not many people presumably want to be represented by one of the most reviled and hated men in the UK. Particually one that's almost certainly got the level of MI-5 Survelliance that can tell you what he will have for breakfast, the night before...


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

johnfirewall Flag 25 Jun 15 12.58pm

We don't even get rid of criminals from outside the EU, but I'd be up for finding a new Australia so we can get rid of some of our own as well. Should have held on to Oz. They barely even let us in now.

 

wombat84 Flag 05 Aug 15 2.03pm

Choudary the C..T has just been nicked.
About F.....g time.

 

Jimenez Flag SELHURSTPARKCHESTER,DA BRONX 05 Aug 15 2.10pm

Quote wombat84 at 05 Aug 2015 2.03pm

Choudary the C..T has just been nicked.
About F.....g time.


Whatever he's been arrested for. I hope it results in him being deported to The USA. It also makes me hanker for the good old days of Police brutality......

 


Pro USA & Israel

wombat84 Flag 05 Aug 15 3.09pm

Quote Jimenez at 05 Aug 2015 2.10pm

Quote wombat84 at 05 Aug 2015 2.03pm

Choudary the C..T has just been nicked.
About F.....g time.


Whatever he's been arrested for. I hope it results in him being deported to The USA. It also makes me hanker for the good old days of Police brutality......


Totally agree.

 

elgrande Flag bedford 05 Aug 15 3.54pm

Lets not forget.......This f***wit is a qualified solicitor,but chooses to live on Benifits.

 


always a Norwood boy, where ever I live.

collier row eagle Flag romford essex via another galaxy 05 Aug 15 4.20pm

"Britain first" has been on this pric*s case for sometime in a campaign to get hate preachers like him of our streets, good news.

 

kingdowieonthewall Flag Sussex, ex-Cronx. 05 Aug 15 4.36pm

Quote Jimenez at 05 Aug 2015 2.10pm

Quote wombat84 at 05 Aug 2015 2.03pm

Choudary the C..T has just been nicked.
About F.....g time.


Whatever he's been arrested for. I hope it results in him being deported to The USA. It also makes me hanker for the good old days of Police brutality......

norbury nick would've done him good.
In the 80s-90s you'd get a mattress put on you and a belting.
much feared was a trip to that nick for over doing it.

 


Kids,tired of being bothered by your pesky parents?
Then leave home, get a job & pay your own bills, while you still know everything.

elgrande Flag bedford 05 Aug 15 4.44pm

Quote kingdowieonthewall at 05 Aug 2015 4.36pm

Quote Jimenez at 05 Aug 2015 2.10pm

Quote wombat84 at 05 Aug 2015 2.03pm

Choudary the C..T has just been nicked.
About F.....g time.


Whatever he's been arrested for. I hope it results in him being deported to The USA. It also makes me hanker for the good old days of Police brutality......

norbury nick would've done him good.
In the 80s
-90s you'd get a mattress put on you and a belting.
much feared was a trip to that nick for over doing it.

He he he .oh I remember it well Ouch,and calling them all the names under the sun.then they would hit you harder.]

 


always a Norwood boy, where ever I live.

Alexi_the_Eagle Flag Newton-le-Willows 05 Aug 15 4.54pm

Quote wombat84 at 05 Aug 2015 2.03pm

Choudary the C..T has just been nicked.
About F.....g time.

Karma will always catch up to him.

 


"Look at that. Accident blackspot? These aren't accidents! They're throwing themselves into the road gladly! Throwing themselves into the road to escape all this hideousness!"

palace777 Flag belfast 05 Aug 15 4.56pm

Quote Alexi_the_Eagle at 05 Aug 2015 4.54pm

Quote wombat84 at 05 Aug 2015 2.03pm

Choudary the C..T has just been nicked.
About F.....g time.

Karma will always catch up to him.


what`s an indian dish got to do with it?

 

Stuk Flag Top half 05 Aug 15 5.19pm

Let's hope he gets the same as Abu Hamza.

 


Optimistic as ever

Alexi_the_Eagle Flag Newton-le-Willows 05 Aug 15 6.20pm

Quote palace777 at 05 Aug 2015 4.56pm

Quote Alexi_the_Eagle at 05 Aug 2015 4.54pm

Quote wombat84 at 05 Aug 2015 2.03pm

Choudary the C..T has just been nicked.
About F.....g time.

Karma will always catch up to him.


what`s an indian dish got to do with it?

I see what you did there

 


"Look at that. Accident blackspot? These aren't accidents! They're throwing themselves into the road gladly! Throwing themselves into the road to escape all this hideousness!"

fed up eagle Flag Between Horley, Surrey and Preston... 05 Aug 15 7.20pm

Quote DANGERCLOSE at 22 Jun 2015 9.51am

Wtf? This sort of thing pisses me off

[Link]

I'm a former serving soldier-left service 3 and a half years ago now-and we were told once when returning from a tour of duty in Afghan that we would have to change into our civvies at the airport so as not to offend people. It's a bloody disgrace.

 

Page 3 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Hate preacher