Quote Stirlingsays at 26 Jul 2015 10.30am
Quote serial thriller at 26 Jul 2015 10.10am
Sadly, as this thread shows, there is an ignorance in British foreign affairs which sees absolutely no hypocrisy in the above facts.
There is no hypocrisy or ignorance.
There is a fundamental disagreement with the idea that we are responsible for what happens within a country after we leave it.
In fact the very idea is ridiculous when you consider the events that have happened after we have left many countries.....Millions died after we left India and so on.
Your logic would have us do what exactly.....bankrupt ourselves by throwing money at unsolvable problems.
Or most probably the 'don't get involved in the first place'.....Yeah really worked out in Syria didn't it.....A country with no intervention that's at war...A war that isn't only with IS but with many groups, even the free Syria Army.
Islamic State itself would have never grown to what it is if we hadn't along with America taken troops out of Iraq.
As for the Iraqi war....That was Bush's baby and the country and events would always going to go this way once those towers came down......We rightly went where the Americans went.
It's the stupidity of the left...With their constant, 'leave, leave' that's enabled Islamic State to grow as large as it has.
None of them want to recognise that through.....They would rather rant on about the original war event....An occurrence we had no influence over once Bush had decided he was going in.
Edited by Stirlingsays (26 Jul 2015 10.30am)
Stirling, interventionist policy does not only come through having troops on the ground. There are military and economic interests in the region which have played a decisive role in the emergence of IS (or whatever PC term Dave wants us to use ) which would still have a major role in combatting them were we to reverse them.
Take Syria as an example. Firstly we did play a fairly explicit interventionist role in the overthrow of the Assad regime, arming opposition forces who were criticised by many investigative agencies for holding tendencies which later became evident as IS emerged. We have also been using drone strikes for around a year now, with very little effect: the Free Syrian Army have actually claimed that US drone strikes are encouraging more and more locals to join IS, so actually bellicose action is proving counter-productive. It is also, as we are seeing in Calais, dehousing people who are in turn forced to flee from IS to Europe.
But actually IS has been aided by us in two more understated but equally disastrous foreign policy events. During their emergence as opposition to Assad, Islamic militants obtained weapons from places like Qatar and Saudi Arabia, weapons which we had very often provided them with, and indeed the CIA facilitated the providing of arms. That we continue to fund places like Saudi Arabia which has continued implicitly to back the Salafist ideology of IS and provide it with military and financial support is scandalous.
But similarly we have to look at our recent support of Turkey and question what the hell we are doing. This is a country which is bombing the Kurdish opposition to IS as well as IS itself, despite the Kurdish forces being one of the few local militias to make significant progress in combatting these nutters. The Turks have massive political interests in doing so, in that the Kurds in Syria are supported by the PKK, and Erdogan's government was under threat in the recent elections to the closely affiliated Kurdish People's Party.
Altering our stance on these three issues: drone strikes, funding IS sympathisers and working in the interests of the Turkish right, would be to massively reduce the power of IS, and thus to reduce the number fleeing from its expansion. Putting troops on the ground would be to enter in to another unwinnable war at the unnecessary cost of hundreds, if not thousands of British lives.
If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4
|