You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Hiroshima
November 22 2026 1.57am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Hiroshima


Page 3 of 7 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >
matt_himself Flag Matataland 06 Aug 15 8.19pm

Quote Kermit8 at 06 Aug 2015 8.31am

It was a real life medical experiment without anaesthetic by the US.

They could have quite easily have dropped the bombs 40 miles from Tokyo in a non-populated area and warned that the city would be next on the list if they didn't surrender.

The population of Hiroshima at the time was mostly kids, women and old people as the men were away soldiering. Something the US would also have obviously known.

A heinous act.

The Japanese, due to their belief that their Emperor was a God, we're not going to surrender.

Bear in mind that up until 1974 there were Japanese soldiers in places like Micronesia still fighting the war and when they were found by locals, they persisted in killing them as they had not had instruction to down weapons.

Plus the Japanese human rights record in the war was barbaric. They tortured and raped at will. Chinese, Koreans, Malay, Singaporean, etc., they didn't care. POW's were treated as sub human scum.

Additionally, the Japanese weren't afraid to sacrifice hundreds of thousands of their own.

The use of nuclear weapons was the last resort but in a situation like that, where you have an enemy who is so intractable, what do you do?

Talk and provide humanitarian aid in the hope they bow down?


Edited by matt_himself (06 Aug 2015 8.20pm)

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

johnny the eagle Flag wivenhoe 06 Aug 15 8.21pm

Quote Jamesrichards8 at 06 Aug 2015 8.13pm

Quote Kermit8 at 06 Aug 2015 7.05pm

Quote Jamesrichards8 at 06 Aug 2015 5.56pm

Quote Kermit8 at 06 Aug 2015 8.31am

It was a real life medical experiment without anaesthetic by the US.

They could have quite easily have dropped the bombs 40 miles from Tokyo in a non-populated area and warned that the city would be next on the list if they didn't surrender.

The population of Hiroshima at the time was mostly kids, women and old people as the men were away soldiering. Something the US would also have obviously known.

A heinous act.


It's called war, kermie. Did Japan warn the US before they hit them below the belt and torpedoed pearl harbour? If you are going to wage war, you have to understand the penalty. Japan gambled, played stupidly, and lost big time.

Edited by Jamesrichards8 (06 Aug 2015 5.58pm)


Yer right. We should have nuked Buenos Aires in '82 and saved 256 British lives.


I don't really think the falklands were on the same scale as the second world war. Also we don't have any nukes

Edited by Jamesrichards8 (06 Aug 2015 8.13pm)

Oh, don't we have nukes, I wonder what them subs in Scotland are carrying then.

 


South London born and bred
red and blue till im dead.

fed up eagle Flag Between Horley, Surrey and Preston... 06 Aug 15 8.37pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 06 Aug 2015 8.07pm

Quote fed up eagle at 06 Aug 2015 8.04pm

Sadly it was necessary as they wouldn't stop fighting. This is unfortunately the brutality of war. A dreadful thing to do but there was no other choice.
Dresden was also brutal but again the Nazis wouldn't stop fighting. The left of course cry about it now and say the likes of 'Bomber' Harris are war criminals, but then the left are stupid.

Dresden was wrong. There were far more appropriate targets that were less risky to our crews for our bombers to attack anyway.


There were reports of first class troop movements in the area. That's why they did it. Wether the reports were correct or not I couldn't possibly say, but ultimately if the Germans had surrendered then many lives could have been saved.

 

Harry Beever Flag Newbury 06 Aug 15 8.38pm

Quote suicideatselhurst at 06 Aug 2015 8.01pm

Quote Kermit8 at 06 Aug 2015 7.05pm

Quote Jamesrichards8 at 06 Aug 2015 5.56pm

Quote Kermit8 at 06 Aug 2015 8.31am

It was a real life medical experiment without anaesthetic by the US.

They could have quite easily have dropped the bombs 40 miles from Tokyo in a non-populated area and warned that the city would be next on the list if they didn't surrender.

The population of Hiroshima at the time was mostly kids, women and old people as the men were away soldiering. Something the US would also have obviously known.

A heinous act.


It's called war, kermie. Did Japan warn the US before they hit them below the belt and torpedoed pearl harbour? If you are going to wage war, you have to understand the penalty. Japan gambled, played stupidly, and lost big time.

Edited by Jamesrichards8 (06 Aug 2015 5.58pm)


Yer right. We should have nuked Buenos Aires in '82 and saved 256 British lives.


Yep we should ..and dont forget the handball by that dirty little cvnt maradonna

On that basis the Paddys should probably nuke Paris for Henry's misdemeanour.

It was an act of unparalleled brutality but a means to an end. I don't really know if that justifies it. Very glad it wasn't my decision and very glad it doesn't sit on my conscience. Is all fair in love and war? Pretty pointless debating the morality of it really. I guess you do what you have to to win. Was it the Duke of Wellington that said "the next saddest thing to a battle lost is a battle won"?

 

fed up eagle Flag Between Horley, Surrey and Preston... 06 Aug 15 8.39pm

Quote johnny the eagle at 06 Aug 2015 8.21pm

Quote Jamesrichards8 at 06 Aug 2015 8.13pm

Quote Kermit8 at 06 Aug 2015 7.05pm

Quote Jamesrichards8 at 06 Aug 2015 5.56pm

Quote Kermit8 at 06 Aug 2015 8.31am

It was a real life medical experiment without anaesthetic by the US.

They could have quite easily have dropped the bombs 40 miles from Tokyo in a non-populated area and warned that the city would be next on the list if they didn't surrender.

The population of Hiroshima at the time was mostly kids, women and old people as the men were away soldiering. Something the US would also have obviously known.

A heinous act.


It's called war, kermie. Did Japan warn the US before they hit them below the belt and torpedoed pearl harbour? If you are going to wage war, you have to understand the penalty. Japan gambled, played stupidly, and lost big time.

Edited by Jamesrichards8 (06 Aug 2015 5.58pm)


Yer right. We should have nuked Buenos Aires in '82 and saved 256 British lives.


I don't really think the falklands were on the same scale as the second world war. Also we don't have any nukes

Edited by Jamesrichards8 (06 Aug 2015 8.13pm)

Oh, don't we have nukes, I wonder what them subs in Scotland are carrying then.


Yep we have nukes, but if the left have their way we won't.

 

suicideatselhurst Flag crawley 06 Aug 15 8.39pm

Quote Mr Palaceman at 06 Aug 2015 8.15pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 05 Aug 2015 10.33pm

70 years ago. Always thought it was a necessary evil but not so sure now.

[Link]

Then again the Japanese still refused to surrender and of course the atrocities they committed were absolutely horrific.

Worryingly there is a significant movement within Japan trying to rewrite history.
[Link]

I was unnecessary but inevitable. Once it had been developed, They had to then use it.

The Japanese tried to surrender before the bomb was dropped after Russia declared war on Japan. The bomb was dropped to show the Russians what the Allies could do.

Secret papers released decades after the war show this. I remember seeing a documentry on the released papers in around 1990. I think it was reported on the BBC at the time.


The Japenese government was split down the middle regarding surrender, the final decision was given to the Emperor, after the second bomb had been dropped, the russians promised they would declare war on japan after Germanys surrender, which they honoured and invaded Manchuria.... it had nothing to do with showing the russians what they had, it was a means to end the war quickly, some U.S. government predictions had the war in Japan not ending until 1946/7.... even with British and Russian forces joining in....even after Okinowa had been overun the Japanese had 6 million men they could send in the field....horrible, but had to be done, no point in judging what people did 70 years ago from the comfort of our keyboards

 


Theres someone in my head ... But its not me

X/Box game Tag bazcpfc1961, clan (HMS)

susmik Flag PLYMOUTH -But Made in Old Coulsdon... 06 Aug 15 8.42pm

An idea why it happened:

[Link]

 


Supported Palace for over 69 years since the age of 7 and have seen all the ups and downs and will probably see many more ups and downs before I go up to the big football club in the sky.

legaleagle Flag 06 Aug 15 9.24pm

Quote TheJudge at 06 Aug 2015 7.49pm

There were people like the lefties on this thread who didn't want to fight and complained about everything during WW2. They didn't like Churchill of course.

Some things never change. Lucky they weren't in charge.


Then there were people like the righties (I wouldn't be so patronising as to say like the righties on this thread) like the owner of the Daily Mail and its headline of "Hurrah for the BUF Blackshirts" and the righties who appeased Hitler and ended up getting is into the mess we faced in May 1940...The appeasers didn't like Churchill of course.Kind of people who complained about those who said Hitler would have to be dealt with,was evil and we'd better get prepared...Lucky they were finally usurped in May 1940.

 

leggedstruggle Flag Croydon 06 Aug 15 9.32pm

Quote legaleagle at 06 Aug 2015 9.24pm

Quote TheJudge at 06 Aug 2015 7.49pm

There were people like the lefties on this thread who didn't want to fight and complained about everything during WW2. They didn't like Churchill of course.

Some things never change. Lucky they weren't in charge.


Then there were people like the righties (I wouldn't be so patronising as to say like the righties on this thread) like the owner of the Daily Mail and its headline of "Hurrah for the BUF Blackshirts" and the righties who appeased Hitler and ended up getting is into the mess we faced in May 1940...The appeasers didn't like Churchill of course.Kind of people who complained about those who said Hitler would have to be dealt with,was evil and we'd better get prepared...Lucky they were finally usurped in May 1940.

But the Communist Party of Britain and its fellow travelers (I wouldn't be so patronising as to say like the lefties on this thread) were models of consistency in their attitude to Hitler.

 


mother-in-law is an anagram of woman hitler

legaleagle Flag 06 Aug 15 9.43pm

You are quite right that the Stalinist CPGB (shame on them)abandoned their opposition to Hitler,following the Soviet Union's deal with Hitler in August 1939 until Hitler's invasion of the USSR in 1941.

You couldn't compare them to any lefties I've seen on this thread since that would be not only patronising but ignorant as well.

Edited by legaleagle (06 Aug 2015 9.44pm)

 

Stirlingsays Flag 06 Aug 15 9.46pm

Quote suicideatselhurst at 06 Aug 2015 8.39pm


The Japenese government was split down the middle regarding surrender, the final decision was given to the Emperor, after the second bomb had been dropped, the russians promised they would declare war on japan after Germanys surrender, which they honoured and invaded Manchuria.... it had nothing to do with showing the russians what they had, it was a means to end the war quickly, some U.S. government predictions had the war in Japan not ending until 1946/7.... even with British and Russian forces joining in....even after Okinowa had been overun the Japanese had 6 million men they could send in the field....horrible, but had to be done, no point in judging what people did 70 years ago from the comfort of our keyboards

I don't mean to be rude but isn't that a contradiction?

You can't say it had to be done and then say you shouldn't judge people on what happened seventy years ago.

The use of the atom bomb shows that in essence there was no 'morality' for the victors. All the evils of the Japanese rule were surpassed with its usage.

It's usage outside of a defensive measure.....as in how it is used now.....Isn't defendable, in my view.

Of course, ever since it was used justifications have been used for it.....video and evidence hidden from the actual event until 40 years after the event.

Edited by Stirlingsays (06 Aug 2015 9.48pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

legaleagle Flag 06 Aug 15 9.50pm

Quote suicideatselhurst at 06 Aug 2015 8.39pm

it had nothing to do with showing the russians what they had, it was a means to end the war quickly,

Don't know about that.

I don't doubt a good part of the reason was the likely loss of US lives in any invasion of "mainland" Japan, plus wanting a quick end to the war to deny the Soviet Union (which only entered the war against Japan in August 1945) too many potential strategic "spoils of victory".

But,at the Potsdam Conference with Stalin and Churchill in July,Truman had told Stalin about a new weapon the US had developed of unusual destructive power and,as the Harry S Truman Memorial Library puts it:

"On the agenda was the partitioning of the postwar world and resolving the problems of the war in the Far East. This included hammering out the details regarding the division of Germany; the movement of populations from Czechoslovakia, Austria, and Italy; the creation of a Council of Foreign Ministers to administer the agreed upon zones of occupation; and issuing a proclamation demanding unconditional surrender from the Japanese government. Truman, despite his relative inexperience in dealing with foreign diplomats, was holding a trump card that would give him confidence in making demands of the other leaders. . .the atomic bomb. The most powerful and destructive armament to date, the atomic bomb was solely in the hands of the United States government."

Edited by legaleagle (06 Aug 2015 9.51pm)

 

leggedstruggle Flag Croydon 06 Aug 15 9.56pm

Quote legaleagle at 06 Aug 2015 9.43pm

You are quite right that the Stalinist CPGB (shame on them)abandoned their opposition to Hitler,following the Soviet Union's deal with Hitler in August 1939 until Hitler's invasion of the USSR in 1941.

You couldn't compare them to any lefties I've seen on this thread since that would be not only patronising but ignorant as well.

Edited by legaleagle (06 Aug 2015 9.44pm)

Most of the rest of the left at the time followed suit 'Imperialist war - keep out of it' etc. I was of course merely taking the piss out of your patronising comment - although most of you are Marxists presumably, so communists or fellow travellers.

 


mother-in-law is an anagram of woman hitler

silvertop Flag Portishead 06 Aug 15 10.01pm

I can actually see the sense in dropping the bomb. My problem is the need to drop it on a city. The U.S. Had complete air supremacy and could have dropped it anywhere they liked. At least start with a more isolated island.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 06 Aug 15 10.02pm

Quote silvertop at 06 Aug 2015 10.01pm

I can actually see the sense in dropping the bomb. My problem is the need to drop it on a city. The U.S. Had complete air supremacy and could have dropped it anywhere they liked. At least start with a more isolated island.


I wonder if this was considered.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

legaleagle Flag 06 Aug 15 10.06pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 06 Aug 2015 9.56pm

Most of the rest of the left at the time followed suit 'Imperialist war - keep out of it' etc. I was of course merely taking the piss out of your patronising comment - although most of you are Marxists presumably, so communists or fellow travellers.

So, most of the rest of the left (left in your eyes probably being anyone not thinking Attila the Hun was a liberal) followed the CPGB line 1939-41 including Attlee,Bevan etc..and we are all likely marxists on here if we are remotely to the "left" of the Tory Party.

I get it and thanks for putting me straight


Edited by legaleagle (06 Aug 2015 10.08pm)

 

suicideatselhurst Flag crawley 06 Aug 15 10.08pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 06 Aug 2015 9.46pm

Quote suicideatselhurst at 06 Aug 2015 8.39pm


The Japenese government was split down the middle regarding surrender, the final decision was given to the Emperor, after the second bomb had been dropped, the russians promised they would declare war on japan after Germanys surrender, which they honoured and invaded Manchuria.... it had nothing to do with showing the russians what they had, it was a means to end the war quickly, some U.S. government predictions had the war in Japan not ending until 1946/7.... even with British and Russian forces joining in....even after Okinowa had been overun the Japanese had 6 million men they could send in the field....horrible, but had to be done, no point in judging what people did 70 years ago from the comfort of our keyboards

I don't mean to be rude but isn't that a contradiction?

You can't say it had to be done and then say you shouldn't judge people on what happened seventy years ago.

The use of the atom bomb shows that in essence there was no 'morality' for the victors. All the evils of the Japanese rule were surpassed with its usage.

It's usage outside of a defensive measure.....as in how it is used now.....Isn't defendable, in my view.

Of course, ever since it was used justifications have been used for it.....video and evidence hidden from the actual event until 40 years after the event.

Edited by Stirlingsays (06 Aug 2015 9.48pm)


mmm dont know...a better phrase would have been "I think it was horrible," and they thought it had to be done at the time...?

 


Theres someone in my head ... But its not me

X/Box game Tag bazcpfc1961, clan (HMS)

TheJudge Flag 06 Aug 15 10.10pm

Quote legaleagle at 06 Aug 2015 9.24pm

Quote TheJudge at 06 Aug 2015 7.49pm

There were people like the lefties on this thread who didn't want to fight and complained about everything during WW2. They didn't like Churchill of course.

Some things never change. Lucky they weren't in charge.


Then there were people like the righties (I wouldn't be so patronising as to say like the righties on this thread) like the owner of the Daily Mail and its headline of "Hurrah for the BUF Blackshirts" and the righties who appeased Hitler and ended up getting is into the mess we faced in May 1940...The appeasers didn't like Churchill of course.Kind of people who complained about those who said Hitler would have to be dealt with,was evil and we'd better get prepared...Lucky they were finally usurped in May 1940.

Well certainly Fascism wasn't frowned upon, pre war, by everyone for sure and certainly Hitler had many admirers over here. But the the truth is that ideology came a distant second to national and personal security when the war started and the Right soon realised that Hitler was a megalomaniac.

Unfortunately, the left, the unions and all the usual suspects were not so keen to roll their sleeves up. Same old same old.

Of course I'm speaking in generalities but I'm happy to engage you on detail if you really want to.

 

leggedstruggle Flag Croydon 06 Aug 15 10.12pm

Quote legaleagle at 06 Aug 2015 10.06pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 06 Aug 2015 9.56pm

Most of the rest of the left at the time followed suit 'Imperialist war - keep out of it' etc. I was of course merely taking the piss out of your patronising comment - although most of you are Marxists presumably, so communists or fellow travellers.

So, most of the rest of the left (left in your eyes probably being anyone not thinking Attila the Hun was a liberal) followed the CPGB line 1939-41 including Attlee,Bevan etc..and we are all likely marxists on here if we are remotely to the "left" of the Tory Party.

I get it and thanks for putting me straight

Edited by legaleagle (06 Aug 2015 10.08pm)

You are familiar with the meaning of the word 'most' I take it. Some, like Orwell, were very consistent in their attitude to Hitler, he often wrote about the hypocrisy of his comrades on the left. Certainly your daft ideas and those of the other lefties here are decidedly Marxist.

 


mother-in-law is an anagram of woman hitler

suicideatselhurst Flag crawley 06 Aug 15 10.13pm

Quote legaleagle at 06 Aug 2015 9.50pm

Quote suicideatselhurst at 06 Aug 2015 8.39pm

it had nothing to do with showing the russians what they had, it was a means to end the war quickly,

Don't know about that.

I don't doubt a good part of the reason was the likely loss of US lives in any invasion of "mainland" Japan, plus wanting a quick end to the war to deny the Soviet Union (which only entered the war against Japan in August 1945) too many potential strategic "spoils of victory".

But,at the Potsdam Conference with Stalin and Churchill in July,Truman had told Stalin about a new weapon the US had developed of unusual destructive power and,as the Harry S Truman Memorial Library puts it:

"On the agenda was the partitioning of the postwar world and resolving the problems of the war in the Far East. This included hammering out the details regarding the division of Germany; the movement of populations from Czechoslovakia, Austria, and Italy; the creation of a Council of Foreign Ministers to administer the agreed upon zones of occupation; and issuing a proclamation demanding unconditional surrender from the Japanese government. Truman, despite his relative inexperience in dealing with foreign diplomats, was holding a trump card that would give him confidence in making demands of the other leaders. . .the atomic bomb. The most powerful and destructive armament to date, the atomic bomb was solely in the hands of the United States government."

Edited by legaleagle (06 Aug 2015 9.51pm)


The potsdam conference was Atlee not churchill, and no doubt Truman was niave in his dealings with stalin and any form of brinkmanship... he may have seen having an atomic bomb as a upper hand, however they only had two and it woild have taken another year to build more... so im leaning towards ending the war quickly...however feel free to disagree

 


Theres someone in my head ... But its not me

X/Box game Tag bazcpfc1961, clan (HMS)

Page 3 of 7 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Hiroshima