You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Retaurant tipping
November 22 2026 1.49am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Retaurant tipping


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
johnfirewall Flag 25 Aug 15 4.17pm

I'm sure I read someone on here state that everything generally goes in to a shared pot so as to benefit the entire staff including the manager, regardless of whether it's cash to the waiter or service charge on your card but presumably that was just in some socialist utopia.

I see the row carries on from Cote being exposed (same people as Bill's) and now everyone seems to be at it.

I'm glad now people might not be made to feel tight by withholding the 12.5% on the premise that they'd be fcuking the chef over in doing so. Looks like you've inadvertently been shorting the waitress instead.

[Link]

Edited by johnfirewall (25 Aug 2015 4.19pm)

 

richard shaw (og)65 Flag my minds eye 25 Aug 15 4.26pm

this is a bugbear of mine . they are putting a service charge on the bill which is discretionary and this goes not as a tip but pays the wages . since I realised this after the independent did a big campaign on this a good few years ago , I now ask if they get this as a tip , if they say they don't I then ask if I leave cash do you get it and every time they say yes .

so get the discretionary tip taken off the bill and leave cash and it is a real tip

 


interviewer " iggy , do you think you influenced anybody?"
iggy pop " I think I wiped out the 60`S "

Stuk Flag Top half 25 Aug 15 4.35pm

Any establishment that automatically adds a service charge is out of order, whether the law allows you not to pay it or not.

I like to tip, but i'll decide how much based on the whole experience.

 


Optimistic as ever

richard shaw (og)65 Flag my minds eye 25 Aug 15 4.48pm

Quote Stuk at 25 Aug 2015 4.35pm

Any establishment that automatically adds a service charge is out of order, whether the law allows you not to pay it or not.

I like to tip, but i'll decide how much based on the whole experience.



correct , how can they presume that I valued the service that I would pay a 12.5% tip any way

 


interviewer " iggy , do you think you influenced anybody?"
iggy pop " I think I wiped out the 60`S "

Stuk Flag Top half 25 Aug 15 4.58pm

Quote richard shaw (og)65 at 25 Aug 2015 4.48pm

Quote Stuk at 25 Aug 2015 4.35pm

Any establishment that automatically adds a service charge is out of order, whether the law allows you not to pay it or not.

I like to tip, but i'll decide how much based on the whole experience.



correct , how can they presume that I valued the service that I would pay a 12.5% tip any way


The best one i've had was when out for one of my nieces birthday. I can't remember what is was called but it has food from all over the world.

They'd added the service charge as the table was more than 8 people, yet the place was self-service and the standard of the food didn't exactly merit the "chefs" getting that much either.

 


Optimistic as ever

richard shaw (og)65 Flag my minds eye 25 Aug 15 4.59pm

this is more like it

 


interviewer " iggy , do you think you influenced anybody?"
iggy pop " I think I wiped out the 60`S "

johnfirewall Flag 25 Aug 15 5.03pm

Quote Stuk at 25 Aug 2015 4.58pm

Quote richard shaw (og)65 at 25 Aug 2015 4.48pm

Quote Stuk at 25 Aug 2015 4.35pm

Any establishment that automatically adds a service charge is out of order, whether the law allows you not to pay it or not.

I like to tip, but i'll decide how much based on the whole experience.



correct , how can they presume that I valued the service that I would pay a 12.5% tip any way


The best one i've had was when out for one of my nieces birthday. I can't remember what is was called but it has food from all over the world.

They'd added the service charge as the table was more than 8 people, yet the place was self-service and the standard of the food didn't exactly merit the "chefs" getting that much either.

Jimmy's?

I do recall being relieved that that wasn't added by default on a table for 2 so I didn't have to bother getting it removed.

 

rob1969 Flag Banstead Surrey 25 Aug 15 5.06pm

Quote Stuk at 25 Aug 2015 4.58pm

Quote richard shaw (og)65 at 25 Aug 2015 4.48pm

Quote Stuk at 25 Aug 2015 4.35pm

Any establishment that automatically adds a service charge is out of order, whether the law allows you not to pay it or not.

I like to tip, but i'll decide how much based on the whole experience.



correct , how can they presume that I valued the service that I would pay a 12.5% tip any way


The best one i've had was when out for one of my nieces birthday. I can't remember what is was called but it has food from all over the world.

They'd added the service charge as the table was more than 8 people, yet the place was self-service and the standard of the food didn't exactly merit the "chefs" getting that much either.

Was in Café Rouge, Bluewater yesterday and noticed they do this too. Why?

 

Stuk Flag Top half 25 Aug 15 5.15pm

Quote johnfirewall at 25 Aug 2015 5.03pm

Quote Stuk at 25 Aug 2015 4.58pm

Quote richard shaw (og)65 at 25 Aug 2015 4.48pm

Quote Stuk at 25 Aug 2015 4.35pm

Any establishment that automatically adds a service charge is out of order, whether the law allows you not to pay it or not.

I like to tip, but i'll decide how much based on the whole experience.



correct , how can they presume that I valued the service that I would pay a 12.5% tip any way


The best one i've had was when out for one of my nieces birthday. I can't remember what is was called but it has food from all over the world.

They'd added the service charge as the table was more than 8 people, yet the place was self-service and the standard of the food didn't exactly merit the "chefs" getting that much either.

Jimmy's?

I do recall being relieved that that wasn't added by default on a table for 2 so I didn't have to bother getting it removed.

It was near the cinema complex in Creepy, if you know the area.

 


Optimistic as ever

Stuk Flag Top half 25 Aug 15 5.18pm

Quote rob1969 at 25 Aug 2015 5.06pm

Quote Stuk at 25 Aug 2015 4.58pm

Quote richard shaw (og)65 at 25 Aug 2015 4.48pm

Quote Stuk at 25 Aug 2015 4.35pm

Any establishment that automatically adds a service charge is out of order, whether the law allows you not to pay it or not.

I like to tip, but i'll decide how much based on the whole experience.



correct , how can they presume that I valued the service that I would pay a 12.5% tip any way


The best one i've had was when out for one of my nieces birthday. I can't remember what is was called but it has food from all over the world.

They'd added the service charge as the table was more than 8 people, yet the place was self-service and the standard of the food didn't exactly merit the "chefs" getting that much either.

Was in Café Rouge, Bluewater yesterday and noticed they do this too. Why?


Because they think by slipping it into the small print, as once you're already in, seated and looking at the menu, possibly ordered drinks too before noticing, that people will not want a confrontation about it and if they're right, it's free money.

 


Optimistic as ever

Hoof Hearted 25 Aug 15 5.25pm

Nando's..... you virtually have to serve yourself.... only went there once and they didn't get a tip.

I like restaurants where you are seated, the waiter takes your order and serves you attentively.

He/she gets a cash tip at my discretion depending on how efficient/friendly/helpful they are.

I would never pay a surcharge added to the bill out of principle.

 

johnfirewall Flag 25 Aug 15 5.29pm

Are we putting the waiter in an uncomfortable position knowing that they are visibly taking money away from their colleagues?

 

SloveniaDave Flag Tirana, Albania 25 Aug 15 5.33pm

Quote rob1969 at 25 Aug 2015 5.06pm

Quote Stuk at 25 Aug 2015 4.58pm

Quote richard shaw (og)65 at 25 Aug 2015 4.48pm

Quote Stuk at 25 Aug 2015 4.35pm

Any establishment that automatically adds a service charge is out of order, whether the law allows you not to pay it or not.

I like to tip, but i'll decide how much based on the whole experience.



correct , how can they presume that I valued the service that I would pay a 12.5% tip any way


The best one i've had was when out for one of my nieces birthday. I can't remember what is was called but it has food from all over the world.

They'd added the service charge as the table was more than 8 people, yet the place was self-service and the standard of the food didn't exactly merit the "chefs" getting that much either.

Was in Café Rouge, Bluewater yesterday and noticed they do this too. Why?


Originally the charge for larger parties was brought in because one large table is the equivalent of 3 or 4 smaller ones as far as a waiter or waitress is concerned. If you have four tables of two people, you can expect, on average, maybe 2 will give reasonable tips. But if you only have one table of eight, then its a bigger gamble.

For table staff who rely on tips, they would be very reluctant to put all their eggs in one basket (as it were) and hope that the party would leave a decent tip.

Not necessarily justifying it, just explaining the rationale.

 


Just because I don't care doesn't mean I don't understand!

My opinions may have changed, but not the fact that I am right.

(Member of the School of Optimism 1969-2016 inclusive)

aquickgame2 Flag Beni = summer,Caribbean = winter 25 Aug 15 5.43pm

If the restaurant put a service charge on the bill, ask the waiter if he gets it,majority will say no.Tell them to take it off the bill and you will pay him a tip in cash.if they can't tell the waiter to change jobs.
Sorry but I only tip once either on the bill or direct

 

Ray in Houston Flag Houston 25 Aug 15 10.27pm

Quote Stuk at 25 Aug 2015 5.18pm

Quote rob1969 at 25 Aug 2015 5.06pm

Quote Stuk at 25 Aug 2015 4.58pm

Quote richard shaw (og)65 at 25 Aug 2015 4.48pm

Quote Stuk at 25 Aug 2015 4.35pm

Any establishment that automatically adds a service charge is out of order, whether the law allows you not to pay it or not.

I like to tip, but i'll decide how much based on the whole experience.



correct , how can they presume that I valued the service that I would pay a 12.5% tip any way


The best one i've had was when out for one of my nieces birthday. I can't remember what is was called but it has food from all over the world.

They'd added the service charge as the table was more than 8 people, yet the place was self-service and the standard of the food didn't exactly merit the "chefs" getting that much either.

Was in Café Rouge, Bluewater yesterday and noticed they do this too. Why?


Because they think by slipping it into the small print, as once you're already in, seated and looking at the menu, possibly ordered drinks too before noticing, that people will not want a confrontation about it and if they're right, it's free money.


The really insidious part is when they still leave the tip space open on the receipt so that you can tip again if you didn't see it already in the bill.

 


We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.

Ray in Houston Flag Houston 25 Aug 15 10.32pm

Quote johnfirewall at 25 Aug 2015 5.29pm

Are we putting the waiter in an uncomfortable position knowing that they are visibly taking money away from their colleagues?


No. It's up to the establishment how they pool / distribute tips. IN the U.S., the waiter has to tip out the busboys, kitchen staff and the bar tender, so anything under the "standard" 15% might actually mean the waiter is out of pocket at the end of the deal.

So, if the food is crap, don't punish the waiter. Ask for the manager and complain to him; they'll typically knock something off your bill - maybe all if it's really bad. BUT, don't forget to tip the waiter on what you would have spent - it's not his fault that the kitchen is having a bad night.

 


We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.

johnfirewall Flag 25 Aug 15 11.05pm

Quote Ray in Houston at 25 Aug 2015 10.32pm

Quote johnfirewall at 25 Aug 2015 5.29pm

Are we putting the waiter in an uncomfortable position knowing that they are visibly taking money away from their colleagues?


No. It's up to the establishment how they pool / distribute tips. IN the U.S., the waiter has to tip out the busboys, kitchen staff and the bar tender, so anything under the "standard" 15% might actually mean the waiter is out of pocket at the end of the deal.

So, if the food is crap, don't punish the waiter. Ask for the manager and complain to him; they'll typically knock something off your bill - maybe all if it's really bad. BUT, don't forget to tip the waiter on what you would have spent - it's not his fault that the kitchen is having a bad night.

That would account for the extra 2.5% on the UK standard, but that's an awful system. Surely you're giving him 20% to make it worthwhile.

 

Jimenez Flag SELHURSTPARKCHESTER,DA BRONX 25 Aug 15 11.38pm

Quote johnfirewall at 25 Aug 2015 11.05pm

Quote Ray in Houston at 25 Aug 2015 10.32pm

Quote johnfirewall at 25 Aug 2015 5.29pm

Are we putting the waiter in an uncomfortable position knowing that they are visibly taking money away from their colleagues?


No. It's up to the establishment how they pool / distribute tips. IN the U.S., the waiter has to tip out the busboys, kitchen staff and the bar tender, so anything under the "standard" 15% might actually mean the waiter is out of pocket at the end of the deal.

So, if the food is crap, don't punish the waiter. Ask for the manager and complain to him; they'll typically knock something off your bill - maybe all if it's really bad. BUT, don't forget to tip the waiter on what you would have spent - it's not his fault that the kitchen is having a bad night.

That would account for the extra 2.5% on the UK standard, but that's an awful system. Surely you're giving him 20% to make it worthwhile.

.......but you can make it work to your advantage. When I was drinking I always tipped the barkeep they would usually give you the 3/4 drink free and If you were drinking Liquor you got BIG measures....

 


Pro USA & Israel

Pawson Palace Flag Croydon 26 Aug 15 9.40am

I never understand why you should have to tip anyone really.

 


Pride of South London
Upper Holmesdale Block P

richard shaw (og)65 Flag my minds eye 26 Aug 15 6.49pm

im not in the restaurant game but I understand it that all tips are pooled between everyone . when the tips that are not shared go to pay the wages it works like this for instance - tips for the month amount to £21,000 , staff wages amount to £ 20,000 , tips left to share out £1,000 .

always leave cash or ask if they get it as extra

 


interviewer " iggy , do you think you influenced anybody?"
iggy pop " I think I wiped out the 60`S "

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Retaurant tipping