You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > French bomb ISIS
November 22 2026 1.49am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

French bomb ISIS


Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
Stuk Flag Top half 29 Sep 15 3.16pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 29 Sep 2015 2.44pm

Quote Stuk at 29 Sep 2015 1.55pm

You need to grasp that not everything can and will be done by the methods you approve of, or believe should be followed.

So what you're saying is, that even if you can't be reasonably sure of the intelligence, you should kill the target, just in case it is the right person?

Doesn't have to be a fair trial, but putting all that authority in the hands of a select few and then not making them accountable is a mistake.

Its not much to ask for, is it, that every time the state kills someone by executive order, that an independent body adjudicate the validity of that order in line with the evidence? Even if its done retrospectively.

Edited by jamiemartin721 (29 Sep 2015 2.46pm)


No, i'm not. That they hit the wrong target isn't even on the table. They hit the target and killed both.

The only thing the Greens seem to be bitching about is taht they didn't get another vote on it. And no one cares about that or them.

Yes it is too much to ask for. It's a waste of time and money.

 


Optimistic as ever

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 29 Sep 15 3.35pm

Quote Stuk at 29 Sep 2015 3.16pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 29 Sep 2015 2.44pm

Quote Stuk at 29 Sep 2015 1.55pm

You need to grasp that not everything can and will be done by the methods you approve of, or believe should be followed.

So what you're saying is, that even if you can't be reasonably sure of the intelligence, you should kill the target, just in case it is the right person?

Doesn't have to be a fair trial, but putting all that authority in the hands of a select few and then not making them accountable is a mistake.

Its not much to ask for, is it, that every time the state kills someone by executive order, that an independent body adjudicate the validity of that order in line with the evidence? Even if its done retrospectively.

Edited by jamiemartin721 (29 Sep 2015 2.46pm)


No, i'm not. That they hit the wrong target isn't even on the table. They hit the target and killed both.

The only thing the Greens seem to be bitching about is taht they didn't get another vote on it. And no one cares about that or them.

Yes it is too much to ask for. It's a waste of time and money.

Job done this time, and fair enough, provided they killed who they claimed they killed I don't have a problem (although I'm curious as some of the claims made about the targets and imminent attacks but that's by the by).

I think the Greens issue is however somewhat valid, given the law, and that is the job of opposition in parliament, to hold the government to its own laws.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Stuk Flag Top half 29 Sep 15 4.45pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 29 Sep 2015 3.35pm

Quote Stuk at 29 Sep 2015 3.16pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 29 Sep 2015 2.44pm

Quote Stuk at 29 Sep 2015 1.55pm

You need to grasp that not everything can and will be done by the methods you approve of, or believe should be followed.

So what you're saying is, that even if you can't be reasonably sure of the intelligence, you should kill the target, just in case it is the right person?

Doesn't have to be a fair trial, but putting all that authority in the hands of a select few and then not making them accountable is a mistake.

Its not much to ask for, is it, that every time the state kills someone by executive order, that an independent body adjudicate the validity of that order in line with the evidence? Even if its done retrospectively.

Edited by jamiemartin721 (29 Sep 2015 2.46pm)


No, i'm not. That they hit the wrong target isn't even on the table. They hit the target and killed both.

The only thing the Greens seem to be bitching about is taht they didn't get another vote on it. And no one cares about that or them.

Yes it is too much to ask for. It's a waste of time and money.

Job done this time, and fair enough, provided they killed who they claimed they killed I don't have a problem (although I'm curious as some of the claims made about the targets and imminent attacks but that's by the by).

I think the Greens issue is however somewhat valid, given the law, and that is the job of opposition in parliament, to hold the government to its own laws.



They are by no means "the oppostition". They did it because they've already been forgotten about since their, self-professed, spectacular GE success.

Remember that no politician does anything unless there's self-interest, even those looney slags.

 


Optimistic as ever

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 30 Sep 15 9.27am

Quote Stuk at 29 Sep 2015 4.45pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 29 Sep 2015 3.35pm

Quote Stuk at 29 Sep 2015 3.16pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 29 Sep 2015 2.44pm

Quote Stuk at 29 Sep 2015 1.55pm

You need to grasp that not everything can and will be done by the methods you approve of, or believe should be followed.

So what you're saying is, that even if you can't be reasonably sure of the intelligence, you should kill the target, just in case it is the right person?

Doesn't have to be a fair trial, but putting all that authority in the hands of a select few and then not making them accountable is a mistake.

Its not much to ask for, is it, that every time the state kills someone by executive order, that an independent body adjudicate the validity of that order in line with the evidence? Even if its done retrospectively.

Edited by jamiemartin721 (29 Sep 2015 2.46pm)


No, i'm not. That they hit the wrong target isn't even on the table. They hit the target and killed both.

The only thing the Greens seem to be bitching about is taht they didn't get another vote on it. And no one cares about that or them.

Yes it is too much to ask for. It's a waste of time and money.

Job done this time, and fair enough, provided they killed who they claimed they killed I don't have a problem (although I'm curious as some of the claims made about the targets and imminent attacks but that's by the by).

I think the Greens issue is however somewhat valid, given the law, and that is the job of opposition in parliament, to hold the government to its own laws.



They are by no means "the oppostition". They did it because they've already been forgotten about since their, self-professed, spectacular GE success.

Remember that no politician does anything unless there's self-interest, even those looney slags.

True, and that's why I believe that a government cannot be trusted with drone strikes without independent oversight. Present the case to an independent board and judge, to decide if something is legal and justified.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Stuk Flag Top half 30 Sep 15 1.31pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 30 Sep 2015 9.27am

Quote Stuk at 29 Sep 2015 4.45pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 29 Sep 2015 3.35pm

Quote Stuk at 29 Sep 2015 3.16pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 29 Sep 2015 2.44pm

Quote Stuk at 29 Sep 2015 1.55pm

You need to grasp that not everything can and will be done by the methods you approve of, or believe should be followed.

So what you're saying is, that even if you can't be reasonably sure of the intelligence, you should kill the target, just in case it is the right person?

Doesn't have to be a fair trial, but putting all that authority in the hands of a select few and then not making them accountable is a mistake.

Its not much to ask for, is it, that every time the state kills someone by executive order, that an independent body adjudicate the validity of that order in line with the evidence? Even if its done retrospectively.

Edited by jamiemartin721 (29 Sep 2015 2.46pm)


No, i'm not. That they hit the wrong target isn't even on the table. They hit the target and killed both.

The only thing the Greens seem to be bitching about is taht they didn't get another vote on it. And no one cares about that or them.

Yes it is too much to ask for. It's a waste of time and money.

Job done this time, and fair enough, provided they killed who they claimed they killed I don't have a problem (although I'm curious as some of the claims made about the targets and imminent attacks but that's by the by).

I think the Greens issue is however somewhat valid, given the law, and that is the job of opposition in parliament, to hold the government to its own laws.



They are by no means "the oppostition". They did it because they've already been forgotten about since their, self-professed, spectacular GE success.

Remember that no politician does anything unless there's self-interest, even those looney slags.

True, and that's why I believe that a government cannot be trusted with drone strikes without independent oversight. Present the case to an independent board and judge, to decide if something is legal and justified.



The military is independent enough of goverment for me.

 


Optimistic as ever

oldcodger Flag 30 Sep 15 9.50pm


So now we have Russians and Syrian army bombing ISIS and most likely rebels and the FSA. The IDF bombing Syrian Army positions, the Coalition forces/Arabs/Kurds bombing ISIS, the Turks bombing the Kurds. A country ripped apart by proxy wars and vested interests. Sometimes leaving a party early isn't such a bad idea..

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 01 Oct 15 10.02am

Quote Stuk at 30 Sep 2015 1.31pm

The military is independent enough of goverment for me.

Operationally they perform the strike, as such they cannot be considered independent. They won't have been providing the evidence, or evaluating its reliability or its legality.

When establishing someones guilt and evidence to that guilt, the Judicary are the ideally placed experts to rule on whether the evidence presented is sufficient to determining they're guilty.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

chris123 Flag hove actually 01 Oct 15 10.13am

Quote oldcodger at 30 Sep 2015 9.50pm


So now we have Russians and Syrian army bombing ISIS and most likely rebels and the FSA. The IDF bombing Syrian Army positions, the Coalition forces/Arabs/Kurds bombing ISIS, the Turks bombing the Kurds. A country ripped apart by proxy wars and vested interests. Sometimes leaving a party early isn't such a bad idea..


Couldn't agree more.

 

topcat Flag Holmesdale / Surbiton 01 Oct 15 10.46am

Quote oldcodger at 30 Sep 2015 9.50pm


So now we have Russians and Syrian army bombing ISIS and most likely rebels and the FSA. The IDF bombing Syrian Army positions, the Coalition forces/Arabs/Kurds bombing ISIS, the Turks bombing the Kurds. A country ripped apart by proxy wars and vested interests. Sometimes leaving a party early isn't such a bad idea..

Indeed. It is one of those conflicts that is easy to see who the bad guys are, but hard to who the good guys are.

 


It's 106 miles to Chicago, we got a full tank of gas, half a pack of cigarettes, it's dark... and we're wearing sunglasses.

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 01 Oct 15 11.16am

Quote topcat at 01 Oct 2015 10.46am

Quote oldcodger at 30 Sep 2015 9.50pm


So now we have Russians and Syrian army bombing ISIS and most likely rebels and the FSA. The IDF bombing Syrian Army positions, the Coalition forces/Arabs/Kurds bombing ISIS, the Turks bombing the Kurds. A country ripped apart by proxy wars and vested interests. Sometimes leaving a party early isn't such a bad idea..

Indeed. It is one of those conflicts that is easy to see who the bad guys are, but hard to who the good guys are.

The bad guys apparently are on the ground. Its almost as if not having a UN Led approach has led to countries pursuing their own agenda in the name of 'Destroying IS'. Its turned from stopping IS it seems into Operation Kill Brown People.

The irony of course is that IS is far less likely to be 'disrupted' by airpower as the Loyalists and Rebels.


Edited by jamiemartin721 (01 Oct 2015 11.19am)

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 01 Oct 15 11.18am

Quote topcat at 01 Oct 2015 10.46am

Quote oldcodger at 30 Sep 2015 9.50pm


So now we have Russians and Syrian army bombing ISIS and most likely rebels and the FSA. The IDF bombing Syrian Army positions, the Coalition forces/Arabs/Kurds bombing ISIS, the Turks bombing the Kurds. A country ripped apart by proxy wars and vested interests. Sometimes leaving a party early isn't such a bad idea..

Indeed. It is one of those conflicts that is easy to see who the bad guys are, but hard to who the good guys are.

There are never good guys and bad guys. I'm pretty sure if you were to ask someone on 'the bad guys side' that they would consider themselves good guys.

Its the Mitchell and Webb SS sketch....


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Pussay Patrol Flag 01 Oct 15 11.29am

[Link]

Yep....really works.....

 


Paua oouaarancì Irà chiyeah Ishé galé ma ba oo ah

leggedstruggle Flag Croydon 01 Oct 15 11.43am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 01 Oct 2015 11.18am

Quote topcat at 01 Oct 2015 10.46am

Quote oldcodger at 30 Sep 2015 9.50pm


So now we have Russians and Syrian army bombing ISIS and most likely rebels and the FSA. The IDF bombing Syrian Army positions, the Coalition forces/Arabs/Kurds bombing ISIS, the Turks bombing the Kurds. A country ripped apart by proxy wars and vested interests. Sometimes leaving a party early isn't such a bad idea..

Indeed. It is one of those conflicts that is easy to see who the bad guys are, but hard to who the good guys are.



There are never good guys and bad guys
. I'm pretty sure if you were to ask someone on 'the bad guys side' that they would consider themselves good guys.

Its the Mitchell and Webb SS sketch....


Nonsense. There were and are plenty of 'bad guys', Hitler, Stalin, Mao Tse-Tung, Pol Pot, Sadam, Mugabe, to name a few.

 


mother-in-law is an anagram of woman hitler

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 01 Oct 15 1.29pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 01 Oct 2015 11.43am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 01 Oct 2015 11.18am

Quote topcat at 01 Oct 2015 10.46am

Quote oldcodger at 30 Sep 2015 9.50pm


So now we have Russians and Syrian army bombing ISIS and most likely rebels and the FSA. The IDF bombing Syrian Army positions, the Coalition forces/Arabs/Kurds bombing ISIS, the Turks bombing the Kurds. A country ripped apart by proxy wars and vested interests. Sometimes leaving a party early isn't such a bad idea..

Indeed. It is one of those conflicts that is easy to see who the bad guys are, but hard to who the good guys are.



There are never good guys and bad guys
. I'm pretty sure if you were to ask someone on 'the bad guys side' that they would consider themselves good guys.

Its the Mitchell and Webb SS sketch....


Nonsense. There were and are plenty of 'bad guys', Hitler, Stalin, Mao Tse-Tung, Pol Pot, Sadam, Mugabe, to name a few.

Pretty sure that the people who followed them didn't regard themselves as bad guys though, is the point. Obviously I agree with that list, but everyone thinks they 'doing the right thing and are good guys'. Usually until its no longer in their best interests.

White hats and black hats, are for movies and childrens stories. But in reality, its the kind of mentality that ends up justifying things like the holocaust or Year Zero.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

leggedstruggle Flag Croydon 01 Oct 15 2.02pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 01 Oct 2015 1.29pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 01 Oct 2015 11.43am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 01 Oct 2015 11.18am

Quote topcat at 01 Oct 2015 10.46am

Quote oldcodger at 30 Sep 2015 9.50pm


So now we have Russians and Syrian army bombing ISIS and most likely rebels and the FSA. The IDF bombing Syrian Army positions, the Coalition forces/Arabs/Kurds bombing ISIS, the Turks bombing the Kurds. A country ripped apart by proxy wars and vested interests. Sometimes leaving a party early isn't such a bad idea..

Indeed. It is one of those conflicts that is easy to see who the bad guys are, but hard to who the good guys are.



There are never good guys and bad guys
. I'm pretty sure if you were to ask someone on 'the bad guys side' that they would consider themselves good guys.

Its the Mitchell and Webb SS sketch....


Nonsense. There were and are plenty of 'bad guys', Hitler, Stalin, Mao Tse-Tung, Pol Pot, Sadam, Mugabe, to name a few.

Pretty sure that the people who followed them didn't regard themselves as bad guys though, is the point. Obviously I agree with that list, but everyone thinks they 'doing the right thing and are good guys'. Usually until its no longer in their best interests.

White hats and black hats, are for movies and childrens stories. But in reality, its the kind of mentality that ends up justifying things like the holocaust or Year Zero.


And your attitude of giving them the benefit of the doubt leads to their rise in the first place.

 


mother-in-law is an anagram of woman hitler

oldcodger Flag 01 Oct 15 3.18pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 01 Oct 2015 11.16am

Quote topcat at 01 Oct 2015 10.46am

Quote oldcodger at 30 Sep 2015 9.50pm


So now we have Russians and Syrian army bombing ISIS and most likely rebels and the FSA. The IDF bombing Syrian Army positions, the Coalition forces/Arabs/Kurds bombing ISIS, the Turks bombing the Kurds. A country ripped apart by proxy wars and vested interests. Sometimes leaving a party early isn't such a bad idea..

Indeed. It is one of those conflicts that is easy to see who the bad guys are, but hard to who the good guys are.

The bad guys apparently are on the ground. Its almost as if not having a UN Led approach has led to countries pursuing their own agenda in the name of 'Destroying IS'. Its turned from stopping IS it seems into Operation Kill Brown People.

The irony of course is that IS is far less likely to be 'disrupted' by airpower as the Loyalists and Rebels.


Edited by jamiemartin721 (01 Oct 2015 11.19am)

Right on the money. Now literally everyone on the ground is 'the enemy'. It was even true before really. Assad was quick to abuse his own people when it helped his interests. Russia to back him and crush all others. The States with a 'better dead than red' attitude towards Syria being a Russian Ally, arming any tom, dick or harry who opposed Assad. All helped to shape this destablised mess of a country.


 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 01 Oct 15 3.21pm

To Legged's post.

Hitler might have said that about the Jews or Gay people.

Nothing wrong with trying to be objective. Most people on here don't seem to have the ability.

Unfortunately, in an us against them situation, we can't afford too much objectivity. It's about self preservation against an enemy who doesn't give a hoot about us.
I wouldn't have given a monkey's if Hitler had fancied himself as the leader of a superior Aryan race if he hadn't invaded Europe and killed 6 million Jews but that way of thinking galvanized his followers and created self justification. That's how you get people to fight and kill.
Good and bad are luxuries you can afford yourself in peace time in that context. Were we "good" when we saturation bombed Dresden ? It was a necessary evil but I couldn't call it good. The same with bombing Japan
Are we right to defend ourself against aggressors by all means necessary ? You bet ya.
If Hitler had won the War there would not be an Israel or maybe not an ISIS. Does that make him good ? Stalin helped defeat Hitler. Does that make him good ?

Life is just not that simple.

Leave your desks tidy.....

Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (01 Oct 2015 3.23pm)

 

leggedstruggle Flag Croydon 01 Oct 15 3.42pm

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 01 Oct 2015 3.21pm

To Legged's post.

Hitler might have said that about the Jews or Gay people.

Nothing wrong with trying to be objective. Most people on here don't seem to have the ability.

Unfortunately, in an us against them situation, we can't afford too much objectivity. It's about self preservation against an enemy who doesn't give a hoot about us.
I wouldn't have given a monkey's if Hitler had fancied himself as the leader of a superior Aryan race if he hadn't invaded Europe and killed 6 million Jews but that way of thinking galvanized his followers and created self justification. That's how you get people to fight and kill.
Good and bad are luxuries you can afford yourself in peace time in that context. Were we "good" when we saturation bombed Dresden ? It was a necessary evil but I couldn't call it good. The same with bombing Japan
Are we right to defend ourself against aggressors by all means necessary ? You bet ya.
If Hitler had won the War there would not be an Israel or maybe not an ISIS. Does that make him good ? Stalin helped defeat Hitler. Does that make him good ?

Life is just not that simple.

Leave your desks tidy.....

Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (01 Oct 2015 3.23pm)

Of course it is not simple. There are no absolute goods and no absolute bads, there are degrees. No person is absolutely good or absolutely evil. But it is quite justifiable to judge someone as principally evil - say Ian Brady. The bombing of Japan and the bombing of Germany were part of an effort to destroy evil movements. To argue that those actions themselves were intrinsically evil is like saying it is evil to amputate a gangrene limb. I don't think it is evil that the state of Israel exists. Yes, Stalin helped to defeat Hitler - only because he had been attacked, he would have been quite happy to have sat back and watch us defeated and the Jews exterminated - one of the most evil b******s who ever lived.

 


mother-in-law is an anagram of woman hitler

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 01 Oct 15 4.05pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 01 Oct 2015 2.02pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 01 Oct 2015 1.29pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 01 Oct 2015 11.43am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 01 Oct 2015 11.18am

Quote topcat at 01 Oct 2015 10.46am

Quote oldcodger at 30 Sep 2015 9.50pm


So now we have Russians and Syrian army bombing ISIS and most likely rebels and the FSA. The IDF bombing Syrian Army positions, the Coalition forces/Arabs/Kurds bombing ISIS, the Turks bombing the Kurds. A country ripped apart by proxy wars and vested interests. Sometimes leaving a party early isn't such a bad idea..

Indeed. It is one of those conflicts that is easy to see who the bad guys are, but hard to who the good guys are.



There are never good guys and bad guys
. I'm pretty sure if you were to ask someone on 'the bad guys side' that they would consider themselves good guys.

Its the Mitchell and Webb SS sketch....


Nonsense. There were and are plenty of 'bad guys', Hitler, Stalin, Mao Tse-Tung, Pol Pot, Sadam, Mugabe, to name a few.

Pretty sure that the people who followed them didn't regard themselves as bad guys though, is the point. Obviously I agree with that list, but everyone thinks they 'doing the right thing and are good guys'. Usually until its no longer in their best interests.

White hats and black hats, are for movies and childrens stories. But in reality, its the kind of mentality that ends up justifying things like the holocaust or Year Zero.


And your attitude of giving them the benefit of the doubt leads to their rise in the first place.

Does it really? I was thinking it was down the rise of Al-Qaeda in Iraq and the movement of the Sunni insurgency in Iraq switching its attentions to Syria, following the uprisings of the Arab Spring there.

So I am quite surprised that actually understanding a very basic truth about human psychology, was responsible for the rise of ISIL, ISIS and its metamorphosis into IS.

But then of course as far back as 2003 I was commenting that overthrowing the Saddam regime would result in a rise in Islamic fundamentalism, and then during the Arab spring, that ultimately Islamist factions would benefit, and again with Libya and the civil war in Syria.

But yeah, my fault. Definitely.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 01 Oct 15 4.16pm

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 01 Oct 2015 3.21pm

To Legged's post.

Hitler might have said that about the Jews or Gay people.

Nothing wrong with trying to be objective. Most people on here don't seem to have the ability.

Unfortunately, in an us against them situation, we can't afford too much objectivity. It's about self preservation against an enemy who doesn't give a hoot about us.
I wouldn't have given a monkey's if Hitler had fancied himself as the leader of a superior Aryan race if he hadn't invaded Europe and killed 6 million Jews but that way of thinking galvanized his followers and created self justification. That's how you get people to fight and kill.
Good and bad are luxuries you can afford yourself in peace time in that context. Were we "good" when we saturation bombed Dresden ? It was a necessary evil but I couldn't call it good. The same with bombing Japan
Are we right to defend ourself against aggressors by all means necessary ? You bet ya.
If Hitler had won the War there would not be an Israel or maybe not an ISIS. Does that make him good ? Stalin helped defeat Hitler. Does that make him good ?

Life is just not that simple.

Leave your desks tidy.....

Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (01 Oct 2015 3.23pm)

Pretty much how I see it.

You also have to know a) who your enemy is b) how you intend to defeat them and c) that your actions aren't actually going to make the situation worse. The last part is really important. In Afghanistan there was a nasty tendency to determine that it was 'us against Taliban' but we were actually very poor at determining who was and wasn't Taliban.

The factional tribal nature and lack of 'clear front lines' meant that factions were reporting that such a tribe was Taliban, and the US ended up fighting a lot of different factions that hadn't been Taliban from the start.

A similar situation exists when you hit 'IS' targets. How do you actually determine they're IS targets? Especially when your 'sources on the ground' aren't reliable. A lot of the areas that are sometimes reported as IS, are held by other factions that may or may not be allied to IS to some degree (ie they'd rather be fighting the Syrian Regime than IS). Not every armed Sunni group in Syria is going to be IS.

But then when you drop a 500lb bomb on a target that maybe isn't quite 'the enemy' you think it is, they soon become the enemy when they're picking up the bits of their friends and relatives.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > French bomb ISIS