You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > red meat cancer risk
November 22 2026 1.49am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

red meat cancer risk


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
sitdownstandup Flag 26 Oct 15 8.21am

think a lot of people know about this, just now the world health organisation is getting involved.

[Link]

 


Man is the most insane species. He worships an invisible God and destroys a visible Nature. Unaware that this Nature he’s destroying is this God he’s worshipping.

Hubert Reeves

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 26 Oct 15 8.23am

The advice is flawed
We are omnivores
Like anything its about the quality of the priduct you consume

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 26 Oct 15 9.47am

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 26 Oct 2015 8.23am

The advice is flawed
We are omnivores
Like anything its about the quality of the priduct you consume

Its more about quantity, although quality can be a factor. Omnivores in nature tend to supplement their diet with meat, rather than regularly eat meat. There is a big difference in how we consume meat and how omnivores in nature eat meat. They eat some meat, not one or two meals a day consisting of meat (also animals in nature don't really have to worry about cancer as a major threat.

Also the amount of red meat that's consumed is an issue (bear in mind that all other omnivores and carnivores would eat meat that's fresh from a kill and don't eat it on a daily basis either - big cats are an exception, but they're pure carnivores, they can even supplement their hydration from meat).

Of course on an individual basis genetic factors play a very important role, but essentially, vegetarians experience a much lower rate of some cancers, especially of the bowel (about 20% lower than the average, and vegans a further 20% lower than vegetarians).


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

lankygit Flag Lincoln 26 Oct 15 1.43pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 26 Oct 2015 8.23am

The advice is flawed
We are omnivores
Like anything its about the quality of the priduct you consume


We are omnivores, but our evolution didn`t include the consumption of processed meat.
That report in the link refers to the risk from processed meat:

"Its report said 50g of processed meat a day - less than two slices of bacon - increased the chance of developing colorectal cancer by 18%.

Meanwhile, it said red meats were "probably carcinogenic" but there was limited evidence"

 


Is this a five minute argument, or the full half hour? [Link]

martin2412 Flag Living The Dream 26 Oct 15 1.51pm

I expect to see government health warnings on sausages, bacon & ham in due course.

SAUSAGES KILL

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 26 Oct 15 2.03pm

Quote lankygit at 26 Oct 2015 1.43pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 26 Oct 2015 8.23am

The advice is flawed
We are omnivores
Like anything its about the quality of the priduct you consume


We are omnivores, but our evolution didn`t include the consumption of processed meat.
That report in the link refers to the risk from processed meat:

"Its report said 50g of processed meat a day - less than two slices of bacon - increased the chance of developing colorectal cancer by 18%.

Meanwhile, it said red meats were "probably carcinogenic" but there was limited evidence"


They have included both. Quoting red meat is probably carcinogenic.

You are right about processed and Jamie makes a valid point about quantity. That applies to all Macro nutrients. Saturated Fat was demonised now people realise the mistake and Sugar is currently getting it in the neck. Quantiy & Quality (often the source) is key

The trouble with studies like this is that it ignores other factors. Those who eat a lot of processed food are often financially poor or time poor and have pressurised lives. There is also the fact that many of these people will also be signifcantly overweight.

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 26 Oct 15 4.33pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 26 Oct 2015 2.03pm

Quote lankygit at 26 Oct 2015 1.43pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 26 Oct 2015 8.23am

The advice is flawed
We are omnivores
Like anything its about the quality of the priduct you consume


We are omnivores, but our evolution didn`t include the consumption of processed meat.
That report in the link refers to the risk from processed meat:

"Its report said 50g of processed meat a day - less than two slices of bacon - increased the chance of developing colorectal cancer by 18%.

Meanwhile, it said red meats were "probably carcinogenic" but there was limited evidence"


They have included both. Quoting red meat is probably carcinogenic.

You are right about processed and Jamie makes a valid point about quantity. That applies to all Macro nutrients. Saturated Fat was demonised now people realise the mistake and Sugar is currently getting it in the neck. Quantiy & Quality (often the source) is key

The trouble with studies like this is that it ignores other factors. Those who eat a lot of processed food are often financially poor or time poor and have pressurised lives. There is also the fact that many of these people will also be signifcantly overweight.

Thing that is important isn't so much quantity as frequency, with carcinogens. We, as a nation, tend to eat meat twice a day, sometimes three times a day, and there in lies the problem, its one of continued exposure, rather than occasional exposure.

Meat is actually a good source of vitamin B, which is probably why omnivores evolved and benefitted from meat supplementing their diet. Problem is, its definitely not good for you long term, especially humans and especially the kinds of meat we like (and the servings we like).

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 26 Oct 15 4.40pm

This is a very good synopsis:

Everybody jumped on the sensational headlines and nobody cared to read the official communique from IARC. They put it as a Class 2A carcinogen, same as glyphosate (Roundup) and caffein. "Probable" carcinogen. In the other hand, alcohol is still Class 1, "known carcinogen".
If you have to be careful, it is to limit your grilled and smoked meat because the processing of these foods involves the addition of polyaromatic hydrocarbons (PAH) from combustion byproducts. These are known carcinogens (Class 1) and tells you one things: BBQ and grill should be a weekend treat and tailgate food, not your daily staple food.

Here is the original link: [Link]

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 26 Oct 15 4.49pm

My rule of thumb is that avoiding carcinogens is largely pointless if you've quit smoking, or still smoke.

Sooner or later something is going to kill you, and chances are its going to be really nasty and you'll suffer.

Rather than worry about what might kill us, or give us a nasty terminal end, we should focus on what we can do, which is offer people who face a 'nasty end' a way out, that doesn't involve slowly decaying, in pain and say slowly drowning in your own fluids, until your heart gives way from lack of oxygen.

Death is inevitable, life is precious, but its not about 'how much you get', but how much you 'get out of it'. We cannot measure the quality of our existence by years. The only reason that cancer worries me, is that I know that the compassion of my country and its laws aim to ensure that I experience as much of that suffering as possible.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

cpfcdboi Flag Thornton heath 28 Oct 15 11.18am

Off to smoke a big fat bacon roll up now

 


London born
palace bred
@cpfcdboi

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 28 Oct 15 11.27am

If anything, bacon taste nicer now.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

phil38 Flag london 28 Oct 15 12.04pm

you can get cancer just by walking down the street now-a-days

 

oldcodger Flag 28 Oct 15 12.08pm

Quote phil38 at 28 Oct 2015 12.04pm

you can get cancer just by walking down the street now-a-days


"The scientific evidence linking both processed meat and tobacco to certain types of cancer is strong. In that sense, both are carcinogens. But smoking increases your relative risk of lung cancer by 2,500 percent; eating two slices of bacon a day increases your relative risk for colorectal cancer by 18 percent. Given the frequency of colorectal cancer, that means your risk of getting colorectal cancer over your life goes from about 5 percent to 6 percent and, well, YBMMV. "

It's all about weighing up the risks.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 28 Oct 15 1.08pm

Quote phil38 at 28 Oct 2015 12.04pm

you can get cancer just by walking down the street now-a-days

That has always been the case, as vehicle emissions and many air pollutants are carcinogens. Nothing new about that.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Ibanez 28 Oct 15 9.58pm

Quote oldcodger at 28 Oct 2015 12.08pm

Quote phil38 at 28 Oct 2015 12.04pm

you can get cancer just by walking down the street now-a-days


"The scientific evidence linking both processed meat and tobacco to certain types of cancer is strong. In that sense, both are carcinogens. But smoking increases your relative risk of lung cancer by 2,500 percent; eating two slices of bacon a day increases your relative risk for colorectal cancer by 18 percent. Given the frequency of colorectal cancer, that means your risk of getting colorectal cancer over your life goes from about 5 percent to 6 percent and, well, YBMMV. "

It's all about weighing up the risks.

Great post. It's shocking how rarely the numbers are mentioned. "Cancer risk" sounds very scary, but 6% chance instead of 5% chance doesn't grab any headlines.

 

matt_himself Flag Matataland 29 Oct 15 6.31am

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 26 Oct 2015 8.23am

The advice is flawed
We are omnivores
Like anything its about the quality of the priduct you consume


Exactly. Have you tried eating just fruit and vegetables? The human body is not designed for that and the results are not pleasant or compliment, pulling something out at random, showing a relative around London sights. That was a messy day.

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

Mr Palaceman Flag 29 Oct 15 7.57am

I'm not a vegetarian but for the last year I have hardly eaten any meat and I feel a lot better for it.

To me it's common sense, if you eat meat every day with all the cr*p they put in it now, no wonder cancer is on the increase. Hormones, growth enhancers, pesticides.

But It's not meat per-say, it's just what they do to it so they can make more money and make it last on the self.

Chicken for instance "was" a low fat, high protein bird back in the day but now it's low protein, high fat/water. When you see chickens running around wild they are skinny.

At the end of the day, you are what you eat. I try and stay away from any processed "food like" products and if it says "part of your 5 a day" on the label, I avoid it like the plague. They may as well put on the label "This is cr*p food but we pretend that it's healthy as we have put an essence of fruit in it".

Proper food labelling would make it easier to make good food choices but if the food industry did that, they wouldn't be able to sell us rubbish food and make a profit by pretending that it's good for you..

 


"You can lead a horse to water but a pencil must be lead"

Stan Laurel

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 29 Oct 15 9.52am

Quote matt_himself at 29 Oct 2015 6.31am

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 26 Oct 2015 8.23am

The advice is flawed
We are omnivores
Like anything its about the quality of the priduct you consume


Exactly. Have you tried eating just fruit and vegetables? The human body is not designed for that and the results are not pleasant or compliment, pulling something out at random, showing a relative around London sights. That was a messy day.

Not entirely true, but not untrue either. Years back when I was vegetarian, the first few weeks were pretty 'difficult', but then no problems. Just turned out that my body hadn't been used to a diet that was vegetables and fruit (and if you don't eat a lot of fruit and then start eating a lot of fruit - its like a bowel tsunami!). Funny enough when I came back over to the meat eaters, I had horrible constipation.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Hoof Hearted 29 Oct 15 10.39am

Eating a bacon/sausage sandwich every day would get boring let alone dangerous.

Every now and then though you crave one and have it... same with dodgy kebabs after a night on the lash.

All these so called experts make me laugh with their warnings about food and lifestyle.

Here's my warning (take heed or not)...

Don't eat a bacon sandwich whilst smoking a roll up and having unprotected anal sex with Julian Clary (as the giver) on the open deck of a roll-on-roll-off car ferry with it's sea doors open travelling from Zeebrugge in a winter low pressure induced storm with high waves and not wearing a life jacket.

 

JohnB Flag 29 Oct 15 10.49am

Bacon and Sausage etc. are in carcinogenic category 1 as is Sun light, so should we just not go outside ever too?

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > red meat cancer risk