You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Is Bert the Head right about media and politics?
November 21 2026 11.03pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Is Bert the Head right about media and politics?


Page 3 of 10 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >
Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 28 Dec 15 10.25pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 28 Dec 2015 9.36pm

The mistake is to see the media as being pro-left, pro-right when its actually in the business of making money. News media tends to pander to its audience and pursues demographics that provide it with funding through things like advertising.

The media isn't really socialist or liberal bias, media is in the business of profit, revenue generation and sales. People like Murdoch couldn't give a sh*t whether or not subsidiary company media slant is, provided it makes money.


This is true, but the average punter is not necessarily aware of that, so the ultimate aim is rather beside the point.

Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (28 Dec 2015 10.27pm)

 

snytaxx Flag London 30 Dec 15 4.45am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 28 Dec 2015 11.28am

Quote snytaxx at 29 Nov 2015 12.15pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 28 Nov 2015 8.58pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 28 Nov 2015 12.09pm

Quote nickgusset at 28 Nov 2015 11.49am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 28 Nov 2015 11.15am

Quote legaleagle at 28 Nov 2015 10.54am

Apologies in advance for rambling...

Good to see the usual suspects engaging in the usual irrelevant "left" bashing.

Bert has a point and makes some sense if readers can see beyond their own knee jerk prejudices,as does Hoof.



My only concern with Bert is his refusal to accept that any of us are capable of evaluating messages and filtering out the spin.

You've made a good case for the unfair nature of Corbyn's reporting, but you have not mentioned the totally unfair nature of the bombardment that Nigel Farage has taken from the media!

Not only that, he has had to put up with being shouted down whilst campaigning by left wing activists and even had a quiet family Sunday lunch in a pub invaded by scumbags that cannot campaign peaceably or in a socially acceptable fashion.

I don't remember you or anyone else making an impassioned plea on Nigel Farage's behalf?

Just accept, that any message imparted into the arena will have some sort of spin on it, and if you want to get nearer to the truth, read a few different sources and make your own mind up as to who is most likely to be the most honest.

What percentage of the population read / watch / listen to a wide range of information sources for balance? I doubt it's very high.

Look at the important debate on immigration. The way it's reported by sections of the media is done so in an inflammatory way to raise heckles thus fuelling unnecessary repercussions. A massive increase in islamophobic attacks on ordinary law abiding people is one example.

The issue about bombing Syria is a very important one. So why is the focus on division in political parties rather than the pros and cons of launching airstrikes?

The thing is Nick you are taking the approach that you and your beliefs are right. We all do, so anyone who disagrees is naïve, stupid, illinformed etc

When was the last time anyone actually changed their mind after reading anything in General Talk? Their views may softened slightly if you're lucky.

As for Corbyn, he is an unmitigated disaster but I think most people have quickly seen through the not so hidden agenda of much of the press. His problem is he seems unable to anticipate the s*** storm that follows after stunts like Mao's book

Ironically of course it was the Conservative government that was doing business with Mao's legacy, one of the most oppressive anti-democratic countries in the world. That was the point of the stunt, to draw attention to the fact that the party that bangs on about Western Values and Freedoms, will doing something like 20bn worth of business with the Chinese state for UK power.


Don't take this as targeted attack but I think your statement above is incorrect for the following reasons.

The China of today economically has very little in common with how Mao left China or the China he would of wanted. I would argue it is Deng Xiao Ping's legacy which the Tories are currently buying into. It was Deng and certainly not Mao who set up the current economic and political system which China currently uses.

The Conservative Party has always been a secret admirer of the "&#37011;&#23567;&#24179;&#29702;&#35770; - Dèng Xi&#462;o píng l&#464; lùn, or to give it its full English name, The Deng Xiaoping theory of the foundation of PRC economic development after the cultural revolution, building the capitalist economy within Chinese communist party control. Whew!

Ironically of course, Deng Xiao Ping actually tried to suppress the 'little red book' as it was Mao's Cultural Revolution and the Gang of Four's "Criticize Deng and Oppose the Rehabilitation of Right-leaning Elements campaign" that led to his political purging and his son being thrown out of a third story window.

Still, lets not let any of that get in the way of a nice political attention seeking stunt in the form of throwing a little red book across the dispatch box. Unsurprisingly that clip is yet to feature on the subway TV bulletins.

After comment - apologies about the random numbers... it appears the HOL HTML scripting is unable to display Chinese Characters, what linguistic bigotry eh?

Edited by snytaxx (29 Nov 2015 12.18pm)

Great post - I agree with it entirely. However I still find the idea of doing business with the PRC, a brutal oppressive regime and regular human rights abuser, abhorrent.

It all comes down to money and diplomacy really. Do you we as a country sit on our moral high horses and talk down at other countries telling them how they aren't good enough to trade with us or do we get stuck in and try and wield influence from the inside?

If we stopped doing business with the PRC, who else would you we also need to stop doing business with? Where would we draw the line? The world is rarely so black and white and its often not clear who the 'good sort' and the not so 'good sort' are.

Take a random selection of countries such as: France, Qatar, China, Singapore, India, pakistan and South African. If I really picked those countries track records on human rights I am sure I would not have to look far to find something I dont agree with. Which of those should we therefore stop trading with? What categories do we use. Some of those countries deny proper free speech, others aren't (proper) democracies, some outlaw homosexuality, others fund terrorist organisations, others oppress women or workers rights. Some even go as far as to deport groups of people based on their ethnicity (*cough* Romani in FRANCE).

Where do you draw the line? Would it be okay to trade with a country with a flawless democracy record but which locks up homosexuals? Does that therefore mean that democracy is more important than gay rights? What about the other way round?

Obviously im not trying to belittle you or make you out to be prioritising evil but my point remains unchanged. If we cut off trade relation with the PRC and start going all 'moral crusade' on people I think we will find the world to be a very lonely place.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 30 Dec 15 11.06am

Quote snytaxx at 30 Dec 2015 4.45am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 28 Dec 2015 11.28am

Quote snytaxx at 29 Nov 2015 12.15pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 28 Nov 2015 8.58pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 28 Nov 2015 12.09pm

Quote nickgusset at 28 Nov 2015 11.49am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 28 Nov 2015 11.15am

Quote legaleagle at 28 Nov 2015 10.54am

Apologies in advance for rambling...

Good to see the usual suspects engaging in the usual irrelevant "left" bashing.

Bert has a point and makes some sense if readers can see beyond their own knee jerk prejudices,as does Hoof.



My only concern with Bert is his refusal to accept that any of us are capable of evaluating messages and filtering out the spin.

You've made a good case for the unfair nature of Corbyn's reporting, but you have not mentioned the totally unfair nature of the bombardment that Nigel Farage has taken from the media!

Not only that, he has had to put up with being shouted down whilst campaigning by left wing activists and even had a quiet family Sunday lunch in a pub invaded by scumbags that cannot campaign peaceably or in a socially acceptable fashion.

I don't remember you or anyone else making an impassioned plea on Nigel Farage's behalf?

Just accept, that any message imparted into the arena will have some sort of spin on it, and if you want to get nearer to the truth, read a few different sources and make your own mind up as to who is most likely to be the most honest.

What percentage of the population read / watch / listen to a wide range of information sources for balance? I doubt it's very high.

Look at the important debate on immigration. The way it's reported by sections of the media is done so in an inflammatory way to raise heckles thus fuelling unnecessary repercussions. A massive increase in islamophobic attacks on ordinary law abiding people is one example.

The issue about bombing Syria is a very important one. So why is the focus on division in political parties rather than the pros and cons of launching airstrikes?

The thing is Nick you are taking the approach that you and your beliefs are right. We all do, so anyone who disagrees is naïve, stupid, illinformed etc

When was the last time anyone actually changed their mind after reading anything in General Talk? Their views may softened slightly if you're lucky.

As for Corbyn, he is an unmitigated disaster but I think most people have quickly seen through the not so hidden agenda of much of the press. His problem is he seems unable to anticipate the s*** storm that follows after stunts like Mao's book

Ironically of course it was the Conservative government that was doing business with Mao's legacy, one of the most oppressive anti-democratic countries in the world. That was the point of the stunt, to draw attention to the fact that the party that bangs on about Western Values and Freedoms, will doing something like 20bn worth of business with the Chinese state for UK power.


Don't take this as targeted attack but I think your statement above is incorrect for the following reasons.

The China of today economically has very little in common with how Mao left China or the China he would of wanted. I would argue it is Deng Xiao Ping's legacy which the Tories are currently buying into. It was Deng and certainly not Mao who set up the current economic and political system which China currently uses.

The Conservative Party has always been a secret admirer of the "&#37011;&#23567;&#24179;&#29702;&#35770; - Dèng Xi&#462;o píng l&#464; lùn, or to give it its full English name, The Deng Xiaoping theory of the foundation of PRC economic development after the cultural revolution, building the capitalist economy within Chinese communist party control. Whew!

Ironically of course, Deng Xiao Ping actually tried to suppress the 'little red book' as it was Mao's Cultural Revolution and the Gang of Four's "Criticize Deng and Oppose the Rehabilitation of Right-leaning Elements campaign" that led to his political purging and his son being thrown out of a third story window.

Still, lets not let any of that get in the way of a nice political attention seeking stunt in the form of throwing a little red book across the dispatch box. Unsurprisingly that clip is yet to feature on the subway TV bulletins.

After comment - apologies about the random numbers... it appears the HOL HTML scripting is unable to display Chinese Characters, what linguistic bigotry eh?

Edited by snytaxx (29 Nov 2015 12.18pm)

Great post - I agree with it entirely. However I still find the idea of doing business with the PRC, a brutal oppressive regime and regular human rights abuser, abhorrent.

It all comes down to money and diplomacy really. Do you we as a country sit on our moral high horses and talk down at other countries telling them how they aren't good enough to trade with us or do we get stuck in and try and wield influence from the inside?

If we stopped doing business with the PRC, who else would you we also need to stop doing business with? Where would we draw the line? The world is rarely so black and white and its often not clear who the 'good sort' and the not so 'good sort' are.

Take a random selection of countries such as: France, Qatar, China, Singapore, India, pakistan and South African. If I really picked those countries track records on human rights I am sure I would not have to look far to find something I dont agree with. Which of those should we therefore stop trading with? What categories do we use. Some of those countries deny proper free speech, others aren't (proper) democracies, some outlaw homosexuality, others fund terrorist organisations, others oppress women or workers rights. Some even go as far as to deport groups of people based on their ethnicity (*cough* Romani in FRANCE).

Where do you draw the line? Would it be okay to trade with a country with a flawless democracy record but which locks up homosexuals? Does that therefore mean that democracy is more important than gay rights? What about the other way round?

Obviously im not trying to belittle you or make you out to be prioritising evil but my point remains unchanged. If we cut off trade relation with the PRC and start going all 'moral crusade' on people I think we will find the world to be a very lonely place.

Fair points, it does however make it somewhat hard to justify criticism of other nations, states and groups when you've just awarded such a massive contract to a country that exemplifies oppression by the state as a matter of direct policy. Similar to the problem of Saudi Arabia, we criticise the rise of Islamism and Islamist terrorism, and then do incredible business with one of the major sponsors of terrorism and exporters of our own enemies.

Given we're a country that often plays a 'moral superiority' card, our own actions tie into a lot of questionable moral decisions which in the end are entirely about money.

We've seen the governments open criticism of workers in Qatar, but then to go and do such business with China makes that stance seem utterly pointless. Our morality is business, plain and simple.

With some of those other countries, the capacity of the UK to leverage change in exchange for commercial / economic business exists however, less so with the PRC which has a very steady record.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 08 May 16 9.46pm

Food for thought...

[Link]

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 08 May 16 10.04pm

Little substance all opinion.

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 08 May 16 10.10pm

I have to admit, the premise posited in the title of this thread gave me a right good laff.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 08 May 16 10.22pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

Food for thought...

[Link]

Not impressed I'm afraid.

David Lammy should be judged on the things he says and most of that is load of bollocks.
The BBC is a great broadcaster but as it runs on tax payers money it has to be directly answerable to the government. All parties will play their little games when reforms are being threatened.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 11 May 16 9.59am

This is the story of some squalid little men (and women), but it is a vital insight into the nexus of the political and corporate media elite. The Guardian, New Statesman and Huffington Post today all run major stories around a “focus group” study in Nuneaton which revealed that voters think Corbyn is “scruffy” and “old-fashioned”. This is deemed front page news.

The publicity was obviously supposed to coincide with Labour losing Nuneaton council, its most marginal council surrounded by Tory territory, in the council elections on Thursday. However Labour held Nuneaton. That did not stop the New Statesman article, by “research” authors James Morris and Ian Warren, from going ahead with the immortal phrase “While today’s Labour party has no hope of representing Nuneaton”. Err, it is still in control of the Council.

The publication is also timed to coincide with a revolt by Labour MPs at this afternoon’s meeting of the Parliamentary Labour Party. The idea is that the “research” would prove that election losses were Corbyn’s fault. That is toned down now after they beat the Tories outside Scotland, but I am told that Progress MPs are still briefed to flourish the Guardian and raise this “research” today. That is meant to get this “research” onto the evening news.

But when you look at the research very closely, you realise that it is absolute rubbish. James Morris and Ian Warren are total charlatans.

Firstly, the whole sample is 16 people. That is right, 16 people. They are supposed all to be ex-Labour, though there is little evidence of that in the transcripts. What is not in dispute is that they are all Tory voters.

So you have 16 Tory voters, in two groups male and female. But out of 16 people there is not one retired person. Not one young voter. Not one person unemployed. And every single one is in a nuclear heterosexual relationship with children. Every single one is a homeowner.

Furthermore their sources of information are (by order most mentioned) the Daily Mail, Sky, the BBC and the Sun. Only one out of 16 mentions the internet as a source of political information.

People who voted Tory constitute already just 24% of the general population. Exclude retired, tenants, single, childless, gay, young and internet savvy people as well, and you get down to a deliberately chosen 5% of the population from which to choose your sample. You then get these 16 carefully chosen, blinkered right wing bigots into a room. Nevertheless something still goes wrong for your research. Two of the 16 (in the female group) state a firm intention to vote Labour next time (while a larger number state they would consider it).

So what do you do if you are a charlatan like James Morris or Ian Warren? You leave that in the transcript, which no journalist will ever read, but you exclude the fact that 2 of the 16 will vote Labour next time from your findings! And you studiously lead the conversation with the group round to the idea that others who are considering voting Labour next time might be more likely to do so with a change of leader.

The idea that locking two carefully selected groups of totally unrepresentative right wingers into a room to self-reinforce their bigoted opinions, in any way constitutes real research, is utterly laughable. The only conclusion is that having carefully selected the people in all of the UK the most likely to dislike Jeremy Corbyn, they dislike Jeremy Corbyn. Next week, a group of young unemployed people from the Easter Road will give their views on David Cameron.

Needless to say the so called journalists who have published this nonsense did no investigation whatsoever of the farcical nature of the “research”. They just published the press release, as witnessed by the fact they all use exactly the same quotes from scores of pages of transcript.

An important question is who paid for this. Obviously it is a Blairite production, but where did the money come from? Greenberg Quinlan Rosner research are credited, and they are extremely expensive. I asked Ian Warren who funded it. First he replied “I did”, then when I asked him who funded Greenberg Quinlan Rosner he stated there was “something sinister” about the question. I asked again twice, but answer came there none. Astonishingly, “who paid for this” did not occur to the mainstream journalists who uncritically published Morris and Warren’s nonsense.

This is a deeply sinister story. Right wing Labour figures hope desperately their own party will lose in Nuneaton. So they commission (and presumably pay for) ludicrously skewed research to show Jeremy Corbyn caused the loss. This absolute non-news item, that a tiny selected group of completely unrepresentative right wingers do not like Jeremy Corbyn, is then plastered on front pages by their Blairite media contacts to coincide with a Parliamentary Labour Party meeting today, in order to further the slow motion coup against Corbyn.

It is actually quite sickening. All of those involved – including the Guardian and New Statesman editors – are very low people indeed.


[Link]

 

Hoof Hearted 11 May 16 10.43am

Originally posted by Cucking Funt

I have to admit, the premise posited in the title of this thread gave me a right good laff.

You know Gusset has been on the wine gums when he starts a thread with that title Dermot.

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 11 May 16 11.19am

I'm struggling to understand why this has turned into another left v right thread - sure, Corbyn is the example used in the initial post, but as is highlighted above, this is far from a problem exclusive to him - Farage is another good example.

Whether you support Corbyn or not, surely the monopolization of the media and the consequent influence on politics is a concern for anyone?

Edited by EverybodyDannsNow (11 May 2016 11.20am)

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 11 May 16 11.31am

The established media report things based on their own agenda. Look at the Sun flip flopping between Tories and Labour.

The good thing about the various social media platforms is that everyone has a voice and it is a lot easier to find various sources for information. The downside is most people search for things that fulfill their confirmation bias

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Hoof Hearted 11 May 16 11.31am

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

I'm struggling to understand why this has turned into another left v right thread - sure, Corbyn is the example used in the initial post, but as is highlighted above, this is far from a problem exclusive to him - Farage is another good example.

Whether you support Corbyn or not, surely the monopolization of the media and the consequent influence on politics is a concern for anyone?

Edited by EverybodyDannsNow (11 May 2016 11.20am)

For a bit of background Dannsy...

Bert the Head pretty much blames the right wing press for everything in every post he makes.

That is why Gusset chose him and Corbyn....Dermot and I just found it hilarious.

But... taking your serious point on board - I agree with you.

Farage has taken a lot more crap than Corbyn or anybody else (I posted this information earlier in the thread).

In an ideal world everyone would be fair and not biased, but we're dealing with human nature and a competitive streak that overrides what is the sensible thing to do.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 11 May 16 11.46am

People tend to get the relationship slightly wrong.

The public consume media, and politicians connect to the public interest, via the media.

As such, the power in the relationship resides within the media corporations, as they can influence both politicians and the public.

As a generalisation, corporations hold power and influence beyond that of citizens and the state, because they have the capacity to 'manufacture consent' with both the public and political bodies.

Take IS - The media has controlled the issue of IS and as a result steered political and public opinion towards intervention, far more than the actions of IS. Even going back to the rout of the Iraqi army, British Policy has been designed because of the media use of IS shock tactics to appal them, whilst polticial parties move to respond to this disgust.

Now whether we should intervene or not, isn't really something we decide alone, we're motivated by the disgust we feel from the media presentation, which is presented in the media, and then responded to by politicians (just an example, not a defence of IS).

The Media really acts as the magnifying glass to the public, and as the representative of 'the average man' to the Politicians.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 11 May 16 11.47am

Originally posted by Hoof Hearted

For a bit of background Dannsy...

Bert the Head pretty much blames the right wing press for everything in every post he makes.

That is why Gusset chose him and Corbyn....Dermot and I just found it hilarious.

But... taking your serious point on board - I agree with you.

Farage has taken a lot more crap than Corbyn or anybody else (I posted this information earlier in the thread).

In an ideal world everyone would be fair and not biased, but we're dealing with human nature and people*, who, by any means necessary, aim to keep the status quo (Who are doing quite well under the current set up.)

EFA

*Including, as posted in the link, from the within the Labour party and so-called left wing publications.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 11 May 16 11.48am

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

I'm struggling to understand why this has turned into another left v right thread - sure, Corbyn is the example used in the initial post, but as is highlighted above, this is far from a problem exclusive to him - Farage is another good example.

Whether you support Corbyn or not, surely the monopolization of the media and the consequent influence on politics is a concern for anyone?

Edited by EverybodyDannsNow (11 May 2016 11.20am)

It should be, but its not an issue that's very prevalent in the media, for fairly obvious reasons. There is no such thing as a free press. Just a very expensive one.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Hoof Hearted 11 May 16 11.53am

It seems everybody is manipulating the news Nick....

[Link]

Facebook's "trending news" was suppressed by their administrative lefty agitators it seems if it was a story they didn't like, or boosted Tory morale.

Unfair or what?

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 11 May 16 12.00pm

Originally posted by Hoof Hearted

For a bit of background Dannsy...

Bert the Head pretty much blames the right wing press for everything in every post he makes.

That is why Gusset chose him and Corbyn....Dermot and I just found it hilarious.

But... taking your serious point on board - I agree with you.

Farage has taken a lot more crap than Corbyn or anybody else (I posted this information earlier in the thread).

In an ideal world everyone would be fair and not biased, but we're dealing with human nature and a competitive streak that overrides what is the sensible thing to do.

Thanks - although I do follow much of general talk more than I post, so I was aware of most of the above.

I guess my point is more that, particularly in light of the Hillsborough episode, where the true capability of the media to protect their interests was exposed, this topic should be more than just another stick to beat Corbyn with - it might be to the right's advantage in this example, but the whole principle that a handful of individuals can control such huge proportions of the media, and as demonstrated in the initial study, essentially unfairly report information to their advantage, is massively concerning.

Edited by EverybodyDannsNow (11 May 2016 12.01pm)

 

Hoof Hearted 11 May 16 12.06pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

Thanks - although I do follow much of general talk more than I post, so I was aware of most of the above.

I guess my point is more that, particularly in light of the Hillsborough episode, where the true capability of the media to protect their interests was exposed, this topic should be more than just another stick to beat Corbyn with - it might be to the right's advantage in this example, but the whole principle that a handful of individuals can control such huge proportions of the media, and as demonstrated in the initial study, essentially unfairly report information to their advantage, is massively concerning.

Edited by EverybodyDannsNow (11 May 2016 12.01pm)

Yep the point you made is entirely valid but as my "facebook" post shows, bias manifests itself everywhere, so it will be hard to eliminate it.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 11 May 16 12.13pm

Originally posted by Hoof Hearted

It seems everybody is manipulating the news Nick....

[Link]

Facebook's "trending news" was suppressed by their administrative lefty agitators it seems if it was a story they didn't like, or boosted Tory morale.

Unfair or what?

If you are going to hire people to promote your propaganda, isn't it worth vetting them first to make sure they're 'on your side'?

Happened this week with the 'rogue marker'. The fault of Pearson education (who are slowly taking over the world of education)

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 11 May 16 12.20pm

Originally posted by Hoof Hearted

Yep the point you made is entirely valid but as my "facebook" post shows, bias manifests itself everywhere, so it will be hard to eliminate it.

Bias does manifest itself everywhere, but it is heavily skewed by the media giants who have more clout, look at fox news for instance and in your example Facebook in the U.S.

However, the internet has meant that alternative sources of views, news and information are available on a global scale now to compete with the giants.

There are not that many blogs that I'd say are above decent, but those that are, are well researched and give good arguments. They've also got a tremendous amount of readers.

 

Page 3 of 10 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Is Bert the Head right about media and politics?