This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Universal Basic Income
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
Seth On a pale blue dot 08 Dec 15 5.12pm |
|
|
Finland is thinking about trialling a system where they give all their citizens an income of 800 Euros a month and scrapping benefits. This was discussed on Newsnight last night and there are some issues with it, but in essence it sounds like a creative and simpler new way of running a nation's finances.
From Forbes Economics & Finance:
Finally, Someone Does Something Sensible: Finland To Bring In A Universal Basic Income
There’s rather a lot of discussion around these days about the merits of a universal basic income. We have, for example, those who tell us that the robots are about to steal all our jobs and therefore we need to tax the capital owners in order to provide that basic income for all. Well, maybe, but it’s not going to work out that way. However, that universal basic income is still a startlingly good idea simply because it’s better than any of the various welfare systems we have at present. But do note: It works by being universal and basic.
[Link]
What do HOLers think?
Edited by Seth (08 Dec 2015 5.15pm)
"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down" FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16
|
Ketteridge Brighton 08 Dec 15 5.18pm |
|
|
Could you post a link, sounds interesting but need to understand if it a variation on tax credits. thanks
One supporter of hacking argued that without it "you will do away with the courage and pluck of the game, and I will be bound to bring over a lot of Frenchmen who would beat you with a week's practice -Blackheath secretary at first meeting of the F.A
|
Ketteridge Brighton 08 Dec 15 5.19pm |
|
|
Sorry seen link, silly me
One supporter of hacking argued that without it "you will do away with the courage and pluck of the game, and I will be bound to bring over a lot of Frenchmen who would beat you with a week's practice -Blackheath secretary at first meeting of the F.A
|
Holmesdale Nick South Croydon 08 Dec 15 5.56pm |
|
|
so as I understand it, everyone over the age of 18 receives a set amount per month.
All other benefits are scrapped.
Therefore the cost of running the benefits and welfare system are dramatically reduced.
Fitter Fans Group 2. No. 17
|
Seth On a pale blue dot 08 Dec 15 6.28pm |
|
Quote Holmesdale Nick at 08 Dec 2015 5.56pm
so as I understand it, everyone over the age of 18 receives a set amount per month.
All other benefits are scrapped.
Therefore the cost of running the benefits and welfare system are dramatically reduced.
I think the cost of the Finland plan is about the same, but much, much simpler and with added benefits such as encouraging people to work or volunteer without the risk of losing benefits.
"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down" FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16
|
DanH SW2 08 Dec 15 6.31pm |
|
Quote Holmesdale Nick at 08 Dec 2015 5.56pm
so as I understand it, everyone over the age of 18 receives a set amount per month.
All other benefits are scrapped.
Therefore the cost of running the benefits and welfare system are dramatically reduced.
Yep. Would also be a lot easier to control immigration I would have thought too if recipients had to be legal citizens/residents.
Be interesting to see how it works if Finland implement it.
|
Seth On a pale blue dot 08 Dec 15 6.35pm |
|
Quote DanH at 08 Dec 2015 6.31pm
Quote Holmesdale Nick at 08 Dec 2015 5.56pm
so as I understand it, everyone over the age of 18 receives a set amount per month.
All other benefits are scrapped.
Therefore the cost of running the benefits and welfare system are dramatically reduced.
Yep. Would also be a lot easier to control immigration I would have thought too if recipients had to be legal citizens/residents.
Be interesting to see how it works if Finland implement it.
Indeed. I believe some areas of The Netherlands are considering trialling it too, as are other places.
Personally I think it's potentially a very good idea which may spread wider if the trials are successful.
"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down" FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16
|
pefwin Where you have to have an English ... 08 Dec 15 8.33pm |
|
|
I remember a school boy getting onto Nationwide because he won a competition with the same idea.
That was 40 years ago.
"Everything is air-droppable at least once."
"When the going gets tough, the tough call for close air support."
|
elgrande bedford 08 Dec 15 9.00pm |
|
|
Population of Finland,5.3 million..Population of uk 63.1million.
Theres your answer.
always a Norwood boy, where ever I live.
|
pefwin Where you have to have an English ... 08 Dec 15 9.04pm |
|
Quote elgrande at 08 Dec 2015 9.00pm
Population of Finland,5.3 million..Population of uk 63.1million.
Theres your answer.
Why?
"Everything is air-droppable at least once."
"When the going gets tough, the tough call for close air support."
|
elgrande bedford 08 Dec 15 9.06pm |
|
Quote pefwin at 08 Dec 2015 9.04pm
Quote elgrande at 08 Dec 2015 9.00pm
Population of Finland,5.3 million..Population of uk 63.1million.
Theres your answer.
Why?
Really.....How do we fund giving at least 50 million people £650 each month.
always a Norwood boy, where ever I live.
|
pefwin Where you have to have an English ... 08 Dec 15 9.10pm |
|
Quote elgrande at 08 Dec 2015 9.06pm
Quote pefwin at 08 Dec 2015 9.04pm
Quote elgrande at 08 Dec 2015 9.00pm
Population of Finland,5.3 million..Population of uk 63.1million.
Theres your answer.
Why?
Really.....How do we fund giving at least 50 million people £650 each month.
From the 50 million.
"Everything is air-droppable at least once."
"When the going gets tough, the tough call for close air support."
|
elgrande bedford 08 Dec 15 9.12pm |
|
Quote pefwin at 08 Dec 2015 9.10pm
Quote elgrande at 08 Dec 2015 9.06pm
Quote pefwin at 08 Dec 2015 9.04pm
Quote elgrande at 08 Dec 2015 9.00pm
Population of Finland,5.3 million..Population of uk 63.1million.
Theres your answer.
Why?
Really.....How do we fund giving at least 50 million people £650 each month.
From the 50 million.
So you want me to pay More tax to fund people who don't pay any?
always a Norwood boy, where ever I live.
|
martin2412 Living The Dream 08 Dec 15 9.14pm |
|
Quote elgrande at 08 Dec 2015 9.06pm
Quote pefwin at 08 Dec 2015 9.04pm
Quote elgrande at 08 Dec 2015 9.00pm
Population of Finland,5.3 million..Population of uk 63.1million.
Theres your answer.
Why?
Really.....How do we fund giving at least 50 million people £650 each month.
We fund it with the extra revenue that a larger population generates.
|
rob1969 Banstead Surrey 08 Dec 15 9.15pm |
|
Quote Seth at 08 Dec 2015 5.12pm
Finland is thinking about trialling a system where they give all their citizens an income of 800 Euros a month and scrapping benefits. This was discussed on Newsnight last night and there are some issues with it, but in essence it sounds like a creative and simpler new way of running a nation's finances.
From Forbes Economics & Finance:
Finally, Someone Does Something Sensible: Finland To Bring In A Universal Basic Income
There’s rather a lot of discussion around these days about the merits of a universal basic income. We have, for example, those who tell us that the robots are about to steal all our jobs and therefore we need to tax the capital owners in order to provide that basic income for all. Well, maybe, but it’s not going to work out that way. However, that universal basic income is still a startlingly good idea simply because it’s better than any of the various welfare systems we have at present. But do note: It works by being universal and basic.
[Link]
What do HOLers think?
Edited by Seth (08 Dec 2015 5.15pm)
Feels like deja vu as sure I read a similar article sometime (years?) ago.
but
|
andyg york 08 Dec 15 9.15pm |
|
|
This is very interesting. I like the idea but have a few questions from an initial read.
The thing I can think of is regional disparities. Should London get extra because of the high housing costs etc?
What about pensions?
It also might be too easy for governments to keep increasing (particularly around election time!)
|
pefwin Where you have to have an English ... 08 Dec 15 9.44pm |
|
Quote elgrande at 08 Dec 2015 9.06pm
Quote pefwin at 08 Dec 2015 9.04pm
Quote elgrande at 08 Dec 2015 9.00pm
Population of Finland,5.3 million..Population of uk 63.1million.
Theres your answer.
Why?
Really.....How do we fund giving at least 50 million people £650 each month.
As the UK's GNP funds you.
"Everything is air-droppable at least once."
"When the going gets tough, the tough call for close air support."
|
Ketteridge Brighton 08 Dec 15 9.44pm |
|
|
Comes down to the intention and how it is applied. If the cost of applying a targeted benefit is so high that given that benefit to everyone is cheaper than it seems sensible, but otherwise potentially you are just giving £6700 away to people who don't really need it. A house share in South Norwood comes in at £100 so £130 a week would not really give me the freedom for additional study/further education or voluntary work to improve my long term career prospects. Currently a lot of money from welfare is badly targeted, the main culprit being housing benefits which is largely use to inflate a housing and in particular the rental sector. It might give people more say in how that money was spent but pulling the plug on this would have huge financial consequences to the wider economy. If you set it at higher enough level to genuinely give people that freedom you are then talking about a re distributive tax so why not just target those that need it, or other measures reducing good quality social housing reduce tuition fess, apprenticeship etc.
Sounds interesting though might need to look more into the rational
One supporter of hacking argued that without it "you will do away with the courage and pluck of the game, and I will be bound to bring over a lot of Frenchmen who would beat you with a week's practice -Blackheath secretary at first meeting of the F.A
|
Ketteridge Brighton 08 Dec 15 10.01pm |
|
Quote andyg at 08 Dec 2015 9.15pm
This is very interesting. I like the idea but have a few questions from an initial read.
The thing I can think of is regional disparities. Should London get extra because of the high housing costs etc?
What about pensions?
It also might be too easy for governments to keep increasing (particularly around election time!)
I was thinking that about regional disparities, but it could work to spread wealth and drive economies in some areas. If i am guaranteed £560 a month why not move to other regions with lower housing costs. Especially if cities encouraged employment sectors that were in high demand but were low paid. The alternative is that it would give a strong reason to social cleanse London of any poor people, 'you've got you basic income if you don't like it get on you bike'
I am right in saying their is a new flat rate state pension about to come in of £150 a week or another way of putting it is £20 high then the article in forbes reckons we can get by on.
One supporter of hacking argued that without it "you will do away with the courage and pluck of the game, and I will be bound to bring over a lot of Frenchmen who would beat you with a week's practice -Blackheath secretary at first meeting of the F.A
|
Stirlingsays 08 Dec 15 10.09pm |
|
|
Crazy idea to me.
Welfare is for the needy. It should never go to the able.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)
|