You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Amir Khan v Saul Alverez
November 22 2026 1.19am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Amir Khan v Saul Alverez


Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
We are goin up! Flag Coulsdon 05 Feb 16 2.26pm

Originally posted by rikz

Yet canelo is by far the harder fight.

Whoever you like or dislike, khan is the bigger name and can demand more money than brook. Khan isn't even the best in his division so why don't brook look elsewhere and call out all the other guys in their weight, it's full with talent. Instead he would rather stay in Britain having mandatory fights living the easy life instead of trying to fight the best.

Khan was chasing mayweather, then Pacquiao, they didn't happen so his signed up to fight the next hardest opponent out there, you might not like him but you have to give respect where it's due.


Brook's camp offered Khan a 60-40 split in Khan's favour. It would be 60% of a huge purse, much bigger than Brook could get elsewhere which is why he wants the fight.

Khan is the bigger name globally and the reason he won't take the Brook fight is that he will a) lose and b) be overtaken by Brook in terms of British reputation.

Khan's made himself look a right tit saying he wants the Brook fight then actively avoiding it for years. Bottler. A valiant loss at middleweight isn't anywhere as damaging to his reputation.

 


The problem with socialism is that you eventually run out of other people's money.

rikz Flag Croydon 05 Feb 16 2.40pm

Originally posted by We are goin up!


Brook's camp offered Khan a 60-40 split in Khan's favour. It would be 60% of a huge purse, much bigger than Brook could get elsewhere which is why he wants the fight.

Khan is the bigger name globally and the reason he won't take the Brook fight is that he will a) lose and b) be overtaken by Brook in terms of British reputation.

Khan's made himself look a right tit saying he wants the Brook fight then actively avoiding it for years. Bottler. A valiant loss at middleweight isn't anywhere as damaging to his reputation.

But your argument dosnt explain why brook won't fight anyone else, it's frustrating they ain't fighting, but that's that it ain't happening soon. so instead of siting on mandatory defenses brook should be calling out all the other guys, if he beat garcia then thurman he would be regarded as the best would hold the ring belt, would be huge in America and would have more pull negotiating with khan but maybe brook is too scared of losing at the first hurdle of trying to be the best.

 

Stuk Flag Top half 05 Feb 16 2.45pm

Originally posted by We are goin up!


Brook's camp offered Khan a 60-40 split in Khan's favour. It would be 60% of a huge purse, much bigger than Brook could get elsewhere which is why he wants the fight.

Khan is the bigger name globally and the reason he won't take the Brook fight is that he will a) lose and b) be overtaken by Brook in terms of British reputation.

Khan's made himself look a right tit saying he wants the Brook fight then actively avoiding it for years. Bottler. A valiant loss at middleweight isn't anywhere as damaging to his reputation.

Smacks of desperation. Brook is crying out for attention.

As I said he's making himself look like Junior Witter did when chasing a fight with Hatton. Hatton took on Mayweather and lost yet he still didn't have to come back to England and fight Witter. Pacquiao saw the numbers Hatton could generate and said I'll have some of that too.

If Khan sells tickets and PPV for this fight, he'll still be able to get good fights out there even with a loss. And Brook is still there for a fall-back payday.

 


Optimistic as ever

dannyh Flag wherever I lay my hat....... 08 Feb 16 9.28am

"Desperation"

I would say recognition. Khan knows Brook will beat him, dress it up how you like. Khan is a avoiding brook. Kahn 's management team know that a loss to Alverez will not be anywhere near as damaging as a loss to brook. Thats why they took that fight, over fighting Brook.

I hope the arrogant little toss pot gets his arse handed to him and Alverez knocks him the f*** out. You watch he'll want to fight Brook then, and I hope he gets the chance to as brook will beat the snot out of him.

 


"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"

rikz Flag Croydon 08 Feb 16 11.37am

You cant blame Khan he was chasing mayweather and Pacquiao, not that I think he deserved a shot at either but he wants to fight the best.
He was also chasing a rematch with garcia, which his own dad came out and said they don't want nothing to do with khan. He was also asking for cotto, roach has come out and said they don't want the khan fight.
The fact is khan has so many more options than brook.
I'm a fan of both fighters but it's obvious that brook dosnt want to fight anyone decent before securing a big payday against khan.

 

Stuk Flag Top half 08 Feb 16 2.06pm

Originally posted by dannyh

"Desperation"

I would say recognition. Khan knows Brook will beat him, dress it up how you like. Khan is a avoiding brook. Kahn 's management team know that a loss to Alverez will not be anywhere near as damaging as a loss to brook. Thats why they took that fight, over fighting Brook.

I hope the arrogant little toss pot gets his arse handed to him and Alverez knocks him the f*** out. You watch he'll want to fight Brook then, and I hope he gets the chance to as brook will beat the snot out of him.

He doesn't. No boxer thinks like that or there's no point being in the game. Do you not recognise that he has secured a bigger fight than Brook v Khan? A fight which only holds domestic interest really.

They will fight after if Khan loses in May, which I expect him to. Then we can see if your prediction (over-confident one IMO) is correct. I don't believe Brook would even beat him until he's shown me more against other high class opponents.

 


Optimistic as ever

dannyh Flag wherever I lay my hat....... 08 Feb 16 2.17pm

khan has struggled when ever he has encountered someone who is not phased with his puinch power, and has a bit of a dig themselves.

Sure he has come to win fights where he has been hit on his arse and credit due for that, but for me every time he steps up to ask a question " am I world class " he gets beaten, and so it will be with Alverez.

You may think my opinion is daft, and thats as may be, but it comes down to this, can Brook take a shot off Khan ? my answer would be yes he can. Ask yourself the same question the other way round ?

 


"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"

Stuk Flag Top half 08 Feb 16 2.30pm

Originally posted by dannyh

khan has struggled when ever he has encountered someone who is not phased with his puinch power, and has a bit of a dig themselves.

Sure he has come to win fights where he has been hit on his arse and credit due for that, but for me every time he steps up to ask a question " am I world class " he gets beaten, and so it will be with Alverez.

You may think my opinion is daft, and thats as may be, but it comes down to this, can Brook take a shot off Khan ? my answer would be yes he can. Ask yourself the same question the other way round ?

Khan doesn't have big punch power if you ask me, he's has speed and technique and he's shown himself to be more punch resilient in his latter fights.

I don't think your opinion that Brook will win is daft, more that you seem to think he'll walk it. He wouldn't even be favourite IMO.

Just read this and Brook gives him credit for taking the fight and is still talking about them fighting after. Khan has all the options, which was my point, Brook doesn't which is why he's made himself look a bit too desperate.

[Link]

Edited by Stuk (08 Feb 2016 2.32pm)

 


Optimistic as ever

rikz Flag Croydon 08 Feb 16 3.13pm

We all want to see great fights and the best fighting each other, khan has delivered us a fight to look forward to, Brook hasn't.

I'd love to see brook vs khan but would be just as excited watching brook vs garcia/thurman or Bradley.

I'll give brook the benefit of the doubt now but after his next fight he must step up cause at the moment it seems like unless his fighting khan his happy to sit on his belt taking on easy mandarory defence with little risk. I've got a feeling he will try to get a shot and drained cotto over for a big name/payday which will pull the wool over the casual fans eyes but I would be less than impressed.

 

sxp55 Flag South Norwood 08 Feb 16 3.17pm

Originally posted by rikz

We all want to see great fights and the best fighting each other, khan has delivered us a fight to look forward to, Brook hasn't.

I'd love to see brook vs khan but would be just as excited watching brook vs garcia/thurman or Bradley.

I'll give brook the benefit of the doubt now but after his next fight he must step up cause at the moment it seems like unless his fighting khan his happy to sit on his belt taking on easy mandarory defence with little risk. I've got a feeling he will try to get a shot and drained cotto over for a big name/payday which will pull the wool over the casual fans eyes but I would be less than impressed.

can't argue with that.

 


@sxp55555

rikz Flag Croydon 08 Feb 16 3.25pm

Just to add khan is a lot better than people give him credit for he just lacks intelligence in the ring. He was a novice when he got stopped by prescot, I thought he beat peterson, the ref was terrible and so biased and he was completely outboxing garcia untill again he showed a lack of intelligence and got caught by a shot thrown in blind hope.

 

youngpalacefan111 Flag 08 Feb 16 3.43pm

You think Brooks going to win because he hits harder than Khan? oh dear. I think its a good fight but Khan has to be the favourite. Amir Khans not world class? oh dear.

 

stanstedeagle Flag Brighton 08 Feb 16 4.09pm

Originally posted by We are goin up!

Avoiding Brook like the plague.

Are you kidding ??

Hes treating Brook like an irritant and taking on a globally appealing fight with one of the most pound for pound dangerous boxers in the game....these two guys will create a spectacle.

No bad mouthing, healthy respect for each other and a knowledge that a win for either cements them in the boxing hall of fame....if Khan loses he can still fight Brook...he aint going anywhere anytime soon.

 

Casual Flag Orpington 08 Feb 16 9.05pm

Now that may weather and paquio are as good as retired. They need as super 6 style tournament in this weight division ( similar to what ward, froch, taylor etc had).
There's lots of decent fighters with loads of bunny that aren't fighting each other. Porter, Thurman, Brook, Khan, Garcia etc
Although as its my idea , my only stipulation is that Broner has to be in it. As id love to see him get splatted 5 times on the bounce.

 

black eagle. Flag south croydon. 08 Feb 16 9.24pm

Khan is world class and will give Alverez and anyone else problems with
blistering hand speed.

Khan has fought better fighters than kell Brook but surely the Khan v Brook has to happen.

Brooks Strength vs Khans Speed.

i think Khan would be a nightmare for Mayweather because off hes hand speed.

sadly don't think it will happen.

 

JL85 Flag London,SE9 08 Feb 16 9.44pm

Originally posted by black eagle.

Khan is world class and will give Alverez and anyone else problems with
blistering hand speed.

Khan has fought better fighters than kell Brook but surely the Khan v Brook has to happen.

Brooks Strength vs Khans Speed.

i think Khan would be a nightmare for Mayweather because off hes hand speed.

sadly don't think it will happen.

Khan would be Mayweathers dream. He's so Ill disciplined in the ring he be boxed to pieces. He's spend all night trying to cut off the ring, being reset every time.


 

dannyh Flag wherever I lay my hat....... 09 Feb 16 9.24am

Originally posted by youngpalacefan111

You think Brooks going to win because he hits harder than Khan? oh dear. I think its a good fight but Khan has to be the favourite. Amir Khans not world class? oh dear.

Listen mate, I have boxed for well over 20 years, ten being in the Army. And becuase of Khans lack of punch resistance YES I do think becuase Brook has heavier hands than Khan he will win.

No one is questioning Khans boxing ability and speed, but as has proven on numerous occasions when he gets tagged his legs turn to Jelly, and brook has very heavey hands and will damage Khan the minute he has the trademark lack of concentration.

And to that the fact that Khan simply doesnt have the punch power to trouble brook and the fight will IMO only go one way stoppage for Brook in the middle to late rounds.

As for Brook not getting any big name fights, Why do you think that is ? No one wants to fight him as they know how under estimated brook is as a boxer, and yes he may be desperate to fight Khan, but not becuase he is desperate or an "irritant" as some have said, but because, he knows he has the beating of him, and it will catapult him finally into the big time that he deserves.

Try answering with something other than Oh dear.

 


"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"

dannyh Flag wherever I lay my hat....... 09 Feb 16 9.28am

Originally posted by black eagle.

Khan is world class and will give Alverez and anyone else problems with
blistering hand speed.

Khan has fought better fighters than kell Brook but surely the Khan v Brook has to happen.

Brooks Strength vs Khans Speed.

i think Khan would be a nightmare for Mayweather because off hes hand speed.

sadly don't think it will happen.

Errr what are you basing that on, have they both fough the same fighters and had different out comes ? or is it just your opinion.

Khan beating Mayweather hahahahahahahahahahahahahahah thats the best one yet on this thread.

Jesus wept.

 


"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"

youngpalacefan111 Flag 09 Feb 16 11.32am

yes its annoying when somebody responds with "oh dear" isn't it why don't you do yourself a favour and see who used this dickish response first. I couldn't care less about your boxing credentials, and nobody is questioning his boxing ability? Again read your own posts. So your telling me khan has not fought the tougher competition? I'm a big Kell Brook fan but he is a nobody and seems content on padding his record until he fights Khan as that's his biggest payday. Your reason for Kell Brook not getting any big named fighters is laughable.

 

dannyh Flag wherever I lay my hat....... 09 Feb 16 11.44am

Originally posted by youngpalacefan111

yes its annoying when somebody responds with "oh dear" isn't it why don't you do yourself a favour and see who used this dickish response first. I couldn't care less about your boxing credentials, and nobody is questioning his boxing ability? Again read your own posts. So your telling me khan has not fought the tougher competition? I'm a big Kell Brook fan but he is a nobody and seems content on padding his record until he fights Khan as that's his biggest payday. Your reason for Kell Brook not getting any big named fighters is laughable.

I have no wish to get into a slanging match with a young lad.

However you have not answered any of my points with any coherant counter argument. Now go and have a fag behind the bike sheds and chill out.

 


"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"

Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Amir Khan v Saul Alverez